Erastus. It is known this anedrim delivered Christ bound unto Pilate, condemned Steven, commanded the Apostles to be scour•e• and put in Prison. Tertullins saith of Paul before Felix, we would have judged him according to our Law; Paul said, Act. 23. to Ananias, thou sittest to judge me according to the Law, Act. 26. P•ul confesseth before Agrippa and Festus, that he obtained power from the high Priests, to hale to prison and beat the Christians, and Paul for fear of the iniquity of this Church or Sanhedrin, dealt with them as Heathen, and appealed to Cesar. Ans. But by what Law of God did they this? It is not denied but the Jews Synedrim being two courts ⟨p. 316⟩did inflict punishment; But that Christ establisheth a civill Sanhedrin as a mean, Matth. 18. To gain the soul of a brother is now the question; we utterly deny this, and gave reasons before thereof, to which I add, if any obeyed not the Church, that is, the Sanhedrin, as Erastus saith, they might be stoned to death as Steven was: Was this Christs mild way, to cite them only before the Roman Senate? Were dead men capable of answering to any further Judicatures? 2. The last step of convening Heathens and Publicans before the Roman Senate, according to Christs order is not to be observed with them, for even Heathens and Publicans, are so far forth our brethren: that 1. We are not, when they offend us, to suffer sin in them, but to rebuke them as Christians, Lev. 19. 18. For this is the Law of nature: The Law of nature will teach us not to hate an Heathen in our heart. 2. We are to labour to gain all, even those that are without the Church, 1 Cor. 9. 19, 20, 21, 22. 1 Pet. 3. 1. And this is Christs way of gaining all, to rebuke and admonish them: Ergo, it was never Christs meaning to deal with Heathens and Publicans so, as at the first we are to drag them before the Heathen Magistrate, that by his sword he may gain them, or take away their life; yea, and Erastus granteth in Ecclesiastical crimes, that the Jews had power of life and death, in the matter of Steven and of Paul, if he had not appealed to Cesar to save his head: Josephus de bel. Judaic. Lib. 5. Cap. 26. Antiquit. Lib. 14. Cap. 12. But in things politic, Cesar took all power of life and death from them:
Erastus. It is known this anedrim delivered Christ bound unto Pilate, condemned Steven, commanded the Apostles to be scour•e• and put in Prison. Tertullins saith of Paul before Felix, we would have judged him according to our Law; Paul said, Act. 23. to Anani•s, thou sittest to judge me according to the Law, Act. 26. P•ul confesseth before Agrippa and Festus, that he obtained power from the high Priests, to hale to prison and beat the Christians, and Paul for fear of the iniquity of this Church or Sanedrim, dealt with them as Heathen, and appealed to Cesar. Ans. But by what Law of God did they this? It is not denyed but the Iews Synedrim being two courts ⟨p. 316⟩did inflict punishment; But that Christ establisheth a civill Sanedrim as a mean, Matth. 18. To gain the soul of a brother is now the question; we utterly deny this, and gave reasons before thereof, to which I adde, if any obeyed not the Church, that is, the Sanedrim, as Erastus saith, they might be stoned to death as Steven was: Was this Christs milde way, to cite them onely before the Romane Senate? Were dead men capable of answering to any further Iudicatures? 2. The last step of conveening Heathens and Publicans before the Romane Senate, according to Christs order is not to be observed with them, for even Heathens and Publicans, are so far forth our brethren: that 1. We are not, when they offend us, to suffer sin in them, but to rebuke them as Christians, Lev. 19. 18. For this is the Law of nature: The Law of nature will teach us not to hate an Heathen in our heart. 2. We are to labour to gain all, even those that are without the Church, 1 Cor. 9. 19, 20, 21, 22. 1 Pet. 3. 1. And this is Christs way of gaining all, to rebuke and admonish them: Ergo, it was never Christs meaning to deal with Heathens and Publicans so, as at the first we are to drag them before the Heathen Magistrate, that by his sword he may gain them, or take away their life; yea, and Erastus granteth in Ecclesiasticall crimes, that the Iews had power of life and death, in the matter of Steven and of Paul, if he had not appealed to Cesar to save his head: Josephus de bel. Judaic. Lib. 5. Cap. 26. Antiquit. Lib. 14. Cap. 12. But in things politick, Cesar took all power of life and death from them: