Ans. 1. The eschewing of false Teachers is a general, and a duty1 no question given to all and every one of the Church: But the place doth no more say in express terms that a single Pastor should give warning particularly by name, that this man, John, Hymeneus, Alexander, are those false Teachers to be eschewed, then it saith, that the Presbytery, which we assert, doth in express terms, show what false Teachers they be, who by name are to be Excommunicated and eschewed; but you see, that Erastus is overcome by truth, so far, as he must say one single Minister may declare that such a false Teacher, by name, is to be eschewed as a Heathen and a Publican, and so in effect excommunicated, and put out of the Church; but he denieth that the Church may declare him a Heathen, as Matth. 18. and that many Elders, [Greek or Hebrew] gathered together in the name of Christ, as it is, 1 Cor. 5. may put out a false ⟨p. 378⟩Teacher, or a wolf out of the flock. 2. We grant that it is spoken to every one, that he should eschew false teachers, yea, and 2 Thes. 3. All that walketh unordinately, all fornicators, extortioners, drunkards, 1 Co•. 5. But that every man should eschew those, whom he in his private judgement conceiveth to be such, before he rebuke them, and labour to gain them, and in case of obstinacy, Tell the Church, as Christ commandeth, Matth. 18. is not commanded, bu• forbidden, Matth. 18. Lev. 1917. Col. 3. 15. For if this should be, that I might immediately, upon my own private grudge, unbrother and cast out of my heart and entire fellowship, every one whom I conceive offendeth me, and walketh unordinately, without observing Christs order, or previous rebuking of him, I make a pathway to perpetual Schisms: 2. A violation of all Laws of fraternity, and Christian Communion. 3. A dissolving and breaking of all Church Communion, and i• were strange, if Erastus will have Christs order kept, Matth. 18. in private offences done by one brother to another, and not in public offences, when a brother offendeth twenty, and a whole Church, as if I were obliged to seek to gain my brothers soul in private and l•sse injuries, and not in public, and more heinous offences.
Ans. 1. The eschewing of false Teachers is a generall, and a duty1 no question given to all and every one of the Church: But the place doth no more say in expresse terms that a single Pastor should give warning particularly by name, that this man, Iohn, Hymeneus, Alexander, are those false Teachers to be eschewed, then it saith, that the Presbytery, which we assert, doth in expresse termes, shew what false Teachers they be, who by name are to be Excommunicated and eschewed; but you see, that Erastus is overcome by truth, so far, as he must say one single Minister may declare that such a false Teacher, by name, is to be eschewed as a Heathen and a Publican, and so in effect excommunicated, and put out of the Church; but he denieth that the Church may declare him a Heathen, as Matth. 18. and that many Elders, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 gathered together in the name of Christ, as it is, 1 Cor. 5. may put out a false ⟨p. 378⟩Teacher, or a wolf out of the flock. 2. We grant that it is spoken to every one, that he should eschew false teachers, yea, and 2 Thes. 3. All that walketh unordinately, all fornicators, extortioners, drunkards, 1 Co•. 5. But that every man should eschew those, whom he in his private judgement conceiveth to be such, before he rebuke them, and labour to gain them, and in case of obst•n•cy, Tell the Church, as Christ commande•h, Matth. 18. is not commanded, bu• forbidden, Matth. 18. Lev. 1917. Col. 3. 15. For if this should be, that I might immediatly, upon my own private grudge, unbrother and cast out of my heart and intire fellowship, every one whom I conceive offendeth me, and walketh unordinately, without observing Christs order, or previous rebuking of him, I make a pathway to perpetuall Schismes: 2. A violation of all Laws of fraternity, and Christian Communion. 3. A diss•lving and breaking of all Church Communion, and i• were strange, if Erastus will have Christs order kept, Matth. 18. in private offences done by one brother to another, and not in publick offences, when a brother offendeth twenty, and a whole Church, as if I were obliged to seek to gain my brothers soul in private and l•sse injuries, and not in publick, and more hainous offences.
- 1To eschew the scandalous is materially to Excommunicatethem.