Ans. The Idolater that maketh defection, and the apostate were once Members of the Church; what hath made them now no Members? Who should judge them, and cast them out? the Magistrate? I answer, there is no Christian Magistrate: If the Church must do it, here truly, is all granted by Erastus, that he hath disputed against in six books, even this very Excommunication. But if there be a Christian Magistrate; what Scripture is there to warrant that he should cast out a Member out of Christs body? Here is an Excommunication without precept, promise, or practise in the word; we read that the Church of Corinth congregated together, hath a command to judge, and cast out a scandalous Member, 1 Cor. 5. 4, 5, 11, 12, 13. out from amongst the midst of them: Let Erastus say as much from the New Testament, for his Magistratical casting ou•. 2. What reason is there by Erastus his way, for casting out an idolater, and a man that defendeth his own wickedness? 1. May not God convert those suddenly; as he did the thief on the cross, and Saul? Ergo, They should not be cast out. 2. The Magistrate cannot more cut off those from being Members of Christs body; then he can remove their faith and internal communion with Christ. Now for this cause Erastus saith, the Church cannot Excommunicate, pag. 1. 2 Thess. 3. and 4. 3. Christ and the Apostles did neither cast out Judas, nor Scribes, Pharisees, or Publicans out of the Church, though they were worse then idolaters. 4. No helps of salvation are to be denied even to idolaters, and to men that defend their own wickedness, but their remaining in the Church amongst the godly, is a help of their salvation; and God inviteth them to repentance, and the staying in the Church; And the Sacraments are to Erastus means of repentance, and this casting out must be to save them: for no power is given of God to the Magistrate or Church for destruction, but for edification▪ Now to put them out of the Church, that they may be saved, is as Erastus conceiteth, ⟨p. 502⟩to cast a lascivious Virgin out of the company of chaste Matrons, to the end she may preserve her chastity: I speak here all in the language of Erastus, who useth all those against casting any out of the Church, by Presbyters; but they stand with equal strength, against his casting out of idolaters and apostates out of the Church, and so do the rest of his Arguments:
Ans. The Idolater that maketh defection, and the apostate were once Members of the Church; what hath made them now no Members? Who should judge them, and cast them out? the Magistrate? I answer, there is no Christian Magistrate: If the Church must do it, here truly, is all granted by Erastus, that he hath disputed against in six books, even this very Excommunication. But if there be a Christian Magistrate; what Scripture is there to warrant that he should cast out a Member out of Christs body? Here is an Excommunication without precept, promise, or practise in the word; we read that the Church of Corinth congregated together, hath a command to judge, and cast out a scandalous Member, 1 Cor. 5. 4, 5, 11, 12, 13. out from amongst the midst of them: Let Erastus say as much from the New Testament, for his Magistraticall casting ou•. 2. What reason is there by Erastus his way, for casting out an idolater, and a man that defendeth his owne wickednesse? 1. May not God convert those suddenly; as he did the thiefe on the crosse, and Saul? Ergo, They should not be cast out. 2. The Magistrate cannot more cut off those from being Members of Christs body; then he can remove their faith and internall communion with Christ. Now for this cause Erastus saith, the Church cannot Excommunicate, pag. 1. 2 Thess. 3. and 4. 3. Christ and the Apostles did neither cast out Iudas, nor Scribes, Pharisees, or Publicans out of the Church, though they were worse then idolaters. 4. No helps of salvation are to be denied even to idolaters, and to men that defend their owne wickednesse, but their remaining in the Church amongst the godly, is a helpe of their salvation; and God inviteth them to repentance, and the staying in the Church; And the Sacraments are to Erastus means of repentance, and this casting out must be to save them: for no power is given of God to the Magistrate or Church for destruction, but for edification▪ Now to put them out of the Church, that they may be saved, is as Erastus conceiteth, ⟨p. 502⟩to cast a lascivious Virgin out of the company of chaste Matr•ns, to the end she may preserve her chastity: I speak here all in the language of Erastus, who useth all those against casting any out of the Church, by Presbyters; but they stand with equall strength, against his casting out of idolaters and apostates out of the Church, and so do the rest of his Arguments: