Ans. 1. Erastus taketh ever for confessed, without any probation, that it is rectus usus, the right use of the holy things of God, that men with bloody hands use them, which is [Greek or Hebrew]: a most false principle, for he that killeth his children to Molech, and that same day cometh into the Sanctuary of God, is so far from the right using of the holy things of God, that the Lord saith expressly, his coming in in that condition to the Sanctuary is, (saith the Lord,) the profaning of my Sanctuary, Ezek. 23. 39. is this rectus usus Ceremoniarum? the right use of the holy things of God? It is not: 1. It is a forbidden use of holy things, Isa. 1. 13. Mat. 7. 6. Mat. 5. 23. 2. It is a rebuked use of holy things,1 Jer. 7. 9, 10, 11. Isa. 66. 3. 3. It is a profaning of holy things, Ezek. 23. 38, 39. 4. It is such a use as bringeth damnation to the party that useth it, 1 Cor. 11. 27, 29. and it is all these quoad externa, in external things. 2. Erastus could yield they be debarred, but by the Magistrate, not by Imaginary Presbyters. But all his Arguments, (as I show before) do prove they should be debarred, à recto usu, from the right use of holy things by no man, no more then they should be debarred from giving of alms, or reading the word, this is Erastus his own Argument; I pray you may the Magistrate, or any on earth by any authority inhibit a Malefactor, or a Murderer, who ought to die by the Magistrate, to read the Word, ⟨p. 499⟩to give alms, to pray for mercy to God, because he hath killed a man? 3. If heretics, apostates, open idolaters are to be debarred, by whom shall they be debarred: Erastus, pag. 207. thinketh they ought2 not to be admitted to the Sacraments, who shall debar them? The Magistrate, (saith he) But the Magistrate himself is the apostate, the heretic, the idolater. 2. He that may debar from the seals, may admit to the seals; he that may do both, Ex Officio, is the formal dispenser of the seals by office, that the Magistrate is not: He that may put out, or take in into the house by supreme power, is the Lord of the house: He who by office may admit some to the Table, and debar other some, is the Steward. But the Magistrate is neither the lord of the Church, nor the steward of the house, by office. We do not hold this consequence; the Lord commanded ill doers to be killed;
Ans. 1. Erastus taketh ever for confessed, without any probation, that it is rectus usus, the right use of the holy things of God, that men with bloodie hands use them, which is 〈non-Latin alphabet〉: a most false principle, for he that killeth his children to Molech, and that same day cometh into the Sanctuary of God, is so farre from the right using of the holy things of God, that the Lord saith expresly, his comming in in that condition to the Sanctuary is, (saith the Lord,) the prophaning of my Sanctuary, Ezek. 23. 39. is this rectus usus Ceremoniarum? the right use of the holy things of God? It is not: 1. It is a forbidden use of holy things, Isa. 1. 13. Mat. 7. 6. Mat. 5. 23. 2. It is a rebuked use of holy things,1 Ier. 7. 9, 10, 11. Isa. 66. 3. 3. It is a prophaning of holy things, Ezek. 23. 38, 39. 4. It is such a use as bringeth damnation to the party that useth it, 1 Cor. 11. 27, 29. and it is all these quoad externa, in externall things. 2. Erastus could yeeld they be debarred, but by the Magistrate, not by Imaginary Presbyters. But all his Arguments, (as I shew before) doe prove they should be debarred, à recto usu, from the right use of holy things by no man, no more then they should be debarred from giving of almes, or reading the word, this is Erastus his owne Argument; I pray you may the Magistrate, or any on earth by any authority inhibite a Malefactor, or a Murtherer, who ought to die by the Magistrate, to read the Word, ⟨p. 499⟩to give almes, to pray for mercy to God, because he hath killed a man? 3. If hereticks, apostates, open idolaters are to be debarred, by whom shall they be debarred: Erastus, pag. 207. thinketh they ought2 not to be admitted to the Sacraments, who shall debar them? The Magistrate, (saith he) But the Magistrate himselfe is the apostate, the heretick, the idolater. 2. He that may debarre from the seals, may admit to the seals; he that may do both, Ex Officio, is the formall dispenser of the seals by office, that the Magistrate is not: He that may put out, or take in into the house by supream power, is the Lord of the house: He who by office may admit some to the Table, and debarre other some, is the Steward. But the Magistrate is neither the lord of the Church, nor the steward of the house, by office. We do not hold this consequence; the Lord commanded ill doers to be killed;
- 1Erastus 341 sequitur (si faci•orosi sint arcendi • Sacrament is) eligendos esse qui malis interdieant oratione, lectione, Elcemosynarum distribution, &c.Erastus 341 sequitur (si faci•orosi sint arcendi • Sacrament is) eligendos esse qui malis interdieant oratione, lectione, Elcemosynarum distributione, &c.
- 2The Magistrate cannot admit, to, and debar from the Sacrament.