Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
The fifth trick of wit, is a distinction of qSuarez, That one 2and the same act of Adoration may be given, and is given in external Worship to the image and to God, but in reference to God, it is Latreia, the high Honouring of God, and in reference to the image, it is an inferior Veneration: So do our Formalists say, as rBurges saith▪ Adoration and Veneration differ not but by mens will; and if it be lawful to Adore God before the Ark, sWhy not at the Sacrament? The Bread and the Wine are Christ significative, (as the Ark had the title of Jehovah) by occasion of the elements, not as they are, but as they signify; we may tender a knee-worship, not at all to them, but only to God or Christ. And again, the holdeth it lawful to Adore the elements, but then Adoration as given to the elements, is Veneration, and Adoration in a large sense, 1 Chron. 29. 20. The people Worshipped God and the King: The outward Adoration was one, as the word by which it is expressed was one; but the Religious and Civill worship were distinct in the mind and intention of the worshippers. Edward, the 6. Book wsaith, Kneeling is to eschew profaning of the Sacrament. Opposite to profaning is external Religious honouring, expressed by kneeling, and that is Adoring. Hence one and that same Adoration and external bowing, is given to Bread and to Christ; but the mind and will of the Adorer maketh the same act in reference to Christ, Adoration, or Latreia, of the highest degree of honour; but in reference to the Bread, lawful Veneration of an inferior nature. Answer 1. If it were possible that the Wise could transmit her body in the act of Harlotry, by, or through a strange Lover to her Husband, her will and mind might change Adultery; if she saith, she giveth her body to a stranger, but in her mind and will intendeth to bring forth children to her own Husband: So if divers acts of the mind, make Religious
kneeling to a stock or Bread lawful, if one should Adore the man Judas as a memorial of Christ, his intention of will might save his Soul; if he say, I give one and the same external worship to Judas and to Christ: Or if Cornelius should say, I give one and the same knee▪ worship, to Peter and to Christ; but in my intention they be far different:
The fifth trick of wit, is a distinction of qSuarez, That one 2and the same act of Adoration may be given, and is given in externall Worship to the image and to God, but in reference to God, it is Latreia, the high Honouring of God, and in reference to the image, it is an inferior Veneration: So do our Formalists say, as rBurges saith▪ Adoration and Veneration differ not but by mens will; and if it be lawfull to Adore God before the Ark, sWhy not at the Sacrament? The Bread and the Wine are Christ significative, (as the Ark had the title of Iehovah) by occasion of the elements, not as they are, but as they signify; we may tender a knee-worship, not at all to them, but only to God or Christ. And again, the holdeth it lawfull to Adore the elements, but then Adoration as given to the elements, is Veneration, and Adoration in a large sence, 1 Chron. 29. 20. The people Worshipped God and the King: The outward Adoration was one, as the word by which it is expressed was one; but the Religious and Civill worship were distinct in the minde and intention of the worshippers. Edward, the 6. Book wsaith, Kneeling is to eschew prophaning of the Sacrament. Opposit to prophaning is externall Religious honouring, expressed by kneeling, and that is Adoring. Hence one and that same Adoration and externall bowing, is given to Bread and to Christ; but the minde and will of the Adorer maketh the same act in reference to Christ, Adoration, or Latreia, of the highest degree of honour; but in reference to the Bread, lawfull Veneration of an inferior nature. Answer 1. If it were possible that the Wise could transmit her body in the act of Harlotry, by, or through a strange Lover to her Husband, her will and minde might change Adultery; if she saith, she giveth her body to a stranger, but in her minde and will intendeth to bring forth children to her own Husband: So if divers acts of the minde, make Religious ⟨p. 170⟩kneeling to a stock or Bread lawfull, if one should Adore the man Iudas as a memoriall of Christ, his intention of will might save his Soul; if he say, I give one and the same externall worship to Iudas and to Christ: Or if Cornelius should say, I give one and the same knee▪ worship, to Peter and to Christ; but in my intention they be far different:
qSuarez, part. 3. to. 1. disp. 54. Sect. 3. Actus [Adorandi] respectu prototypi est proprie Latreia &c. Respectu vero imaginis est inferior Veneratio.
25. Distin.
rBurges, Lawfulness of kneeling cap. 8. p. 14, 15.Burges, Lawfulnes of kneeling cap. 8. p. 14, 15.
For I Worship Judas and Peter in that act with Civill homage Commanded in the fifth Commandment, as they be Christs Apostles, and represent him; but in that same I Worship Christ with the highest honour, called Latreia: Vasquez and Burges make them one external Worship. The three Children might have kneeled to the Image of Nebuchadnezzar, for their mind and will (as Formalists say) might have put another signification of honouring the Lord Jehovah, upon their knee-worship; and external kneeling could not have been denied to the Lord Jehovah; and so the three Children should not have given Divine honour and knee glory to the Image, and they were fools who did hazard their bodies to the fire: But wise men think, if they had given knee-worship (what ever their heart thought) they should have obeyed the King, yet they profess disobedience, Dan. 3. 18. We will not worship thy graven image. 2. Neither think we the Athenians gave that same honour to the similitude Act. 17. 29. of God, that they gave to the God that Paul Preached, who made Heaven and earth, v. 23, 24. Yet in giving Worship external to both, they were Idolaters, ver. 29. Nor did the men of Lystra give the same heart-honour to the Deities of Jupiter and Mercury, which they gave to the shapes of men; yet are they Idolaters in that. 3. Mr. Burges saith, Israel 1 Chron. 29. 20. in one and the same act (external) Worshipped God and the King, because one and the same word expresseth honour both to God and the King. But how shall we call that act? Civill, or Religious, or mixed? and did they transmit Latreia, divine honour through the King to God? he hath a Metaphysical faith who believeth such dreams, because one word is used to express both the worshipping of God and the King, therefore it was one external act of worshipping, and differenced in the mind and intention of the worshippers; the consequence is most weak, 1 Sam. 12. 18. All the people greatly feared the Lord and Samuel, Prov. 24. 21. My son, fear the Lord and the King, is it one manner of fear really, that is both religious to God, and to Samuel, and to the Lord, and the ⟨p. 171⟩King▪ because one word expresseth both?
For I Worship Iudas and Peter in that act with Civill homage Commanded in the fifth Commandment, as they be Christs Apostles, and represent him; but in that same I Worship Christ with the highest honour, called Latreia: Vasquez and Burges make them one externall Worship. The three Children might have kneeled to the Image of Nebuchadnezzer, for their minde and will (as Formalists say) might have put another signification of honouring the Lord Iehovah, upon their knee-worship; and externall kneeling could not have been denyed to the Lord Iehovah; and so the three Children should not have given Divine honour and kneeglory to the Image, and they were fooles who did hazard their bodies to the fire: But wisemen think, if they had given knee-worship (what ever their heart thought) they should have obeyed the King, yet they professe disobedience, Dan. 3. 18. We will not worship thy graven image. 2. Neither think we the Athenians gave that same honour to the similitude Act. 17. 29. of God, that they gave to the God that Paul Preached, who made Heaven and earth, v. 23, 24. Yet in giving Worship externall to both, they were Idolaters, ver. 29. Nor did the men of Lystra give the same heart-honour to the Deities of Iupiter and Mercury, which they gave to the shapes of men; yet are they Idolaters in that. 3. Mr. Burges saith, Israel 1 Chron. 29. 20. in one and the same act (externall) Worshipped God and the King, because one and the same word expresseth honour both to God and the King. But how shall we call that act? Civill, or Religious, or mixt? and did they transmit Latreia, divine honour through the King to God? he hath a Metaphysicall faith who beleeveth such dreames, because one word is used to expresse both the worshipping of God and the King, therefore it was one externall act of worshipping, and differenced in the minde and intention of the worshippers; the consequence is most weake, 1 Sam. 12. 18. All the people greatly feared the Lord and Samuel, Prov. 24. 21. My son, feare the Lord and the King, is it one manner of feare really, that is both religious to God, and to Samuel, and to the Lord, and the ⟨p. 171⟩King▪ because one word expresseth both?
I see not but one & the same action of bowing may be made to God, to Christ, to the water in Baptism, to the Bible, to the Sun and Moon, and we might kneel and Adore a Toad, a straw, and Satan, as they represent Gods wisdom and power, and through that same external knee-worship also Adore God: What, may we not then Religiously Adore all things and Creatures, as they represent God the first being.
I see not but one & the same action of bowing may be made to God, to Christ, to the water in Baptisme, to the Bible, to the Sun and Moon, and we might kneel and Adore a Toad, a straw, and Satan, as they represent Gods wisdom and power, and through that same externall knee-worship also Adore God: What, may we not then Religiously Adore all things and Creatures, as they represent God the first being.
As for Adoring of the Ark and foot-stool of God: 1. Joan. xGisenius, a Lutheran saith, The Jews had precept and promise to Worship God before the Ark, we have no Command to tie external Adoration to any place or Creature. 2. yDidoclavius saith, It is lawful to Adore God before the Ark, and the Symbols of his immediate presence, because God is there to receive his own Worship himself, by an immediate indwelling presence: For saith zMr. Weames, He appeared in glory above the Ark, betwixt the Cherubims, and it 4was a type of Christ who dwelt in our flesh; but it is not lawful to Worship him, before the Symbols of his grace. 3. The Ark was a type in the act of teaching, we grant; but that it was in the act of Adoring, God who was immediately present, and a Symbol Vicegerent of God, we read not. There is no need of mediate signs, where God is immediately present, and Adored as he was in the Ark; they were to fix both senses and thoughts immediately upon God. 4. They were to worship, not the Ark, but the precept is, & incurvate vos scabello, Worship toward the Ark. aArias Mont. turneth it, Worship to the Ark: The Greek Fathers of the second Nicene. Council, ignorant of the Hebrew Tongue, would have the Lord Commanding to Adore his foot-stool; whereas the Particle ([Greek or Hebrew]) is a note of the Dative case, and often it signifieth motion to a thing, or at a place, [Greek or Hebrew] ad dextram, and doth not absolutely signify the accusative case. bMusculus ad Scabellum, ⟨p. 172⟩he maketh it the Ark of the Testament. Calvin, cthe Temple. Junius, dmaketh it well to signify the measure of bowing, bow to the foot-stool, or ground, or pavement of the Temple where the Lords feet are, as he sate on the Cherubims, 1 Chron. 28. 1. For there is no ground for Adoring the Ark; but the words are to be read, Exalt the Lord our God, and bow your selves, (to wit, to Jehovah, who showeth himself, or dwelleth at his foot-stool) that is, betwixt the Cherubims, 2 Sam. 6. 1. For the word [Greek or Hebrew] at his foot-stool, is not constructed with the Verb, [Greek or Hebrew] incurvate vos: Jesuits and Formalists, devised that construction, but it is to be constructed with the word, [Greek or Hebrew] which is to be repeated from the former part of the verse, Bow your selves to Jehovah who dwelleth in the Ark, or in the Temple: A familiar eleipsis to the Hebrews, Psal.
As for Adoring of the Ark and foot-stool of God: 1. Ioan. xGisenius, a Lutheran saith, The Iews had precept and promise to Worship God before the Ark, we have no Command to tye externall Adoration to any place or Creature. 2. yDidoclavius saith, It is lawfull to Adore God before the Ark, and the Symboles of his immediate presence, because God is there to receive his own Worship himself, by an immediate indwelling presence: For saith zMr. Weames, He appeared in glory above the Ark, betwixt the Cherubims, and it 4was a type of Christ who dvvelt in our flesh; but it is not lavvfull to Worship him, before the Symboles of his grace. 3. The Ark was a type in the act of teaching, we grant; but that it was in the act of Adoring, God who was immediately present, and a Symboll Vicegerent of God, we reade not. There is no need of mediate signes, where God is immediately present, and Adored as he was in the Ark; they were to fixe both senses and thoughts immediately upon God. 4. They were to worship, not the Ark, but the precept is, & incurvate vos scabello, Worship tovvard the Ark. aArias Mont. turneth it, Worship to the Ark: The Greek Fathers of the second Nicen. Councel, ignorant of the Hebrew Tongue, would have the Lord Commanding to Adore his foot-stool; whereas the Particle (〈non-Latin alphabet〉) is a note of the Dative case, and often it signifieth motion to a thing, or at a place, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 ad dextram, and doth not absolutely signifie the accusative case. bMusculus ad Scabellum, ⟨p. 172⟩he maketh it the Ark of the Testament. Calvine, cthe Temple. Iunius, dmaketh it well to signifie the measure of bowing, bow to the foot-stool, or ground, or pavement of the Temple where the Lords feet are, as he sate on the Cherubims,
xJoan. Gisenive in •uo Patisi•o, disp. 25, n. 40.Joan. Giseniue in •uo Patisi•o, disp. 25, n. 40.
yDidocl. in Altari damasc. Hospinianus de originc festorum Christian. contra. Gretser. Profeste corporis Christi, fol: 94. 7. Arca non est bab••a pro d•• vivente,—nec propterea adorata. So answereth Molinaus in his buckler of faith of Images, Sect. 118. and Fran. Whites way to the Church, Cap. 9. pag. 3.
zWeames 3. Volume of the Ceremon. Law, Cap. 3. pag. 12.Weames 3. Volumn of the Ceremon. Law, Cap. 3. pag. 12.
4The place (worship at his footstool) discussed.
aArias Montanus. [Greek or Hebrew].Arias Montanus. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
dJunius, Annotation ibid. Lyranus a dorandam Deum aute arcam, non ipsam arcam. Tylenus in syntag nat. de preca. disp. 49. th. 2. nu. 29. particula. [Greek or Hebrew]. Notat idem quod versus. Vatablus adorate ad scabellum, i. e. in templo ante arcam.Junius, Annotation ibid. Lyranus a dorandam Deum aute arcam, non ipsam arcam. Tylenus in syntag nat. de preca. disp. 49. th. 2. nu. 29. particula. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Notat idem quod versus. Vatablus adorate ad scabellum, i. e. in templo ante arcam.
5. 8. I will bow my self (to the Jehovah dwelling) in the Temple of thy holiness, as we are taught, Our Father which art in Heaven: So [Greek or Hebrew] and it is a description of God from the place where he dwelt, and exhibited his presence to his rude people. 4. It is ignorance in Burges to prove God may be Adored in the elements, because they are as excellent Symbols of Gods presence as the Ark: for created excellency is no ground of Adoring the elements, except it be a Godhead, and uncreated excellency: We condemn Pope eAnastasius, who directeth Reverend bowing at the hearing of the Gospel, and not of the Epistles, as if the Gospel were holier then the Epistles.
5. 8. I will bow my self (to the Iehovah dwelling) in the Temple of thy holinesse, as we are taught, Our Father which art in Heaven: So 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 and it is a description of God from the place where he dwelt, and exhibited his presence to his rude people. 4. It is ignorance in Burges to prove God may be Adored in the elements, because they are as excellent Symbols of Gods presence as the Ark: for created excellency is no ground of Adoring the elements, except it be a Godhead, and uncreated excellency: We condemne Pope eAnastasius, who directeth Reverend bowing at the hearing of the Gospel, and not of the Epistles, as if the Gospel were holier then the Epistles.
eGratian de conser. dist. 1. cap. 68. Prayer may as lawfully be given to the Creature as Adoration. There is a Prayer made to the image of the face of Jesus written in linen, Salve Sancta facies nostri redemptoris salve vultus domini imago beata,—nos deduc ad propria • felix figura, ad videndum faciem qua est Christi pura.Gratian de conser. dist. 1. cap. 68. Prayer may as lawfully be given to the Creature as Adoration. There is a Prayer made to the image of the face of Jesus written in linnen, Salve Sancta facies nostri redemptoris salve vultus domini imago beata,—nos deduc ad propria • felix figura, ad videndum faciem qua est Christi pura.
But if Adoration may be given to the elements, because knee worship signifieth according to humane institution, and mans will, and are taken from customs of men, and so doth signify less honour then is due to God: Let me be resolved of this doubt, words of Prayer signify according to mens institution and their will, no less then Religious gestures do, and we may say to a stock, (Thou art my Father) and it is in our will that (Father) signify a representative Father, not an infinite and Independent Father, such as God only is.
But if Adoration may be given to the elements, because kneeworship signifieth according to humane institution, and mans will, and are taken from customes of men, and so doth signifie lesse honour then is due to God: Let me be resolved of this doubt, words of Prayer signifie according to mens institution and their will, no lesse then Religious gestures do, and we may say to a stock, (Thou art my Father) and it is in our will that (Father) signifie a representative Father, not an infinite and Independent Father, such as God only is.
And if the image in external kneeling, be Adored Per aliud, or co-adored with the Sampler, because it is one with the Sampler; Why may we not pray to the image, and fix our faith and hope on ⟨p. 173⟩the image and elements by co-adoration, or in relative praying and trusting in them? Yet fthe Fathers of Trent for shame deny that we should pray to images, and put our trust in them: yet do Formalists turn the enunciative words of Christ (This is my body) in an optative mood, and a Prayer, The body and blood of Christ (they mean the elements in their hands) preserve thee to eternal life: And we are not ignorant, that faith and hope are ascribed to the Cross, and this sung in the Church of Rome:
And if the image in externall kneeling, be Adored Per aliud, or co-adored with the Samplar, because it is one with the Samplar; Why may we not pray to the image, and fixe our faith and hope on ⟨p. 173⟩the image and elements by co-adoration, or in relative praying and trusting in them? Yet fthe Fathers of Trent for shame deny that we should pray to images, and put our trust in them: yet do Formalists turn the enunciative words of Christ (This is my body) in an optative mood, and a Prayer, The body and blood of Christ (they mean the elements in their hands) preserve thee to eternall life: And we are not ignorant, that faith and hope are ascribed to the Crosse, and this sung in the Church of Rome:
A Learned Papist, gRaphael de la Torres saith plainly, It is lawful to pray to images, so the inward devotion be directed to God: But if the Jews in their Idolatrous worship acknowledged the image to be but a representation of God, and a Book, Jer. 10. 8. They did no wrong who said Jer. 2. ver. 27. to a stock, Thou art my father, and to a stone, Thou hast brought me forth: For condition maketh all, if they speak by a figure; for the Papists when they speak to the Cross, and call the Cross their only hope, the Cross is not better born nor a stock, it is but timber or dumb wood: Now how doth not the dumb wood to which Prayers are made, as if Christ himself were present, partake of Prayers and Gods honour, in an inferior and relative way? For the wood standeth before him who prayeth to it, as God by representation, and as an actual Vicegerent, and tree-deputy of God and Christ; it is no less worshipful by mouth-worship, by praying to it, as to the passive object of Adoration, as capable of knee-worship by bowing down to it; and a distinction may save idolatry in the one, as well as in the other: And our Formalists bowing Religiously to bread, do not Adore bread, (as our half Papists say) and so may they pray to bread, and not Adore bread, for they are as well masters of Grammar, to impose significations at their will upon words, as they be Lords of gestures and Ceremonies, to cause kneeling express Veneration to the images, and to elements, and not Divine Adoration.
A Learned Papist, gRaphael de la Torres saith plainly, It is lawfull to pray to images, so the inward devotion be directed to God: But if the Iews in their Idolatrous worship acknoweledged the image to be but a representation of God, and a Book, Jer. 10. 8. They did no wrong who said Ier. 2. ver. 27. to a stock, Thou art my father, and to a stone, Thou hast brought me forth: For condition maketh all, if they speak by a figure; for the Papists when they speak to the Crosse, and call the Crosse their only hope, the Crosse is not better born nor a stock, it is but timber or dumbe wood: Now how doth not the dumbe wood to which Prayers are made, as if Christ himself were present, partake of Prayers and Gods honour, in an inferior and relative way? For the wood standeth before him who prayeth to it, as God by representation, and as an actuall Vicegerent, and tree-deputy of God and Christ; it is no lesse worshipfull by mouth-worship, by praying to it, as to the passive object of Adoration, as capable of knee-worship by bowing down to it; and a distinction may save idolatry in the one, as well as in the other: And our Formalists bowing Religiously to bread, do not Adore bread, (as our half Papists say) and so may they pray to bread, and not Adore bread, for they are as well masters of Grammar, to impose significations at their will upon words, as they be Lords of gestures and Ceremonies, to cause kneeling expresse Veneration to the images, and to elements, and not Divine Adoration.
gRaphael de la Torres in 22. q. 95 art 2. disp. 6. dub. 5. Eusebius, lib. 3. De praeparat. Evang. teacheth us, that Rudiores tantum ad ligna & lapides respiciunt, sapientes autem (Gentiles) voluerunt Deum & dci virtutes sensibus nostris per imagines nobis familiariter deferri. They made Images books of God. Athanasius in orat. contr. idolat. Dieunt Philosophi statuas quidem non essedcos, sed simulacbra deorum, ideo baberi ut dys sub istis imaginibus respondeant.
Here two great Jesuits, Suarez and Vasquez help the matter for hSuarez saith, There be some acts of worship as faith and prayer, which precisely respect a reasonable and intelligent person, therefore this prayer (Hail *cross) it is a figurative speech, and a Metonymy, continens pro re contenta; and the speech is directed to him who was crucified, and therefore a prayer (saith this Idolater) is considered ut petitio, vel ut honor quidam, either as a petition, and so it is not directed but to God, but as prayer is an honour expressed in such words and signs, the image also is thought to be honoured by praying to it, as the sampler to wit Christ, is honoured; soft words. Answ. 1. If praying and believing3 do properly respect a reasonable creature, so doth positive honouring which is esteemed, by the law of nature, praemium virtutis, a reward of virtue; now virtue moral to be a foundation of honour, is as vainly given to a tree, or a stock, as faith and prayer, but to speak to any in prayer, and make our requests known to them may be thought proper only to a reasonable person, who only can understand our prayer, and in reason answer our necessities, which a stock cannot do: but secondly, I answer a stock is by Analogy, and as it is God representatively, as capable of reason to answer, and help us, and pity us, in respect it can notably well represent the Majesty of God, who can answer, help, and pity, as our Idolaters teach, as it is capable of knee-worship, and that honour which is given to God, though in an higher degree; for the formal reason why Images and elements are capable of knee-glory, due to him who sweareth that all knees shall how to him, is, because they represent God, and not because of themselves they have any divinity or Godhead in them. Now the same formal reason holdeth here, for the cross, stone, tree, or elements that are prayed unto in that religious state, as they are the object of praying, do represent God, therefore they are also capable of faith and prayer, glory, as of knee-worship, or knee-glory. 2.
Here two great Iesuites, Suarez and Vasquez helpe the matter for hSuarez saith, There be some acts of worship as faith and prayer, which precisely respect a reasonable and intelligent person, therefore this prayer (Haile *crosse) it is a figurative speech, and a Metonymie, continens pro re contenta; and the speech is directed to him who was crucified, and therefore a prayer (saith this Idolater) is considered ut petitio, vel ut honor quidam, either as a petition, and so it is not directed but to God, but as prayer is an honour expressed in such words and signes, the image also is thought to be honoured by praying to it, as the samplar to wit Christ, is honoured; soft words. Answ. 1. If praying and beleeving3 doe properly respect a reasonable creature, so doth positive honouring which is esteemed, by the law of nature, praemium virtutis, a reward of vertue; now vertue morall to be a foundation of honour, is as vainly given to a tree, or a stocke, as faith and prayer, but to speak to any in prayer, and make our requests known to them may be thought proper onely to a reasonable person, who onely can understand our prayer, and in reason answer our necessities, which a stock cannot doe: but secondly, I answer a stock is by Analogie, and as it is God representatively, as capable of reason to answer, and helpe us, and pitty us, in respect it can notably well represent the Majestie of God, who can answer, helpe, and pitty, as our Idolaters teach, as it is capable of knee-worship, and that honour which is given to God, though in an higher degree; for the formall reason why Images and elements are capable of knee-glory, due to him who sweareth that all knees shall how to him, is, because they represent God, and not because of themselves they have any divinity or Godhead in them. Now the same formall reason holdeth here, for the crosse, stone, tree, or elements that are prayed unto in that religious state, as they are the object of praying, doe represent God, therefore they are also capable of faith and prayer, glory, as of knee-worship, or knee-glory. 2.
Faith, hope, and charity (as iSuarez saith) in so far as they are given to God, for giving of honour to him as to the supreme Lord, they put on the nature of adoration, and in that same place he defineth adoration to be the exhibition of honour due to any in the acknowledgement of excellency and submission and service due to him: Now Suarez reproveth Durandus and Pic. Mirandula, because they denied that the Image was adored, but would only have honour given to ⟨p. 175⟩God, at the naked presence of the Image, as a memorable sign, but it is certain, as to trust in God, and to pray to him is incommunicable to the creature, so to adore any in acknowledgement of supreme excellency is incommunicable to the creature, therefore either the image is adored with the same knee-worship that is given to God, and that improperly and by a figure, as Durandus and Mirandula taught contrary to the mind of Suarez, and idolatrous Jesuits and F•rmalists, or else prayers may be made to wood and stone, as to God, and that properly and without a figure; as knee-worship is tendered to wood and stone by Jesuits doctrine, prope••y and without a figure. 3. Papists deny that sacrifices may be offered to Images, yet they burn incense to images; but that is not, saith ka Franciscan Antonius Capellus, a sacrifice, for it is tendered to men, to dead carrions, and to things that are blessed, and requireth neither Altar, nor Priest: It is true, they say so, but burning incense to the brazen Serpent is condemned as Idolatry, and Altar and Priest is not of the essence of a sacrifice; but however as sacrificing is a recognition that we hold all we have of God, and therefore we sacrifice creatures to him, so any adoring of stocks is an acknowledgement that these stocks or stones are by way of representation, that God of whom we hold all the creatures: and do not Papists for the honour of God, make oblations to Ministers, and burn incense to Saints? and why may not prayers be offered to them also? 4. It is a wild distinction where he faith that prayers as honour may be tendered to Images, but not prayers as petitions, whereas the very act of calling upon God in the day of trouble, Psal. 50. 15. is an honouring and glorifying God, and praying to God is due to God, as he is to be believed in, and to be preached amongst men, Rom. 10. 14. 15.
Faith, hope, and charity (as iSuarez saith) in so farre as they are given to God, for giving of honour to him as to the supream Lord, they put on the nature of adoration, and in that same place he defineth adoration to be the exhibition of honour due to any in the acknowlegement of excellency and submission and service due to him: Now Suarez reprooveth Durandus and Pic. Mirandula, because they denied that the Image was adored, but would onely have honour given to ⟨p. 175⟩God, at the naked presence of the Image, as a memorable signe, but it is certaine, as to trust in God, and to pray to him is incommunicable to the creature, so to adore any in acknowledgement of supreame excellencie is incommunicable to the creature, therefore either the image is adored with the same knee-worship that is given to God, and that improperly and by a figure, as Durandus and Mirandula taught contrary to the mind of Suarez, and idolatrous Iesuites and F•rmalists, or else prayers may be made to wood and stone, as to God, and that properly and without a figure; as knee-worship is tendered to wood and stone by Iesuits doctrine, prope••y and without a figure. 3. Papists deny that sacrifices may be offered to Images, yet they burne incense to images; but that is not, saith ka Fransciscan Antonius Capellus, a sacrifice, for it is tendred to men, to dead carions, and to things that are blessed, and requireth neither Altar, nor Priest: It is true, they say so, but burning incense to the brazen Serpent is condemned as Idolatry, and Altar and Priest is not of the essence of a sacrifice; but however as sacrificing is a recognition that we hold all we have of God, and therefore we sacrifice creatures to him, so any adoring of stocks is an acknowledgement that these stocks or stones are by way of representation, that God of whom we hold all the creatures: and doe not Papists for the honour of God, make oblations to Ministers, and burn incense to Saints? and why may not prayers be offered to them also? 4. It is a wild distinction where he faith that prayers as honour may be tendered to Images, but not prayers as petitions, whereas the very act of calling upon God in the day of trouble, Psal. 50. 15. is an honouring and glorifying God, and praying to God is due to God, as he is to be beleeved in, and to be preached amongst men, Rom. 10. 14. 15.
And so is he worthy to be glorified as the subject of preaching; then it is a vain thing to difference betwixt petitioning to God, and honouring God, because in that I petition God, in my necessities, I submit to him as to God, who can answer and hear prayers: If therefore the Image and the wood be capable of the honour of praying, it is also capable of the honour of petitioning, so as we may as properly petition and supplicate the stock, as give to it the glory of prayers. 5. If Formalists say in the third person, (the body Sacramental of the Lord save thee,) they may upon the same ground say, (O thou Sacramental body of the Lord save me) for this ⟨p. 176⟩is a prayer to God, (O that God would save his people,) no less then this, (O God save thy people,) the variation of persons in the Grammar, maketh not the one to be a prayer, and not the other. Vasquez lsaith, There is not alike reason, why praises, prayers, and Sacrifices should be tendered to Idols, & knee-worship & Adoration, because from the affection of Adoring the sampler, there is derived an external note of submission to the image, which by a common name is called the honour, Worship and Adoration tendered to the image in a bodily manner, and being done before the image, tendeth to the honouring of the sampler; but the outward action of Praising, Praying, Sacrificing, is commonly called Praising, Praying, Sacrificing, in relation to the Sampler, to wit, God, and no way in relation to the image, or to things without life; neither are they by accident referred to the images, only they be tendered to God before images, Coram illis. But I Answer, This is but to beg the Question, for we deny, that from Adoring the image, there resulteth any Adoring of God, but a great dishonouring of his Name. 2. Durandus, Mirandula, Hulcot, deny that Adoring of God, Coram imaginibus tanquam signis memorativis, before the images as memorials of God, should be an Adoring of the images: And Suarez saith, If images be only remembrances and memorials in the act of Adoration, this taketh much honour from the images, and is, saith mhe, An Adoring of the Sampler, but not an Adoring of the image: Though nVasquez; expounding Gregory's mind, (which superstitious man calleth them, ogood books) contradict Suarez in this, yea, and himself also;
And so is he worthy to be glorified as the subject of preaching; then it is a vaine thing to difference betwixt peti•ioning to God, and honouring God, because in that I petition God, in my necessities, I submit to him as to God, who can answer and heare prayers: If therefore the Image and the wood be capable of the honour of praying, it is also capable of the honour of petitioning, so as we may as properly petition and supplicate the stocke, as give to it the glory of prayers. 5. If Formalists say in the third person, (the body Sacramentall of the Lord save thee,) they may upon the same ground say, (O thou Sacramentall body of the Lord save me) for this ⟨p. 176⟩is a prayer to God, (O that God would save his people,) no lesse then this, (O God save thy people,) the variation of persons in the Grammar, maketh not the one to be a prayer, and not the other. Vasquez lsaith, There is not alike reason, why praises, prayers, and Sacrifices should be tendred to Idols, & knee-worship & Adoration, because from the affection of Adoring the samplar, there is derived an externall note of submission to the image, which by a common name is called the honour, Worship and Adoration tendred to the image in a bodily manner, and being done before the image, tendeth to the honouring of the samplar; but the outward action of Praising, Praying, Sacrificing, is commonly called Praising, Praying, Sacrificing, in relation to the Samplar, to wit, God, and no way in relation to the image, or to things without life; neither are they by accident referred to the images, only they be tendred to God before images, Coram illis. But I Answer, This is but to beg the Question, for we deny, that from Adoring the image, there resulteth any Adoring of God, but a great dishonouring of his Name. 2. Durandus, Mirandula, Hulcot, deny that Adoring of God, Coram imaginibus tanquam signis memorativis, before the images as memorials of God, should be an Adoring of the images: And Suarez saith, If images be only remembrances and memorials in the act of Adoration, this taketh much honour from the images, and is, saith mhe, An Adoring of the Samplar, but not an Adoring of the image: Though nVasquez; expounding Gregories minde, (which superstitious man calleth them, ogood books) contradict Suarez in this, yea, and himself also;
mSuarez tom. 1. in 3. q. 25. art. 3. disp. 54. Sect. 5. Si tantum coram imaginibus Adoratur deus, hoc multum derogat imaginum venerationi, nam •x eo non tantum sequitur imagines [clementa Sacramentalia] minus coli, quam exemplaria, sed etiam sequitur illas non coli omnius,—sed exemplaria tantum.
nVasquez, tom. 1. part. 3. q. 25. disp. 108. cap. 14. Nam iconomachi qui ad solam recordationem imaginibus utuntur, ante illas genu• a non flectunt nec se prostemunt; sic enim ipsas not• exteriore adorarent, sed erecti absque ullo corporis gestu, qui reverentiam indicet, •oram imagine exemplaris recordantur, & ipsum spiritu solum adorant.
oGregorius Mag. l. 7. Epist. 53. if these be his Epistles.
for he saith, The enemies of images (he meaneth the Reformed Churches) who use them only for memorials and books, (it is a lye that we use them as books,) will not bow their knee to them, for then (saith he) they should Adore them; and therefore (saith Vasquez,) if Christ be not in very deed, in his presence in the Sacrament present, the knee-worship is tendered to bread and wine, which is (saith he) Idolatry; therefore either our Formalists are Transubstantiators, or Idolaters, or both; ⟨p. 177⟩by this learned Jesuits judgement, and why by this same reason may we not say against pVasquez, that the bodily offerings of prayers, praises, and sacrifices to God, before the Image as the Image, is an honouring of the Image by prayer, they say to the tree of the Cross.
for he saith, The enemies of images (he meaneth the Reformed Churches) who use them only for memorials and books, (it is a lye that we use them as books,) will not bow their knee to them, for then (saith he) they should Adore them; and therefore (saith Vasquez,) if Christ be not in very deed, in his presence in the Sacrament present, the knee-worship is tendred to bread and wine, which is (saith he) Idolatry; therefore either our Formalists are Transubstantiators, or Idolaters, or both; ⟨p. 177⟩by this learned Iesuites judgement, and why by this same reason may we not say against pVasquez, that the bodily offerings of prayers, prayses, and sacrifices to God, before the Image as the Image, is an honouring of the Image by prayer, they say to the tree of the Crosse.
pVasquez ibid. He who adoreth a saint (saith Joan. d• lugo de myster. inincarnat disp. 36. sect. 3. n. 29.) for friendship and grace which he hath arguitivè, by consequence he worshipeth God of whom the man hath grace, yet it is not needful that he formally adore God, and in recto in so doing for he may honour the saint and not formally honour God, for the saint and God are two divers objects. Answ. This proveth our point, that when I adore an Image, intending to adore God, some •oule-adoration adhereth to the Image, and that is a taste of Gods proper glory given to a stock, or a stone.Vasquez ibid. Hee who adoreth a saint (saith Ioan. d• lugo de myster. inincarnat disp. 36. sect. 3. n. 29.) for friendship and grace which hee hath arguitivè, by consequence hee worshipeth God of whom the man hath grace, yet it is not needfull that he formally adore God, and in recto in so doing for he may honour the saint and not formally honour God, for the saint and God are two divers objects. Answ. This proveth our point, that when I adore an Image, intending to adore God, some •oule-adoration adhereth to the Image, and that is a taste of Gods proper glory given to a stocke, or a stone.
Increase righteousness in us, and give remission of sins, O tree cross to guilty sinners. Names at Rome go as men will, but the honour it self is put upon the dumb wood, which is due to Christ. O it is but a figure (say they) yea but (say we) prayers and praises in a bodily manner, and vocally are tendered to the wood, yet if the wife commit adultery with her husbands brother, because he representeth her husband, I think the matter should be washen with Ink, and badly excused to say, O the loving wife for strong love to her husband committeth figurative adultery, and that bodily harlotry is referred to the brother of her husband by accident, and to her husband kindly, and per se, for himself. The same way, if Formalists bow their knee to bread, that such a holy mystery be not profaned. We know they cannot understand civill or countrey non-prophanation, that they intend; for kneeling and evil manners at the Lords table do well consist together. Now religious nonprophanation by knee-worship, is adoring of these mysterious elements. Ergo they make prayers and sing praises, and offer sacrifices to the bread, Let them see to this and answer to it if they can. The sixth evasion of wit, I find in qJohannes de Lugo, who saith, 1. That the image and sampler making one and the same object, by aggregation, the inward affection besides external knee-worship is given to both, but to the Image relatively, and for God or the sampler, and not for proper divine excellency in it, and therefore the Councils (saith he) call it not adoration in spiritu, but it is tendered to God absolutely. ⟨p. 178⟩2. We give adoration of internal submission to God, or the sampler as the debt of potestative justice, but we do not so worship the Image, we have no civill or politic communication with the Image, 2because it is not a reasonable creature, and therefore the worship of the Image is as it were a material and lifeless action; when we uncover our head to the Image, by that action we would say or signify nothing to the Image, but to the sampler, or to God only. 3. The inward submission that we tender to the Image, is not that we submit to it, as to a thing more excellent then we, for that were a foolish lye;
Increase righteousnesse in us, and give remission of sinnes, O tree crosse to guilty sinners. Names at Rome goe as men will, but the honour it selfe is put upon the dumbe wood, which is due to Christ. O it is but a figure (say they) yea but (say we) prayers and praises in a bodily manner, and vocally are tendred to the wood, yet if the wife commit adultery with her husbands brother, because he representeth her husband, I thinke the matter should be washen with Inke, and badly excused to say, O the loving wife for strong love to her husband committeth figurative adultery, and that bodily harlotry is referred to the brother of her husband by accident, and to her husband kindly, and per se, for himselfe. The same way, if Formalists bow their knee to bread, that such a holy mystery be not prophaned. We know they cannot understand civill or countrey non-prophanation, that they intend; for kneeling and evill maners at the Lords table doe well consist together. Now religious nonprophanation by knee-worship, is adoring of these mysterious elements. Ergo they make prayers and sing praises, and offer sacrifices to the bread, Let them see to this and answer to it if they can. The sixt evasion of wit, I find in qJohannes de Lugo, who saith, 1. That the image and samplar making one and the same object, by aggregation, the inward affection besides externall knee-worship is given to both, but to the Image relatively, and for God or the samplar, and not for proper divine excellencie in it, and therefore the Councels (saith he) call it not adoration in spiritu, but it is tendered to God absolutely. ⟨p. 178⟩2. We give adoration of internall submission to God, or the samplar as the debt of potestative justice, but we doe not so worship the Image, we have no civill or politick communication with the Image, 2because it is not a reasonable creature, and therefore the worship of the Image is as it were a materiall and livelesse action; when we uncover our head to the Image, by that action we would say or signifie nothing to the Image, but to the samplar, or to God onely. 3. The inward submission that we tender to the Image, is not that we submit to it, as to a thing more excellent then we, for that were a foolish lye;
qJoan. de lugo. de myst. incar. disp. 36. sect. 3. n. 25, 26, 27. & seq. Respectus imaginis est quasi materialis & inanimatus, quia sic ap•rimus caput imagini, ut per illam actionem nihil velimus imagini dicere aut significare, sed soli exemplari, ad quod dirigitur ille actus pro ut significativus & prout civilis communicatio; & ideo respectu illius solum videtur esse actio animata. De Lugo ibid. Hoc enim esset stultum mendacium, quia absoluté loquend• meliores sumus nos quam Imago sancti Petri. And conform to this the seventh pretended and bastard Councell calleth them half holy, and half true, half false worshippers of God, Antonius Capellus citeth it, Advers. prim. regis Anglia, c. 30. Who will have Images to stand only for memorials, but not to be worshipped.Ioan. de lugo. de myst. incar. disp. 36. sect. 3. n. 25, 26, 27. & seq. Respectus imaginis est quasi materialis & inanimatus, quia sic ap•rimus caput imagini, ut per illam actionem nihil velimus imagini dicere aut significare, sed soli exemplari, ad quod dirigitur ille actus pro ut significativus & prout civilis communicatio; & ideo respectu illius solum videtur esse actio animata. De Lugo ibid. Hoc enim esset stultum mendacium, quia absoluté loquend• meliores sumus nos quam Imago sancti Petri. And conforme to this the seventh pretended and bastard Councell calleth them halfe holy, and halfe true, halfe false worshipers of God, Antonius Capellus citeth it, Advers. prim. regis Anglia, c. 30. Who will have Images to stand onely for memorialls, but not to be worshipped.
2Concil. seventh art. 1. p. 458. Qui vero dicunt su• nicer usum imaginum ad memoriam solum, non vero ad salutationem •as habentes illud quidem recipientes, hoc vero re•icien•es, s•miprobi quadantenus, & falso v•ti [ut ita dicam] deprehenduntur.Concil. seventh art. 1. p. 458. Qui vero dicunt su••icere usum imaginum ad memoriam solum, non vero ad salutationem •as habentes illud quidem recipientes, hoc vero re•icienes, smiprobi quadantenus, & falso vti [ut ita dicam] deprehenduntur.
yet (saith he) (that the man might fulfil the cup of the iniquity of his Fathers) we kiss not the Image in recto directly tendering honour to it, but to God and the sampler before it. 1. Because then I should adore my own breast when I knock upon it adoring the Eucharist. 2. Because so I bow to the wall before me. 3. If I have no honourable opinion of the Image, I do not adore it at all. 4. By kneeling to the Image, I have a will of submitting externally my affection to the Image, I yield to it▪ as a thing above me, giving to it the higher place 4. The act of adoration is simply terminated upon the Image, as a thing contra distinguished from the sampler, though it be adored with the same action with which the sampler is adored. Thus the •e•uite.
yet (saith he) (that the man might fulfill the cup of the iniquity of his Fathers) we kisse not the Image in recto directly tendring honour to it, but to God and the samplar before it. 1. Because then I should adore my owne breast when I knocke upon it adoring the Eucharist. 2. Because so I bow to the wall before me. 3. If I have no honourable opinion of the Image, I doe not adore it at all. 4. By kneeling to the Image, I have a will of submitting externally my affection to the Image, I yeeld to it▪ as a thing above me, giving to it the higher place 4. The act of adoration is simply terminated upon the Image, as a thing contra distinguished from the samplar, though it be adored with the same action with which the samplar is adored. Thus the •e•uite.
Answ. But here all men may see many contradictions, and that he casteth down all that formerly he hath said, ••. Images even as1 they represent God are dead things, and less then a redeemed Saint, Ergo, I can give them no submission of external honour. 2. I signify and say nothing of honour to the Image, even as it respecteth God, and representeth him, because the dignity of representing God doth not elevate it to be a reasonable creature, therefore I cannot honour it, and it were a foolish lye to say that the Image as representing God, were a reasonable creature. 3. As it representeth God, it cannot hear payers, nor deliver in trouble, as the Holy One of Israel can do; Ergo by the Holy Ghosts argument, I cannot bow to a lye, Esa. 44. 17. and 46. 9. Hab. 2. 19. 20. it made not the heaven and the earth, but by a figure, because it representeth the maker of heaven and earth, wherefore it should have but figurative honour at the best, and that is no real honour, Jer. 10. 8, 11, 12, 4. There is no debt of justice due to the dumb wood, or element, honour of external submission is a debt of potestative justice due to a superior, the Images and Elements are not my superior. ⟨p. 179⟩1. They be means, I the end. 2. They be void of life and reason which I have. 3. They are not redeemed, sanctified, and to be glorified as I am. Joan. de Lugo answereth, As I may love Peter for the goodness that is not in Peter but in another, as I may love and desire good to Peter, for the goodness that is in his father, and not in himself, and so pay the debt of affection to him for another, so I may honour an Image for the debt of honour that I owe to the sampler represented by the Image, therefore it is not required to the essence of adoration, that we acknowledge debt due to every thing adored for another; it is sufficient a debt be acknowledged, either to the Image, or the sampler. Answ. The debt of love and the debt of honour are not alike. I owe honour to superiors only as superiors, I owe love to superiors, equals, inferiors. If I truly adore an Image, I truly acknowledge excellency in the Image, I truly yield to it, a worthier place then I deserve to have my selfe, (saith rde Lugo) Ergo, by the fifth Commandment according to the debt of justice, I owe fear, honour, and reverence to it, else I adore it by a figure, which the Jesuit doth deny.
Answ. But here all men may see many contradictions, and that he casteth downe all that formerly he hath said, ••. Images even as1 they represent God are dead things, and lesse then a redeemed Saint, Ergo, I can give them no submission of externall honour. 2. I signifie and say nothing of honour to the Image, even as it respecteth God, and representeth him, because the dignity of representing God doth not elevate it to be a reasonable creature, therefore I cannot honour it, and it were a foolish lye to say that the Image as representing God, were a reasonable creature. 3. As it representeth God, it cannot heare payers, nor deliver in trouble, as the Holy One of Israel can doe; Ergo by the Holy Ghosts argument, I cannot bow to a lye, Esa. 44. 17. and 46. 9. Hab. 2. 19. 20. it made not the heaven and the earth, but by a figure, because it representeth the maker of heaven and earth, wherefore it should have but figurative honour at the best, and that is no reall honour, Jer. 10. 8, 11, 12, 4. There is no debt of justice due to the dumb wood, or element, honour of externall submission is a debt of potestative justice due to a superiour, the Images and Elements are not my superiour. ⟨p. 179⟩1. They be meanes, I the end. 2. They bee void of life and reason which I have. 3. They are not redeemed, sanctified, and to be glorified as I am. Ioan. de Lugo answereth, As I may love Peter for the goodnesse that is not in Peter but in another, as I may love and desire good to Peter, for the goodnesse that is in his father, and not in himself, and so pay the debt of affection to him for another, so I may honour an Image for the debt of honour that I owe to the samplar represented by the Image, therefore it is not required to the essence of adoration, that we acknowledge debt due to every thing adored for another; it is sufficient a debt be acknowledged, either to the Image, or the samplar. Answ. The debt of love and the debt of honour are not alike. I owe honour to superiours onely as superiours, I owe love to superiours, equals, inferiours. If I truly adore an Image, I truly acknowledge excellency in the Image, I truly yeeld to it, a worthier place then I deserve to have my selfe, (saith rde Lugo) Ergo, by the fifth Commandement according to the debt of justice, I owe feare, honour, and reverence to it, else I adore it by a figure, which the Iesuite doth deny.
1Answ.
rDe Lugo ibid. 39. imagines vere cedo exterius, daudo illi meliorē & superiorem loam honorifice eam tracta• do.De Lugo ibid. 39. imagi•s vere cedo exterius, daudo illi meliorē & superiorem lo•um honorifice eam tracta• do.
I am not afraid that they say, Damascene, sa superstitious Monk alloweth Images to be adored. So doeth tthat pretended seventh Synod, or (u) the second Nicene Synod, and xStephanus and Adrianus, as we may read in Juo. yNicephorus speaketh many fables for Images, he showeth us that Luke the Evangelist should have painted the Images of Christ and the Virgin Mary. zAnd that aholy Sylvester had the Images of Peter and Paul, and showed them to the Emperor Constantine, and bCanisius a fabulous man saith, there appeared to Sylvester at the dedication feast of Saint Salvator's church the picture of Christ in the Wall, but the original of Images seemeth to be the vanity of man, saith cthe Wise Man. 2. The keeping of the dead in memory, saith dCyprian, ad defunctorum vultus per imaginem detinendos expressa sunt simulachra, inde posteris facta sunt sacra quae primitus assumpta fuerunt solatia, in aliis codicibus ad solatia. 3. The blind heathen wanting the light of Scripture, began to worship Images. eEusebius saith it began first [Greek or Hebrew], from the Heathenish custom it came that Peter and Pauls Images were first made. Men did it saith fAugustine, ut Paganorum concilient benevolentiam, to conciliate the favour of Pagans, it may be seen out of Gregorius
I am not afraid that they say, Damascen, sa superstitious Monke alloweth Images to be adored. So doeth tthat pretended seventh Synod, or (u) the second Nicene Synod, and xStephanus and Adrianus, as we may read in Juo. yNicephorus speaketh many fables for Images, he sheweth us that Luke the Evangelist should have painted the Images of Christ and the Virgin Mary. zAnd that aholy Silvester had the Images of Peter and Paul, and shewed them to the Emperour Constantine, and bCanisius a fabulous man saith, there appeared to Silvester at the dedication feast of Saint Salvators church the picture of Christ in the Wall, but the originall of Images seemeth to be the vanity of man, saith cthe Wiseman. 2. The keeping of the dead in memory, saith dCyprian, ad defunctorum vultus per imaginem detinendos expressa sunt simulachra, inde posteris facta sunt sacra quae primitus assumpta fuerunt solatia, in aliis codicibus ad solatia. 3. The blinde heathen wanting the light of Scripture, began to worship Images. eEusebius saith it began first 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, from the Heathenish custome it came that Peter and Pauls Images were first made. Men did it saith fAugustine, ut Paganorum concilient benevolentiam, to conciliate the favour of Pagans, it may bee seene out of Gregorius
gMagnus, saith hVoetius, that the worshipping of Images crept in but the sixth age. In the first three hundred years, Images were not admitted (saith our Country-man iPatrick Simpson) into the place of worship, in the fourth, fifth and sixth Century, they were admitted into temples, but for the most part without opinion of adoration. In the second Nicene Council, an obscure age, (saith kPetrus Molinaeus) when the scriptures were taken away, it is ordained that Images should be adored, but not the Images of the Father. Quoniamquis sit non novimus, deique natura spectanda proponi non potest ac pingi. But only the Image of the Son. This Council was Anno 787. as saith lBellarmine. But this wicked Fathers argument proves also that the Image of God the Father may be painted, while they prove worshipping of Images, because the Psalmist saith, The Lord arose as a mighty man after Wine. But mGenebrard saith this Council of Nice, was controlled by a Council in the West. nBarronius mentioneth two Epistles written by Gregorious 2. a defender of Images, wherein he saith, the Son may be painted, not the Father. This Council was approved by Constantine, Ireneus, and a Greek copy of the Synod sent to oAdrian the Pope. But 1. this wicked Synod did not maintain adoration of Images, such as Suarez, Bellarmine, Vasquez, Peri•rius, &c. now hold, but only veneration. 2. Images were placed in the Churches, saith pPaul. Diaconus, multis contra dicentibus, many speaking against i•. And qBergomens. saith, the Emperor Constantine himself not long after did abrogate the Acts of this Synod, and rthe Synod of Frankfort condemned this Synod. See sAventinus; tHincmarus saith it is true they of Frankfort allowed Images to be in Churches, but not to be adored. wUrspergensis saith that this synod did write a book against the second Council of Nice, called otherwise the seventh general Council. A book came out▪ in France, and after in Germany under the name of Charles the Great, condemning by strong reasons the adoration of Images, and answereth all the arguments of the Nicene Fathers on the contrary, Tannerus the Jesuit saith this was a forged Book.
gMagnus, saith hVoetius, that the worshiping of Images crept in but the sixt age. In the first three hundred yeeres, Images were not admitted (saith our Country-man iPatrick Sympson) into the place of worship, in the fourth, fifth and sixt Centurie, they were admitted into temples, but for the most part without opinion of adoration. In the second Nicene Councell, an obscure age, (saith kPetrus Molinaeus) when the scriptures were taken away, it is ordained that Images should be adored, but not the Images of the Father. Quoniamquis sit non novimus, deique natura spectanda proponi non potest ac pingi. But onely the Image of the Son. This Councell was Anno 787. as saith lBellarmine. But this wicked Fathers argument proves also that the Image of God the Father may be painted, while they prove worshipping of Images, because the Psalmist saith, The Lord arose as a mighty man after Wine. But mGenebrard saith this Councell of Nice, was controuled by a Councell in the West. nBarronius mentioneth two Epistles written by Gregorious 2. a defender of Images, wherein he saith, the Sonne may be painted, not the Father. This Councell was approved by Constantine, Ireneus, and a Greeke copie of the Synod sent to oAdrian the Pope. But 1. this wicked Synod did not maintaine adoration of Images, such as Suarez, Bellarmine, Vasquez, Peri•rius, &c. now hold, but onely veneration. 2. Images were placed in the Churches, saith pPaul. Diaconus, multis contra dicentibus, many speaking against i•. And qBergomens. saith, the Emperour Constantine himselfe not long after did abrogate the Acts of this Synod, and r
gGregor. mag. Epist, ad Serenum Massilien shem lib. 7. Ep. 109.Gregor. mag. Epist, ad Serenum Massilien sem lib. 7. Ep. 109.
hVoetius in desper. caus. papat. lib. 3. c. 6. sect. 2.
iSimpson 6. Century of the worshipping of Images, p. 38.Sympson 6. Century of the worshipping of Images, p. 38.
kPet. Molin•us Buckler of Faith of Images, Sect. 118. pag. 308.
lBellarm de scrip. in Chron.
mGenebrard •hron. an. 794. p. 308.
nBarronius An. 726. Observe that Aeneas Sylvius epist. 301. saith, ante▪ Nicenam Synodum unusquisque sibi vivebat, quemadmodum sibi visum est, & paro•s respectus ad Romanam ecclesiam •abe•atur, a Metropolitan Bishop, a step to the Popedom, was first created here in Romes Car•bage, Constantinople, Antiochia.Barronius An. 726. Observe that Aeneas Sylvius epist. 301. saith, ante▪ Nicenam Synodum unusquisque sibi vivebat, quemadmodum sibi visum est, & paro•s respectus ad Romanam ecclesiam •abe•atur, a Metropolitan Bishop, a step to the Popedome, was first created here in Romes Car•bage, Constantin•ple, Antiochia.
But against famous ⟨p. 181⟩and learned Authors saying the contrary, and so xHincmarius and yEctius make mention of this book, and Pope Adrianus (as zHospinianus doth well observe) doth approve of this Synod of Frankfurt by his Letters written to the Emperor of Constantinople, and the Patriarch Tharasius.
But against famous ⟨p. 181⟩and learned Authors saying the contrary, and so xHincmarius and yEctius make mention of this book, and Pope Adrianus (as zHospinianus doth well observe) doth approve of this Synod of Francford by his Letters written to the Emperour of Constantinople, and the Patriarch Tharasius.
xHincmarin. Archiepiscopus Remorum c. 10. cont. Hincmarin. •andunensem Episcop.
The first five hundred years (saith aCalvin) images were not worshipped. Caj•s Caligula a proud Tyrant, commanded the Jews to set up his image in the Temple: the Jews answered they should rather die then pollute the Temple of God with images, as •aith bJosephus and cEusebius, and this fell out while the Apostles lived.
The first five hundred years (saith aCalvin) images were not worshipped. Caj•s Caligula a proud Tyrant, commanded the Iews to set up his image in the Temple: the Iews answered they should rather die then pollute the Temple of God with images, as •aith bIosephus and cEusebius, and this fell out while the Apostles lived.
Ann. 108. Plunius 2. writeth to Trajanus under the third Persecution, That Christians were men of good conversation, and detested vices, worshipped Christ, and would not worship Imagesd, as that Letter beareth: and eEusebius, reporteth Adrian had a purpose, (as saith fBucol.) to build a Church for the honour of Christ void of Images. See gSymson that ancient Writer: hJustine Martyr in this Age; Omnes imagines ad cultum proposit as simpliciter damnant Christiani. iTertullian, a most ancient writer, who lived under Severus in time of the fifth Persecution, as kthe Magdeburgenses testify; saith, Nos adoramus oculis ad caelum sublatis, non adimagines seu picturas, and, indignum ut imago Dei vivi imagini idoli, & mortu: fiat similis, (saith lhe also) and not only thinketh it unlawful to represent God by an Image, but also saith, that Craftsmen, who profess themselves Christians, ought no• to make Images of God. An ancient Writer mClemens Alexandrinus, Non est nobis imago sensibilis de materiâ sensibili, nisi quae precipitur intelligentiâ. Deus enim qui solus est verè Deas, intelligentiâ precipitur, non sensu: We have no sensible Image of sensible matter, because God is taken up by the understanding, not by the sense: and nNihil in rebus genitis potest referre Dei imaginem. This ancient Writer flourished, saith oCatolog. Testium veritat. Anno 150. or as pHospinian saith Ann, 200. and qIreneus, the disciple ⟨p. 182⟩of Polycarpus, an hearer of John the Apostle maketh it the Heresy of the Gnostics, that they held that Pilate made the Image of Jesus: Et quod imagines baberent Christi, Apostolorum atque Philosophorum▪ easque coronarent, ac colendas propo•erent. aCyprian saith, Idols, or Images, be not only against the Law of God, but against the nature of man; bOrigen said, The Images of Christians are Christians indeed, with Gods Image: and, Nos veno ideo non honor amus simulachrá, quia quantū possumus, cavemnus, ne in•idamus in eam crudelitatem, ut et iis tribuamus divinitatis aliquid. cGrave Athanasius saith, [Greek or Hebrew] The invention of Images is from an evil fountain, and not from good, and whatsoever hath a bad beginning, cannot be deemed in any thing good, being altogether bad: The Papist Harding bringeth in a counterfeit Dialogue of Athanasius, betwixt Christ and his Church; and Christ comforting his Church, because she was persecuted for worshipping Christs Image;
Ann. 108. Plunius 2. writeth to Trajanus under the third Persecution, That Christians were men of good conversation, and detested vices, worshipped Christ, and would not worship Imagesd, as that Letter beareth: and eEusebius, reporteth Adrian had a purpose, (as saith fBucol.) to build a Church for the honour of Christ void of Images. See gSymson that ancient Writer: hJustine Martyr in this Age; Omnes imagines ad cultum proposit as simpliciter damnant Christiani. iTertullian, a most ancient writer, who lived under Severus in time of the fifth Persecution, as kthe Magdeburgenses testifie; saith, Nos adoramus oculis ad caelum sublatis, non adimagines seu picturas, and, indignum ut imago Dei vivi imagini idoli, & mortu: fiat similis, (saith lhe also) and not only thinketh it unlawfull to represent God by an Image, but also saith, that Craftsmen, who professe themselves Christians, ought no• to make Images of God. An ancient Writer mClemens Alexandrinus, Non est nobis imago sensibilis de materiâ sensibili, nisi quae precipitur intelligentiâ. Deus enim qui solus est verè Deas, intelligentiâ precipitur, non sensu: We have no sensible Image of sensible matter, because God is taken up by the understanding, not by the sense: and nNihil in rebus genitis potest referre Dei imaginem. This ancient Writer flourished, saith oCatolog. Testium veritat. Anno 150. or as pHospinian saith Ann, 200. and q
dEpist. Plinii. 2 ad Imporat Trajan.
eEuseb. Histor. lib. 3. cap. 33.
fBucol•. in Alexand. severo.
gSymson 1. Century cap. 1.
hJustin. Martyr. in Dialog. cum. Trypho. & apolog. 2.
but when and where this persecution was, none knoweth, for many times hath the Church been persecuted for not worshipping Images; but see the answer of the learned dJewell thereunto; eEpiphanius, who lived, Anno 370. proveth against the3 Collyridiams, That Mary nor no creature should be adored. Unde est simulachrificum hoc studium et diabolious conantus? praetext• enim 4justitiae sempersubiens hominum, mentem drabolus, mortalem naturam in hominum oculis deificans, Statuas humanas, imagines press ferentes per artum, veritatem expressit, et mortui quidem sunt qui adorantur: Item, Revera sanctum erat corpus Mariae, non tamen Deus, honorata, non in adorationem data. Mary was not God, and therefore is not to be adored: He professeth that he did rive a veil, that had painted in it the Image of Christ, or of some man▪ Cum ego videssem in Ecclesia Christi▪ contra authoritatem scripturarum, hominis pendere imaginem, scidi illud, &c.
but when and where this persecution was, none knoweth, for many times hath the Church been persecured for not worshipping Images; but see the answer of the learned dJewell thereunto; eEpiphanius, who lived, Anno 370. proveth against the3 Collyridiams, That Mary nor no creature should be adored. Ʋnde est simulachrificum hoc studium et diabolious conantus? praetext• enim 4justitiae sempersubiens hominum, mentem drabolus, mortalem naturam in hominum oculis deificans, Statuas humanas, imagines pre se ferentes per artum, veritatem expressit, et mortui quidem sunt qui adorantur: Item, Revera sanctum erat corpus Mariae, non tamen Deus, honorata, non in adorationem data. Mary was not God, and therefore is not to be adored: He professeth that he did rive a vail, that had painted in it the Image of Christ, or of some man▪ Cum ego videssem in Ecclesia Christi▪ contra authoritatem scripturarum, hominis pendere imaginem, scidi illud, &c.
dJewell against Harding 14. art. of adora•. pag. 506, 507.
eEpiphanius lib. 3. cont. Collyridianos.
3[f] Idem ibid.
4(g) Lactantius, institut. l. 2. cap. 2. Etenim hominis imago necessaria tum videtur, cum procul abest, supervacua futura cum presto est, dei autem cujus spiritus ac numen ubique diffusum, abesse nunquam potest, semper utique imago supervacua est. The Arguments of the ancients against Images.
Lactantius Formianus, Images are to represent these who are absent. God is every where present, it is vanity therefore to form an image of God. Also hThere is no Religion, where there is an image: Also ⟨p. 183⟩iyour gods be either in Heaven, or not; if they be not in Heaven, why do ye worship them? If they be in Heaven, why do ye not lift your eyes to Heaven while you adore them? Why do you convert your eyes toward walls, stocks and stones, rather then toward that place where you imagine your gods to be?
Lactantius Formianus, Images are to represent these who are absent. God is every where present, it is vanity therefore to forme an image of God. Also hThere is no Religion, where there is an image: Also ⟨p. 183⟩iyour gods be either in Heaven, or not; if they be not in Heaven, why do ye worship them? If they be in Heaven, why do ye not lift your eyes to Heaven while you adore them? Why do you convert your eyes toward walls, stocks and stones, rather then toward that place where you imagine your gods to be?
hLactantius lib. 2. cap. 19.
iIb. Cur ad parietes & signa, & lapides potissimum quam illo spectatis, ubi cos esse credatis. ib. instit. div. l. 2. c. 1.
kHis Arguments against Images be these: l1. They forget reason, when they fear the work of their own hands: 2. mGod is not absent, but present every where: 3. nThe image is a dead thing void of sense, God is the eternal and everliving God: 4. oNothing mortal should be worshipped. 5. pWhat vanity to hope for protection from these things, which cannot defend themselves • 6. qThe image is less and viler then the worshipper: 7. rMan according to Gods image, is the image of God. 8. (s) God needeth nothing, neither torches because he made the light, nor images. This man lived, Anno 300. Before which time the Church of Christ being persecuted, they had no Churches, nor Images to be ornaments in their Churches, as saith (t) Ambrosius, and also uChrysostom, who was displeased with the fooleries in Temples in his time, and saith, They were not like the Temples of the Apostolic Churches: and xTertullian, and yEusebius saith, They had then, Simplices domos, Simple houses, void of paintries and pictures: And the want of Temples was objected against Christian Religion, as zOrigen cleareth in the time of Constantine, the son of Chlorus, as saith, aSozomen, and bEusebius, Temples were builded, but as cJoan. Quintinus expoundeth Tertullian, without the ornaments of images, and dTertullian himself maketh building of Altars, and portraits, Idol•tricos cultus, Idolatrous worship. In the forty years space, betwixt the reign of Valerian, and the 19. year of Diocletian, there were Oratories and Temples builded, but neither painted Pictures, nor Images in them, as saith [e] Eusebius: Yea, of thirty Bishops of Rome, even from Peter and Paul to Sylvester, and Constantine the Emperor; to wit, three hundred years, there were none, who were not persecuted to blood, or to death, or some other way. It is a vain thing to say, they had breathing time to build17⟨p. 184⟩Temples, and erect Altars, and golden Images of Christ, and the Virgin Mary, and the Saints. It is true, in the two hundred year after Christ, under Alexander Severus, Gordianus, Philippus, Gallienus; Churches were builded, as fNicephorus saith, but again under Diocletian they were demolished to the ground, but observe well there were no Images of Christ broken, which that Tyrant in despite of Christ, would not have omitted; see gEusebius, they were builded again under great Constantine, so hSozomen, iOtho Phrisingensis kand Nicephorus.
kHis Arguments against Images be these: l1. They forget reason, when they fear the work of their own hands: 2. mGod is not absent, but present every where: 3. nThe image is a dead thing void of sense, God is the eternall and everliving God: 4. oNothing mortall should be worshipped. 5. pWhat vanity to hope for protection from these things, which cannot defend themselves • 6. qThe image is lesse and viler then the worshipper: 7. rMan according to Gods image, is the image of God. 8. (s) God needeth nothing, neither torches because he made the light, nor images. This man lived, Anno 300. Before which time the Church of Christ being persecuted, they had no Churches, nor Images to be ornaments in their Churches, as saith (t) Ambrosius, and also uChrysostom, who was displeased with the fooleries in Temples in his time, and saith, They were not like the Templ•s of the Apostolick Churches: and xTertullian, and yEusebius saith, They had then, Simplices domos, Simple houses, void of paintries and pictures: And the want of Temples was objected against Christian Religion, as zOrigen cleareth in the time of Constantine, the son of Chlorus, as saith, aSozomen, and bEusebius, Temples were builded, but as
kinstit. l. 2. c. 2.
lIbid.
mInstit. l 2. c. 3.
nInstit. l. 2. c. 4.
oInstit. l. 2. c. 18.
pIbid.
qInstit. l. 6. c. 11.
rAmbros. officior l. 2. cap. 21.
uChrys. l. 2. epist. 246.
xTertullian apol et c•nt. valent.
yEusebius hist. ec. l. 9. c 10.
zOrigen cont. cles. l. 9. c. 4.
aSozomen l. 1. c. 8.
bEuseb. in vita constan. l. •.
cJoan Armitants in explan••io can 5. concilii gangren
dTertull. lib. de Idol. Plutarch in vitae Numae non dum ingenia Grecorum atque Tuscorum fingendis simulachris urbem inundaverunt, ita Tertullian, Apol. c. 25.
The dream of Platina, for the building of a Church, by the donation of Constantine, with twelve portions of earth, equal to the number of the twelve Apostles, and of another Church, with the title of the holy Cross at Jerusalem, which Helena found in that place, and Constantine placed in this Church at Rome, is refuted by lHospinian: yet is there no word of any Images in these Churches.
The dream of Platina, for the building of a Church, by the donation of Constantine, with twelve portions of earth, equall to the number of the twelve Apostles, and of another Church, with the title of the holy Crosse at Ierusalem, which Helena found in that place, and Constantine placed in this Church at Rome, is refuted by lHospinian: yet is there no word of any Images in these Churches.
mArnobius An. 330. maintaineth against the heathen, that the Christians ought to have no Images: 1. Because the device of images is a novelty, and was not before two thousand years, but God and Religion are no new things. 2. nBecause either the Gods dwelleth in their images, against their will, or of their own accord; if the former be said, they are compelled, which is absurd. If the latter, then they do either bide always in their images, and so are miserable, or they go out of the images when they please, and then the images are empty things.
mArnobius An. 330. maintaineth against the heathen, that the Christians ought to have no Images: 1. Because the device of images is a novelty, and was not before two thousand years, but God and Religion are no new things. 2. nBecause either the Gods dwelleth in their images, against their will, or of their own accord; if the former be said, they are compelled, which is absurd. If the latter, then they do either bide alwayes in their images, and so are miserable, or they go out of the images when they please, and then the images are empty things.
That could not be: 1. Because his manhood was joined with his Godhead, and could not be separated therefrom. 2. Because his Godhead cannot be represented, Mortuis, & inanimatis coloribus, with dead and lifeless colours. bHieronimus, who lived, An. 331. under Constantine, denieth that any Creature, Angel, or Virgin Mary should be worshipped. cRuffinus faith, Helena the mother of Constantine adored crucified Christ, but antiquity saith not, that she adored the nails that fixed him to the Cross, because they were but creatures.
That could not be: 1. Because his manhood was joyned with his Godhead, and could not be separated therefrom. 2. Because his Godhead cannot be represented, Mortuis, & inanimatis coloribus, with dead and livelesse colours. bHieronimus, who lived, An. 331. under Constantine, denyeth that any Creature, Angel, or Virgin Mary should be worshipped. cRuffinus faith, Helena the mother of Constantine adored crucified Christ, but antiquity saith not, that she adored the nails that fixed him to the Crosse, because they were but creatures.
dAmbrosius, who lived, Anno 370. condemneth Images. 1. Because they change the images of the dead, in the glory of God, who worshippeth images: 2. The living serve the dead. 3. They take from ⟨p. 185⟩stocks and stones what they are, and give to them, what they are not. 4. eIdols are unclean. 5. It is undecentf, to worship what men maketh with their hands. 6. Because gimages are but shadows.
hAugustine condemneth Images. 1. Because they infect the weak minds of rude people, to worship them. 2. They have eyes and see not. 3. The creatures are images of God, not stocks. 4. Idols iare husks and empty. 5. These kwho brought in Images, took away the fear of God, and increased error. 6. Martyrs lare not gods. 7. Confounded mbe they who worship stones, our living stone Christ is in heaven.
hAugustine condemneth Images. 1. Because they infect the vveak mindes of rude people, to worship them. 2. They have eyes and see not. 3. The creatures are images of God, not stocks. 4. Idols iare huskes and empty. 5. These kwho brought in Images, tooke away the feare of God, and increased error. 6. Martyrs lare not gods. 7. Confounded mbe they who worship stones, our living stone Christ is in heaven.
8. aThough worshippers of Images say, they worship God in Images, yet they worship devils; for good men, as Paul and Barnabas, Angels, and Cornelius forbade men to worship them. 9. It is a shame to adore a beast endowed with sense and life, far more to adore a dumb and lifeless creature, August, ps. 113. bChrysostom is against Images. 1. Because the Law of God forbiddeth them. 2. cGod must be honoured, as he willeth himself. 3. It is da depressing of souls to worship Images. eIt cometh from Satan to take Gods glory from him, fit is mockery that man should be the creator of God, the Creator of all things.
8. aThough worshippers of Images say, they worship God in Images, yet they worship devills; for good men, as Paul and Barnabas, Angels, and Cornelius forbade men to worship them. 9. It is a shame to adore a beast endowed with sense and life, farre more to adore a dumbe and livelesse creature, August, ps. 113. bChrysostome is against Images. 1. Because the Law of God forbiddeth them. 2. cGod must be honoured, as he willeth himselfe. 3. It is da depressing of soules to worship Images. eIt commeth from Satan to take Gods glory from him, fit is mockerie that man should be the creator of God, the Creator of all things.
hDamascene a superstitious man much for Images acknowledgeth two things. 1. That Images are but [Greek or Hebrew] unwritten traditions. 2. He acknowledgeth that the brazen Serpent, the Cherubims were made for signification, not for imitation or adoration.
hDamascen a superstitious man much for Images acknowledgeth two things. 1. That Images are but 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 unwritten traditions. 2. He ackowledgeth that the brazen Serpent, the Cherubims were made for signification, not for imitation or adoration.
hGregor. lin. 9. ep. 9. Perlatum est ad nos, quod inconsider• to zelo succensus sanctorum magines sub bac, quasi excusatione, ne adorari debuissent, confregeris, & quidem, quia cas adorari, vet•isses omnino laudamus, fregisse vero reprehendimus.
(i)Gregorius Magnus, though he be alleged by Papists for adoration of Images. Yet in his Epistle to Serenus Bishop of Massilia, An. 600. he forbiddeth the adoration of Images, and alloweth only the Historical use of them, as is observed by kFran. White, lby Hospinian and mCatol. testum veritatis, and nthis man being the first who brought Images into the Church hath this Caveat, atque indica (saith he to Sirenus) quod non tibi, ipsa visio historiae quae, pictura teste, pandebatur, displicueri•: sed illa adoratio quae picturis ⟨p. 186⟩fuerit in competenter exhibita, & si quis imagines facere voluerit, minimè prohibe, adorare vero imagines omnibus modis divita, sed hoc solicitè admoneas, ut ex visione rei gestae, ardorem conjunctionis percipiant, & in adoration solius Trinitatis prosternantur. It is clear that this man teacheth an adoration of Images, though he make them only books to the rude. This same oGregorius will have the sign of the cross adored, because when the Devil came to a Jew sleeping in the night in the Temple of an Idol, the Jew being afraid, signed himself with the Cross, and the Devil fled; but when doth Jews come in any Christian Churches, or Idol-Temples, who abhor the name of Christ, and so hate both the Cross and Christ, and what can be proved from a fact of Satan?
(i)Gregorius Magnus, though he be alledged by Papists for adoration of Images. Yet in his Epistle to Serenus Bishop of Massilia, An. 600. he forbiddeth the adoration of Images, and alloweth onely the Historicall use of them, as is observed by kFran. White, lby Hospinian and mCatol. testum veritatis, and nthis man being the first who brought Images into the Church hath this Caveat, atque indica (saith he to Sirenus) quod non tibi, ipsa visio historiae quae, pictura teste, pandebatur, displicueri•: sed illa adoratio quae picturis ⟨p. 186⟩fuerit in competenter exhibita, & si quis imagines facere voluerit, minimè prohibe, adorare vero imagines omnibus modis divita, sed hoc solicitè admoneas, ut ex visione rei gestae, ardorem conjunctionis percipiant, & in adoratione solius Trinitatis prosternantur. It is cleare that this man teacheth an adoration of Images, though he make them onely bookes to the rude. This same oGregorius will have the signe of the crosse adored, because when the Devill came to a Iew sleeping in the night in the Temple of an Idoll, the Iew being afraid, signed himselfe with the Crosse, and the Divell fled; but when doth Iewes come in any Christian Churches, or Idoll-Temples, who abhorre the name of Christ, and so hate both the Crosse and Christ, and what can be proved from a fact of Sathan?
kFran. Whites way to the Church, ch. 9, sect. 2. p. 114.
In the eighth age, pBede Imaginum cultus & adoratio, the worshipping and adoring of Images is unlawful. 1. Because they have no office in the doctrine of the Gospel. 2. qWe are forbidden to adore, salute, or worship them. 3. The (d) rChurch is not taught to seek the Lord by Images, but by faith and good works. 4. The sApostolic Church did not worship God in Images. 5. Images twant, documento antiquitatis, antiquity, example, and the Scripture. 6. We wfrustrate God of worship due to him. 7. Peter uPaul, Angels forbade to worship them, but God only.
In the eighth age, pBeda Imaginum cultus & adoratio, the worshipping and adoring of Images is unlawfull. 1. Because they have no office in the doctrine of the Gospell. 2. qWe are forbidden to adore, salute, or worship them. 3. The (d) rChurch is not taught to seeke the Lord by Images, but by faith and good workes. 4. The sApostolique Church did not worship God in Images. 5. Images twant, documento antiquitatis, antiquity, example, and the Scripture. 6. We wfrustrate God of worship due to him. 7. Peter uPaul, Angels forbad to worship them, but God only.
pBede l. 2. c. 21. ad peragenda nostrae salutis mysteria nullum penitus officium habere n•scuntur.Beda l. 2. c. 21. ad peragenda nostrae salutis mysteria nullum penitus officium habere n•scuntur.
qBede l. 1. c. 9. adorare, salutare, collar, inhibemur pene in cunctis scripturae locis.Beda l. 1. c. 9. adorare, salutare, colare, inhibemur pene in cunctis scripturae locis.
rIdem. l. 1. c. 21.
sIdem l. 1. c. 24. Idem l. 6. c. 21.
tIbid.
wCod. l. 8. tit. 12. leg. 20. Theodos. Valentinian
We forbid the Church (saith the civill Law) to be obscured with Images. Have the Image of God, (saith xEphrem) in thy heart, non colorum varietate in ligno, not in Images and colours. Who can make (saith yDamascene) a representation of the invisible God. zGretserus saith, the Jews would not admit of Ensigns and Trophies of the Romans for fear Images should be hidden under them. So said Josephus abefore him. Their own men say with us, bHulcot who lived an. 1346. saith Latreia, divine worship belongeth to God only, the Image is not God, neither the Cross; (saith Joan. Pic. Mirandula, Concl. 3.) nor the Image of Christ is to be adored (adoration Latreia eo modo quo ponit Thomas) with divine worship, the guise of Thomas Aquinas cPeresius Ajala a Popish Bishop, for adoration of Images, saith he, there is neither Scripture, nor Church tradition, nor consent of Fathers, nor good reason to make it good. For saith dGabriel ⟨p. 187⟩Biel, The image either considered in it self as it is metal or stone, or as it is a holy sign, is a sensible Creature, to which Latreia, Divine honour should not be given: and the Romish cDecrees saith, We commend you that you forbid images of Saints to be Worshipped: The dDouai Doctors say, Idols have eyes and cannot see, &c. Now if they have Images of God and Christ which can see, and hear, and speak, we exceedingly desire to know: eAlexander Allensis, fDurandus say, That images in themselves, and properly, are not to be Worshipped.
We forbid the Church (saith the civill Law) to be obscured with Images. Have the Image of God, (saith xEphrem) in thy heart, non colorum varietate in ligno, not in Images and colours. Who can make (saith yDamascen) a representation of the invisible God. zGretserus saith, the Iewes would not admit of Ensignes and Trophies of the Romans for fear Images should be hidden under them. So said Josephus abefore him. Their own men say with us, bHulcot who lived an. 1346. saith Latreia, divine worship belongeth to God onely, the Image is not God, neither the Crosse; (saith Ioan. Pic. Mirandula, Concl. 3.) nor the Image of Christ is to be adored (adoratione Latreia eo modo quo ponit Thomas) with divine worship, the guise of Thomas Aquinas cPeresius Ajala a Popish Bishop, for adoration of Images, saith he, there is neither Scripture, nor Church tradition, nor consent of Fathers, nor good reason to make it good. For saith dGabriel ⟨p. 187⟩Biel, The image either considered in it self as it is mettall or stone, or as it is a holy signe, is a sensible Creature, to which Latreia, Divine honour should not be given: and the Romish cDecrees saith, We commend you that you forbid images of Saints to be Worshipped: The dDoway Doctors say, Idols have eyes and cannot see, &c. Now if they have Images of God and Christ which can see, and hear, and speak, we exceedingly desire to know: eAlexander Allensis, fDurandus say, That images in themselves, and properly, are not to be Worshipped.
cPeresius Ajala de trad. pag. 3. De Imagineque scripturam neque traditionem, neque communem sensum sanctorum, neque concilium generalis determinationem, neque etiam rationem adducunt.
dGabriel Biel in Can. lec. 49.
cD•cret. 3. dist. 3. c. 27. Grego.
dDouai men, Annot. 2 Sam. 5. 8. The blind and the lame shall not enter in the Temple.Doway men, Annot. 2 Sam. 5. 8. The blinde and the lame shall not enter in the Temple.
gGeo: Cassander wisheth, That they had continued (in majorum suorum sententia) in the mind of their forefathers, and that the Superstition of people in, Worshipping images had been suppressed. The Council convened by hConstantius Capronimus condemneth Worshipping of Images, or placing them in Churches. 1. Because it is forbidden in the second Commandment. 2. The Picturing of Christ is a dividing of the two Natures. 3. It is against the Ancients, Epiphanius, Nazianzen, Chrysostom, Athanasius, Amphylocius, Theodorus, Eusebius Pamphili. The Council of Nice is builded upon lies. Adrian Bishop of Rome, writeth to the Council of Nice, That the Emperor Constantine being a Leper, and labouring to cure his Leprosy by shedding of innocent Babes blood; Peter and Paul appeared to him by night, in a Vision, and bade him go to be Baptized by Sylvester, and that he, to be cured by Sylvesters Baptizing, builded a Temple with the Images of Peter and Paul. This is as true as the Image of Christ spake to Tho: Aquinas at Naples, Bene Scripsistti de me, Thoma, Why is not all Evangel that Aquinas hath written then? For their own Platina asaith, The story of Constantine's Leprosy is a fable; and Socrates saith, That Constantine was sick when he was 65. years, and he maketh no mention of his leprosy; so bHospinianus saith, and our own cSimson saith, That Sylvester and Marcus his successor were both dead before Constantine was Baptized: dGenebradus a Papist saith, ⟨p. 188⟩down right, that the Council of Frankford condemned the second Nicene Council; But eBellarmine, fSuarez, gSanderus' hAlanus, deny that the Doctrine of the second Nicene Council for Adoring images, is Condemned by the Council of Frankford; they say it is only expounded, and that the right way of Adoring images is made manifest: Yea, saith iNauclerus, kSabellicus, and lBlandus: The Council of Frankford reserveth due honour to images, and saith nothing against the Council of Nice. But this is to deny daylight at Noon-day: For mAnnonius is most clear in it, and nAbbot Uspergens. othe Book of Charles the Great saith the same. The Synod of Frankford was convened An. 794. of purpose to condemn the second Synod of Nice, called the seventh pretended and false Synod: pAventinus saith expressly, Scita Grecorum (in Synodo Nicena decreta) de imaginibus adorandis in concili• francofurtensi rescissa & abolita sunt:
gGeo: Cassander wisheth, That they had continued (in majorum suorum sententia) in the minde of their forefathers, and that the Superstition of people in, Worshipping images had been suppressed. The Councell convened by hConstantius Capronimus condemneth Worshipping of Images, or placing them in Churches. 1. Because it is forbidden in the second Commandment. 2. The Picturing of Christ is a dividing of the two Natures. 3. It is against the Ancients, Epiphanius, Nazianzen, Chrysostome, Athanasius, Amphylocius, Theodorus, Eusebius Pamphili. The Councell of Nice is builded upon lies. Adrian Bishiop of Rome, writeth to the Councell of Nice, That the Emperour Constantine being a Leaper, and labouring to cure his Leprosie by shedding of innocent Babes blood; Peter and Paul appeared to him by night, in a Vision, and bade him go to be Baptized by Sylvester, and that he, to be cured by Sylvesters Baptizing, builded a Temple with the Images of Peter and Paul. This is as true as the Image of Christ spake to Tho: Aquinas at Naples, Bene Scripsistti de me, Thoma, Why is not all Evangell that Aquinas hath written then? For their own Platina asaith, The story of Constantines Leprosie is a fable; and Socrates saith, That Constantine was sick when he was 65. years, and he maketh no mention of his leprosie; so bHospinianus saith, and our own cSimson saith, That Sylvester and Marcus his successor were both dead before Constantine was Baptized: dGenebradus a Papist saith, ⟨p. 188⟩down right, that the Councell of Frankford condemned the second Nicene Councell; But eBellarmine, fSuarez, gSanderus' hAlanus, deny that the Doctrine of the second Nicene Councell for Adoring images, is Condemned by the Councell of Frankford; they say it is onely expounded, and that the right way of Adoring images is made manifest: Yea, saith
gCassand. In Consultatione ad ferdinandum & maximilianum art. An. 1170.
hConcil. Constantine polit. An. 755. of 338. Bishops. Yea, this same second councel of Nice, and the seventh Epistle to the Synod, condemneth Nestorius of Idolatry, and condemneth the Arians as Idolaters, who Worshipped Christ whom they believed to be a man only: And Athanasius, contr. Arian. Orati. 1. And Nyssenus in Laud. Bas. And Nazianzen, Orati. 40. say. To Adore a Creature, though in the Name of Christ or God, is Idolatry.Concil. Constantin• polit. An. 755. of 338. Bishops. Yea, this same second councel of Nice, and the seventh Epistle to the Synod, condemneth Nestorius of Idolatry, and condemneth the Arians as Idolaters, who Worshipped Christ whom they believed to be a man onely: And Athanasius, contr. Arian. Orati. 1. And Nyssenus in Laud. Bas. And Nazianzen, Orati. 40. say. To Adore a Creature, though in the Name of Christ or God, is Idolatry.
and aUspergensis saith, in this Synod it was decreed, Ut septima & universalis Synodus, nec septima nec aliquid diceretur, quasi supervacua ab omnibus abdica tu est; and the same saith bEginradus, cGeo• Cassander: But the very Arguments in the Nicene Council are set down, and dissolved in the Frankford Council, as our own Master dSimson observeth: As the Nicene Council reasoneth from the Cherubims, and the brazen Serpent. Frankford Answereth, These were made at Gods Commandment, images not so. 2. Yea, say they, and with them eLorinus, The Cherubims and brazen Serpent were not made to be Worshipped; see these and many other Arguments, set down and Answered by the Council of Frankford: As also saith fthe Learned Author of Catol. Test. Verit. The Arguments used by this Council, proveth that no Adoration is due to Images, as may be hence collected: As also out of the book of gCharles against the dreams of Tarasius, whose entry to the Priesthood was unlawful, and was a gross Idolater, and against the Idolater Pope Adrian; Because 1. There is no holiness in images, either as they are figures or colours, or as they are Consecrated. ⟨p. 189⟩2. Because to Adore is to glorify, hbut only God is to be glorified. 3. God Commanded us not to love images, but men, and sent his son in the flesh for men, and not for images; and if ithey be not to be believed on, neither are they to be Adored. 4. It cannot be proved that the honour of the image, is the honour of the Sampler: Christ said not, What ye do to images, ye do to me, nor he that receiveth images, receiveth me. This Argument proveth, that Veneration is not due to the Images, as to books of the Trinity; because that the Veneration of the Image, is an honouring of God, there must be an union betwixt the Images and God or Christ, betwixt the Tree and Christ. 1. There is no union lawful, that can be a Warrant of honouring any thing; but an union Warranted of God, betwixt Crossing in the Air, and Dedication to Christs Service, betwixt Surplice and Pastoral Sanctity; There is no union, nor is there a personal union betwixt Christ and the Image: Nor 2. an union of parts, as betwixt the shoulders and the head. Nor 3. is there a Divine relative union, as betwixt the mean or the end, the Servant or the Lord: for as aJohn White saith well;
and aVspergensis saith, in this Synod it was decreed, Ʋt septima & universalis Synodus, nec septima nec aliquid diceretur, quasi supervacua ab omnibus abdica tu est; and the same saith bEginradus, cGeo• Cassander: But the very Arguments in the Nicene Councell are set down, and dissolved in the Frankford Councell, as our own Master dSimson observeth: As the Nicene Councell reasoneth from the Cherubims, and the brazen Serpent. Frankfoord Answereth, These were made at Gods Commandment, images not so. 2. Yea, say they, and with them eLorinus, The Cherubims and brazen Serpent were not made to be Worshipped; see these and many other Arguments, set down and Answered by the Councell of Frankfoord: As also saith fthe Learned Author of Catol. Test. Verit. The Arguments used by this Councell, proveth that no Adoration is due to Images, as may be hence collected: As also out of the book of gCharles against the dreames of Tarasius, whose entry to the Priesthood was unlawfull, and was a grosse Idolater, and against the Idolater Pope Adrian; Because 1. There is no holinesse in images, either as they are figures or colours, or as they are Consecrated. ⟨p. 189⟩2. Because to Adore is to glorifie, hbut only God is to be glorified. 3. God Commandedus not to love images, but men, and sent his son in the flesh for men, and not for images; and if ithey be not to be believed on, neither are they to be Adored. 4. It cannot be proved that the honour of the image, is the honour of the Samplar: Christ said not, What ye do to images, ye do to me, nor he that receiveth images, receiveth me. This Argument proveth, that Veneration is not due to the Images, as to books of the Trinity; because that the Veneration of the Image, is an honouring of God, there must be an union betwixt the Images and God or Christ, betwixt the Tree and Christ. 1. There is no union lawfull, that can be a Warrant of honouring any thing; but an union Warranted of God, betwixt Crossing in the Air, and Dedication to Christs Service, betwixt Surplice and Pastorall Sanctity; There is no union, nor is there a personall union betwixt Christ and the Image: Nor 2. an union of parts, as betwixt the shoulders and the head. Nor 3. is there a Divine relative union, as betwixt the mean or the end, the Servant or the Lord: for as
aUspergens. in Chron. Anno 793.Vspergens. in Chron. Anno 793.
bEginradus in vita Caroli Magni.
cCassander in Consul. ad ferdinand. & Maxmilian imp.
dSimson, Treatise of Images, pag. 48.
eLorinus in Art. 17. ver. 25. Serpentem. Conflari•jusfit non quod adorari vellet, nam postea confregit.
fCatol. Test. Verit. lib. 8. pag. 882, 883, 884.
gCaroli. lib. 1. cap. 2.
hCarlo. lib. 1. c. 21.
iCaro. lib. 2. cap. 24. Caro. lib. 3. cap. 16.
aWhite against Fisher, p. 224.
1 Chron. 28. 1
. For there is no ground for Adoring the Ark; but the words are to be read, Exalt the Lord our God, and bow your selves, (to wit, to Iehovah, who sheweth himself, or dwelleth at his foot-stool) that is, betwixt the Cherubims,
. For the word 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 at his foot-stool, is not constructed with the Verb, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 incurvate vos: Jesuits and Formalists, devised that construction, but it is to be constructed with the word, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 which is to be repeated from the former part of the verse, Bow your selves to Jehovah who dwelleth in the Ark, or in the Temple: A familiar eleipsis to the Hebrews, Psal.
Vrspergensis saith that this synod did write a book against the second Councell of Nice, called otherwise the seventh generall Councell. A booke came out▪ in France, and after in Germany under the name of Charles the Great, condemning by strong reasons the adoration of Images, and answereth all the arguments of the Nicene Fathers on the contrary, Tannerus the Iesuite saith this was a forged Booke.
Synod Frankfort.Synod Franckford.
sAventinus lib. 4.
tHincmarus cap. 20. contra Jandu••ns•m.Hincmarus cap. 20. contra Iandu••ns•m.
wUrspergens. in Histor.Vrspergens. in Histor.
Ireneus, the disciple
⟨p. 182⟩
of Polycarpus, an hearer of John the Apostle maketh it the Heresie of the Gnosticks, that they held that Pilate made the Image of Iesus: Et quod imagines baberent Christi, Apostolorum atque Philosophorum▪ easque coronarent, ac colendas propo•erent.
Origen said, The Images of Christians are Christians indeed, with Gods Image: and, Nos veno ideo non honor amus simulachrá, quia quantū possumus, cavemnus, ne in•idamus in eam crudelitatem, ut et iis tribuamus divinitatis aliquid.
Grave Athanasius saith, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 The invention of Images is from an evil fountain, and not from good, and whatsoever hath a bad beginning, cannot be deemed in any thing good, being altogether bad: The Papist Harding bringeth in a counterfeit Dialogue of Athanasius, betwixt Christ and his Church; and Christ comforting his Church, because she was persecuted for worshipping Christs Image;
Tertullian himself maketh building of Altars, and portracts, Idol•tricos cultus, Idolatrous worship. In the fourty years space, betwixt the reign of Valerian, and the 19. year of Dicclesian, there were Oratories and Temples builded, but neither painted Pictures, nor Images in them, as saith [e] Eusebius: Yea, of thirty Bishops of Rome, even from Peter and Paul to Sylvester, and Constantine the Emperour; to wit, three hundred years, there were none, who were not persecuted to blood, or to death, or some other way. It is a vain thing to say, they had breathing time to build
Temples, and erect Altars, and golden Images of Christ, and the Virgin Mary, and the Saints. It is true, in the two hundreth year after Christ, under Alexander Severus, Gordianus, Philippus, Gallienus; Churches were builded, as
Nicephorus saith, but again under Dioclesian they were demolished to the ground, but observe well there were no Images of Christ broken, which that Tyrant in despite of Christ, would not have omitted; see
Blandus: The Councell of Frankford reserveth due honour to images, and saith nothing against the Councell of Nice. But this is to deny daylight at Noon-day: For
the Book of Charles the Great saith the same. The Synod of Frankford was convened An. 794. of purpose to condemne the second Synod of Nice, called the seventh pretended and false Synod: