V. Rule. To do any good action, or lawful, or indifferent, when I probably foresee a scandal will follow, is an active scandal, for I prefer my own will, to my brothers salvation (saith gAntoninus, and hNavarret,) and therefore saith (i) Antoninus; A virgin going abroad, without just necessity, where her beauty shall be a snar• to young men, or to go out upon a necessary cause with a whorish attire, is an active scandal, her feet▪ abideth not in her house, saith kSolomon. And lNavarre, saith, It is to sin mortally and mSylvester saith, If the Popes commandment do but smell of venial sin, and if by giving audience thereunto, it be presumed that the state of the Church shall be troubled, or a scandal shall arise, though the commandment go out under the pain of Excommunication, it is not to be obeyed. oVasques, and ⟨p. 14⟩pSuarez say, to sell, gift, or dispose of any things indifferent, when we foresee they shall abuse them, is to commit the sin of active scandalizing. Yea, the form of an Idol, though he never adore it, doth highly scandalize, and qAntoninus rSylvester, sCorduba, tMedina, uthe Jesuit Zanches teach, That to contribute to that which we see, shall induce any to sin, is to be guilty of scandalizing. And the reasons be these; 1. We are not to prefer our will to the salvation of our brother. 2. Things less necessary, then our brothers salvation, in that case become not necessary, and so fruitless and idle. 3. Charity inferferreth, that we hinder so far, as we can, the ruin of our brothers soul, Scandal is spiritual homicide. 4. To contribute any moral help, and influence to our brothers fall, and soul-ruin, is to be accessory to his sin▪ Hence Ceremonies and things not necessary to salvation, may be omitted altogether in their specialities, when the practising of them doth scandalize, and so though kneeling in Gods worship cannot well be universally omitted, yet kneeling appropriate to such an act of worship may be omitted, and ought to be omitted, if it scandalize, and Ceremonies which scandalize universally, seeing they are not in their very kind necessary to salvation, are to be abolished.
V. Rule. To doe any good action, or lawfull, or indifferent, when I probably foresee a scandall will follow, is an active scandall, for I preferre my owne will, to my brothers salvation (saith gAntoninus, and hNavarret,) and therefore saith (i) Antoninus; A virgin going abroad, without just necessitie, where her beautie shall be a snar• to young men, or to goe out upon a necessary cause with a whorish attire, is an active scandall, her feet▪ abideth not in her house, saith kSolomon. And lNavarr, saith, It is to sinne mortally and mSilvester saith, If the Popes commandement doe but smell of veniall sinne, and if by giving audience thereunto, it be presumed that the state of the Church shall be troubled, or a scandall shall arise, though the commandement goe out under the paine of Excommunication, it is not to bee obeyed. oVasques, and ⟨p. 14⟩pSuarez say, to sell, gift, or dispose of any things indifferent, when we foresee they shall abuse them, is to commit the sinne of active scandalizing. Yea, the forme of an Idol, though he never adore it, doth highly scandalize, and qAntoninus rSilvester, sCorduba, tMetina, uthe Jesuit Zanches teach, That to contribute to that which we see, shall induce any to sinne, is to be guilty of scandalizing. And the reasons be these; 1. We are not to preferre our will to the salvation of our brother. 2. Things lesse necessarie, then our brothers salvation, in that case become not necessarie, and so fruitlesse and idle. 3. Charitie inferferreth, that we hinder so far, as we can, the ruine of our brothers soul, Scandaell is spirituall homicide. 4. To contribute any morall help, and influence to our brothers fall, and soul-ruine, is to be accessarie to his sinne Hence Ceremonies and things not necessarie to salvation, may be omitted altogether in their specialities, when the practising of them doth scandalize, and so though kneeling in Gods worship cannot well be universally omitted, yet kneeling appropriate to such an act of worship may be omitted, and ought to be omitted, if it scandalize, and Ceremonies which scandalize universally, seeing they are not in their very kinde necessarie to salvation, are to be abolished.
- gAntoninus 2 p. to. 1 cap 9▪ sect. ult. tit 3. cap 4 Verereus est pecca•i proximi qui absque ullâ just• causâ non impedit scandalum, quod ex suo opere est f•turum, quia videtur contemnere vitam spiritualem fratris
- hNavarre. in sum. cap 4. • 13.Navarr. in sum. cap 4. • 13.
- kProverb 7.
- lNavarre. in sum. cap 4. n. 13▪ Mortaliter peccat, qui ita parvi aestimat salutemproximi, ut absque justa necessitate, & utilitate, ex •ola sua voluntate aliquid facit, unde fra•er est scandalizandus.Navar•. in sum. cap 4. n. 13▪ Mortaliter peccat, qui ita parvi aestimat salutemproximi, ut absque justa necessitate, & utilitate, ex •ola sua voluntate aliquid facit, unde fra•er est scandalizandus.
- mSylvester in summa in verbo, obedientia, n 5. Si Papae mandatum sapiat etiam peccatum veniale Item si ex obedientia praesum•retur status Ecclesiae perturbandus, vel aliud malum aut scandalum futurum, etiamsi praeciperetur sub soe•â Excommunicationis—non est ei obediendum.Silvester in summa in verbo, obedientia, n 5. Si Papae mandatum sapiat etiam peccatum veniale Item si ex obedientia praesum•retur sta•us Ecclesiae perturbandus, vel aliud malum aut scandalum futurum, etiamsi praeciperetur sub soe•â Excommunicationis—non est ei obediendum.