pp. 19–238 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
That which may be removed by information and instruction, cannot be a warrant to us of a total abstinence, from the obedience of the laws, or which is all one, of an avowed disclaiming of the authority of them. But the scandal of the weak taken by Perth Articles, may be removed by information, or instruction. Ergo.
That which may be removed by information and instruction, cannot be awarrand to us of a totall abstinence, from the obedience of the lawes, or which is all one, of an avowed disclaiming of the authoritie of them. But the scandall of the weake taken by Pearth Articles, may be removed by information, or instruction. Ergo.
I must crave here leave for a pause, and ask the question. ⟨p. 20⟩1. If information and light given to beware of the scandal of Ceremonies and things indifferent, can make them the lawful object of Church Canons, D. Forbes and other say so. But 1. This1 is that which Papists say to our Divines, who object that Images are pits and snares to Idolatry. This danger (saith aJohannes de Lugo) the Popes Professor at Rome, is easily prevented by the instruction and care of Prelates, who are to teach, that Images have no dignity of themselves, but only from the sampler. And so bBellarm. the Jesuit, cVasquez. dEstius. eThe Council of Magountine helpeth the matter. Let our Pastors (say they) carefully teach the people, that Images are not set up, that we should adore them, but that they should be helps for our memory. 2. Paul gave strong reasons for lawfulness of days, and meats, that weak Jews should not be scandalized at the eating thereof. yet he would neither pass them in a Church Canon, nor practise them himself, while the world standeth, 1 Cor. 8. 13. yea, he proveth Rom. 14. by eight strong Arguments, that it was not lawful to practise them. Ergo, he presupposeth that information of Pastors should not take away the scandal of the weak, as Rom. 14. 14. There is nothing unclean of it self. Ergo, It is lawful to eat all meats, 1 Cor. 10. 26. The earth is the Lords. Ergo, eat what is set before you, v. 23. all things are lawful, and yet he saith, eat not, give no offence, if meat offend my brother, I will not eat to the worlds end. 1 Cor. 8. 13. 3. This vain argument presupposeth that the want of literal information, is the adequate cause of falling in scandal, a vain reason. Peter actively and culpably scandalized Christ in his carnal counsel, Master, pity thy self, Mat. 16 21. 22. 23. yet Christ was sufficiently enlightened, that he could not be scandalized. But certain it is, that the will and depraved inclination is the cause why we fall in scandal, even when we know that others who publicly sinneth, doth sin, and that we should not be scandalized. Now no reason in Pastors preaching, or in Church-Canon, can take away the inclination ⟨p. 21⟩of the heart to evil, and therefore no information of Pastors can remove the scandal of the weak;
I must crave here leave for a pause, and aske the question. ⟨p. 20⟩1. If information and light given to beware of the scandall of Ceremonies and things indifferent, can make them the lawfull object of Church Canons, D. Forbes and other say so. But 1. This1 is that which Papists say to our Divines, who object that Images are pits and snares to Idolatrie. This danger (saith aJohannes de Lugo) the Popes Professor at Rome, is easily prevented by the instruction and care of Prelates, who are to teach, that Images have no dignitie of themselves, but onely from the samplar. And so bBellarm. the Jesuit, cƲasquez. dEstius. eThe Councell of Magountine helpeth the matter. Let our Pastours (say they) carefully teach the people, that Images are not set up, that we should adore them, but that they should be helps for our memorie. 2. Paul gave strong reasons for lawfulnesse of dayes, and meats, that weake Jewes should not be scandalized at the eating thereof. yet he would neither passe them in a Church Canon, nor practise them himselfe, while the world standeth, 1 Cor. 8. 13. yea, he proveth Rom. 14. by eight strong Arguments, that it was not lawfull to practise them. Ergo, he presuproseth that information of Pastours should not take away the scandall of the weake, as Rom. 14. 14. There is nothing uncleane of it selfe. Ergo, It is lawfull to eat all meats, 1 Cor. 10. 26. The earth is the Lords. Ergo, eat what is set before you, v. 23. all things are lawfull, and yet he saith, eat not, give no offence, if meat offend my brother, I will not eat to the worlds end. 1 Cor. 8. 13. 3. This vaine argument presupposeth that the want of literall information, is the adequat cause of falling in scandall, a vaine reason. Peter actively and culpably scandalized Christ in his carnall counsell, Master, pitty thy selfe,
For then David in committing adultery, Noah in drunkenness, Lot in his incestuous folly with his own daughters, Peter in denying his Saviour, should not have caused others within, or without the Church to stumble, nor have culpably scandalized them; So David. Noah, Lot, and Peter, had preached to all that heard of their fall, that adultery, drunkenness, incest, and denial of Christ, were grievous sins to be avoided, and that it was sin for any to be scandalized thereat, for such information should have given sufficient literal information to beware of the like sins. Yea, a father might enclose in a chamber, his son and a beautiful virgin, and if he should sufficiently inform his son of the guiltiness, and punishment of harlotry, he should not lay a stumbling-block before his son. Yet we all know, a stumbling-block may be laid before the inclination no less, then before the blind mind, yea suppose, to warn a Traveller of a pit, in his way, might be sufficient, to make the digger of the pit free of laying a stumbling-block in the way (as it is not) seeing to make a pit is not indifferent, yet it shall not free the Commanders of Ceremonies and the acts of Perth Assembly of active scandal, because men naturally loving life and health, hate to fall into pits, which may endanger their life, and so have no inward moral inclination to fall into a pit; but men though informed of spiritual falls, and warned to beware of them, yet love and incline to Idolatry, and therefore to warn them to beware, and yet set the powder near the fire, is but to scorn the craft, and to mock men. Yea, in that they desire and require, that the people beware of the Ceremonies, and require that Pastors inform them of the danger; they grant that Ceremonies are powder amongst the pitchers, and yet they be innocent, and indifferent creatures, as if they would call them indifferent pits, indifferent whores to allure, beware of them; indifferent pest-clothes, see that your inclination touch them not. Yea, then Hezekiah had given no scandal, if he had commanded the brazen Serpent still to stand, and had commanded the Priests to preach that the Serpent was not God, and therefore warned the people of their Idolatry in burning Incense to ⟨p. 22⟩it, only let it stand as a memorial of Gods power in curing the people, who were stung with Serpents in the Wilderness.
For then David in committing adulterie, Noah in drunkenness, Lot in his incestuous folly with his owne daughters, Peter in denying his Saviour, should not have caused others within, or without the Church to stumble, nor have culpably scandalized them; So David. Noah, Lot, and Peter, had preached to all that heard of their fall, that adulterie, drunkenness, incest, and denyall of Christ, were grievous sinnes to be avoyded, and that it was sin for any to be scandalized thereat, for such information should have given sufficient literall information to beware of the like sinnes. Yea, a father might inclose in a chamber, his sonne and a beautifull virgin, and if he should sufficiently informe his son of the guiltiness, and punishment of harlotrie, he should not lay a stumbling-block before his sonne. Yet we all know, a stumbling-block may be layed before the inclination no lesse, then before the blind minde, yea suppose, to warne a Traveller of a pit, in his way, might be sufficient, to make the digger of the pit free of laying a stumbling-block in the way (as it is not) seeing to make a pit is not indifferent, yet it shall not free the Commanders of Ceremonies and the acts of Pearth Assemblie of active scandall, because men naturally loving life and health, hate to fall into pitts, which may indanger their life, and so have no inward morall inclination to fall into a pitt; but men though informed of spirituall falls, and warned to beware of them, yet love and incline to Idolatrie, and therefore to warne them to beware, and yet set the powder neere the fire, is but to scorne the craft, and to mock men. Yea, in that they desire and require, that the people beware of the Ceremonies, and require that Pastours informe them of the danger; they grant that Ceremonies are powder amongst the pitchers, and yet they be innocent, and indifferent creatures, as if they would call them indifferent pitts, indifferent whoores to allure, beware of them; indifferent pest-cloathes, see that your inclination touch them not. Yea, then Ezechiah had given no scandall, if he had commanded the brazen Serpent still to stand, and had commanded the Priests to preach that the Serpent was not God, and therefore warned the people of their Idolatrie in burning Incence to
So if the Israelites should give their sons and daughters to marry strange women of the Canaanites, if they should ordain the Priests to teach carefully their married children, to beware, that they were not drawn away, by these idolatrous marriages, to serve the Gods of the Canaanites, they should not lay a stumbling-block before their sons and daughters. Yea, these who excel in light, may be weak in grace, and in hazard to be ensnared, by the idolatry and superstition of Ceremonies.
So if the Israelites should give their sonnes and daughters to marry strange women of the Canaanites, if they should ordaine the Priests to teach carefully their married children, to beware, that they were not drawne away, by these idolatrous marriages, to serve the Gods of the Canaanites, they should not lay a stumbling-block before their sonnes and daughters. Yea, these who excell in light, may be weake in grace, and in hazard to be insnared, by the idolatrie and superstition of Ceremonies.
4. The law of nature provideth all possible and lawful means for the removal of every thing, that may ruin his soul, for whom Christ died, but not only information of the danger of Ceremonies, but also the removal of the pits themselves, to wit, the Ceremonies are possible and lawful means.
4. The law of nature provideth all possible and lawfull meanes for the removall of every thing, that may rnine his soule, for whom Christ died, but not onely information of the danger of Ceremonies, but also the removall of the pitts themselves, to wit, the Ceremonies are possible and lawfull meanes.
5. 1. This were an idle Sabbath work to expound such themes as these Sacramental bowing is an humble adoring of God, not of bread, (and as it pleased God by the foolishness of preaching to save believers, so it pleased Prelates, by the foolishness of holy days and Saints days, to teach the people articles of faith, and by the Surplice to teach pastoral innocency, and by confirmation to bless children▪ ) 2 cCalvin, and dLuther teach, that no word should be heard in the Church, nisi purum Dei verbum, but the pure word of God. Surplice humane and Saints days, crossing, kneeling, cannot be a text that Ministers can preach on, and expound, for they are commanded to speak Gods word, Ezech. 7. To read Gods law, and give the meaning and sense thereof, Nehem. 8. 8. and to expone the Scriptures, Luk. 24. 27. not to teach the meaning of wretched Ceremonies, for in that they should not be the Pastors of Christ, but speak with the mouth of Antichrist, and Exod. 12. 26. 27. If the children ask the fathers, what mean ye by this Passover, they were to answer, It is the Sacrifice of the Lords Passover. So if they ask what meaneth your kneeling to Bread, your Saints days, your Surplice and Crossing, you must answer, they are the Ceremonies of the Lords Supper, and Baptism; What uncouth bleating were this? 6. Shall people (saith D. Ammes ebe fed with this East wind, the virtue of Surplice, when there be so little time, to learn the main ⟨p. 23⟩things of the Gospel? also some preach none, some study never Ceremonies, some blush to speak of such toys. Yea▪ and alas often saith, fBannes the weak are not capable of distinctions, it is hard to draw the wits of rude people along the untwisted thread of distinctions, that the elements are objectum adorationis à quo significative and objectum adorationis relativae materiale, non adorationis formale. I conceive the Doctors of Aberdeen have ado with their wits to understand them, they must be taught of D. Morton's essential and accidental worship; of Bellarmines additions perfecting, and additions corrupting the word of God. And whereas D. Forbes saith; It is a shame for Ministers, and teachers of others to pretend weakness, though the flock might be ignorant. Answer. Weakness, is weakness of faith,
And I think Ministers may pretend this upon too good grounds, and weakness of faith is often a great inclination to superstition. 2. Though the Ministers refusing the Ceremonies, should understand them as well as these who writ books for their defence, yet it will not follow that they should practise them, for their forbearance is for fear of scandalizing the weak. Paul had perfect knowledge of his Christian liberty, as any man, yet he would not eat meats to the worlds end, which should offend his brother. The stronger should not scandalize the weak, because they are stronger.
And I thinke Ministers may pretend this upon too good grounds, and weaknes of faith is often a great inclination to superstition. 2. Though the Ministers refusing the Ceremonies, should understand them as well as these who writ bookes for their defence, yet it will not follow that they should practise them, for their forbearance is for feare of scandalizing the weak. Paul had perfect knowledge of his Christian libertie, as any man, yet he would not eat meats to the worlds end, which should offend his brother. The stronger should not scandalize the weak, because they are stronger.
5. 1. This were an idle Sabbath work to expound such theams as these Sacramentall bowing is an humble adoring of God, not of bread, (and as it pleased God by the foolishness of preaching to save beleevers, so it pleased Prelates, by the foolishnes of holy dayes and Saints dayes, to teach the people articles of faith, and by the Surplice to teach pastorall innocencie, and by confirmation to blesse children▪ ) 2 cCalvin, and dLuther teach, that no word should be heard in the Church, nisi purum Dei verbum, but the pure word of God. Surplice humane and Saints dayes, crossing, kneeling, cannot be a text that Ministers can preach on, and expound, for they are commanded to speak Gods word, Ezech. 7. To read Gods law, and give the meaning and sense thereof, Nehem. 8. 8. and to expone the Scriptures, Luk. 24. 27. not to teach the meaning of wretched Ceremonies, for in that they should not be the Pastours of Christ, but speak with the mouth of Antichrist, and Exod. 12. 26. 27. If the children ask the fathers, what mean yee by this Passeover, they were to answer, It is the Sacrifice of the Lords Passeover. So if they ask what meaneth your kneeling to Bread, your Saints dayes, your Surplice and Crossing, you must answer, they are the Ceremonies of the Lords Supper, and Baptisme; What uncouth bleating were this? 6. Shall people (saith D. Ammes ebe fedde with this East wind, the vertue of Surplice, when there be so little time, to learne the maine ⟨p. 23⟩things of the Gospell? also some preach none, some studie never Ceremonies, some blush to speake of such toyes. Yea▪ and alas often saith, fBannes the weake are not capable of distinctions, it is hard to draw the wits of rude people along the untwisted threed of distinctions, that the elements are objectum adorationis à quo significative and objectum adorationis relativae materiale, non adorationis formale. I conceive the Doctors of Aberdeen have adoe with their wits to understand them, they must be taught of D. Mortounes essentiall and accidentall worship; of Bellarmines additions perfecting, and additions corrupting the word of God. And whereas D. Forbes saith; It is a shame for Ministers, and teachers of others to pretend weaknes, though the flock might be ignorant. Answer. Weakness, is weakness of faith, Rom. 14. 1. and weaknesse of grace, not weakness in literall light.