pp. 25–263 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
What if the thing be commanded by the Civill Magistrate under pain of death, and by Ecclesiastical authority under pain of Excommunication, shall we for fear of scandal causelessly taken, which may be removed by information, or for the scandal of the malicious, abstain from a thing lawful and expedient enjoined by authority, and incur these grievous punishments of death▪ temporal and spiritual? We believe your selves, who speak most of scandal, would be loath to take such a yoke upon you.
What if the thing be commanded by the Civill Magistrate under paine of death, and by Ecclesiasticall authoritie under paine of Excommunication, shall we for feare of scandall causlesly taken, which may be removed by information, or for the scandall of the malitious, abstaine from a thing lawfull and expedient injoyned by authoritie, and incurre these grievous punishments of death▪ temporall and spirituall? We believe your selves, who speake most of scandall, would be loath to take such a yoake upon you.
Answer. The first part of this Argument is Logic from a sore▪ skin▪ That which we are bidden do under pain of death, that we must do, the just logic of the King of Babylon, to prove it is lawful to worship the Kings golden Image, Dan. 3. 15. I have scarce heard Papists for shame press to conclude the equity and lawfulness of a Law, from the penalty of a law, Suffering (as your Jesuits and Arminians teach you) falleth not under Free-will, and is not culpably evil, nor is Excommunication except you be Papists, death of the soul, when the cause of Excommunication is not just, and deserveth no censure, but it may be some of you think (Mr. Sibbald I know doth it) that Navarrus, and their Gregory said true, that unjust Excommunication is valid, and to be feared: but if this argument (as I see not head nor feet in it) be founded upon the lawfulness and expediency of Ceremonies commanded, then not to practise them at all. So first they be lawful. 2 Expedient▪ 3 Commanded by lawful authority, is sin, and all sin is a death of the soul, and then you may put your Argument from grievous punishments of body and soul in your pocket, for it is of no use here▪ for whether punishment Civill or Ecclesiastic follow upon disobedience to Superiors, it is sin. 3. That none of us ⟨p. 26⟩would die or be Excommunicated for eschewing Scandal, is no good argument, though many have suffered as hard as death, banishment, and proscription of all, and Excommunication also. But the truth is, you might have said; Shall we incur for scandal the loss of our stipends, and (one fair before the wind, qualification) for a Bishopric?
Answer. The first part of this Argument is Logick from a sore▪ skinne▪ That which we are bidden doe under paine of death, that we must doe, the just logick of the King of Babylon, to prove it is lawfull to worship the Kings golden Image, Dan. 3. 15. I have scarce heard Papists for shame presse to conclude the equity and lawfulnesse of a Law, from the penaltie of a law, Suffering (as your Jesuits and Arminians teach you) falleth not under Free-will, and is not culpably evill, nor is Excommunication except you be Papists, death of the soule, when the cause of Excommunication is not just, and deserveth no censure, but it may be some of you think (Mr. Sibbald I know doth it) that Navarrus, and their Gregorie said true, that unjust Excommunication is valid, and to be feared: but if this argument (as I see not head nor feet in it) be founded upon the lawfulnesse and expediencie of Ceremonies commanded, then not to practise them at all. So first they be lawfull. 2 Expedient▪ 3 Commanded by lawfull authority, is sinne, and all sinne is a death of the soule, and then you may put your Argument from grievous punishments of body and soule in your pocket, for it is of no use here▪ for whether punishment Civill or Ecclesiastick follow upon disobedience to Superiours, it is sinne. 3. That none of us ⟨p. 26⟩would die or be Excommunicated for eschewing Scandall, is no good argument, though many have suffered as hard as death, banishment, and proscription of all, and Excommunication also. But the truth is, you might have said; Shall we incurre for scandall the losse of our st•pends, and (one faire before the wind, qualification) for a Bishoprick?