Answer, I deny not but it is murder, for they teach, that a man may publish that which by consequence, destroyeth the faith of fundamentals, and so subvert the faith of others, which to do is a sin, but because the man followeth the dictment of his erroneous conscience it is no sin to the man that so teacheth, yea, he may innocently suffer persecution for his conscience, thus erroneous, yea, and dye a martyr for it. Ergo, if the following of an erroneous conscience, shall make a less sin to be no sin but innocency, it shall make a greater sin, to wit, killing of his son to his heavenly father, no sin, and so he may lawfully do it. Nor will it suffice to say, to offer a man to God and kill him, is against the light of nature, and vincibly a sin; what then? if the man believe he is commanded to kill him, his erroneous conscience must bind, as the offering of whole burnt offerings to God, to us is a sin, against the light of nature, in regard the law of nature can no more warrant it, then it can warrant Christ to offer up himself to God. But upon the supposition of Libertines, it's no murder, nor is it punishable at all, because the father may, yea, & lawfully ought to worship God according to the indictment of his conscience, whither the conscience be right, or bloody and erroneous, and yet he is not punishable for blood-shed, by their way for merely, and simply, without any malignancy or hatred to the child; he believes, he ought to prefer his maker, to his dearest child's life as well as Abraham, and the conscience doth naturally, and as under no Law, simply believe it is the like service, and worship that Abraham would have ⟨p. 382⟩gratefully performed unto God, if God in reward of that love, had not forbidden him again to kill his Sonne. And this answer presupposes also, that it is impossible for a father to have such a conscience, as may stimulate, and command to kill his son, and that in the authority, and name of God, as he erroneously, yea, and as he invincibly holdeth, as Socinians, Familists, Papists, believe purgatory, merits, justification by works, who yet are not to be punished for their conscience, according to Libertines.
Answer, I deny not but it is murther, for they teach, that a man may publish that which by consequence, destroyeth the faith of fundamentals, and so subvert the faith of others, which to do is a sin, but because the man followeth the dictment of his erroneous conscience it is no sin to the man that so teacheth, yea, he may innocently suffer persecution for his conscience, thus erroneous, yea, and dye a martyr for it. Ergo, if the following of an erroneous conscience, shall make a lesse sin to be no sin but innocency, it shall make a greater sin, to wit, killing of his son to his heavenly father, no sin, and so he may lawfully do it. Nor wil it suffice to say, to offer a man to God and kill him, is against the light of nature, and vincibly a sin; what then? if the man beleeve he is commanded to kill him, his erroneous conscience must bind, as the offering of whole burnt offerings to God, to us is a sin, against the light of nature, in regard the law of nature can no more warrant it, then it can warrant Christ to offer up himself to God. But upon the supposition of Libertines, it's no murther, nor is it punishable at al, because the father may, yea, & lawfully ought to worship God according to the indictment of his conscience, whither the conscience be right, or bloody and erroneous, and yet he is not punishable for blood-shed, by their way for meerly, and simply, without any malignancy or hatred to the child; he beleeves, he ought to preferre his maker, to his dearest childs life as well as Abraham, and the conscience doth naturally, and as under no Law, simply beleeve it is the like service, and worship that Abraham would have ⟨p. 382⟩gratefully performed unto God, if God in reward of that love, had not forbidden him againe to kill his Sonne. And this answer presupposes also, that it is impossible for a father to have such a conscience, as may stimulate, and command to kill his son, and that in the authority, and name of God, as he erroneously, yea, and as he invincibly holdeth, as Socinians, Familists, Papists, beleeve purgatory, merits, justification by workes, who yet are not to be punished for their conscience, according to Libertines.