But if on the contrary the offender stand out in defence of his sin, as well against the whole Church, as he did before against the Brethren, who dealt with him in private, the Church then entereth into consideration of the Nature and Quality of the offence, whether it be gross and heinous, such as is condemned by the light of nature, (like those cast out by the Apostle, 1 Cor. 5.11.) or whether it be such as (through some mist of ignorance, or strength of present passion) he doth not clearly discern the sinfulness of it: if it be of the former sort, they proceed then to excommunication, both in respect of the nature of the crime (whereof more hereafter) as also in respect of his contumacy to the Church. If it be of the later sort, the Church proceedeth not forthwith to excommunication of the offender, but after once or twice admonition; For in this case it is with the offender as with an Heretic, who may err at first, and stand in his error, for want of clear light, and is therefore once and again (according to the rule of the Apostle, Tit. 3.10) to be admonished before he be rejected: when therefore an admonition is judged seasonable, one of the Elders, with the consent of the whole Church, doth recollect the offence, and all the arguments of weight, which have been publicly or privately used to convince the offender of his sin, and discovereth to him also, that invalidity and shallowness of all his answers and evasions; and thereupon doth solemnly, in the name of the Lord, admonish and charge him to see the danger of such a sin, and distemper of his soul, in maintaining of it; that so (if it be the will of God) he may be recovered out of the snare of the Tempter. Whilst the Brother is thus cast, and lieth under the censure of admonition, he standeth in the judgement of the whole Church, as a convinced public offender; and therefore, till he be reconciled to the Church by the penitent and public acknowledgement of his sin before them, he doth abstain from the Lords Table; according to the direction of our Saviour, who would not have an offender present himself nor his gift before the altar, whilst the guilt of the offence of his brother lay upon him, Mat. 5.23, 24. or, as the Priests in the Law did forbear to eat of the holy bread, whilst they lay in uncleanness, Lev. 22.3, 4.
But if on the contrary the offender stand out in defence of his sin, as well against the whole Church, as he did before against the Brethren, who dealt with him in private, the Church then entereth into consideration of the Nature and Quality of the offence, whether it be grosse and hainous, such as is condemned by the light of nature, (like those cast out by the Apostle, 1 Cor. 5.11.) or whether it be such as (through some mist of ignorance, or strength of present passion) he doth not clearly discerne the sinfulnesse of it: if it be of the former sort, they proceed then to excommunication, both in respect of the nature of the crime (whereof more hereafter) as also in respect of his contumacy to the Church. If it be of the later sort, the Church proceedeth not forthwith to excommunication of the offender, but after once or twice admonition; For in this case it is with the offender as with an Heretike, who may erre at first, and stand in his error, for want of clear light, and is therefore once and again (according to the rule of the Apostle, Tit. 3.10) to be admonished before he be rejected: when therefore an admonition is judged seasonable, one of the Elders, with the consent of the whole Church, doth recollect the offence, and all the arguments of weight, which have been publikely or privately used to convince the offender of his sinne, and discovereth to him also, that invalidity and shallownesse of all his answers and evasions; and thereupon doth solemnly, in the name of the Lord, admonish and charge him to see the danger of such a sin, and distemper of his soule, in maintaining of it; that so (if it be the will of God) he may be recovered out of the snare of the Tempter. Whilst the Brother is thus cast, and lyeth under the censure of admonition, he standeth in the judgement of the whole Church, as a convinced publike offender; and therefore, till hee be reconciled to the Church by the penitent and publique acknowledgement of his sin before them, hee doth abstain from the Lords Table; according to the direction of our Saviour, who would not have an offender present himself nor his gift before the altar, whilest the guilt of the offence of his brother lay upon him, Mat. 5.23, 24. or, as the Priests in the Law did forbear to eat of the holy bread, whilest they lay in uncleannesse, Lev. 22.3, 4.