If this is not remembered, the true State of the Question is forgotten: The Argument ought to be formed thus, All the Adult Members in the Church have in the sight of God, a right to the Sacrament: But some Adult Members in the Church are Unregenerates and Hypocrites, therefore some Unregenerate men, and Hypocrites have in the sight of God, a right unto the Sacrament. Now the Proposition, or Major of his Syllogism is denied. Nor has Mr. S. in all his Sermon said any thing to Prove it: His confounding a right to Sacraments, in foro Poli, as Divines express it, in the sight of Heaven, with a right in foro Solt, in the sight of men, has led him into Mistakes. Hence he argues, It is Lawful for Unregenerate men to keep Covenant with God. Who can deny that? But they must really be in Covenant with God, before they can Keep His Covenant. If men come to the ⟨p. 78⟩Lords Supper in their Sins, they will not thereby keep Gods Covenant, but Profane and Pollute it. Men may be visible Saints, and Pollute it. Men may be visible Saints, and externally in Covenant with God, and often renew their Covenant by coming to His Table, and yet God not approve of their meddling with his holy Institutions, but says of them, That they have nothing to do, to take His Covenant into their Mouths, because they hate Conversion & Godliness, in the Power of it. Let not this seem strange, (s)for it is Plain clear Scripture, Psal. 50. 5, 16, 17. When Mr. S. argues, That it is the Churches duty to receive Unregenerate men, Nay, to require them to come to the Lords Table, and it would be very strange (he thinks) that it should be the Duty of the Church to require them to come, and yet their Duty to stay away because Unconverted. (p. 12, 24.) But let it not seem a Paradox, to say, it may be the duty of the Church to receive those, who nevertheless ought not to come to the Lords Supper, because, De occultis non judicat Ecclesia. Some men know that by themselves which if the Church knew of them, they would never receive them. Who ought to come, and Who are to be received, are two distinct Questions; as (t)Ursin & Pareus have ⟨p. 79⟩rightly determined. Another great Divine (u)distinguisheth these two things, Who ought to come to the Sacrament, and who ought to be admitted. None ought to come, except those who truly Believe and Repent; none ought to be admitted, except such as are supposed to be Believers and Penitent. Mr.
If this is not remembred, the true State of the Question is forgotten: The Argument ought to be formed thus, All the Adult Members in the Church have in the sight of God, a right to the Sacrament: But some Adult Members in the Church are Unregenerates and Hypocrites, therefore some Unregenerate men, and Hypocrites have in the sight of God, a right unto the Sacrament. Now the Proposition, or Major of his Syllogism is denyed. Nor has Mr. S. in all his Sermon said any thing to Prove it: His confounding a right to Sacraments, in foro Poli, as Divines express it, in the sight of Heaven, with a right in foro Solt, in the sight of men, has led him into Mistakes. Hence he argues, It is Lawful for Unregenerate men to keep Covenant with God. Who can deny that? But they must really be in Covenant with God, before they can Keep His Covenant. If men come to the ⟨p. 78⟩Lords Supper in their Sins, they will not thereby keep Gods Covenant, but Profane and Pollute it. Men may be visible Saints, and Pollute it. Men may be visible Saints, and externally in Covenant with God, and often renew their Covenant by coming to His Table, and yet God not approve of their medling with his holy Institutions, but says of them, That they have nothing to do, to take His Covenant into their Mouths, because they hate Conversion & Godliness, in the Power of it. Let not this seem strange, (s)for it is Plain clear Scripture, Psal. 50. 5, 16, 17. When Mr. S. argues, That it is the Churches duty to receive Unregenerate men, Nay, to require them to come to the Lords Table, and it would be very strange (he thinks) that it should be the Duty of the Church to require them to come, and yet their Duty to stay away because Unconverted. (p. 12, 24.) But let it not seem a Paradox, to say, it may be the duty of the Church to receive those, who nevertheless ought not to come to the Lords Supper, because, De occultis non judicat Ecclesia. Some men know that by themselves which if the Church knew of them, they would never receive them. Who ought to come, and Who are to be received, are two distinct Questions; as (t)Ursin & Pareus have ⟨p. 79⟩rightly determined. Another great Divine (u)distinguisheth these two things, Who ought to come to the Sacrament, and who ought to be admitted. None ought to come, except those who truly Believe and Repent; none ought to be admitted, except such as are supposed to be Believers and Penitent. Mr.
- (s)See Mr. Pools Annot. on Psal. 50.
- (t)Catech, in Quest. 131.
- (u)Gillespy. Ubi Supra sic etiam, Rutherford apud Baxter. p. 390.