pp. 6696,663 passagespart 43 of 167
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Green. Sir, I have no authority to judge any man: nevertheless, I doubt not but that I am of the true catholic church, howsoever our lear••• men here judge of me.
Welsh. Why, then do you suppose your own wit and learning better than all their's? If you do not give credit only to them, other learned […] shall resort unto you, that shall persuade you by the scriptures and doctors.
Welch. Why, then do you suppose your own wit and learning better than all their's? If you do not give credit only to them, other learned 〈…〉 shall resort unto you, that shall persuade you by the scriptures and doctors.
Green. Sir, God knoweth that I refuse not to learn any child, but I would embrace the truth from the mouth of a natural fool, in any thing wherein I am ignorant, and that in all things, saving my saith: but concerning the truth, wherein I am thoroughly persuaded, I cannot submit myself to learn, unless it be, as your mastership said, that I peruse books on both sides. For so might I make myself an indifferent judge; otherwise I may be seduced. AND here we had a long discourse of the church, wherein his learning and wit was far above mine: but in the end I told him I was persuaded, and that he did but lose his labour.
Green. Sir, God knoweth that I refuse not to learn any child, but I would embrace the truth from the mouth of a natural fool, in any thing wherein I am ignorant, and that in all things, saving my saith: but concerning the truth, wherein I am thorougly persuaded, I cannot submit myself to learn, unless it be, as your mastership said, that I peruse books on both sides. For so might I make myself an indifferent judge; otherwise I may be seduced. AND here we had a long discourse of the church, wherein his learning and wit was far above mine: but in the end I told him I was persuaded, and that he did but lose his labour.
Welsh. Why then, what shall I report to my lord?
Welch. Why then, what shall I report to my lord?
Green. Even as it pleaseth you, or else you may say that I would be glad to learn, if I had books on both sides.
SO he going in, the bishops (being risen and ready to depart) asked how he liked me? He answered, In faith, my lord, he will be glad to learn. Which words when they were spoken, lest they should mistake his meaning and mine, I said, yea, so that I have books on both sides, as Calvin, and my lord of Canterbury's books, and such others. Well, said my lord, I will satisfy thy mind therein also; and they were all in great hopes, that shortly I should become a good catholic as they call it.
THEN was I brought into my lord's inner chamber (where you were) and there was put in a chamber with Mr. Dee, who treated me very friendly. That night I supped at my lord's table, and lay with Mr. Dee in the chamber you did see. On the morrow I was served at dinner from my lord's table, and at night did eat in the hall with his gentleman; where I have been placed ever since, and fared wonderful well. Yea, to say the truth, I had my liberty within the bounds of his lordship's house: for my lodgings and fare, scarce have I been at any time abroad in better case so long together, and have found so much gentleness of my lord and his chaplains, and other servants, that I should easily have forgotten that I was in prison, were it not that this good cheer was often powdered with unsavoury sauces of examinations, exhortations, posings, and disputations.
THEN was I brought into my lord's inner chamber (where you were) and there was put in a chamber with Mr. Dee, who treated me very friendly. That night I supped at my lord's table, and lay with Mr. Dee in the chamber you did see. On the morrow I was served at dinner from my lord's table, and at night did eat in the hall with his gentleman; where I have been placed ever since, and fared wonderful well. Yea, to say the truth, I had my liberty within the bounds of his lordship's house: for my lodgings and fare, scarce have I been at any time abroad in better case so long together, and have found so much gentleness of my lord and his chaplains, and other servants, that I should easily have forgotten that I was in prison, were it not that this good chear was often powdered with unsavoury sauces of examinations, exhortations, posings, and disputations.
FOR shortly after supper, the first Monday at night, I was had into my lord's bed chamber, and there he would know of me how I came first into these heresies: I said, I was persuaded thereto by the scriptures, and authorities of the doctors, alleged by Peter Martyr in his lectures upon the eleventh chapter of the first epistle to the Corinthians, while he treated there on that place of the Lord's supper for a month together. But then my lord enforced the plainness of Christ's words, and his almighty power, demanding of me, what reason should move me from the literal sense of the words: but I having no lust to those matters, would have alleged that there were books sufficient of that matter, as Peter Martyr, Cranmer, and Oecolampadius: nevertheless, when this shift would not serve, but I was constrained to say somewhat, I said I was moved from the literal sense by the manner of speaking, by the circumstance, and by conference of other places of the scriptures. It is evident that Christ took bread, and that he showed them (they seeing it) bread, which he affirmed to be his body.
FOR shortly after supper, the first Monday at night, I was had into my lord's bed chamber, and there he would know of me how I came first into these heresies: I said, I was persuaded thereto by the scriptures, and authorities of the doctors, alledged by Peter Martyr in his lectures upon the eleventh chapter of the first epistle to the Corinthians, while he treated there on that place of the Lord's supper for a month together. But then my lord inforced the plainness of Christ's words, and his almighty power, demanding of me, what reason should move me from the literal sense of the words: but I having no lust to those matters, would have alledged that there were books sufficient of that matter, as Peter Martyr, Cranmer, and Oecolampadius: nevertheless, when this shift would not serve, but I was constrained to say somewhat, I said I was moved from the literal sense by the manner of speaking, by the circumstance, and by conference of other places of the scriptures. It is evident that Christ took bread, and that he shewed them (they seeing it) bread, which he affirmed to be his body.
CHRIST affirmed that bread was body.
BUT that affirmation taken literally, can by no means be true.
ERGO, The words, if they be taken according to the letter, cannot be true.
FOR this predication, Panis est corpus Christi, or, Corpus Christi est panis, is neither Identica nor Accidentalis, nor Essentialis praedicatio. Wherefore of necessity I must say it was spoken in the same sense, as Christ was a door, a vine, and a way. Neither can it serve to say, that it was not bread that he affirmed to be his body, and that for two causes.
FOR whatsoever he showed, that was bread, for nought else was seen.
FOR whatsoever he shewed, that was bread, for nought else was seen.
BUT that which he showed he affirmed to be his body.
BUT that which he shewed he affi•med to be his body.
THE second reason is, For that it was not changed before, seeing Benedixit, is Gratias egit, or else Christ affirmed no true proposition, and you are without authority.
IN the end of this letter there were noted these sentences following, collected for confirmation of his former assertions, viz.
Eadem locutio populi, that is, The phrase is used and spoken upon the cup.
Dicitur postea panis. It is called bread in the same place afterwards.
Eadem ratione rejecero corpus, qua tu panem, that ⟨p. 148⟩is, By the same reason as it may be denied to be bread, it may be denied to be the body.
Ascendit in coelum, that is, His body ascended into heaven.
Corpore nobis fectus est similis in omnibus post nativitatem. At nostrum corpus non potest esse in duobus locis. Ergo, &c. In body he was like to us in all things after his nativity (sin excepted). Seeing then our body cannot be in two places at once: Ergo, neither his.
Discipuli non stupebant, &c. His disciples took it as no miracle nor wonder.
THUS, as it seemeth, for this time they left off. But not long after the bishop perceiving Green's learning and constancy to be such, as neither he, nor any of his doctors and chaplains could by the scriptures refute, began then to object and put in practice his chief and strongest argument against him; which was the rigour of the law, and cruelty of execution: an argument, I assure you, which without the special grace of our God to flesh is insupportable. And therefore using law as a cloak of his tyranny, the 28th day of November, the said bishop examined him upon certain points of christian religion. Whereunto when he had answered, the bishop appointed the register (as their most common manner is) there to draw out an order of confession: which being afterwards read unto Green, was also subscribed by him, as a confirmation of his former assertions: the tenor whereof here ensueth.
BARTLET GREEN, born in the city of London, in the parish of Basing-hall, of the diocese of London, and of the age of 25 years, being examined in the bishop's palace the 27th day of November, Anno 1555, upon certain articles▪ answered as followeth, viz. That neither in the time of king Edward, after the mass by him was put down, neither in the time of queen Mary after the mass was restored again, he hath heard […] mass at all; but he saith that in the reign of the said queen's majesty, he the said Bartlet, two times, to wit, at two Easter-tides or days, in the chamber of John Pulline, one of the preachers in king Edward's time, within the parish of St. Michael's, Cornhill, of the diocese of London, did receive the communion with the said Pulline, and Christopher Goodman, sometime reader of the divinity lecture in Oxford, now gone beyond the sea; and the second time with the said Pulline, and with one Rimneger, Master of Arts, of Magdalen college, in Oxford: and this examinate also saith, that at both the said communions, he and the other […] named, did take and receive bread and wine, […] bread and wine he c•lled sacramental bread, […] sacramental wine, which he saith were used there by them, Pulline only reading the words of the institution, expressed in the book of communion. IN which receiving and using, this examinate saith, that the others aforenamed did receive the sacrament of the Lord's-supper, and that they received material bread and material wine, no substance thereof changed, and so no real presence of the body and blood of Christ there being, but only grace added thereto. And further, this examinate saith, that he had heretofore, during the reign of the queen's-majesty aforesaid, refused▪ and so now doth refuse to come and hear mass, and to receive the sacrament of the altar, as they are now used and administered in this church of England, because he saith, that concerning the mass, he cannot be persuaded in his conscience, that the sacrifice pretended to be in the same, is agreeable to God's word, or maintainable by the same: and that without deadly offence he cannot worship the body and blood of Christ that is pretended to be there.
BARTLET GREEN, born in the city of London, in the parish of Basing-hall, of the diocese of London, and of the age of 25 years, being examined in the bishop's palace the 27th day of November, Anno 1555, upon certain articles▪ answered as followeth, viz. That neither in the time of king Edward, after the mass by him was put down, neither in the time of queen Mary after the mass was restored again, he hath heard mass at all; but he saith that in the reign of the said queen's majesty, he the said Bartlet, two times, to wit, at two Easter-tides or days, in the chamber of John Pulline, one of the preachers in king Edward's time, within the parish of St. Michael's, Cornhill, of the diocese of London, did receive the communion with the said Pulline, and Christopher Goodman, sometime reader of the divinity lecture in Oxford, now gone beyond the sea; and the second time with the said Pulline, and with one Rimneger, Master of Arts, of Magdalen college, in Oxford: and this examinate also saith, that at both the said communions, he and the other named, did take and receive bread and wine, bread and wine he clled sacramental bread, sacramental wine, which he saith were used there by them, Pulline only reading the words of the institution, expressed in the book of communion. IN which receiving and using, this examinate saith, that the others aforenamed did receive the sacrament of the Lord's-supper, and that they received material bread and material wine, no substance thereof changed, and so no real presence of the body and blood of Christ there being, but only grace added thereto. And further, this examinate saith, that he had heretofore, during the reign of the queen's-majesty aforesaid, refused and so now doth refuse to come and hear mass, and to receive the sacrament of the altar, as they are now used and administered in this church of England, because he saith, that concerning the mass, he cannot be persuaded in his conscience, that the sacrifice pretended to be in the same, is agreeable to God's word, or maintainable by the same: and that without deadly offence he cannot worship the body and blood of Christ that is pretended to be there.
And as concerning the sacrament of the altar, this examinate saith, that he heretofore during the said reign, hath refused, and now doth refuse to receive the same▪ as is now used in this church of England, because it is not used according to the institution of Christ▪ but both in a strange tongue, and also ministered ⟨p. 149⟩in both kinds; and besides that, contrary to God's word it is there taught, that the thing there administered is to be adored, as the real and true body of Christ. And furthermore this examinate saith, that during the said reign he hath not been confessed to the priest, nor received absolution at his hands, because he is not bound by God's word to make auricular confession. BARTLET GREEN.
MANY other conferences and examinations they brought him unto. But in the end (seeing his steadiness of faith to be such, against which neither their threatenings, nor yet their flattering promises could prevail) the 13th day of January the bishop caused him with the rest before mentioned, to be brought into the consistory of St. Paul's; where being set in his judgment seat, accompanied by Mr. Fecknam, then d•an of the same church, and other his chaplains, after he had condemned the other six, he then calling for Bartlet Green, began with these, or the like words:
MANY other conferences and examinations they brought him unto. But in the end (seeing his steadiness of faith to be such, against which neither their threatnings, nor yet their flattering promises could prevail) the 13th day of January the bishop caused him with the rest before mentioned, to be brought into the consistory of St. Paul's; where being set in his judgment seat, accompanied by Mr. Fecknam, then d•an of the same church, and other his chaplains, after he had condemned the other six, he then calling for Bartlet Green, began with these, or the like words:
HONOURABLE AUDIENCE, I think it best to op•n unto you the conversation of this man, called Bartlet Green. And▪ because you shall not charge me, that I go about to seek any man's blood, here you shall hear the council's letters which they sent with him unto me. The effect whereof is; that whereas he had been a long time confined in the tower of London for heresy, they have now sent him unto me to be ordered, according to the laws therefore provided. And now •o thee, Bartlet Green, I propose these nine articles. Then he read the articles before mentioned, which were generally objected to all these seven prisoners, to wit, Thomas Whittle, John Tudson, John Went, Thomas Brown, Isabel Foster, Joan Lashford, Bartlet Green.
BUT when Mr. Green would have answered them particularly▪ he was put to silence, with promise that he should have time to answer sufficiently and therefore •he bishop proceeding, said, that when Green came first to his house, he desired to have the books of the ancient doctors of the church to read which he said he granted him.
WHEREUNTO Green answered, and said, that if the doctors were with indifferent judgment weighed, they made more a great deal with him, than they did with them.
UPON which words, Dr. Fecknam, dean of St. Paul's, stood up, and marvelling why he said so, asked him if he would be content to stand to the judgment of the doctors.
GREEN then said, that he was content to stand to the doctors' judgment.
I will then propound unto you (said Fecknam) the doctors, and interpret them yourself. So he alleged a place of Chrysostom, Ad popul. Antioch. which was this: Elijah ascendens melotam suam post se reliquit: Christus vero ascendens carnem suam assumpsit, & eandem post see reliquit. "Elijah going up, left his cloak behind him: but Christ ascending up took his flesh, and also left it behind him." And he demanded of Green how he understood the place.
I will then propound unto you (said Fecknam) the doctors, and interpret them yourself. So he alledged a place of Chrysostom, Ad popul. Antioch. which was this: Elias ascendens melotam suam post se reliquit: Christus vero ascendens carnem suam assumpsit, & eandem post se reliquit. "Elias going up, left his cloak behind him: but Christ ascending up took his flesh, and also left it behind him." And he demanded of Green how he understood the place.
THEN Green desired him that he would confer the doctors' sayings together, and therefore alleged the same doctor again, writing upon 1 Cor. x. "Is not the bread which we bless the communication of the Lord's body?" Whereby he proved that this doctor called this sacrament but a sign of the Lord's body. Many other words of probation and trial were between them.
THEN Green desired him that he would confer the doctors' sayings together, and therefore alledged the same doctor again, writing upon 1 Cor. x. "Is not the bread which we bless the communication of the Lord's body?" Whereby he proved that this doctor called this sacrament but a sign of the Lord's body. Many other words of probation and trial were between them.
AT last Fecknam demanded of him, how long he had been of this opinion. For Mr. Green, said he, you confessed once to me, that when you were at Oxford at school, you were called the rankest papist in that house, and being compelled to go to the the lecture of Peter Martyr, you were converted from your old doctrine.
AND Green confessed the same.
THEN Fecknam said, that Green told him the said Peter Martyr was a papist at his first coming to Oxford. Whereupon he made an exclamation, and prayed the people to consider how vain his doctrine was that he professed, which was grounded upon one man, and that upon so inconstant a man as Peter Martyr, who perceiving the wicked intent of ⟨p. 150⟩the council, was content to please them, and forsake the true and catholic faith.
GREEN said, that he grounded not his faith upon Peter Martyr nor any other, nor did believe so because Peter Martyr believed the same; but because he had heard the scriptures, and the doctors of the church truly and wholesomely expounded by him; neither had he any regard of the man, but of the word which he spake. And further he said, that he heard the said Peter Martyr say often, that he had not, while he was a papist, read Chrysostom upon the •enth to the Corinthians, nor many other places of the doctors: but when he had read them and wel• considered them, he was content to yield to the doctors, having first humbled himself in prayer, desiring God to illuminate him, and bring him to the true understanding of the scripture. Which thing (said Green) if you, my lord, would do, I do not doubt but God would open your eyes, and show you his truth, no more than I doubt his words to be true that saith, "Ask, and it shall be given to you; knock, and it shall be opened unto you," &c.
GREEN said, that he grounded not his faith upon Peter Martyr nor any other, nor did believe so because Peter Martyr believed the same; but because he had heard the scriptures, and the doctors of the church truly and wholesomely expounded by him; neither had he any regard of the man, but of the word which he spake. And further he said, that he heard the said Peter Martyr say often, that he had not, while he was a papist, read Chrysostom upon the •enth to the Corinthians, nor many other places of the doctors: but when he had read them and wel• considered them, he was content to yield to the doctors, having first humbled himself in prayer, desiring God to illuminate him, and bring him to the true understanding of the scripture. Which thing (said Green) if you, my lord, would do, I do not doubt but God would open your eyes, and shew you his truth, no more than I doubt his words to be true that saith, "Ask, and it shall be given to you; knock, and it shall be opened unto you," &c.
THEN Fecknam asked him what he thought of this article, The holy catholic church.