pp. 6696,663 passagespart 49 of 167
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
WELL, not long after this king Edward died, being almost sixteen years old, to the great sorrow, but greater calamity of the whole realm. After whose decease, immediately it was commanded that the lady Jane (who was unwilling thereunto) should be proclaimed queen. Which thing the common people much disliked, not that they did so much favour the lady Mary, before whom they saw the lady Jane preferred, as for the hatred conceived against some whom they could not favour.
BESIDES this, there happened also other causes of […] between the nobles and commons the same […] what injuries of commons and enclosures wrongfully held, with other inordinate pollings and uncharitable dealings between the landlords and tenants, I cannot tell. But in fine, thus the matter •ell out, that the lady Mary hearing of the death of her brother, and shifting for herself, was so assisted by the commons, that she soon prevailed. Who being established in the possession of the realm, not long after came to London: and after she had first caused the two fathers, the duke of Northumberland, and the duke of Suffolk, to be beheaded (as […] been already related), she likewise caused the lady Jane, being both in age tender, and innocent from this crime, after she could by no means be earned from the constancy of her faith, together with her husband, to be beheaded.
BESIDES this, there happened also other causes of 〈…〉 between the nobles and commons the same 〈…〉 what injuries of commons and enclosures wrongfully held, with other inordinate pollings and •ncharitable dealings between the landlords and tenants, I cannot tell. But in fine, thus the matter •ell out, that the lady Mary hearing of the death of her brother, and shifting for herself, was so assisted by the commons, that she soon prevailed. Who being established in the possession of the realm, not long after came to London: and after she had first caused the two fathers, the duke of Northumberland, and the duke of Suffolk, to be beheaded (as 〈…〉 been already related), she likewise caused the lady Jane, being both in age tender, and innocent from this crime, after she could by no means be earned from the constancy of her faith, together with her husband, to be beheaded.
THE rest of the nobles, paying fines, were forgiven, the archbishop of Canterbury only excepted: […] though he desired pardon, by means of his […], could obtain none; insomuch that the queen would not once vouchsafe to see him. For as yet the old grudge against the archbishop for the divorcement of her mother, remained hid in the bottom of her heart. Besides this divorce, she remembered the state of religion changed: all which was imputed to the archbishop as the cause thereof.
THE rest of the nobles, paying fines, were forgiven, the archbishop of Canterbury only excepted: 〈…〉 though he desired pardon, by means of his 〈…〉, could obtain none; insomuch that the queen would not once vouchsafe to see him. For as yet the old grudge against the archbishop for the divorcement of her mother, remained hid in the bottom of her heart. Besides this divorce, she remembered the state of religion changed: all which was imputed to the archbishop as the cause thereof.
WHILE these things were doing, a rumour was in all men's mouths, that the archbishop, to gain favour with the queen, had promised to say a dirge mass after the old custom, for the funeral of king Edward, her brother. Neither wanted there some who reported that he had already said mass at Canterbury; which mass indeed was said by Dr. Thornton. This rumour Cranmer thinking speedily to stop, gave forth a writing of his purgation: the tenor whereof being before expressed, I need not here again recite.
THIS bill being thus written, and lying openly in a window in his chamber, cometh in by chance Mr. Story, then bishop of Rochester, who after he had read and perused the same, required the archbishop to have a copy of the bill. The archbishop granting the same, and by Mr. Story's lending it to another friend, there were divers copies taken, and the thing published abroad among the common people, insomuch that almost every scrivener's shop was occupied in copying out the same: and so at length some of these copies coming to the bishop's hands, and so brought to the council, and they sending it to the commissioners, the matter was known, and so he commanded to appear.
WHEREUPON Dr. Cranmer appeared at the day prefixed, before the said commissioners, bringing a true inventory, as he was commanded, of all his goods. That done, a bishop of the queen's privy council, being one of the said commissioners, after the inventory was received, made mention of the bill: My lord, said he, there is a bill put forth in your name, wherein you seem to be aggrieved with setting up the mass again; we doubt not but you are sorry that it is gone abroad.
TO whom the archbishop answered, As I do not deny myself to be the author of that bill or letter, so must I confess here unto you, concerning the same bill, that I am sorry that the said bill went from me in such sort as it did. For when I had written it, Mr. Story got the copy from me, and it is now come abroad, and as I understand, the city is full of it. For which I am sorry, that it so passed my hands: for I intended otherwise to have made it in a more large and ample manner, and minded to have set it on St. Paul's-church door, and on the doors of all the churches in London, with mine own seal joined thereunto.
AT which words, when they saw the constancy of the man, they dismissed him, affirming they had no more at present to say unto him, but that shortly he should hear farther. The said bishop declared afterwards to one of Dr. Cranmer's friends, that notwithstanding his attainder of treason, the queen's determination at that time was, that Cranmer should only be deprived of his archbishopric, and have had a sufficient living assigned him, upon his exhibiting of a true inventory, with commandment to keep his house without meddling in matters of religion. But how true that was I have not to say. This is certain, that not long after this, he was sent to the Tower, and soon after condemned for treason. Notwithstanding the queen, when she could not honestly deny him his pardon, seeing all the rest were ⟨p. 184⟩discharged, and especially, seeing he last (of all others) subscribed to king Edward's request, and that against his own will, released to him his action of treason, and accused him only of heresy, which the archbishop liked well, and came to pass as he wished, because the cause was not his own but Christ's; not the queen's but the church's. Thus stood the cause of Cranmer, till at length it was determined by the queen and the council, that he should be removed from the Tower where he was prisoner, to Oxford, there to dispute with the doctors and divines. And privily word was sent before to them of Oxford to prepare themselves, and make them ready to dispute. And although the queen and the bishops had concluded before what should become of him, yet it pleased them that the matter should be debated with arguments, that under some honest show of disputation the murder of the man might be covered. Neither could their hasty speed of revenge abide any long delay; and therefore in all haste he was carried to Oxford.
AT which words, when they saw the constancy of the man, they dismissed him, affirming they had no more at present to say unto him, but that shortly he should hear farther. The said bishop declared afterwards to one of Dr. Cranmer's friends, that notwithstanding his attainder of treason, the queen's determination at that time was, that Cranmer should only be deprived of his archbishopric, and have had a sufficient living assigned him, upon his exhibiting of a true inventory, with commandment to keep his house without meddling in matters of religion. But how true that was I have not to say. This is certain, that not long after this, he was sent to the Tower, and soon after condemned for treason. Notwithstanding the queen, when she could not honestly deny him his pardon, seeing all the rest were
WHAT this disputation was and how it was handled, what were the questions and reasons on both sides, and also touching his condemnation by the university and prolocutor, because it hath been sufficiently declared, we intend now therefore to proceed to his final judgment and order of condemnation, which was the twelfth day of September, 1555, and seven days before the condemnation of bishop Ridley and Mr. Latimer, as is before-mentioned. The story whereof here followeth, faithfully corrected by the report and narration (coming by chance to our hands) of one who being both present thereat, and also a devout favourer of the see and faction of Rome, can lack no credit (I think) with such who seek what they can to discredit whatsoever maketh not with their fancied religion of Rome.
AFTER the disputations done and finished in Oxford between the doctors of both universities, and the three worthy bishops, Drs. Cranmer, Ridley, and Latimer, ye heard then how sentence condemnatory, immediately upon the same, was administered against them by Dr. Weston and others of the university; whereby they were judged to be here••••, and so committed to the mayor and sheriffs of Oxford. But forasmuch as the sentence given against them was void in law, (for at that time […] authority of the pope was not yet received into the land) therefore a new commission was sent from Rome, and a new process framed for the conviction of these reverend and godly learned men aforesaid. In which commission, first was Dr. James Brooks, bishop of Gloucester, the pope's sub delegate, with Dr. Martin and Dr. Story, commissioners in the king and queen's behalf for the execution of the same. Of which three commissioners above-named, as touching Dr. Martin, this by the way is to be understood, that although he was used for an instrument of the pope's side to serve a turn (whose book also is extant against the lawful marriage of priests) yet notwithstanding neither was he so bitter an enemy in this persecution as the other commissioners were; and also in the time of queen Elizabeth, were divers other doctors of the arches refused to be sworn against the pope, he denied not the oath; and yet notwithstanding not altogether here to be excused. But to the purpose of this st••ry. Whereof, first, it shall be requisite to decla•• the circumstance, and the whole state of the ma• ter, as in a general description, before we come to their orations, according as, in a part of a certain letter concerning the same, it came to our hands.
AFTER the disputations done and finished in Oxford between the doctors of both universities, and the three worthy bishops, Drs. Cranmer, Ridley, and Latimer, ye heard then how sentence condemnatory, immediately upon the same, was administered against them by Dr. Weston and others of the university; whereby they were judged to be here••••, and so committed to the mayor and sheriffs of Oxford. But forasmuch as the sentence given against them was void in law, (for at that time 〈…〉 authority of the pope was not yet received into the land) therefore a new commission was sent from Rome, and a new process framed for the conviction of these reverend and godly learned men aforesaid. In which commission, first was Dr. James Brooks, bishop of Gloucester, the pope's sub delegate, with Dr. Martin and Dr. Story, commissioners in the king and queen's behalf for the execution of the same. Of which three commissioners above-named, as touching Dr. Martin, this by the way is to be understood, that although he was used for an instrument of the pope's side to serve a turn (whose book also is extant against the lawful marriage of priests) yet notwithstanding neither was he so bitter an enemy in this persecution as the other commissioners were; and also in the time of queen Elizabeth, were divers other doctors of the arches refused to be sworn against the pope, he denied not the oath; and yet notwithstanding not altogether here to be excused. But to the purpose of this stry. Whereof, first, it shall be requisite to decla the circumstance, and the whole state of the ma ter, as in a general description, before we come to their orations, according as, in a part of a certain letter concerning the same, it came to our hands.
IMPRIMIS, Here is to be understood, that at the coming down of the aforesaid commissioners, which was upon Thursday the 12th of September, 1555, in the church of St. Mary, and in the east end of the said church, at the high altar, was erected a solemn scaffold for bishop-Brooks aforesaid, representing the pope's person ten feet high. The seat was made that he might sit under the sacrament of the altar. And on the right hand of the pope's delegate, beneath him sat Dr. Martin, and on the left hand sat Dr. Story, the king and queen's commissioners, who were both doctors of the civil law, and underneath them other doctors, scribes and pharisees also, with the pope's collector, and a number of such others.
AND thus these bishops being placed in their pontificials, the archbishop of Canterbury was sent for to come before them. He having intelligence of ⟨p. 185⟩them that were there, thus ordered himself. He came forth of the prison to the church of St. Mary, set forth with bills and spears for fear he should start away, being clothed in a fair black gown, with his hood on both shoulders, such as doctors of divinity use to wear in the university. Who, after he came into the church, and did see them sit in their pontificals, he did not pull off his cap to any of them, but stood still till he was called.
AND anon one of the ••octors for the pope, also his doctor, called, Thomas, archbishop of Canterbury, appear here and make answer to what shall be laid to thy charge; that is to say, for blasphemy, incontinence and heresy; and make answer here to the bishop of Gloucester, representing the pope's person.
UPON this he being brought nearer unto the scaffold, where the aforesaid bishop sat, he first well viewed the place of judgment, and espying where the king and queen's majesties' proctors were, putting off his cap, he first humbly bowing his knee to the ground, made reverence to the one, and after to the other.
THAT done, beholding the bishop in the face, he put on his bonnet again, making no manner of token of obedience towards him at all. Whereat the bishop being offended, said unto him, that it might beseem him right well, weighing the authority he did represent, to do his duty unto him.
WHEREUNTO Dr. Cranmer answered and said, That he had once taken a solemn oath, never to consent to the admitting of the bishop of Rome's authority into this realm of England again; and that he had done it advisedly, and meant by God's grace to keep it; and therefore would commit nothing either by sign or token, which might argue his consent to the receiving of the same; and so desired the said bishop to judge him, and that he did it not for any contempt to his person, which he could willingly have honoured as well as any of the others, if his commission had come from as good an authority as their's. This he answered both modestly, wisely, and patiently, with his cap on his head, not once bowing or making any reverence to him that represented the pope's person, which was wondrously marked by the people that were there present and saw it, and marked it as high as could be possible.
WHEREUNTO Dr. Cranmer answered and said, That he had once taken a solemn oath, never to consent to the admitting of the bishop of Rome's authority into this realm of England again; and that he had done it advisedly, and meant by God's grace to keep it; and therefore would commit nothing either by sign or token, which might argue his consent to the receiving of the same; and so desired the said bishop to judge him, and that he did it not for any contempt to his person, which he could willingly have honoured as well as any of the others, if his commission had come from as good an authority as their's. This he answered both modestly, wisely, and patiently, with his cap on his head, not once bowing or making any reverence to him that represented the pope's person, which was wonderously marked by the poople that were there present and saw it, and marked it as high as could be possible.
WHEN after many means used they perceived that the archbishop would not move his bonnet, the bishop proceeded in these words following.
MY lord, at this present we are to come to you as commissioners, and for you, not intruding ourselves by our own authority, but sent by commission, partly from the pope's holiness, partly from the king and queen's most excellent majesties, not to your utter discomfort, but to your comfort if you will yourself. We come, not to judge you, but to put you in remembrance of what you have been, and may be. Neither come we to dispute with you, but to examine you in certain matters; which being done, to make relation thereof to him that hath power to judge you. The first being well taken, shall make the second to be well taken. For if you, of your part, be moved to come to a conformity, then shall not only we on our side take joy of our examination, but also they that have sent us.
AND first, as charity doth move us, I would think good somewhat to exhort you, and that by the second chapter of St. John in the Revelations, "Remember from whence thou art fallen, and do the first works, or if not,"—and you know what followeth. Remember yourself from whence you have fallen. You have fallen from the universal and catholic church of Christ, from the very true and received faith of all Christendom and that by open heresy. You have fallen from your promise to God, from your fidelity and allegiance, and that by open preaching, marriage, and adultery. You have fallen from your sovereign prince and queen by open treason. Remember therefore from whence you are fallen. Your fall is great, the danger cannot be seen. Wherefore, when I say, Remember from whence you are fallen, I put you in ⟨p. 186⟩mind not only of your fall, but also of the state you were in before your fall. You were some time, as I and other poor men, in a mean estate; God I take to witness, I speak it to no reproach or abasement of you, but to put you in memory, how God hath called you from a low to an high degree, from one degree to another, from better to better, and never gave you over, till he had appointed you an ambassador, metropolitan of all England, and pastor of his own flock: such great trust did he put you in, in his church; what could he do more? for even as he ordained Moses to be a ruler over his church of Israel, and give him full authority of the same; so did he make you over his church of England. And when did he this for you? forsooth when you gave no occasion or cause of mistrust either to him or to his magistrates. For although it be conjectured, that in all your time you were not upright in the honour and faith of Christ, but rather set up on purpose as a fit instrument, whereby the church might be spoiled and brought into ruin; yet may it appear by many of your doings otherwise, and I, for my part, as it behoveth each one of us, shall think the best. For who was thought as then more devout? who was more religious in the face of the world? who was thought to have more conscience of a vow-making, and observing the order of the church, more earnest in the defence of the real presence of Christ's body and blood in the sacrament of the altar than you were? and then all things prospered with you; your prince favoured you; yea, God himself favoured you;
your candlestick was set up in the highest place of the church, and the light of your candle was over all the church; I would to God it had so continued still.
BUT after you begin to fall by schism, and would not acknowledge the pope's holiness as supreme head, but would stoutly uphold the unlawful requests of King Henry the Eighth, and would bear with what should not be borne withal, then began you to fancy unlawful liberty; and when you had exiled a good conscience, then ensued great shipwreck in the sea, which was out of the true and catholic church into the sea of desperation; for, as he saith, without the church there is no salvation. When you had forsaken God, God forsook you, and gave you over to your own will, and suffered you to fall from schism to apostasy, from apostasy to heresy, and from heresy to perjury, from perjury to treason, and so in conclusion into the full indignation of our sovereign prince, which you may think a just punishment of God for your other abominable opinions.
BUT after you begin to fall by schism, and would not acknowledge the pope's holiness as supreme head, but would stoutly uphold the unlawful requests of King Henry the Eighth, and would bear with what should not be borne withal, then began you to fancy unlawful liberty; and when you had exiled a good conscience, then ensued great shipwreck in the sea, which was out of the true and catholic church into the sea of desperation; for, as he saith, without the church there is no salvation. When you had forsaken God, God forsook you, and gave you over to your own will, and suffered you to fall from schism to apostacy, from apostacy to heresy, and from heresy to perjury, from perjury to treason, and so in conclusion into the full indignation of our sovereign prince, which you may think a just punishment of God for your other abominable opinions.
AFTER that, ye fell lower and lower and now […] the lowest degree of all, to the end of honour and life. For if the light of your candle be as it ha• been hitherto dusky, your candlestick is like to be removed, and have a great fall, so low, and so far out of knowledge, that it be quite out of God's favour, and past all hope of recovery: for in […] there is no redemption. The danger whereof being so great, very pity causeth me to say, "Remember from whence thou hast fallen;" I add also, and whither you fall.
AFTER that, ye fell lower and lower and now 〈…〉 the lowest degree of all, to the end of honour and life. For if the light of your candle be as it ha• been hitherto dusky, your candlestick is like to be removed, and have a great fall, so low, and so far out of knowledge, that it be quite out of God's favour, and past all hope of recovery: for in 〈…〉 there is no redemption. The danger whereof being so great, very pity causeth me to say, "Remember from whence thou hast fallen;" I add also, and whither you fall.
BUT here peradventure you will say to […] ▪ What, sir, my fall is not so great as you make it▪ I have not yet fallen from the catholic church. […] that is not the catholic church that the pope i• […] of. There is another church. But as […] that I answer, You are sure of that as the Donati•• were, for they said they had the true church, and that the name of true Christians remained only in Africa, where only their seditions were preached. And as you think, so thought Novatus, that all they that did acknowledge their supreme head at the see of Rome, were out of the Church of Christs. But here St. Cyprian, defending Cornelius against Novatus, Book ii. Epist. 6. saith on this wise, The church is one, which church, whereas it is one, it cannot be here and there. So that if Novatus was in the church, then was not Cornelius, who indeed by lawful succession succeeded pope Fabian. Here St. Cyprian intendeth by the whole process to prove, and concludeth thereupon, that the true church was only at Rome. Gather you then what will follow your fall. But you will you say peradventure, that you fell not by heresy, and so said the A•ians, alleging for themselves that they had scripture, and went about to support their schism by scripture; for indeed they had more places by two and forty, which by their torture seemed to depend upon scripture, than the catholics had.
BUT here peradventure you will say to 〈…〉 ▪ What, sir, my fall is not so great as you make it▪ I have not yet fallen from the catholic church. 〈…〉 that is not the catholic church that the pope i• 〈…〉 of. There is another church. But as 〈…〉 that I answer, You are sure of that as the Donati•• were, for they said they had the true church, and that the name of true Christians remained only in Africa, where only their seditions were preached. And as you think, so thought Novatus, that all they that did acknowledge their supreme head at the see of Rome, were out of the Church of Christs. But here St. Cyprian, defending Cornelius against Novatus, Book ii. Epist. 6. saith on this wise, The church is one, which church, whereas it is one, it cannot be here and there. So that if Novatus was in the church, then was not Cornelius, who indeed by lawful succession succeeded pope Fabian. Here St. Cyprian intendeth by the whole process to prove, and concludeth thereupon, that the true church was only at Rome. Gather you then what will follow your fall. But you will you say peradventure, that you fell not by heresy, and so said the Aians, alledging for themselves that they had scripture, and went about to support their schism by scripture; for indeed they had more places by two and forty, which by their torture seemed to depend upon scripture, than the catholics had.
SO did the Marcions endeavour to prove their heresy by scripture. But those are not scriptures; ⟨p. 187⟩for they are not truly alleged, nor truly interpreted, but untruly wrested and wrong, according to their own fantasies. And therefore were they all justly condemned for their wrong taking of the scriptures, and the church replieth against them, saying, What make you here in my heritage? from whence came you? the scripture is mine inheritance; I am right heir thereof: I hold it by true succession of the apostles; for as the apostles required me to hold, so do I hold it. The apostles have received me, and put me in my right, and have rejected you as bastards, having no title thereunto.
SO did the Marcions endeavour to prove their heresy by scripture. But those are not scriptures; ⟨p. 187⟩for they are not truly alledged, nor truly interpreted, but untruly wrested and wrong, according to their own fantasies. And therefore were they all justly condemned for their wrong taking of the scriptures, and the church replieth against them, saying, What make you here in my heritage? from whence came you? the scripture is mine inheritance; I am right heir thereof: I hold it by true succession of the apostles; for as the apostles required me to hold, so do I hold it. The apostles have received me, and put me in my right, and have rejected you as bastards, having no title thereunto.
ALSO you will deny that you have fallen by apostasy, by breaking your vow; and so Vigilantius said, insomuch that he would admit none to his ministry, but those who had their wives bagged with children. What now? shall we say, that Vigilantius did not fall therefore? Did not Donatus Novatus fall, because they said so, and brought scripture for their defence? Then let us believe […] we list, pretending well, and say so: for except the church which condemneth them for their saying so, do approve us for so doing, then will she condemn you also: so that your denial will not stand. And therefore I tell you, Remember from whence you are fallen, and how long you shall fall if you hold on as you do begin. But I trust you will not continue, but revoke yourself in time, and the remedy followeth.
ALSO you will deny that you have fallen by apostacy, by breaking your vow; and so Vigilantius said, insomuch that he would admit none to his ministry, but those who had their wives bagged with children. What now? shall we say, that Vigilantius did not fall therefore? Did not Donatus Novatus fall, because they said so, and brought scripture for their defence? Then let us believe 〈…〉 we list, pretending well, and say so: for except the church which condemneth them for their saying so, do approve us for so doing, then will she condemn you also: so that your denial will not stand. And therefore I tell you, Remember from whence you are fallen, and how long you shall fall if you hold on as you do begin. But I trust you will not continue, but revoke yourself in time, and the remedy followeth.
REPENT, and do thy first works, for by such means as you have fallen you must rise again. First, your heart hath fallen, then your tongue and your pen, and besides your own damage, hath caused many more to fall. Therefore first your heart must turn, and then shall the tongue and pen be quickly turned; or else I will come unto thee quickly, and will remove thy candlestick out of his place.
I need not to teach you a method to turn; you know the ready way yourself. But I would God I could but exhort you to the right and truth, then the way should soon be found out. For if you remember how many you have brought by abominable heresy into the way of perdition, I doubt not but very conscience would move you, as much for them as for yourself, to come again. And so would you spare neither tongue nor pen, if the heart were once reformed; for as touching that point, the Holy Ghost toucheth their hearts very near by the mouth of his holy prophet Ezekiel, when he requireth the blood of his flock at the priest's hands, for lack of good and wholesome food. How much more should this touch your guilty heart, having overmuch diligence to teach them the way of perdition, and feeding them with baggage and corrupt food, which is heresy; "He that shall convert a sinner from his wicked life, shall save his soul from death, and shall cover the multitude of sins." So that if it be true, that he who converteth a sinner, saveth a soul; then the contrary must needs be true, that he that perverteth a soul, and teacheth him the way to perdition, must needs be damned.
ORIGEN, on the epistle of St. Paul to the Romans, saith the damnation of those that preach heresy doth increase to the day of judgment. The more that perish by heretical doctrine, the more grievous shall their torment be, that minister such doctrine. Berengarius, who seemed to fear that danger, provided for it in his life-time, but not without a troubled and disquiet conscience. He did not only repent, but recant, and not so much for himself, as for them whom he had with most pestilent heresies infected. For as he lay on his deathbed, upon Epiphany-day, he demanded of them that were present, Is this (quoth he) the day of Epiphany, and appearing of the Lord? They answered him, Yea. Then (quoth he) this day shall the Lord appear to me, either to my comfort, or to my discomfort. This remorse argueth, that he feared the danger of them whom he had taught and led out of the faith of Christ. Origen, upon him, saith in this wise, "Although his own blood was not upon his head, for that he did repent, and was sorry for his former errors, yet being converted, he feared the blood of them whom he had infected, and who received his doctrine."
LET this move you even at the last point. Insomuch as your case is not unlike to Berengarius, let your repentance be like also. And what should stay you (tell me) from this godly return? Fear that you have gone so far ye may not return? Nay, then I may say as David said, "You fear where you ⟨p. 188⟩have no cause to fear." For if you repent and be heartily sorry for your former heresy and apostasy, you need not to fear. For as God, of his part, is merciful and gracious to the repentant sinner, so is the king, so is the queen merciful, which you may well perceive by your own case, since you might have suffered a great while ago for treason committed against her highness, but you have been spared and reserved upon hope of amendment, which she conceived very good of you, but now (as it seemeth) is but a very desperate hope. And what do you thereby? "According to the hardness of your heart you treasure up to yourself anger in the day of wrath."
LET this move you even at the last point. Insomuch as your case is not unlike to Berengarius, let your repentance be like also. And what should stay you (tell me) from this godly return? Fear that you have gone so far ye may not return? Nay, then I may say as David said, "You fear where you ⟨p. 188⟩have no cause to fear." For if you repent and be heartily sorry for your former heresy and apostacy, you need not to fear. For as God, of his part, is merciful and gracious to the repentant sinner, so is the king, so is the queen merciful, which you may well perceive by your own case, since you might have suffered a great while ago for treason committed against her highness, but you have been spared and reserved upon hope of amendment, which she conceived very good of you, but now (as it seemeth) is but a very desperate hope. And what do you thereby? "According to the hardness of your heart you treasure up to yourself anger in the day of wrath."
WELL, what is it then, if fear do not hinder you? Shame, to unsay that you have said? Nay, it is no shame, unless you think it shame to agree with the true and catholic church of Christ. And if that be shame, then blame St. Paul, who persecuted the disciples of Christ with the sword; then blame St. Peter, who denied his master Christ with an oath, that he never knew him. St. Cyprian, before his return being a witch; St. Austin, being nine years out of the church; they thought it no shame after their return, because that they had returned. Shall it then be a shame for you to convert and consent with the church of Christ? No, no.
WHAT is it then that doth hinder you? Glory of the world? Nay, as for the vanity of the world, I for my part judge not in you, being a man of learning and knowing your estate.
AND as for the loss of your estimation, it is ten to one that where you were archbishop of Canterbury, and metropolitan of all England, it is ten to one (I say) that you shall be well still, yea, and rather better.
AND as for the winning of good men, there is no doubt but all that are here present, and the whole congregation of Christ's church also, will more rejoice at your return, than they were sorry for your fall. And as for the other, you need not to doubt, but they will all come after; and to say the truth, if you should lose them for ever it were no force, you should have no loss thereby at all. I do not here intimate them which should confirm your estimation. For as St. Paul, after his conversion, […] received into the church of Christ, with wonderful joy to the whole congregation, even so shall you be▪ The fame of your return shall be spread abroad throughout all Christendom, where your face […] never known.
AND as for the winning of good men, there is no doubt but all that are here present, and the whole congregation of Christ's church also, will more rejoice at your return, than they were sorry for your fall. And as for the other, you need not to doubt, but they will all come after; and to say the truth, if you should lose them for ever it were no force, you should have no loss thereby at all. I do not here intimate them which should confirm your estimation. For as St. Paul, after his conversion, 〈…〉 received into the church of Christ, with wonderful joy to the whole congregation, even so shall you be▪ The fame of your return shall be spread abroad throughout all Christendom, where your face 〈…〉 never known.
BUT you will say perhaps, your conscience will not suffer you. My lord, there is a good conscience, and there is a bad conscience. The good conscience have not they, as St. Paul declareth to Timothy, concerning Hymeneus and Alexander. The evil and bad conscience is, saith St. Cyprian, well to be known by his mark. What mark? This conscience is marked with the print of heresy. This conscience is a wicked, filthy, and a branded conscience, which I trust is not in you. I have conceived a better hope of you than so, or else I would never go about to persuade or exhort […] But what conscience should stay you to return to the catholic faith and universal church of Christ▪ What conscience doth separate you to that devilish and several church? To a liberty which never […] ground in the holy scriptures? If you judge your liberty to be good, then judge you all Christendom to do evil besides you.
BUT you will say perhaps, your conscience will not suffer you. My lord, there is a good conscience, and there is a bad conscience. The good conscience have not they, as St. Paul declareth to Timothy, concerning Hymeneus and Alexander. The evil and bad conscience is, saith St. Cyprian, well to be known by his mark. What mark? This conscience is marked with the print of heresy. This conscience is a wicked, filthy, and a branded conscience, which I trust is not in you. I have conceived a better hope of you than so, or else I would never go about to persuade or exhort 〈…〉 But what conscience should stay you to return to the catholic faith and universal church of Christ▪ What conscience doth separate you to that divili•h and several church? To a liberty which never 〈…〉 ground in the holy scriptures? If you judge your liberty to be good, then judge you all Christendom to do evil besides you.
O what a presumptuous persuasion is this, upon this utterly to forsake the church of Christ? Under what colour or pretence do you this? For the abuses? As though in your church were no abuses: yes, that there were. And if you forsake the universal church for the abuses, why do you not then forsake your particular church, and so be flitting from one to another? That is not the best way, to slip from the church for the abuses; for if you had seen abuses, you should rather have endeavoured for a reformation than for a defection. He is a good surgeon, who for a little pain in the toe will cut off the whole leg. He helpeth well the toothache, which cutteth away the head by the shoulders. You are like Diogenes; for Diogenes on a time envying the cleanliness of Plato, said on this wise, Behold, I tread on the pride of Plato. Plato answered, But with another sort of pride. So that Diogenes seemed more faulty of the two.
O what a presumptuous persuasion is this, upon this utterly to forsake the church of Christ? Under what colour or pretence do you this? For the abuses? As though in your church were no abuses: yes, that there were. And if you forsake the universal church for the abuses, why do you not then forsake your particular church, and so be flitting from one to another? That is not the best way, to slip from the church for the abuses; for if you had seen abuses, you should rather have endeavoured for a reformation than for a defection. He is a good surgeon, who for a little pain in the toe will cut off the whole leg. He helpeth well the toothach, which cutteth away the head by the shoulders. You are like Diogenes; for Diogenes on a time envying the cleanliness of Plato, said on this wise, Behold, I tread on the pride of Plato. Plato answered, But with another sort of pride. So that Diogenes seemed more faulty of the two.
BUT when we have said all that we can, peradventure you will say, I will not return. And to ⟨p. 186⟩that I say, I will not answer. Nevertheless, hear what Christ saith to such stiff-necked people in the parable of the supper. When he had sent out his men to call them in that were appointed, and they would not come, he bade his servants go into the highways and streets, to compel men to come in. If then the church will not lose any member that may be compelled to come in, you must think it good to take the compulsion, lest you lose your part of the supper which the Lord hath prepared for you, and this compulsion standeth well with charity.
BUT it may be perhaps, that some that animated you to stick to your tackle, and not to give over, bearing you in hand that your opinion is good, and that you shall die in a good quarrel, and God shall accept your oblation. But hear what Christ saith of a meaner gift; If thou come to the altar to offer thy oblation, and knowest that thy brother hast somewhat to say against thee, leave there thy gift, and go and be reconciled to thy brother, and then come and offer up thy gift, or else thy brother will make thy offering unsavoury before God. This he said unto all the world, to the end they should know how their offerings should be received, if they were not according.
REMEMBER you therefore before you offer up your offering, whether your gift be qualified or no. Remember the church of Rome, and also of England, where not one only brother, but a number have matter against you, so just that they will make your burnt-offering stink before God, except you be reconciled. If you must needs appoint upon a sacrifice, make yet a mean first to them that have to lay against you. I say no more than the church hath allowed me to say. For the sacrifice that is offered without the church is not profitable. The premises therefore considered, for God's sake I say, "Remember therefore from whence •hou art fallen, and repent, and do thy first works, or else I will come unto thee quickly, and will remove thy candlestick out of his place, except thou repent." Cast not yourself away, spare your body, spare your soul, spare them also whom you have seduced, spare the shedding of Christ's blood for you in vain. Harden not your heart, acknowledge the truth, yield to the prescript word of God, to the catholic church of Rome, to the received verity of all Christendom. Wed not yourself to your own self-will. Stand not too much in your own conceit. Think not yourself wiser than all Christendom is besides you. Leave off this unjust cavil. How? Leave what? Leave reason, leave wonder, and believe as the catholic church doth believe and teach you. Persuade with yourself, that without the church there is no salvation. And thus much have I said of charity. If this poor simple exhortation of mine may sink into your head, and take effect with you, then have I said as I would have said, otherwise not as I would, but as I could for this present.
AND thus bishop Brooks finishing his oration, sat down. After whom, Dr. Martin taking the matter in hand, began thus.