pp. 41–51144 passagespart 1 of 4
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
WHILE the lords were seating themselves, the bishop of London came aside to me and whispered in my ear, desiring me to behave prudently before the lords of the queen's majesty's council, and to take heed what I said; and thus he pretended to give me counsel, because he wished me to do well, as I might now if I would.
AND after the lords and other worshipful gentlemen were sat, my lord of London placed himself at the end of the table, and called me to him, and by the lords I was placed at the upper end against him▪ where I kneeling down, the lords commanded me to stand up, and the bishop spoke to me in the following manner.
Bonner. Mr. Philpot, I have heretofore both privately myself, and openly before the lords of the clergy, more times than once caused you to be conversed with, to reform you of your errors, but I have not yet found you so tractable a• I would wish: wherefore now I have desired those honourable lord• of the temporality, and of the queen's majesty's council, who have taken pains with me this day, (I thank them for it), to hear you, and what you can say, that they may be judges whether I have sought all means to do you good or no: and I dare be bold to say in their behalf, that if you show yourself conformable to the queen's majesty's proceedings, you shall find as much favour for your deliverance as you can wish. I speak not this to fawn upon you, but to bring you home unto the church. Now let them hear what you have to say.
Bonner. Mr. Philpot, I have heretofore both privately myself, and openly before the lords of the clergy, more times than once caused you to be conversed with, to reform you of your errors, but I have not yet found you so tractable a• I would wish: wherefore now I have desired those honourable lord• of the temporality, and of the queen's majesty's council, who have taken pains with me this day, (I thank them for it), to hear you, and what you can say, that they may be judges whether I have sought all means to do you good or no: and I dare be bold to say in their behalf, that if you shew yourself conformable to the queen's majesty's proceedings, you shall find as much favour for your deliverance as you can wish. I speak not this to fawn upon you, but to bring you home unto the church. Now let them hear what you have to say.
Phil. My lord, I thank God that I have this day such an honourable audience to declare my mind before. And I cannot but commend your lordship's equity in this behalf, which agreeth with the order of the primitive church, which was, if any body had been suspected of heresy, as I am now, he should be called first before the archbishop or bishop of the diocese where he was suspected; secondly, in the presence of others his fellow bishops and learned elders; and thirdly, in hearing of the laity; where after the judgment of God's word declared, and with the assent of our bishops and consent of the people, he was condemned for an heretic, or absolved. And the second point of that good order I have found at your lordship's hands already, in being called before you and your fellow bishops; and now have the third sort of men, at whose hands I trust to find more righteousness in my cause, than I have found with my lords of the clergy: God ⟨p. 42⟩grant that I may have at the last the judgment of God's word concerning the same.
Bond. Mr. Philpot, I pray you ere you go any further, tell my lords here plainly, whether you were by me or by my procurement committed to prison or not, and whether I have showed you any cruelty since you have been committed to my prison.
Bon. Mr. Philpot, I pray you ere you go any further, tell my lords here plainly, whether you were by me or by my procurement committed to prison or not, and whether I have shewed you any cruelty since you have been committed to my prison.
Phil. If it shall please your lordship to give me leave to declare forth my matter, I will touch that afterward.
Rich. Answer first of all to my lord's two questions, and then proceed forth of the matter. How say you? Were you imprisoned by my lord or no? Can you find any fault since with his cruel using of you?
Phil. I cannot lay to my lord's charge the cause of my imprisonment, neither may I say that he hath used me cruelly; but rather for my part I may say, that I have found more gentleness at his lordship's hands, than I did at my own ordinary's, for the time I have been within his prison, because he hath called me three or four times to mine answer, to which I was not in a year and a half before.
Rich. Well, now go to your matter.
Phil. The matter is, that I am imprisoned for the disputations held by me in the convocation-house against the sacrament of the altar, which matter was not moved principally by me, but by the prolocutor, with the consent of the queen's majesty and of the whole house, and that house, being a member of the parliament-house, which ought to be a place of free speech for all men of the house, by the ancient and laudable custom of this realm. Wherefore I think myself to have sustained hitherto great injury for speaking my conscience free•• in such a place as I might lawfully do it: and I desire your honourable lordships judgment who are of the parliament-house, whether of right I ought to be impeached for the same, and sustain the loss of my living (as I have done), and moreover of my life, as it is sought.
Rich. You are deceived herein; for the convocation-house is no part of the parliament-house.
Phil. My lord, I have always understood the contrary by such as are more expert men in things of this realm than I: and again, the title of every act leadeth me think otherwise, which allegeth the agreement of the spirituality and temporality assembled together.
Phil. My lord, I have always understood the contrary by such as are more expert men in things of this realm than I: and again, the title of every act leadeth me think otherwise, which alledgeth the agreement of the spirituality and temporality assembled together.
Rich. Yea, that is meant of the spiritual lords of the upper house.
Wind. Indeed the convocation-house is called together by one writ of the summons of the parliament of an old custom; notwithstanding that house is no part of the parliament-house.
Phil. My lords, I must be contented to abide your judgments in this behalf.
Rich. We have told you the truth. And yet we would not that you should be troubled for any thing that there was spoken, so that you having spoken amiss, do declare now that you are sorry for what you have said.
Bond. My lords, he hath spoken there manifest heresy, yea, and there stoutly maintained the same against the blessed sacrament of the altar (and with that he put off his cap, that all the lords might reverence and veil their bonnets at that idol as he did), and would not allow the real presence of the body and blood of Christ in the same: yet, my lords, God forbid that I should endeavour to show him extremity for so doing, in case he will repent and revoke his wicked sayings; and if in faith he will so do, with your lordships consent, he shall be released by and by; if he will not, he shall have the extremity of the law, and that shortly.
Bon. My lords, he hath spoken there manifest heresy, yea, and there stoutly maintained the same against the blessed sacrament of the altar (and with that he put off his cap, that all the lords might reverence and vail their bonnets at that idol as he did), and would not allow the real presence of the body and blood of Christ in the same: yet, my lords, God forbid that I should endeavour to shew him extremity for so doing, in case he will repent and revoke his wicked sayings; and if in faith he will so do, with your lordships consent, he shall be released by and by; if he will not, he shall have the extremity of the law, and that shortly.
Lord Chamberlain. My lord of London speaketh reasonably unto you: take it while it is offered you.
Rich. How say you? will you acknowledge the real presence of the body and blood of Christ, as all learned men of this realm do, in the mass, and as I do, and will believe as long as I live, I do protest it?
Phil. My lord, I do acknowledge in the sacrament of the body and blood of Christ such a ⟨p. 43⟩presence as the word of God doth allow and teach me.
Rich. That shall be no otherwise than you like.
Bond. A sacrament is the sign of a holy thing; so that there is both the sign, which is the accident (as the whiteness, roundness, and shape of bread), and there is also the thing itself, as very Christ both God and man. But these heretics will have the sacrament to be but bare signs. How say you? declare unto my lords here whether you do allow the thing itself in the sacrament, or no.
Bon. A sacrament is the sign of a holy thing; so that there is both the sign, which is the accident (as the whiteness, roundness, and shape of bread), and there is also the thing itself, as very Christ both God and man. But these hereti•s will have the sacrament to be but bare signs. How say you? declare unto my lords here whether you do allow the thing itself in the sacrament, or no.
Phil. I do confess that in the Lord's supper there are in due respects both the sign and the thing signified, when it is duly administered after the institution of Christ.
Bond. You may see how he goeth about the bush (as he hath done before) with my lords of the clergy, and dare not utter his mind plainly.
Bon. You may see how he goeth about the bush (as he hath done before) with my lords of the clergy, and dare not utter his mind plainly.
Rich. Show us what manner of presence you allow in the sacrament.
Rich. Shew us what manner of presence you allow in the sacrament.
Phil. If it please you, my lord of London, to give me leave to proceed orderly thereunto, and to le• me declare my mind without interruption, I will thoroughly open my mind therein.
Lord Shandois. I pray you, my lord, let him speak his mind.
Phil. My lords, that at first I have not plainly declared my judgment unto you, the reason is this, because I cannot speak hereof without the danger of my life.
Rich. There is none of us here that seeketh thy life, or means to take any advantage of that thou shalt speak.
Phil. Although I mistrust not your honourable lordships that be here of the temporality; yet here is one that sitteth against me (pointing to the lord of London) that will lay it to my charge even to death. Notwithstanding, seeing your honours do require me to declare my mind of the presence of Christ in the sacrament, that ye may perceive that I am not ashamed of the presence of Christ, neither do maintain any opinion without probable and sufficient authority of scripture, I will show you frankly my mind without all colour, whatsoever shall ensue unto me therefore, if my lord of London will not hinder me to utter my mind.
Phil. Although I mistrust not your honourable lordships that be here of the temporality; yet here is one that sitteth against me (pointing to the lord of London) that will lay it to my charge even to death. Notwithstanding, seeing your honours do require me to declare my mind of the presence of Christ in the sacrament, that ye may perceive that I am not ashamed of the presence of Christ, neither do maintain any opinion without probable and sufficient authority of scripture, I will shew you frankly my mind without all colour, whatsoever shall ensue unto me therefor, if my lord of London will not hinder me to utter my mind.
Rich. My lord, permit him to say what he can, seeing he is willing to show his mind.
Rich. My lord, permit him to say what he can, seeing he is willing to shew his mind.
Bond. I am content, my lords, let him say what he can, I will hear him.
Bon. I am content, my lords, let him say what he can, I will hear him.
Phil. That which I do intend to speak unto you (right honourable lords) I do protest here, first before God and his angels, that I speak it not of vain-glory, neither of singularity, neither of wilful stubbornness, but truly upon a good conscience, grounded upon God's word, against which I dare not go for fear of damnation, Which will follow that which is done contrary to knowledge. Neither do I disagree to the proceedings of this realm in the religion, in that I love not the queen (whom I love from the bottom of my heart), but because I ought to love and fear God in his word more than man in his laws, though I stand, as I seem to do, in this consideration, and for no other, as God I call to witness. THERE are two things principally, by which the clergy at this day deceive the whole realm; that is, the sacrament of the body and blood of Christ, and the name of the catholic church: which they do usurp, having indeed neither of them. And as touching their sacrament, which they term of the altar, I say now as I said in the convocation-house, that it is not the sacrament of Christ, neither in the same is there any manner of Christ's presence. Wherefore they deceive the queen's majesty, and you of the nobility of this realm, in making you to believe that to be a sacrament which is none, and cause you to commit manifest idolatry in worshipping that for God, which is no God. And in testimony of this to be true, besides manifest proof, which I am able to make to the queen's majesty, and to all you of her nobility, I will yield my life; which to do, if it were not upon sure ground, it were to my utter damnation. ⟨p. 44⟩AND where they take on them the name of the catholic church (whereby they blind many people's eyes) they are nothing so, calling you from the true religion which was revealed and taught in king Edward's time, unto vain superstition. And this I will say for the trial hereof, that if they can prove themselves to be the catholic church (as they shall never be able to do), I will never be against their doings, but revoke all that I have said. And I shall desire you, my lords, to be a means for me to the queen's majesty, that I may be brought to the just trial hereof. Yea, I will not refuse to stand against ten of the best of them in this realm.
And if they be able to prove otherwise than I have said, either by writing or reasoning, with good and lawful authority, I will here promise to recant whatsoever I have said, and to consent to them in all points. AND in the declaration of these things more at large, which now I write in sum, the bishop of London would have interrupted me, but the lords procured my liberty to make out my argument, to the great grief of the lord bishop of London, as it appeared by the dumps he was in.
Bond. It hath been told me before, that you love to make a long tale.
Bon. It hath been told me before, that you love to make a long tale.
Rich. All heretics do boast of the Spirit of God, and every one would have a church by himself; as Joan of Kent, and the Anabaptists. I had myself Joan of Kent a week in my house after the writ was out for her to be burnt, where my lord of Canterbury, and bishop Ridley resorted almost daily unto her: but she was so high in the Spirit, that they could do nothing with her for all their learning. But she went wilfully into the fire, was burnt, and so do you now.
Phil. As for Joan of Kent, she was a vain woman (I knew her well) and an heretic indeed, well worthy to be burnt, because she stood against one of the manifest articles of our faith, contrary to the scriptures: and such vain spirits are soon known from the true Spirit of God and his church, for that the same abideth within the limits of God's word, and will not go out of the same, neither stubbornly maintain any thing contrary to the word, as I have God's word thoroughly on my side to show for that I stand in.
Phil. As for Joan of Kent, she was a vain woman (I knew her well) and an heretic indeed, well wor•hy to be burnt, because she stood against one of the manifest articles of our faith, contrary to the scriptures: and such vain spirits are soon known from the true Spirit of God and his church, for that the same abi•eth within the limits of God's word, and will not go out of the same, neither stubbornly maintain any thing contrary to the word, as I have God's word thoroughly on my side to shew for that I stand in.
Bond. I pray you, how will you join me these two scriptures together; Pater major me est; & pater & ego unum su•us. I must interpret the same, because my lords here understand not the Latin, that is to say, "The Father is greater than I; and I and the Father are one." But I cry your mercy, my lords, I have mis spoken, in saying you understand no Latin; for the most part of you understand Latin as well as I. But I speak in consideration of my lord Shandois, and Mr. Bridges his brother▪ whom I take to be no great Latin men. Now show your cunning, and join these two scriptures by the word if you can.
Bon. I pray you, how will you join me these two scriptures together; Pater major me est; & pater & ego unum su•us. I must interpret the same, because my lords here understand not the Latin, that is to say, "The Father is greater than I; and I and the Father are one." But I cry your mercy, my lords, I have mis spoken, in saying you understand no Latin; for the most part of you understand Latin as well as I. But I speak in consideration of my lord Shandois, and Mr. Bridges his brother▪ whom I take to be no great Latin men. Now shew your cunning, and join these two scriptures by the word if you can.
Phil. Yes, that I can right well. For we must understand that in Christ there be two natures, the divinity and humanity, and in respect of his humanity, it is spoken of Christ, "The Father is greater than I." But in respect of his Deity he said again, "The Father and I be one."