pp. 62–6783 passagespart 2 of 3
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Harps. You think it cometh of the Hebrew word Massah, as though none were versed in the Hebrew but yourself.
Phil. I have not gone so long to school, to derive the signification of the word Missa, which is a Latin word, out of Hebrew: but I have learned to interpret Greek words by Greek, and Latin by Latin, and Hebrew by Hebrew; I take the communion to be called Missa, a mittendo, of such things as at the celebration of the communion were sent by such as were of ability, to the relief of the poor, where the rich brought according to their devotion and ability, and required the minister in the celebration of the communion to pray unto God for them, and to accept their common alms▪ which they at such times did send for the relief of their poor brethren and sisters; and for this it was called Missa, as learned men do witness. At which celebration of the mass, all that were present did communicate under both kinds, according to Christ's institution, as they did in St. Augustine's time. But unless you can show that your mass is used as it then was, you shall never by the name of mass (which St. Augustine attributed to the true use of the communion) prove your private mass to be a sacrament, unless you can prove the same now to be in your masses as was then, which is clean contrary.
Phil. I have not gone so long to school, to derive the signification of the word Missa, which is a Latin word, out of Hebrew: but I have learned to interpret Greek words by Greek, and Latin by Latin, and Hebrew by Hebrew; I take the communion to be called Missa, a mittendo, of such things as at the celebration of the communion were sent by such as were of ability, to the relief of the poor, where the rich brought according to their devotion and ability, and required the minister in the celebration of the communion to pray unto God for them, and to accept their common alms▪ which they at such times did send for the relief of their poor brethren and sisters; and for this it was called Missa, as learned men do witness. At which celebration of the mass, all that were present did communicate under both kinds, according to Christ's institution, as they did in St. Augustine's time. But unless you can shew that your mass is used as it then was, you shall never by the name of mass (which St. Augustine attributed to the true use of the communion) prove your private mass to be a sacrament, unless you can prove the same now to be in your masses as was then, which is clean contrary.
Harps. What, deny you the mass to be a sacrament? For shame speak it not.
Phil. I will not be ashamed to deny it, if you cannot prove it.
Harps. Why, it is a sacrifice, which is more than a sacrament.
Phil. You may make of it as much as you like: but you shall never make it a sacrifice, as you may imagine thereof, but first it must be a sacrament, for of the sacrament you deduce your sacrifice.
Harps. Why? doth not Christ say, "This is my body?" and doth not the priest pronounce the same that Christ did?
Phil. The pronunciation only is not enough, unless the words be therewithal applied to the use, as Christ spake them to. For though you speak the words of baptism over water ever so many times▪ yet there is no baptism unless there be a christian person to be baptized.
Harps. Nay, that is not alike; for, Hoc est corpus meum, manducate, that is, "This is my body," said also, Accipite, manducate, that is, Take ye, eat ye. And except the former part of the institution of Christ's sacrament be accomplished according to the communion; the latter, "This is my body," can have no verification, take it which way you will, and how you will.
Morrow-mass Chaplain. Why then you will make the sacrament to stand in the receiving, and that receiving maketh it a sacrament.
Phil. I do not say, that the receiving only maketh it a sacrament, but I say, that a common receiving must needs be concurrent with the true sacrament▪ as a necessary member, without which it cannot be a sacrament, because Christ has made this a principal part of the sacrament, "Take ye, eat ye," which you do not in your mass according to Christ's institution; wherefore, it can be no sacrament, for that it wanteth Christ's institution.
Cousins. We do forbid none to come to it, but as many as like may be partakers with us at the mass if they require it.
Cosins. We do forbid none to come to it, but as many as like may be partakers with us at the mass if they require it.
Phil. Nay, that they shall not, though they require it, you will minister but one kind unto them, which is not after Christ's institution. Besides that, you ought before you go to mass, to exhort all that be present to make a sacrifice of thanksgiving, for Christ's passion with you, and exhort them to be partakers with you, according to Christ's commandment, saying unto all that be present, "Take ye, eat ye:" and likewise by preaching show forth the Lord's death, which you do […].
Phil. Nay, that they shall not, though they require it, you will minister but one kind unto them, which is not after Christ's institution. Besides that, you ought before you go to mass, to exhort all that be present to make a sacrifice of thanksgiving, for Christ's passion with you, and exhort them to be partakers with you, according to Christ's commandment, saying unto all that be present, "Take ye, eat ye:" and likewise by preaching shew forth the Lord's death, which you do 〈…〉.
Cousins. What if all things be done, even as you would have it, and whilst the minister is about to administer the sacrament, before any have received it th•re arise a sudden hurly burly, that the communicants he compelled to go away; is it not a sacrament for all that none hath communicated besides the priest?
Cosins. What if all things be done, even as you would have it, and whilst the minister is about to administer the sacrament, before any have received it th•re arise a sudden hurly burly, that the communicants he compelled to go away; is it not a sacrament for all that none hath communicated besides the priest?
Phil. In this case, where all things are appointed to be done according to God's word, if incident necessity had not hindered, I cannot say but it is a sacrament, and that he who hath received, hath the true sacrament. After this, the morrow-mass priest made this apish reason.
Morrow-mass Priest. If the sacrament of the mass be no sacrament, unless all do receive it, because Christ said, "Take ye, eat ye," then the sacrament of baptism is no sacrament where there is but one baptized▪ because Christ said to his apostles, "Go preach the gospel to all creatures, baptizing all nations in the name of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost."
Phil. In that saying of Christ, "Baptizing all nations," is a commandment to the apostles, to baptize all sorts of men, and to exclude none that believe, be he Gentile or Jew, not meaning all at once, for that were impossible. And there are many examples that baptism may be singularly ministered to one person, as we have example of Christ baptized of John, and in the Eunuch baptized of Philip, with many more such like: but so have you not of the sacrament of the body and blood of Christ, but contrariwise by the express words of St. Paul, you are commanded to use it in a communion and participation of many together: 1 Cor. xi. "As oft as ye come together to eat (meaning the Lord's supper) tarry one for another." And also the minister in the celebration of the sacrament speaketh unto all that be present in Christ's behalf, to communicate with him, saying, "Take ye, eat ye." Wherefore, as many as are present and do not communicate▪ break God's commandment in not receiving the same, and the minister is no just minister that doth not distribute the sacrament as Christ did, to all that are present; and where God's word is transgressed, there is not Christ present, and consequently it is no sacrament.
Harps. What, would you have it no sacrament without it be a communion?
Phil. I make it not so, but God's express word teacheth me so, yea, also all the ancient writers; as ⟨p. 66⟩Chrysostom writing upon the epistle to the Ephesians, saith, That the oblation is in vain, where none doth communicate with the priest. If by his judgment the action of the priest alone is in vain, where is no communion, how can that be a sacrament, which he calleth a vain oblation, and a vain standing at the altar?
Cousins. Such a fellow I have never heard, you will not have the mass to be a sacrament; you are no man for me to reason with. Come, let us go, pointing to the morrow-mass chaplain; we will leave you (Mr. Archdeacon) and him together; and so they went away. Afterwards the archdeacon fell into earnest persuasions with me, saying:
Cosins. Such a fellow I have never heard, you will not have the mass to be a sacrament; you are no man for me to reason with. Come, let us go, pointing to the morrow-mass chaplain; we will leave you (Mr. Archdeacon) and him together; and so they went away. Afterwards the archdeacon fell into earnest persuasions with me, saying:
Harps. Mr. Philpot, you and I have been acquainted these many years; we were school-fellows both in Winchester and in Oxford. Wherefore I must wish you as well to do as myself, and I pray you so think of me.
Phil. I thank you for your good will towards me. But if you be deceived (as I am sure you are), I shall desire you not to wish me deceived with you. For before God I tell you plainly, you are highly deceived, and maintain false religion, and be not those men you take yourselves for: and if you do not repent, and leave off your persecuting Christ's truth, you will go to the devil for it. Therefore consider it in time, I give you warning, for else in the day of judgment I shall be a witness against you, that I told you this here talking together.
Harps. Fie, that is but your own singular opinion; I perceive you are now still that man you were in Oxford.
Phil. I trust you can report no notorious evil that ever you knew by me there.
Harps. I can say no evil of your conversation, but I knew you to be a studious man. Marry, if you remember when we met in disputation in Paris, you would not lightly give over, and for that cause I speak what I said.
Harps. I can say no evil of your conversation, but I knew you to be a studious man. Marry, if you remember when we met in disputation in Par•is, you would not lightly give over, and for that cause I speak what I said.
Phil. Mr. Harpsfield, you know in the schools of Oxford, when we were young men, we did strive much upon vain glory, and upon contention, more than for the truth: but now our years and riper learning teach us to fall to a truth, which must be our portion for ever. And if I was then, in my time of ignorance, earnest in my own cause, I ought now to be earnest in my master Christ's cause, and his truth. I know now that nothing done upon vain glory and singularity can please God, have it ever so godly a show: wherefore I pray you judge not so of me now.
Phil. Mr. Harpsfield, you know in the schools of Oxford, when we were young men, we did strive much upon vain glory, and upon contention, more than for the truth: but now our years and riper learning teach us to fall to a truth, which must be our portion for ever. And if I was then, in my time of ignorance, earnest in my own cause, I ought now to be earnest in my master Christ's cause, and his truth. I know now that nothing done upon vain glory and singularity can please God, have it ever so godly a shew: wherefore I pray you judge not so of me now.
Harps. What, will you think yourself better learned than all the learned men in this realm?
Phil. My faith hangeth not upon the learned of the world, but on the learned of God's word.
Harps. Well, I will talk with you no more as now, but pray God to open your heart.
Phil. I pray God open both our hearts, to do more his will than we have done in times past.
Harps. Ho, keeper, take him away with you.
Phil. I pray you, Mr. Harpsfield, tell me what this pronoun (Hoc) doth demonstrate and show, in this indicative proposition as you call it, Hoc est corpus meum, This is my body?
Phil. I pray you, Mr. Harpsfield, tell me what this pronoun (Hoc) doth demonstrate and shew, in this indicative proposition as you call it, Hoc est corpus meum, This is my body?
Harps. It doth demonstrate the substance of bread, which by the words spoken by the priest, and by the omnipotency of God, is turned into the substance of Christ's very body.
Phil. Is the substance of bread, as you say, turned into Christ's body?
Harps. Yea, that it is.
Phil. Why, then Christ's body receiveth daily a great increase of many thousand pieces of bread into his body, and that is his body become now, which was not before, and by this you would seem to make, that there is an alteration in Christ's glorified body, which is a wicked thing to think.
Harps. Then he fetched about again, and remembering ⟨p. 67⟩himself better, and seeing the inconvenience of his first assertion, of the transubstantiation of bread into Christ's body, he said, That the substance of bread, after the words spoken by the priest, was evacuated or vanished away by the omnipotency of God.
Phil. This is another song than you sung first: and here you may see how contrary you are to yourselves. For indeed your schoolmen do hold, That the very substance of bread is really turned into the very substance of Christ's body. And now you perceiving of late the inconvenience which is objected against you in that opinion, are driven so imagine a new shift, and say, The substance of bread is evacuated, contrary to that which your church hath at first believed and taught. O what contrariety is there among you, and all to deface the sincere truth.
Harps. Is not God omnipotent? and cannot he do as he hath said?
Phil. But his omnipotence will not do as you say, contrary to his word and to his honour. It is not God's honour to include him bodily into a piece of bread, and of necessity to tie him thereto. It is not God's honour for you to make a piece of bread God and man, which you see before your face doth putrefy after a certain time. Is not God's omnipotence as able to give his body with the sacramental bread, as to make so many turnings away of the bread, as you do, and that directly against the scripture, which calleth it bread many times after consecration? Are you not ashamed to make so many alterations of the Lord's institution as you do, and take away the substantial parts of the sacrament, as, "Take ye, eat ye, drink ye all of this; do ye this in remembrance of me;" and to place in their stead, Hear ye, gaze ye, knock ye, worship ye, offer ye, sacrifice ye for the quick and the dead! If this be not blasphemy to God and his sacraments, to add and to pluck away in this sort, and that contrary to the mind of all ancient writers, and contrary to the example of Christ and all his apostles, tell me▪
Phil. But his omnipotence will not do as you say, contrary to his word and to his honour. It is not God's honour to include him bodily into a piece of bread, and of necessity to tie him thereto. It is not God's honour for you to make a piece of bread God and man, which you see before your face doth putrify after a certain time. Is not God's omnipotence as able to give his body with the sacramental bread, as to make so many turnings away of the bread, as you do, and that directly against the scripture, which calleth it bread many times after consecration? Are you not ashamed to make so many alterations of the Lord's institution as you do, and take away the substantial parts of the sacrament, as, "Take ye, eat ye, drink ye all of this; do ye this in remembrance of me;" and to place in their stead, Hear ye, gaze ye, knock ye, worship ye, offer ye, sacrifice ye for the quick and the dead! If this be not blasphemy to God and his sacraments, to add and to pluck away in this sort, and that contrary to the mind of all ancient writers, and contrary to the example of Christ and all his apostles, tell me▪