pp. 69–81226 passagespart 1 of 6
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
BEING sent for with my keeper, the bishop of London met me at his hall-door, and full ma••erly he played the gentleman usher to bring me before the lords, saying▪
Bond. My lords, I shall desire you to take some pains with this man, he is a gentleman, and I would he should do well, but he will wilfully cast away himself.
Bon. My lords, I shall desire you to take some pains with this man, he is a gentleman, and I would he should do well, but he will wilfully cast away himself.
Durham. Come hither, sir, what is your name?
Phil. My name is Philpot.
Dur. I have heard of that name to be a worshipful stock, and since you are a gentleman, do as you may live worshipfully among other gentlemen. What is the cause of your trouble now?
I told him the cause, as in my former examinations is expressed.
Dur. Well, all causes set apart, will you now be a conformable man to the catholic faith, and leave all new-fangled opinions and heresies? I was in Germany with Luther at the beginning of these opinions, and can tell how they began. Leave them and follow the catholic church throughout the whole world, as the whole realm now doth.
Phil. My lord, I am in the catholic faith, and desire to live and die in the same: but it is not unknown to your lordship, that I, with others, these twenty years have been taught another manner of faith than you now go about to compel us unto; wherefore it is requisite that we have time to weigh the same, and to hear how it agreeth with God's word. For faith is at a sudden neither won, neither removed, but as St. Paul saith, "Faith cometh by hearing, and hearing by […]"
Phil. My lord, I am in the catholic faith, and desire to live and die in the same: but it is not unknown to your lordship, that I, with others, these twenty years have been taught another manner of faith than you now go about to compel us unto; wherefore it is requisite that we have time to weigh the same, and to hear how it agreeth with God's word. For faith is at a sudden neither won, neither removed, but as St. Paul saith, "Faith cometh by hearing, and hearing by 〈…〉"
Chichester. And if you will give me leave, my lord, I will show him how he taketh the saying of St. Paul amiss, as many others now […] do, alleging the same, that they ought […] compelled to believe, whereas St. Paul mea••• of infidels, and not of the faithful; and so St. Austin, writing against the Donatists, saith, That the faithful may be compelled to believe.
Chichester. And if you will give me leave, my lord, I will shew him how he taketh the saying of St. Paul amiss, as many others now 〈…〉 do, alledging the same, that they ought 〈…〉 compelled to believe, whereas St. Paul mea••• of infidels, and not of the faithful; and so St. Austin, writing against the Donatists, saith, That the faithful may be compelled to believe.
Phil. St. Bernard, (if it please your lordship, doth take that sense of St. Paul as I do, saying) that faith must be persuaded to a man, and not enjoined. And St. Augustine speaketh of such •s were first thoroughly persuaded by manifest scriptures, and yet would resist of stubborn wilfulness.
Chi. So Bernard meaneth of infidels also.
Phil. No, my lord, that he doth not, for he writeth not of the infidels, but he writeth of such as were deceived by errors.
Chi. My lord of Durham, I ha•e been so bold as to interrupt your lordship of your tale, I pray you now proceed on.
Chi. My lord of Durham, I ha•e been so bold as to interrup• your lordship of your tale, I pray you now proceed on.
Dur. Mr. Philpot, will you be of the same catholic faith and church with us you were baptized in, and your godfathers promised for you, and hold as we do? and then may you be rid out of trouble. I perceive you are learned, and it is • pity but you should do well.
Phil. I […] of the same catholic faith and catholic church I was baptized into, and in that will I live and di•.
Phil. I 〈…〉 of the same catholic faith and catholic church I was baptized into, and in that will I live and di•.
Dur. That is well said; if you hold there, you cannot but do well.
Chi. Yea, my lord, but he meaneth otherwise than you do. Are you of the same faith your godfathers and godmothers were, or no?
Phil. I cannot tell what faith they were of certainly, but I am of the saith I was baptized into, which is the faith of Christ; for I was not baptized into the faith of my godfathers, but in the faith of Christ.
Chi. St. Austin faith▪ That infants are baptized in the faith of their godfathers.
Phil. St. Augustine, in so saying, meaneth of the faith of Christ, which the godfathers do, or ought to believe, and not otherwise.
Dur. How say you, will you believe as we do, and all the learned of the realm, or no? and be of one church with us.
Phil. My lords, it is not unknown to you, that there have been always two churches.
Chi. Nay, tha• is not so: there is but one catholic church.
Phil. I shall desire your lordships to hear out my tale, and to take my meaning. For I know there is but one true church; but always from the beginning there hath been joined to the same true church, a false church, adversary to the true: and that was declared at first in Abel and Cain, who persecuted and slew his brother▪ in whom (St. Augustine witnesseth) is represented the false and true church. And that as soon as God had chosen his peculiar people, and showed unto them his sanctuary, holy statutes, and will, anon after arose the false church, and ten of the twelve tribes of Israel divided themselves from the true church of Judah and Benjamin, and made one to themselves at Bethel, and set up •olden calves▪ and yet pretended therewith to serve God, and so abused his word. Notwithstanding God was displeased with them, and ceased not his wrath until he had utterly destroyed them.
Phil. I shall desire your lordships to hear out my tale, and to take my meaning. For I know there is but one true church; but always from the beginning there hath been joined to the same true church, a false church, adversary to the true: and that was declared at first in Abel and Cain, who persecuted and slew his brother▪ in whom (St. Augustine witnesseth) is represented the false and true church. And that as soon as God had chosen his peculiar people, and shewed unto them his sanctuary, holy statutes, and will, anon after arose the false church, and ten of the twelve tribes of Israel divided themselves from the true church of Judah and Benjamin, and made one to themselves at Bethel, and set up •olden calves▪ and yet pretended therewith to serve God, and so abused his word. Notwithstanding God was displeased with them, and ceased not his wrath until he had utterly destroyed them.
Chi. I will grant you before the coming of Christ there were two churches in the old law; but in the new law since Christ's coming, you cannot show it to be so by the scriptures.
Chi. I will grant you before the coming of Christ there were two churches in the old law; but in the new law since Christ's coming, you cannot shew it to be so by the scriptures.
Phil. Yes, my lord, that I can, if you would give me leave. After Christ had chosen his apostles, was there not a Judas in the new law, and a Simon Magus, and were they not of the church?
Chi. Yea, but I mean after the gospel was written, where can you find me two churches after Christ had ascended, and sent the Holy Ghost?
Phil. The gospel was within eight years after the ascension written by St. Matthew; and the writing thereof is not material to the declaration of these two churches to have been always from time to time, as by example it may be showed: and yet as bad as my memory is, I remember in the New Testament mention is made of two churches, as it appeareth in the Revelations, and also as St. Paul to the Thessalonians •aketh mention, that Antichrist, with his false generation, shall sit in the temple of God. To which Chichester replied not.
Phil. The gospel was within eight years after the ascension written by St. Matthew; and the writing thereof is not material to the declaration of these two churches to have been always from time to time, as by example it may be shewed: and yet as bad as my memory is, I remember in the New Testament mention is made of two churches, as it appeareth in the Revelations, and also as St. Paul to the Thessalonians •aketh mention, that Antichrist, with his false generation, shall sit in the temple of God. To which Chichester replied not.
Dur. The church in scripture is likened to a great fisher's net, which contained in it both good ⟨p. 71⟩fish and bad fish. I trust you will be of the better sort, and lean to th• truth.
Phil. My lord, it is my whole desire now to follow that which is good, whatsoever I have done in times past, and to cle••e to God's truth.
Dur. Do you so, and then you shall do well: it is almost night, my lord of London, I must needs be gone.
Bond. Nay, my lord of Durham, I must desire your lordship, and my lord of Chichester, to tarry a little while. And before he had so said, the bishop of Bath went his way without saying a word. What, my lord of Bath, will you be gone? I pray you tarry. My lords, I have earnest matters to charge this man withal, whereof I would your lordships to be made privy, and I have them here written in a libel, I pray you sit down again, or else I will. First, I lay to him here, that he hath written in a bible, which I took from him, this erroneous saying, that "The Holy Ghost is Christ's vicar on earth." Wilt thou abide by this saying of thine, that the Spirit is Christ's vicar on earth?
Bon. Nay, my lord of Durham, I must desire your lordship, and my lord of Chichester, to tarry a little while. And before he had so said, the bishop of Bath went his way without saying a word. What, my lord of Bath, will you be gone? I pray you tarry. My lords, I have earnest matters to charge this man withal, whereof I would your lordships to be made privy, and I have them here written in a libel, I pray you sit down again, or else I will. First, I lay to him here, that he hath written in a bible, which I took from him, this erroneous saying, that "The Holy Ghost is Christ's vicar on earth." Wilt thou abide by this saying of thine, that the Spirit is Christ's vicar on earth?
Phil. My lord, it is not my saying, it is a more learned man's than mine: for I use not to write mine own sayings, but the notable sayings of other ancient writers, as all others be where you find the same written. And as I remember, it is even the saying of St. Bernard, and a saying that I need not be ashamed of neither you to be offended at, as my lord of Durham, and my lord of Chichester, by their learning can discern, and will not reckon it ill said.
Bond. Will they not? Why take away the first syllable, and it soundeth Arius.
Bon. Will they not? Why take away the first syllable, and it soundeth Arius.
Phil. That is far fetched indeed; if your lordship will scan men's sayings in such wise, you may find out what you list.
Bond. But to help this, I find moreover with his own hand, in another book, "In me, John Philpot, where sin did abound, grace hath super-abounded." I pray you what super-abundant grace have you more than other men? So said Arius, That he had abundance of grace above all others.
Bon. But to help this, I find moreover with his own hand, in another book, "In me, John Philpot, where sin did abound, grace hath super-abounded." I pray you what super-abundant grace have you more than other men? So said Arius, That he had abundance of grace above all others.
Phil. My lord, you need not be offended with that saying more than the other, for it is the saying of St. Paul himself, and I did apply it to myself for my comfort, knowing that though my sins be huge and great in the sight of God, yet is his mercy and grace above them all. And concerning Arius and his adherents, I defy them, and it is well known that I have written against him.
Bond. Also I lay to thy charge that thou killed thy father, and was accursed of thy mother on her death-bed, as I can bring witness thereof.
Bon. Also I lay to thy charge that thou killed thy father, and was accursed of thy mother on her death-bed, as I can bring witness thereof.
Phil. O my lord, what blasphemy is this? Hath your lordship nothing of truth to charge me withal, but (as I may speak it with your honour) such blasphemous lies? If any of these can be proved, I will promise to recant at Paul's Cross what you will have me: I am so sure they are as great blasphemies as may be objected to any man. Ha, my lords, I pray you, consider how my lord of London hath hitherto proceeded against me: for indeed he hath none other but such pretended slanderous lies.