Besides this also remaineth yet another try••ing toy of most vain distinction, to wit:1 Of the Sacrament, and not the thing:1 Of the Sacrament and the thing:2 Of the thing and not the Sacrament.3 Of which division there is not one member so much that is not altogether rotten. First whereas he placeth the Sacrament in certain empty and Metaphysical forms removed from the thing it self, therein he doeth no more digress from all conveniency of reason, and the judgement of the ancient fathers, than most blockishly vary from himself. For discoursing a little erst of the nature of a Sacrament, he affirmed that it ought to be of such efficacy, as might be able to refresh the bodies of them that did receive it. But these fantastical forms removed from the things, do not refresh the body. Ergo they be not the Sacrament in any respect. Again, whereas he sayeth that these visible kinds be the Sacrament only, yea and a Sacrament also of a double thing: because they signify both, and do carry an express likeness of both: this is also of both parts false. For first the thing that is neither bread nor the body, nor a thing, but a Sacrament of a thing only: not a creature, but the accident of a creature, nor is any substance at all, how can it possibly be, that the same thing which is not any thing at all, may seem to be a Sacrament of some one thing, and of some substance,5 yea and that also of a double thing? Or what kind of likeness at the length may there seem to be betwixt these monstrous forms, and the body of Christ, either natural or mystical, in the one whereof we do receive nourishment? in the other unity: sithence in forms there is neither any power to refresh body or soul, nor any union or knit ting ⟨image 96⟩together of parts and members? Moreover wher• as the same Lombard doeth affirm that the natural flesh of Christ is the Sacrament of Ecclesiastical union: how will he agree with himself.6 Whereas now he doeth abide by it, that these visible forms be the Sacrament of that conjunction? What monster will this bug whelp forth at the length? That cannot be contented to have littered his visible forms for a Sacrament of a double thing: unless he must also whelp• forth unto us a double Sacrament out of the same empty paunch of forms?
Besides this also remayneth yet another try••ing toy of most vaine distinction, to witte:1 Of the Sacrament, and not the thing:1 Of the Sacrament and the thing:2 Of the thing and not the Sacrament.3 Of which diuision there is not one member so much that is not altogither rotten. First wheras he placeth the Sacrament in certaine emptie and Metaphis•cal formes remooued from the thing it selfe, therein he doeth no more digresse from all conueniencie of reason, and the iudgement of the auncient fathers, than most blockishly vary from himself. For discoursing a litle earst of the nature of a Sacramēt, he affirmed that it ought to be of such efficacie, as migh• be able to refresh the bodies of them that did receyue it. But these fantastical formes remoued from the thinges, doe not refreshe the bodie. Ergo they bee not the Sacrament in anie respect. Againe, whereas hee sayeth that these visible kindes bee the Sacrament onely, yea and a Sacrament also of a double thing: bycause they signifie both, and doe carie an expresse likenesse of both: this is also of both partes false. For first the thing that is neither breade nor the bodie, nor a thing, but a Sacrament of a thing onely: not a creature, but the accident of a creature, nor is any substaunce at all, howe can it possibly bee, that the same thing which is not any thing at all, may seeme to bee a Sacrament of some one thing, and of some substaunce,5 yea and that also of a double thing? Or what kinde of likenesse at the length may there seeme to bee betwixt these monstrous formes, and the bodie of Christe, eyther naturall or mysticall, in the one whereof wee doe receyue nourishment? in the other vnitie: sithence in formes there is neyther any power to refreshe bodie or soule, nor any vnion or kni• ting ⟨image 96⟩together of partes and members? Moreouer wher• as the same Lombarde doeth affirme that the naturall fleshe of Christ is the Sacrament of Ecclesiasticall vnion: howe will hee agree with himselfe.6
- 1Lib. 4. dist. 8.
- 1The Sacrament only.The Sacrament onely.
- 2The Sacrament and the thing.
- 3The thing, and not the Sacrament.
- 5The visible forms cannot be the Sacrament of a double thing: to w•t of the body, and of the mystical body.The visible formes cannot be the Sacramēt of a double thing: to w•t of the bodie, and of the mysticall bodie.
- 6An argument against Lombard who doth affirm that the natural body of Christ is a Sacrament of his mystical body. that is to say, The churchAn argument agaynst Lombarde who doth affirme that the natural bodie of Christ is a Sacrament of his mystical bodie. that is to say, The church