And for his addition hereunto, that Christ after he took the bread and wine, and before he distributed them, by his miraculous and omnipotent benediction converted them into his own body and blood, as he showeth by his words plainly pronounced of them, This is my body. Though it be nothing to the Argument, and a mere begging of the point in Question, yet let us consider a little of it, where in the Text he findeth that Christ thus converted them: for the words, This is my body (as was formerly showed) do not evince it. But he findeth it (it seemeth) in the benediction or the blessing of the bread; which is yet against the common conceit of his Associates, that say there was no conversion at all till Christ uttered those words, This is my body. Hear we Bellarmine a little parguing this point against Luther. Having acknowledged (as was said formerly) that Christs words, This is my body, may bear either the sense that we give them, or the sense that they give them, but not that sense, that the Lutherans give: For (saith he) the Lord took bread, and blessed it, and gave it his Disciples, saying, This is my body. Bread therefore he took; bread he blessed, and of bread of he said, This is my body. Either therefore Christ by blessing changed the bread into his body truly and properly, or he changed it improperly and figuratively, by adding signification (or as Theodoret rather, *by adding to nature that grace) which before it had not. If he changed it truly and properly, then gave he bread changed, and of that bread so changed he truly said, This is my body, that is, that which is contained under the shape of bread is no more bread, but my body: and ⟨p. 137⟩this we say, If it be said that he changed the bread figuratively, then shall there be that bread given the Apostles, that is figuratively Christs body, and those words, This is my body have this sense, This is the figure of my body: and so the Protestants hold. Yea so indeed (as you have heard before) did Augustine in precise terms after Tertullian expound them, who belike then by Bellarmines ground was in this point a Protestant. Now let either Bellarmine, or this Answerer prove that our Saviour by his blessing wrought any other conversion, and we will yield unto them.
And for his addition hereunto, that Christ after hee tooke the bread and wine, and before hee distributed them, by his miraculous and omnipotent benediction converted them into his owne body and blood, as hee sheweth by his wordes plainely pronounced of them, This is my body. Though it be nothing to the Argument, and a meere begging of the point in Question, yet let vs consider a little of it, where in the Text hee findeth that Christ thus converted them: for the wordes, This is my body (as was formerly shewed) doe not euince it. But he findeth it (it seemeth) in the benediction or the blessing of the bread; which is yet against the common conceite of his Associates, that say there was no conversion at all till Christ vttered those words, This is my body. Heare we Bellarmine a little parguing this point against Luther. Hauing acknowledged (as was said formerly) that Christs words, This is my body, may beare either the sence that wee giue them, or the sense that they giue them, but not that sense, that the Lutherans giue: For (saith hee) the Lord tooke bread, and blessed it, and gaue it his Disciples, saying, This is my body. Bread therefore he tooke; bread hee blessed, and of bread of he said, This is my body. Either therefore Christ by blessing changed the bread into his body truely and properly, or he changed it improperly and figuratiuely, by adding signification (or as Theodoret rather, *by adding to nature that grace) which before it had not. If hee changed it truely and properly, then gaue he bread changed, and of that bread so changed he truely said, This is my body, that is, that which is contained vnder the shape of bread is no more bread, but my body: and ⟨p. 137⟩this we say, If it be said that he changed the bread figuratiuely, then shall there be that bread given the Apostles, that is siguratiuely Christs body, and those words, This is my body haue this sense, This is the figure of my body: and so the Protestants hold. Yea so indeede (as you haue heard before) did Augustine in precise tearmes after Tertullian expound them, who belike then by Bellarmines ground was in this point a Protestant. Now let either Bellarmine, or this Answerer prooue that our Sauiour by his blessing wrought any other conuersion, and wee will yeeld vnto them.
- pBellar. de Euchar. lib. 3. cap. 19.
- *[Greek or Hebrew].〈non-Latin alphabet〉.