A01532:394
A discussion of the popish doctrine of transubstantiation wherein the same is declared, by…A discussion of the popish doctrine of transubstantiation vvherein the same is declared, by…
A discussion of the popish doctrine of transubstantiation wherein the same is declared, by the confession of their own writers, to have no necessary ground in Gods Word: as also it is further demonstrated to be against Scripture, nature, sense, reason, religion, and the judgement of t5xxauncients, and the faith of our ancestors: written by Thomas Gataker B. of D. and pastor of Rotherhith.A discussion of the popish doctrine of transubstantiation vvherein the same is declared, by the confession of their owne writers, to haue no necessary ground in Gods Word: as also it is further demonstrated to be against Scripture, nature, sense, reason, religion, and the iudgement of t5xxauncients, and the faith of our auncestours: written by Thomas Gataker B. of D. and pastor of Rotherhith.
London: printed by John for William Sheffard, 1624London: printed by Iohn for William Sheffard, 1624
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Part 2 › Division 8: Division 8.Part 2 › Division 8: Diuision 8.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
2. He saith that the accidents of bread and wine remaining retain still their old names. To what purpose? For who doubteth but that the accidents, that is, the colour, savour, shape, size, &c. of the elements, remain still in the Eucharist, not without a subject, as they say, (for how can accidents so do, when the very *essence of an accident, as it is an accident, is to be in some subject?) but in the self same subject, wherein formerly they were? And what should hinder but that remaining so, they should retain still their old names? But neither are the accidents of bread and wine, bread and wine: and it is absurd to say either that the Apostle by bread meant the accidents of bread only; when he said ''The bread which we break, &c. and, “Let a man eat of that bread, &c. Or that by the fruit of the vine our Saviour meant nothing but the acci dents of wine, when he said, *I will drink henceforth no more of this fruit of the vine, &c. So that his reason is ridiculous, The accidents remaining retain still their old names; therefore the substance that is gone retaineth it own name still: or, the colour, savour shape and size retain their old names, and that which is in the Eucharist what ever it be, is said still to be white, round, thin well tasted, &c. and that with good reason, since it is so still as it was; ⟨p. 142⟩therefore though it be no more bread now, yet is it said to be so still. Sure reason and this mans brain were far asunder, when he writ this.
2. He saith that the accidents of bread and wine remaining retaine still their old names. To what purpose? For who doubteth but that the accidents, that is, the colour, sauour, shape, sise, &c. of the elements, remaine still in the Eucharist, not without a subiect, as they say, (for how can accidents so do, when the very *essence of an accident, as it is an accident, is to be in some subiect?) but in the selfe same subiect, wherein formerly they were? And what should hinder but that remaining so, they should retaine still their old names? But neither are the accidents of bread and wine, bread and wine: and it is absurd to say either that the Apostle by bread meant the accidents of bread onely; when he said