A01532:549
A discussion of the popish doctrine of transubstantiation wherein the same is declared, by…A discussion of the popish doctrine of transubstantiation vvherein the same is declared, by…
A discussion of the popish doctrine of transubstantiation wherein the same is declared, by the confession of their own writers, to have no necessary ground in Gods Word: as also it is further demonstrated to be against Scripture, nature, sense, reason, religion, and the judgement of t5xxauncients, and the faith of our ancestors: written by Thomas Gataker B. of D. and pastor of Rotherhith.A discussion of the popish doctrine of transubstantiation vvherein the same is declared, by the confession of their owne writers, to haue no necessary ground in Gods Word: as also it is further demonstrated to be against Scripture, nature, sense, reason, religion, and the iudgement of t5xxauncients, and the faith of our auncestours: written by Thomas Gataker B. of D. and pastor of Rotherhith.
London: printed by John for William Sheffard, 1624London: printed by Iohn for William Sheffard, 1624
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Part 2 › Division 14: Division 14.Part 2 › Division 14: Diuision 14.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
2. This fellow is either extremely impudent, or grossly ignorant, that dare so boldly and confidently avouch that all these Nations conspire with them in the celebration and belief of Sacrifice and Sacrament: Whereas it is commonly known that the most of these have their Liturgies in their own languages, which they have not; communicate the people in both kinds, which they do not; consecrate, not wafers, as they do, but whole loaves: and many of them, the Greeks especially, not unleavened but leavened; hold the consecration to be effected, not by the repetition of those words, This is my body, but by prayer and supplication; mingle no water with their wine; use no elevation for the worshipping of the Sacrament; nor admit the Popish Transubstantiation: as out of good Historiographers, their several Liturgies, and some of their own writers, both M. Breerwood in his book of Religions and Languages, and Th. A. in his Discourse of Catholic Traditions, at large show. Jeremiah the Greek Patriarch, whom he afterward citeth, affirmeth expressly, ⟨p. 204⟩that *at our Saviours last Supper that flesh of our Lord which he carried about him was not given the Apostles to eat, nor his blood to drink; nor are they now given in the holy mysteries, &c. And again, that this bread, when it is offered, is common bread offered only to God; but afterwards is made extraordinary bread. And in the Council of Florence (as appeareth in the last Session) some controversy there was between the Greek Church and theirs about the “transmutation of the Elements in the Eucharist; nor do we find that they ever came therein to any general accord or agreement unto this day. Now where (think you) is this mans face or his forehead, that dare so confidently aver that both these and all the Christian world but we conspire with them herein, both for opinion and in practise? Yea when he telleth us (to let us understand that he hath been a Traveller; and it may be brought as little wit or honesty with him home, as he carried out) that he hath seen their celebrations the same with theirs: he showeth therein, (if he say true, that he hath seen their celebrations) that against his own knowledge, when he thus writ, he told us a gross untruth;
2. This fellow is either extreamely impudent, or grossely ignorant, that dare so boldly and confidently auouch that all these Nations conspire with them in the celebration and beleefe of Sacrifice and Sacrament: Whereas it is commonly knowne that the most of these haue their Litur gies in their owne languages, which they haue not; communicate the people in both kindes, which they do not; consecrate, not wafers, as they doe, but whole loaues: and many of them, the Greekes especially, not vnleauened but leauened; hold the consecration to be effected, not by the repetition of those wordes, This is my body, but by prayer and supplication; mingle no water with their wine; vse no eleuation for the worshipping of the Sacrament; nor admit the Popish Transubstantiation: as out of good Historiographers, their seuerall Liturgies, and some of their owne writers, both M. Breerwood in his booke of Religions and Languages, and Th. A. in his Discourse of Catholicke Traditions, at large shew. Ieremy the Greeke Patriarcke, whom he afterward citeth, affirmeth expresly,