A01760:665
A dispute against the English-popish ceremonies, obtruded upon the Church of Scotland Wherein not…A dispute against the English-popish ceremonies, obtruded vpon the Church of Scotland Wherein not…
A dispute against the English-popish ceremonies, obtruded upon the Church of Scotland Wherein not only our own arguments [sic] against the same are strongly confirmed, but likewise the answers and defences of our opposites, such as Hooker, Morton ... Forbesse, &c. particularly confuted.A dispute against the English-popish ceremonies, obtruded vpon the Church of Scotland Wherein not only our ovvne argumemts [sic] against the same are strongly confirmed, but likewise the ansvveres and defences of our opposites, such as Hooker, Mortoune ... Forbesse, &c. particularly confuted.
Leiden: printed by W. Christiaens, 1637
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
But I reply, that either we must judge a thing to be repugnant or not repugnant to the Word, to be indifferent or not indifferent in itself, because the Church judgeth so of it, or else because the Church proveth unto us by an evident reason that it is so. If the latter; we have what we would. If the former; we are just where we were; The argument is still set a foot: then we must receive every thing (be it never so bad,) as indifferent, if only the Church happen so to judge of it. For quod competit alicui qua tali, &c. So that if we receive any thing as indifferent, for this respect, because the Church judgeth it to be so, then shall we receive every thing for indifferent; which the Church shall so judge of.
But I reply, that either we must judge a thing to be repugnant or not repugnant to the Word, to be indifferent or not indiffere•t in itself, because the Church judgeth so of it, or else because the Church proveth unto us by an evident reason that it is so. If the latter; we have what we would. If the former; we are just where we were; The argument is still set a foot: then we must receive every thing (be it never so bad,) as indifferent, if only the Church happen so to judge of it. For quod competit alicui qua tali, &c. So that if we receive any thing as indifferent, for this respect, because the Church judgeth it to be so, then shall we receive every thing for indifferent; which the Church shall so judge of.
3. The Church is forbidden to add any thing to the commandments Sect. 10 of God, which he hath given unto us, concerning his worship and service. Deut. 4. 2. and 12, 32. Prov. 30. 6. therefore she may not lawfully prescribe any thing in the works of Divine worship, if it be not a mere circumstance, belonging to that kind of things which were not determinable by Scripture.
3. The Church is forbidden to adde any thing to the commandements Sect. 10 of God, which he hath given unto us, concerning his worship and service.