A03618:84
An answer unto my lord of Winchester's [sic] book entitled a detection of the…An answer vnto my lord of wynthesters [sic] booke intytlyd a detection of the…
An answer unto my lord of Winchester's [sic] book entitled a detection of the devils sophistry wherewith he robbeth the unlearned people of the true belief in the most blessed sacrament of the altar made by Johann Hopper.An answer vnto my lord of wynthesters [sic] booke intytlyd a detection of the deuyls sophistrye wherwith he robith the vnlernyd people of the trew byleef in the moost blessyd sacrament of the aulter made by Johann Hoper.
printed by Augustine Fries, 1547printed by Augustyne Fries, 1547
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
to say the peace maker between god and man. This body of Christ is only in heaven and no where else, as Jo saith 1. Epist. 2. so doth August. writ tractat in Joan. 30. Sursum est dominus, & iterum corpus enim domini resurrexit, in uno loco oportet esse, so dooth the master of the sentence allege his words, and not, in uno loco esse potest, as the later edition readeth. How fond doctrine the school men teacheth it is plain. Lambertus in the sentence innocentius in the decretales. De summa trinitate, & fide Cath. ca. ffirmiter, and Nicolaus pape de consec. Dict. 2. cap. Ego Berengarius. This doctrine subverteth it self if men Mark it well. For as soon as they have confessed the bread to be the essential, and substantial body of Christ, and the wine, his natural blood they add, sed inuisibiliter & ineffabiliter, & non ut in loco, non qualitative, ant quantitative. So doth Thomas aquinas part 3. Quaest 76. and Lombertus lib. sentent. 4. Distinct. 10. sophistically dispute the matter. Is it not à wounder that men will not mark what contradiction is in there words, first the say Christs very natural corporal, physical, substantial and real body is in the sacrament. The body that died upon the cross. Was buried that rise the third day, that was taken into heavens, and yet they make it with out quality, and quantity, ⟨image 56⟩es notis this a marvellous doctrine to say Christ now hat• a body, that is nether great nether small truly if he have now such a body as is invisible, without all qualities and quantities, then had he never upon the earth à true body, but à fantastical body as they make him to have in the sacrament. But I confirm my faith by the scripture that teacheth of his incarnation and very manhood Matt. 1. Luc. 1. Rom. 1. Ebr•. 1. 2. 9. 10. Matt. 26. 27. Mark 14. […] and by all the scripture and let this false imagination of Christs body pass that they speak of to be in the sacrament. And would the Christian reader, not to be moved, with this doctrine at all. But to set saint August. against the master of the sentence, and all other school doctors be the realists or formalists. He declareth plainly that no body can be, except it occupy place Epist ad Dardanum 57. Spatia inquit locorum tolle corporibus, nusquam erunt, & quia nusquam erunt, nec erunt. Tolle ipsa corpora qualitatibus corporum, nō erit ubi sint, & ideo necesse est, ut non sint.