Th'overthrow of stage-plays, by the way of controversy betwixt D. Gager and D. Rainoldes…Th'overthrow of stage-playes, by the way of controversie betwixt D. Gager and D. Rainoldes…
Th'overthrow of stage-plays, by the way of controversy betwixt D. Gager and D. Rainoldes wherein all the reasons that can be made for them are notably refuted; th'objections answered, and the case so cleared and resolved, as that the judgement of any man, that is not froward and perverse, may easily be satisfied. Wherein is manifestly proved, that it is not only unlawful to be an actor, but a beholder of those vanities. Whereunto are added also and annexed in th'end certain latin letters betwixt the said Master Rainoldes, and D. Gentiles, reader of the civill law in Oxford, concerning the same matter.Th'overthrow of stage-playes, by the way of controversie betwixt D. Gager and D. Rainoldes wherein all the reasons that can be made for them are notably refuted; th'objections aunswered, and the case so cleared and resolved, as that the iudgement of any man, that is not froward and perverse, may easelie be satisfied. Wherein is manifestly proved, that it is not onely vnlawfull to bee an actor, but a beholder of those vanities. Wherevnto are added also and annexed in th'end certeine latine letters betwixt the sayed Maister Rainoldes, and D. Gentiles, reader of the civill law in Oxford, concerning the same matter.
John Rainolds 1549–1607Middelburg: printed by Richard Schilders, 1599
[8], 163, [1], 164-190, [1] p. · 74k words · STC 20616 · ESTC S115568
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And the exercises of declaiming, answering, opposing, do help to breed ripeness in those arts. Our Saviours sentence therefore that one thing is needful, argueth not these exercises to be unnecessary. No more doth Solomon's saying that all things are vanity, prove them to be vain. For out of 1those all things him self doeth except, the cfear of God (as you note) and (as you should have noted) the keeping of Gods commandments. Wherefore sith our Students be commanded by God dto employ the pieces of money that he hath given them, in trade and traffic as it were, to make gai•e thereof; ⟨p. 126⟩and the trade, wherein they must employ their time, is, to get them selves all instruments of learning, by which they emay be able to 2exhort with wholesome doctrine; and 3convince such as gainsay it: their practise of exhortatory and convincing faculties, of declamations, of elenches, of oppositions and suppositions, can not be condemned, as vain, by his word, by whom fthe evil servant is condemned, as gunprofitable, for hhiding his talent in the earth. Well may you have heard a Preacher in the pulpit affirm that which you mention: but I doubt whether you understood him well. For you allege him so, as if he had pronounced those exercises simply, & in them selves, vain: Which it were injurious to think, that a learned and a godly Preacher (such do you report him; and I, not knowing who it was, do believe you) should purpose to affirm: seeing Christ;
against a trueth, although with purpose for the trueth. It is not to be thought then, that the Preacher, terming our exercises vain, meant that they are such simply and in them selves; but as they are used by us, by many of us, to sundry fruitless ends, not to make us fitter for the
And the exercises of declaiming, answering, opposing, doe helpe to breede ripenes in those artes. Our Saviours sentence therefore that one thing is needfull, argueth not these exercises to be vnnecessarie. No more doth Salamons saying that all things are vanitie, proove them to be vaine. For out of 1those all things him selfe doeth except, the cfeare of God (as you note) and (as you should haue noted) the keeping of Gods commaundements. Wherefore sith our Students be commaunded by God dto employ the pieces of moony that hee hath given them, in trade and traficke as it were, to make gai•e therof; ⟨p. 126⟩and the trade, wherein they must employ their time, is, to gett them selves all instrumentes of learning, by whiche they emay be able to 2exhort with wholesome doctrine; and 3convince such as gainsay it: their practise of exhortatorie and convincing faculties, of declamations, of elenches, of oppositions and suppositions, can not be condemned, as vaine, by his woord, by whom fthe evill servant is condemned, as gvnprofitable, for hhyding his talent in the earth. Well may you haue heard a Preacher in the pulpitt affirme that which you mention: but I doubt whether you vnderstoode him well. For you alleage him so, as if he had pronoūced those exercises simply, & in them selves, vaine: Which it were iniurious to thinke, that a learned and a godli• Preacher (such doe you report him; and I, not knowing who it was, doe beleeve you) should purpose to affirme: feing Christ; iwhose mouth was never defiled with toy or anie vaine thing, vsed certaine of them, as oppositions namely. For what are koppositions but arguments obiected against a point in question? What was it but an argument obiected so by Christ, when against the lSadduces, denying the resurrection, mhe vrged a text of Moses? and against the nPharises, holding no more of Christ but that he was Davids sonne, a otestimonie of David? Yea, in this later he did that which of all things in our disputations might seeme to be most vaine, obiect pagainst a trueth, although with purpose for the trueth. It is not to be thought then, that the Preacher, terming our exercises vaine, meant that they are such simply and in them selves; but as they are vsed by vs, by many of vs, to sundry fruitlesse endes, not to make vs fitter for the qgood and 4need full edifying of men:
1Heb. HACCOL with HE (an article as it were) expressed & expounded by Tremellius & Junius, Eccl. 1. 2. & 12. 10Heb. HACCOL wt HE (an article as it were) expressed & expounded by Tremellius & Iunius, Eccl. 1. 2. & 12. 10
nor to advance rgodliness profitable for all things, but to increase or make a show of sthat knowledge, which therefore is called tvanity by the wise man, because it hath vno permanent and lasting commodity, xnor bringeth us salvation and eternal life. Whereof it doeth no more follow that the exercises are vain, as you conclude; then if one should reason that the fear of God, (which you except) is vain, upon that place of Isaiah, yTheir f•are toward me is taught by the precept of men. For, if, notwithstanding that zthe Jews worshipped and feared God in vain, ⟨p. 127⟩fearing him amiss according to the precepts of men, not to his word, yet the fear of God is most beneficial, and awas to some among the Jews too: then may declamations, supposititions, oppositions, and such scholastical exercises be profitable & fruitful, even unto some among us also, though many of us make them vanity of vanities, as vain as that bstrife is which Saint Paul reproveth, I mean, both 5void of wholesome juice, & 6full of poison. But to what purpose are these discourses, will you say, of exercises fit for scholars, and Terence not to be read unto them, till they be of riper years & judgement? To let you understand, that whereas you tell us, you come upon the stage to practise your style, to acquaint your selves with Plautus, to embolden your youth, to try their voices, confirm their memories, frame their speech and action; you are so far from justifying your plays by this defence, that you condemn them more. For if the tale of Jupiter with Danaë, in Eunuchus, should not be read to such as your Melantho and Nais: much less should they be taught the same tale 7urged farther, in Ulysses •edux; and less yet another tale of cwanton Salmacis 8with her boy; in Hippolytus. If they should not as much as salute Terence, the finest Comical Poet, for pureness of the Latin tongue in dTullies judgement: much less should they be made well acquainted with Plautus; and less yet with Rivals. If they should not be suffered to peruse writings of base & filthy quality, nor to cast their eyes, as it were, upon them: much less should they engrave them by heart in their remembrance, express them with voice, commend them with action, deliver them with boldness.
nor to advance rgodlines profitable for all things, but to encrease or make a shew of sthat knowledge, which therfore is called tvanitie by the wise man, because it hath vno permanent and lasting commoditie, xnor bringeth vs salvation and eternall life. Whereof it doeth no more folow that the exercises are vaine, as you conclude; then if one should reason that the feare of God, (which you except) is vaine, vpon that place of Esay, yTheir f•are toward me is taught by the precept of men. For, if, notwithstanding that zthe Iewes worshipped and feared God in vaine, ⟨p. 127⟩fearing him amisse according to the precepts of men, not to his woord, yet the feare of God is most beneficiall, and awas to some among the Iewes too: then may declamations, supposititions, oppositions, and such schol•sticall exercises be profitable & fruitfull, even vnto some among vs also, though many of vs make them vanitie of vanities, as vaine as that bstrife is which Saint Paul reprooveth, I meane, both 5voide of wholesome iuice, & 6ful of poyson. But to what purpose are these discourses, will you say, of exercises fitt for scholers, and Terence not to be read vnto them, till they be of riper yeares & iudgement? To let you vnderstand, that whereas you tell vs, you come vpon the stage to practise your style, to acquaint your selues with Plautus, to embolden your youth, to trye their voices, confirme their memories, frame their speech and action; you are so farre from iustifying your playes by this defense, that you condemne thē more. For if the tale of Iupiter with Danaë, in Eunuchus, should not be read to such as your Melantho and Nais: much lesse should they be taught the same tale
If they should not exercise their style, their speech, their memory, but in honest, virtuous, and commendable matters, which in use of life may serve them to good purpose: much less should they meditate how they may inflame & tender youth with love; entice him to dalliance, to whoredom, to incest; inure their minds and bodies to uncomely, dissolute, railing, boasting, knavish, foolish, brainsick, drunken conceits, words, and gestures. Wherefore to the Timothees, that are among your Students, I must say in like sort as Saint Paul to Timothy: eConsider what I say; and the Lord give you ⟨p. 128⟩understanding in all things.
If they should not exercise their style, their speech, their memorie, but in honest, vertuous, and commendable matters, which in vse of lise may serve them to good purpose: much lesse should they meditate how they may inflame & tender youth with loue; entise him to daliance, to hoordom, to incest; inure their mindes and bodyes to vncoomly, dissolute, railing, boasting, knavish, foolish, brainsicke, drunken conceits, woordes, and gestures. Wherefore to the Timothees, that are among your Students, I must say in like sort as Saint Paul to Timothee: eConsider what I say; and the Lord giue you ⟨p. 128⟩vnderstanding in all things.
Now, the inconveniences and mischiefs of your plays being so notorious and manifold, as I have showed: the rest of mine answer opposed to your reasons devised for their defence, will easily deliver it self from your cavils. For where you having said that your Students did not misspend their time therein, because they spent no more time then useth to be spent in sports, sleep, talk, and learned releasing of the mind from study; and having added thereto that, sith there is a time for sports, plays, dances, and man consisting not of one part alone doeth need recreation, therefore you may be stage-players; I answered to the former, that by the like reason a student haunting a dicing house, or tavern, or stews, might prove that he did not misspend his time thereat; to the later, that recreation is necessary for Scholars, yet would it not beseem them to play at stool-ball among wenches, nor at Mumchance or Maw with idle lost companions; nor at trunks in Guile-halls, nor to dance about Maypoles, nor to rifle in alehouses, nor to carouse in Taverns, nor to steal Deere, nor to rob Orchards: you reply that to compare your plays to these things, it exceedeth the compass of any tolerable resemblance; and thereupon eftsoons you surname them hard and incomparable comparisons. Wherein how incomparably you lavish out of measure, and exceed the compass of any reasonable speech, you may quickly see, now that I have proved your plays to be evil: si•h these things being likewise evil and disorderly, and so agreeing with them in a general point, it is clear they may be resembled thereunto.
Now, the inconveniences and mischiefes of your playes being so notorious and manifold, as I haue shewed: the rest of mine answer opposed to your reasons devised for their defense, will easilie deliver it selfe from your cavills. For where you having said that your Students did not misspend their time therein, because they spent no more time then vseth to be spent in sports, sleepe, talke, and learned releasing of the minde from studie; and having added thereto that, sith there is a time for sportes, playes, danses, and man consisting not of one part alone doeth neede recreation, therefore you may be stage-players; I answered to the former, that by the like reason a student haunting a dicing house, or taverne, or stewes, might proove that he did not misspend his time thereat; to the later, that recreation is necessarie for Schollers, yet would it not beseeme them to play at stoole-ball amonge wenches, nor at Mumchance or Maw with idle lost companions; nor at trunkes in Guile-halls, nor to danse about Maypoles, nor to rifle in alehouses, nor to carowse in Tavernes, nor to steale Deere, nor to robbe Orchyards: you reply that to compare your playes to these things, it exceedeth the compasse of any tollerable resemblance; and therevpon eftsoones you surname them hard and incomparable comparisons. Wherein howe incomparably you lavish out of measure, and exceede the compasse of any reasonable speach, you may quickly see, now that I haue prooved your playes to be evill: si•h these things being likewise evill and disorderlie, and so agreeing with them in a generall point, it is cleere they may be resembled therevnto.
The Scripture compareth four Saviour to an 9usurer, who desireth gain by the money he lendeth; gthe children of light to an unjust steward, who maketh him self friends with his masters goods against a time of need, hthe coming of the Lorde• day to a thief in the night, who cometh suddenly and unlooked for. Comparisons not tolerable, if the special qualities of usurers, of unjust men, of thieves, should be meant: but very good and fit, if we mark the general points that they are matched in. Or, if Scripture-eloquence, which yet St iAustin magnifieth, seem base in your eyes; though, seem it never so ⟨p. 129⟩base, I trust you will not say that to compare our Saviour, and so forth, to these things, it exceedeth the compass of any tolerable resemblance: but the eloquence, the learning, the authority of Homer, whose wit (k you say) 1enlightened both men and Gods together, whose 2majesty you worship with 3prayer and 4thanksgiving, to 5whom you wish eternal glory, and call him 6the eternal old man, will suffice to open your eyes and stop your mouth. For he compareth lvaliant Ajax to an ass, that being in a corn-field will not be driven out with any cudgels of boys till he have filled his belly; the m Grecians and Trojans about Sarpedon's carcass, to flies about a milk-pail in a warm spring-time, all busy and loth to leave it. There are nwho find fault with these comparisons, I grant, as overbase and abject: but your adoration of Homer doeth persuade me, that you will make more of ohis censure, who, for the general drift thereof, approveth them. At least you shall be forced to yield by your own words, in as much as having compared our reproof of your expense in plays to ptheir speech who said of the costly ointment poured upon Christs head, what needed this wast? and being told the difference of that fact from yours; you say, that though you know there is an infinite difference between yours and the action against the which it was hypocritically first used: yet you think it may also be applied against, either the niggardise, or the hypocrisy of any Momus, that shall condemn all expense as cast away, that is sometimes moderately bestowed upon honest sports and pastimes. For how can it be chosen but to compare your charges on plays to those on Christ, must needs exceed the compass of any tolerable resemblance:
The Scripture compareth four Saviour to an 9vsurer, who desireth gaine by the moony hee lendeth; gthe children of light to an vniust steward, who maketh him selfe frendes with his maisters goods against a time of neede, hthe coming of the Lorde• day to a thiefe in the night, who cometh suddenly and vnlooked for. Comparisons not tollerable, if the speciall qualities of vsurers, of vniust men, of the•ves, should bee meant: but very good and fitt, if wee marke the generall points that they are matched in. Or, if Scripture-eloquence, which yet St iAustin magnifieth, seeme base in your eyes; though, seeme it never so ⟨p. 129⟩base, I trust you will not say that to compare our Saviour, and so foorth, to these things, it exceedeth the compasse of any tolerable resemblance: but the eloquence, the learning, the autoritie of Homer, whose witt (k you say) 1enlightned both men and Gods together, whose 2maiestie you worshippe with 3prayer and 4thankesgiuing, to 5whom you wish eternall glorie, and call him 6the eternall olde man, will suffice to open your eyes and stoppe your mouth. For he compareth lvaliant Aiax to an asse, that being in a corne-field will not bee driven out with any cudgels of boyes till he haue filled his belly; the m Grecians and Troians about Sarpedons carkasse, to flies about a milke-paile in a warme spring-time, all busy and loth to leaue it. There are
unless things agreeing in a general point, as you suppose (though falsely) these to do in honesty, may be very well resembled each to other? And 7why should you reprove it in me as a hard incomparable deed: when you think it comparable and soft in your own case? Chiefly, sith you know, that even in the degree of honest matters too, whereon expenses are made, there is an infinite difference between the actions, which you match: I can not say so of those that I compare. Nay, some of the things that I compare your stage-plays with, are less evil; as namely, ⟨p. 130⟩for scholars to play at stoolball among wenches: which to do by day light, in open streets, in their own likeness, were not so unmeet and inconvenient for them, as to be attired in women's raiment, by women, within doors, in the night time, to go to and fro, and come upon the stage, and play Melantho, or Nais. Contrariwise, the action wherewith you match yours; was infinitely better, as your self acknowledge: and had, as you must also acknowledge, 8less bestowed thereon, then yours had. So that your consequution doeth halt here again; It was no wast to be at lesser cost in working a good work on Christ; Ergo it is no wast to be at greater charges in setting forth of plays. But mine is unreprovable; It beseemeth not scholars to play at stoolball among wenches, though modest and chaste; Therefore it beseemeth them not to play wanton women on the stage. The same may I say of the two comparisons, which herewithall you check; the former, alleged out of Salvianus, or out of Scripture rather; the later, adjoined by me for illustrating and opening the former: to wit, that with the players of lewd and naughty parts it fareth as with a fool committing wickedness in pastime; and they are like a mad man, who casteth firebrands, arrows, and mortal things, and saith, was I not in sport? For a mad man casting firebrands, and the like, endangereth bodies only: the players of lewd parts do endanger souls. And a fool committing wickedness in pastime hath seldom many admirers and followers to hurt: the players have as many, as a great Theatre holdeth, and can hear them say, But O Cupido, or, O quàm juvaret.
vnlesse things agreeing in a generall point, as you suppose (though falsly) these to doe in honestie, may be very well resembled eche to other? And 7why should you reproove it in me as a hard incomparable deede: when you thinke it comparable and soft in your own case? Chiefly, sith you know, that even in the degree of honest matters too, whereon expenses are made, there is an infinite difference betwene the actions, which you match: I can not say so of those that I compare. Nay, some of the thinges that I compare your stage-playes with, are lesse evill; as namelie, ⟨p. 130⟩for scholers to play at stooleball among wenches: which to doe by day light, in open streetes, in their owne likenes, were not so vnmeete and inconvenient for them, as to be attired in wemens raiment, by wemen, within doores, in the night time, to goe to and fro, and come vpon the stage, and play Melantho, or Nais. Contrariwise, the action wherewith you match yours; was infinitely better, as your selfe acknowledge: and had, as you must also acknowledge, 8lesse bestowed thereon, then yours had. So that your consequution doeth halt here againe; It was no wast to bee at lesser cost in woorking a good woorke on Christ; Ergo it is no wast to bee at greater charges in setting foorth of playes. But mine is vnreprooveable; It beseemeth not scholers to play at stooleball among wenches, though modest and chast; Therefore it beseemeth them not to play wanton wemen on the stage. The same may I say of the two comparisons, which herewithall you checke; the former, alleaged out of Salvianus, or out of Scripture rather; the later, adioyned by mee for illustrating and opening the former: to weete, that with the players of lewde and naughty parts it fareth as with ae foole committing wickednes in pastime; and they are like a mad man, who casteth firebrands, arrowes, and mortall thinges, and saith, was I not in sport? For a mad man casting firebrandes, and the like, endangereth bodies onely: the players of lewde parts doe endanger sowles. And a foole commiting wickednesse in pastime hath seldome many admirers and folowers to hurt: the players haue as many, as a great Theater holdeth, and can heare them say, But O Cupido, or, O quàm juvaret.
7Quis tule• Gracchos d• sedition que rents? Juvenal. sat. […].Quis tule• Gracchos d• seditione que rentes? Iuvenal. sat. 〈…〉.
8[Greek or Hebrew], or [Greek or Hebrew], it was esteemed by them, who amplified it to the uttermost. Mark. 14. 5. Joh. 12 5. And that may amount to nine or ten pound of our money.〈non-Latin alphabet〉, or 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, it was esteemed by thē, who amplified it to the vttermost. Mark. 14. 5. Ioh. 12 5. And that may amount to nine or ten pound of our moony.
Wherefore when you amplify hereupon, and tell me, you could have wished that such comparisons had been forborne, if not for the plays them selves, though also they ought for the plays them selves, being things that savour of some wit, learning, and judgement; yet in respect of the actors, your whole house, the spectators, approvers, authors, writers; all which points you load with pathetical circumstances otherwhere entreated of: you force me to say I could have wished also that you had forborne these Galba-tricks of seeking to prejudice the trueth and equity of causes with partial affections and respect of persons, a qthing ⟨p. 131⟩condemned by Scripture; and that you had considered that if plays savouring of some wit learning, and judgement, ought not to be compared to such things as I mentioned, then your self did ill in praising and allowing that part of my discourse, wherein the fool and mad man served for comparisons. For you gave testimony thereof, that I had written copiously and truly against the bad effects of stage-plays in general. Yea, specifying the proofs that I made by sundry examples and authorities, among which the authority of Salvianus was, you soothed it as containing a truth, and well handled. But the stage-plays spoken of by Salvianus, did savour of some wit, learning, and judgement: as what play doeth nor? at least of all those that any ancient Poet wrote. Your reason therefore brought from the savour of wit learning, and judgement, to cross my comparisons; doeth cross your own allowance of that which you acknowledged to be well spoken against the bad effects of stage-plays in general. And thus, as rLycurgus the Thracian imagining that he was hewing down a vine with his hatchet, is said to have slain his son, and maimed him self: likewise you intending to show that my comparisons are hard and incomparable, and exceed the compass of any tolerable resemblance, and should have been forborne, have wounded unawares your eternal old man, and your self grievously.
Wherefore when you amplifie herevpon, and tell me, you could haue wisht that such comparisons had bene forborne, if not for the playes them selves, though also they ought for the playes them selves, being thinges that savour of some witt, learning, and iudgement; yet in respect of the actors, your whole house, the spectators, approovers, autours, writers; all which points you loade with patheticall circumstances otherwhere entreated of: you force me to say I could haue wisht also that you had forborne these Galba-trickes of seeking to preiudice the trueth and equitie of causes with partiall affections and respect of persons, a qthing ⟨p. 131⟩condemned by Scriptire; and that you had considered that if playes savouring of some witt learning, and iudgement, ought not to be compared to such things as I mentioned, then your selfe did ill in praysing and allowing that part of my discourse, wherein the foole and mad man served for comparisons. For you gaue testimonie therof, that I had written copiously and truly against the bad effects of stage-playes in generall. Yea, specifying the proofes that I made by sundry examples and autorities, among which the autoritie of Salvianus was, you soothed it as containing a truth, and well handled. But the stage-playes spoken of by Salvianus, did savour of some witt, learning, and iudgement: as what play doeth nor? at least of all those that any ancient Poët wrote. Your reason therfore brought from the savour of witt learning, and iudgement, to crosse my comparisons; doeth crosse your owne allowance of that which you acknowledged to be well spoken against the bad effects of stage-playes in generall. And thus, as rLycurgus the Thracian imagining that hee was hewing downe a vine with his hatchet, is said to have slaine his sonne, and maimed him selfe: likewise you intending to shew that my comparisons are hard and incomparable, and exceede the compasse of any tolerable resemblance, and should haue bene forborne, haue wounded vnawares your eternall olde man, and your selfe greevously.
A more grievous wound have you given your self in saying that you presumed your plays to be lawful, when you made your simple assertion (so you term it) that there is a needful time for sports. For this is in effect as much as if you said, that you played the sSophister, 9begging the point in question, and taking it as granted. The which kind of dealing, if it had any sinews to grapple with an adversary, the Jesuits might trouble us, by saying that the Catholic faith must be kept; and they presume that Popery is the Catholic faith. Likewise the meanest advocate in a court of law might speed all his clients, by saying that such as have wrong offered them, ought to be relieved; and he presumeth his clients have so. Neither had you needed to write so long a reply of twelve leaves to me: twelve words might have sufficed, that you presume my cause is naught, and ⟨p. 132⟩naughty things must not be credited. But your self acknowledge that this proveth not the lawfulness of your plays. So that, in affirming you did presume them to be lawful, and calling it a simple assertion which you avowed concerning sports, you speak more trueth then you intended. For it is a simple assertion in deed to say that sports are needful, against a mans arguments who saith that stage-plays are unlawful. And he may be justly noted of presumption, who, being unable to prove a thing he fancieth, condemneth them as Momes that are minded otherwise and bring sound proof against it.
A more greevous wound haue you giuen your selfe in saying that you presumed your playes to be lawfull, when you made your simple assertion (so you terme it) that there is a needfull time for sports. For this is in effect as much as if you saide, that you played the sSophister, 9begging the point in question, and taking it as granted. The which kinde of dealing, if it had any sinewes to graple with an adversarie, the Iesuits might trooble vs, by saying that the Catholike faith must be kept; and they presume that Poperie is the Catholike faith. Likewise the meanest advocate in a court of law might speede all his clients, by saying that such as haue wrong offered them, ought to be releeved; and hee presumeth his clients haue so. Neither had you needed to write so long a reply of twelue leaves to me: twelue wordes might haue sufficed, that you presume my cause is naught, and ⟨p. 132⟩naughty things must not be credited. But your selfe acknowledge that this prooveth not the lawfulnes of your playes. So that, in affirming you did presume them to bee lawfull, and calling it a simple assertion which you avowed concerning sports, you speake more trueth then you intended. For it is a simple assertion in deede to say that sports are needfull, against a mans arguments who saith that stage-playes are vnlawfull. And hee may be iustly noted of presumption, who, beeing vnable to proove a thing he fansieth, condemneth them as Momes that are minded otherwise and bring sound proofe against it.
sAristo. de • prehē. Soph.Aristo. de • prehē. Soph.
Howbeit, had you kept your self within the compass of such oversights, you were more excusable. But it is a greater fault to play the slanderer by falsifying mens words, and fathering upon them an erroneous sentence, which never came into their minds, nor fell out of their mouths or pens. And what do you else, when having said that I use many words against dancing, you reply that you love to see honest dancing; and, you see no cause in reason, charity, or Christian liberty, why dancing should simply be condemned. For hereby you insinuate, or pronounce rather, that I condemned dancing simply, and honest dancing: whereas my words were that dances of Penelope's wooers, of Melantho, of other of her maids, and simply all stage-dancing do savour of dishonesty. Which differeth as much from that you father on me, as the speech of Christ, tDestroy ye this temple, & in three days I will raise it up again, meaning of his body, did differ from that which vthe false witnesses affirmed him to have said of the temple of God, xthe temple made with hands. Nay, it surpasseth that of the false witnesses: it differeth as much as if, where Christ said, that yall ungodly men shall perish, they had fathered on him that all men shall perish. And your crime herein is the more blameworthy, because I had so plainly excepted certain dancing, that you can not seem to have mistaken my words, and read all dancing, for all stage-dancing; but wilfully and advisedly to have misreported me. For I said expressly, I meant those dances that I specified, and not zDavids dancing, which St aAmbrose doeth well distinguish from them. Now St Ambrose saith that Davids religious and ⟨p. 133⟩godly dancing is decent: but 1the dangerous dancing practised by players, and the 2foolish toys, the dotages, of the stage; 3are faulty even in youth too. So both mine own words, and the author I cited, do manifestly show, that when you took upon you to praise honest dancing, and said you saw no cause in charity or reason why dancing should simply be condemned, you could not but in reason and charity see cause, why you should have dealt more simply and honestly, then so calumniously to raise a false surmise of me. You know what creature it is, whom the bscripture nameth a 4calumniator.
Howbeit, had you kept your selfe within the compasse of such oversights, you were more excusable. But it is a greater fault to play the sclanderer by falsifying mens wordes, and fathering vpon them an erroneous sentence, which never came into their mindes, nor fell out of their mouths or pennes. And what doe you else, when having saide that I vse many wordes against dansing, you reply that you loue to see honest dansing; and, you see no cause in reason, charitie, or Christian libertie, why dansing should simply be condemned. For hereby you insinuate, or pronounce rather, that I condemned dansing simply, and honest dansing: whereas my wordes were that danses of Penelopes wooers, of Melantho, of other of her maides, and simply all stage-dansing do savour of dishonestie. Which differeth as much from that you father on me, as the speech of Christ, tDestroy ye this temple, & in three dayes I will raise it vp againe, meaning of his body, did differ from that which vthe false witnesses affirmed him to haue said of the temple of God, xthe temple made with handes. Nay, it surpasseth that of the false witnesses: it differeth as much as if, where Christ saide, that yall vngodly men shall perish, they had fathered on him that all men shall perish. And your crime herein is the more blamewoorthy, because I had so plainly excepted certaine dansing, that you can not seeme to haue mistaken my wordes, and reade all dansing, for all stage-dansing; but wilfully and advisedly to haue misreported mee. For I said expressely, I meant those danses that I specified, and not zDavids dansing, which St aAmbrose doeth well distinguish from them. Now St Ambrose saith that Davids religious and ⟨p. 133⟩godly dansing is decent: but 1the dangerous dansing practised by players, and the 2foolish toyes, the dotages, of the stage; 3
Beside, as you offend in charging me with that I said not: so in going about to overthrow that which I said. For whereas I affirmed that dancing of Penelope's wooers with her maids, and simply all stage-dancing, is disallowed by the light of nature; and for proof thereof did allege the testimonies, of Romans putt by Nero, of Philistines putting Samson to it, and of all ancient 1laws in a manner, yea of reason it self, as Arias Montanus noteth: you, avouching two mens opinions to the contrary, do add, that to apply, either the dancing of those noble Romans, whom Nero enforced to dance so publicly; or, Samsons dancing among the Philistines; or, the note of Arias Montanus, against your dancing only of two sober measures, is a comparison without all measure. Wherein first, through negligence of marking my words, or desire of crossing them before you understood them, you misreport my drift: and say that I applied those things against your dancing only of two sober measures, (you mean, the wooers dancing with the maids,) which I applied not against it alone, but against the rest of your stage-dancing also, that is, all your stage-playing. For this did I betoken by the name of stage-dancing, the better to express the sentence, that I had in hand, of Saint Ambrose, who by 5dancing noteth all histrionical motions and playings on the stage, in like sort as cHorace saith, 8one was requested to dance Polyphemus, meaning to play his part; and 7Plancus danced Glaucus, in dUelleius story; and g stage-players danced Oedipus, and Hercules, in eMacrobius; and fArnobius speaketh of 9dancing Europa, Leda, Ganymedes. Neither was it hard for you to perceive that I meant ⟨p. 134⟩thus much, if you had better weighed the branches of my speech, & proofs thereto answering, concluded with the note of Arias Montanus, touching not only dancers, but persons of such shows & spectacles. Chiefly if you had looked on the author him self, and marked that in the persons of such shows and spectacles, he compriseth stage-players; as the 1generality of his words, exemplified by Nero, maketh plain.
Beside, as you offend in charging me with that I said not: so in going about to overthrow that which I said. For whereas I affirmed that dansing of Penelopes wooers with her maides, and simply all stage-dansing, is disallowed by the light of nature; and for proofe thereof did alleage the testimonies, of Romans putt by Nero, of Philistines putting Samson to it, and of all ancient 1lawes in a manner, yea of reason it selfe, as Arias Montanus noteth: you, avouching two mens opinions to the contrarie, doe adde, that to apply, either the dansing of those noble Romans, whom Nero enforced to danse so publikely; or, Samsons dansing among the Philistines; or, the note of Arias Montanus, against your dansing onely of two sober measures, is a comparison without all measure. Wherein first, through negligence of marking my words, or desire of crossing them before you vnderstood them, you misreport my drift: and say that I applyed those thinges against your dansing onely of two sober measures, (you meane, the wooers dansing with the maides,) which I applyed not against it alone, but against the rest of your stage-dansing also, that is, all your stage-playing. For this did I betoken by the name of stage-dansing, the better to expresse the sentence, that I had in hand, of Saint Ambrose, who by 5dansing noteth all histrionicall motions and playings on the stage, in like sort as cHorace saith, 8one was requested to danse Polyphemus, meaning to play his part; and 7Plancus dansed Glaucus, in dUelleius storie; and g stage-players dansed Oedipus, and Hercules, in eMacrobius; and fArnobius speaketh of 9dansing Europa, Leda, Ganymedes. Neither was it hard for you to perceiue that I meant ⟨p. 134⟩thus much, if you had better weighed the branches of my speech, & proofes therto answering, concluded with the note of Arias Montanus, touching not onely dansers, but persons of such shewes & spectacles. Chiefly if you had looked on the autour him selfe, and marked that in the persons of such shewes and spectacles, he compriseth stage-players; as the
16 Pastorē saltaret uti Cyclopa, rogabat: Nil illi larva, aut tragicis opus esse cothurnis.6 Pastorē saltaret vti Cyclopa, rogabat: Nil illi larva, aut tragicis opus esse cothurnis.
5Saltationis lubricae histrionicos motus & scenae deliramenta.
9Si Europa, fi Leda, si Ganymedes fuerit saltatus, aut Dana. compescit motum irarum Jupiter?Si Europa, fi Leda, si Ganymedes fuerit saltatus, aut Dana. cōpescit motum irarum Iuppiter?
1Hujus generis actions ingenuo homine indigniffimas duxerunt, qui de virtute vera, deque corruptis hominū moribus prudenter loq•ti sunt. Ut ille de Nerone: In scena nunquā cantavit Orestes. &c. Juv. sat. 8Hujus generis actiones ingenuo homine indigniffimas duxerunt, qui de virtute vera, deque corruptis hominū moribus prudēter loq•ti sunt. Vt ille de Nerone: In scena nunquā cantavit Orestes. &c. Iuv. sat. 8
An other injury is it, that you term those proofs of mine, a comparison; and (which is more) a comparison without all measure. What hmeasure you did use in the meting out hereof, I can not guess: unless peradventure, because that you had heard that comparisons are odious, you hoped you should make all my proofs odious by naming them comparisons. For I, having noted, against your argument drawn from sports and recreations, that sports by the light of nature, are accounted unseemly, bad, infamous, and so is all stage-dancing; did allege the judgements of Romans, of Philistines, of ancient laws well nigh all, and of reason it self, as testimonies to prove that proposition by; not as comparisons, but as testimonies And therefore in the note of Arias Montanus, I did omit that he saith of 2the law of God condemning stage-plays likewise, because that might go higher then the light of nature. Otherwise, you may be sure that I, who cited him for mens laws, a thing of weaker proof, would not have omitted the law of GOD, his strongest argument. But if I had joined supernatural light to the light of nature, and had produced testimonies of the Scripture also: would you have replied, that, to allege the Scripture, is a comparison without all measure? You must by like reason. And what should stay you from it? All would have espied that it were no comparison. Why more, then the note of Arias Montanus? which yet, when you had cast my allegation of the Romans and Philistines in such a mould, that it could not appear I brought them in as testimonies; you named with them for company a comparison too. Though, seeing you are grieved with my applying of it against your stage-dancing, and that induced you to call it a comparison: me thinks you should have fastened that odious name rather on the proposition ⟨p. 135⟩proved by those testimonies. For the proofs reach not you immediately, they fight not nigh at hand: the proposition doeth; as being the major of that argument, whereof your stage-players make the minor. And the proposition, condemning all stage-dancing, doth give a deadlier wound; nether can it choose but light on your stage-dancing: the proofs might seem to be more easily avoided; or, coming so far off, to raze the skin only. Again, my applying of the proposition to you, by the assumption, would deserve more worthily the name of a comparison:
An other iniurie is it, that you terme those proofes of mine, a comparison; and (which is more) a comparison without all measure. What hmeasure you did vse in the meting out hereof, I can not guesse: vnlesse peradventure, because that you had heard that comparisons are odious, you hoped you should make all my proofes odious by naming them comparisons. For I, having noted, against your argument drawne from sports and recreations, that sports by the light of nature, are accounted vnseemelie, bad, infamous, and so is all stage-dansing; did alleage the iudgements of Romans, of Philistines, of ancient lawes well nigh all, and of reason it selfe, as testimonies to proove that proposition by; not as comparisons, but as testimonies And therefore in the note of Arias Montanus, I did omitt that he saith of 2the law of God condemning stage-playes likewise, because that might goe higher then the light of nature. Otherwise, you may be sure that I, who cited him for mens lawes, a thing of weaker proofe, would not have omitted the lawe of GOD, his strongest argument. But if I had ioyned supernaturall light to the light of nature, and had produced testimonies of the Scripture also: would you have replied, that, to alleage the Scripture, is a comparison without all measure? You must by like reason. And what should stay you from it? All would have espied that it were no comparison. Why more, then the note of Arias Montanus? which yet, when you had cast my allegation of the Romans and Philistines in such a mould, that it could not appeare I brought them in as testimonies; you named with them for company a comparison too. Though, seeing you are greeved with my applying of it against your stage-dansing, and that induced you to call it a cōparison: me thinks you should have fastned that odious name rather on the proposition ⟨p. 135⟩prooved by those testimonies. For the proofes reach not you immediatlie, they fight not nigh at hande: the proposition doeth; as being the maior of that argument, wherof your stage-players make the minor. And the proposition, condemning all stage-dansing, doth giue a deadlyer wound; nether can it choose but light on your stage-dansing: the proofes might seeme to be more easilie avoided; or, comming so farre off, to raze the skinne onely. Againe, my applying of the proposition to you, by the assumption, would deserve more woorthily the name of a comparison:
and the assumption being particular, or singular; the proposition universal; were not this applying of all against some, a comparison without all measure?
and the assumption being particular, or singular; the proposition vniversall; were not this applying of all against some, a comparison without all measure?
The third injurious part offered me in this point, is, that you allege the judgement of Homer and Sir Thomas Eliot, as making for that dancing, which I did reprove. And bringing in the former of them by a 3figure, saying, To omit Homers judgment thereof; him self you call an excellent observer of decorum in all things, and quote for his judgement ithe eight book of his Odyssea. Now, better had it ben••or you to omit him without a figure in deed: sith he, describing there the life of King Alcinous, and of his people, the Phaeacians, sayeth, that 4they took pleasure continually in feasting, and music, and dancing, and bravery of apparel, and hot baths, and chambering: wherein a lively pattern of a wanton, riotous, voluptuous, Epicures life, being set forth by Homer, as kHorace, lAthenaeus, mEustathius may teach you: if I should not have blamed dancing in your plays, because such an excellent observer of decorum saith the Phoeacians used it; then must the nbelly be your players God, because such an excellent observer of decorum saith the Phoeacians served it. Moreover seeing that the Music which the minstrel gave them to their dancing, was a 5song of Mars taken in adultery with Venus Vulcans wife; & you commend in dancing the number of the footing well expressing, answering, and as it were acting the measure and meaning of the Music: you see what good instructions you give men by extolling your excellent observer of decorum in all things. Add thereunto that he, so good an observer of decorum, maketh the ⟨p. 136⟩Phoeacian actors dance with 6others of their own sex, or 7single. Which how much, & why, it is more allowable, then men and women to dance together: I wish you to consider, by weighing, with examples mentioned in oScripture, the judgement of pDivines thereon. So shall you perceive, that Homer in the eight book of his Odyssea, hath no sufficient warrant for Melantho to dance together with Eurymachus, the maids with the wooers; no not though they were maids and Melantho in deed; much less for boys attired like Melantho, & maids, to dance with men upon a stage. The later of your authors you allege directly; and, that learned Knight Sir Thomas Eliot, say you, among other things that he writeth in a book of his, in the praise of dancing, compareth the man treading the measures, to Fortitude, and the woman on his hand, to Temperance.
The third iniurious part offered me in this point, is, that you alleage the iudgement of Homer and Syr Thomas Eliot, as making for that dansing, which I did reproove. And bringing in the former of them by a 3figure, saying, To omit Homers iudgment thereof; him self you call an excellent observer of decorum in all things, and quote for his iudgement ithe eight booke of his Odyssea. Now, better had it ben••or you to omit him without a figure in deede: sith he, describing there the life of King Alcinous, and of his people, the Phaeacians, saieth, that 4they tooke pleasure continually in feasting, and musicke, and daunsing, and braverie of apparell, and hott baths, and chambering: wherein a livelie paterne of a wanton, riotous, voluptuous, Epicures life, being sett foorth by Homer, as kHorace, lAthenaeus, mEustathius may teach you: if I should not haue blamed dansing in your playes, because such an excellent observer of decorum saith the Phoeacians vsed it; then must the nbelly bee your players God, because such an excellent observer of decorū saith the Phoeacians served it. Moreover seeing that the Musicke which the minstrell gave thē to their dansing, was a 5song of Mars taken in adulterie with Venus Vulcans wife; & you commend in dansing the number of the footing wel expressing, answering, and as it were acting the measure and meaning of the Musike: you see what good instructions you give men by extolling your excellent observer of decorum in all things. Adde therevnto that he, so good an observer of decorum, maketh the ⟨p. 136⟩Phoeacian actors danse with 6others of their owne sexe, or 7
3Praeteritio.
iOdyss. […].Odyss. 〈…〉.
4[Greek or Hebrew].〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
kEpist. lib. 1. ep. 2. Alcinoique In cute curanda plus aequo operata juventus.Epist. lib. 1. ep. 2. Alcinoique In cute curanda plus aequo operata iuventus.
You add, that you have seen the book, and you remember he useth this comparison in it. But did you not remember the name of the book too? or was it for some special cause that you concealed it? your words might give a man occasion to think, that he had written a book in the praise of dancing: which that he did, I qfind not. I guess you mean therefore his book entitled the Governor. Wherein rhe praiseth Dancing, and uttereth somewhat like to that avouched by you, and streateth of circumstances (a point you touch also) which being all observed, dancing may be honestly and honourably used: But his speech of Fortitude and Temperance represented by men and maidens in a dance, cometh nothing near your maids and wooers measures, whereto you would stretch it. For, among diverse manners and kinds of dancing used in ancient time, he rehearseth one, wherein (as tLucian saith, translated word for word by him in a manner) 8danced young men and maidens; the man going before, and expressing 9such motions as he might afterward use in war; the maiden following him modestly and shamefastlie; so that it represented a pleasant conjunction of temperance & fortitude. Now those warlike motions were (as vPlato showeth, speaking of the like dance) gestures which resembled, partly the avoiding all sorts of wounds and blows by 1bending aside, by 2going back, by 3leaping up, by 4bowing down; partly ⟨p. 137⟩the enforcing of enemies by shooting 5arrows, and casting 6darts at them, and giving them 7all sorts of wounds. Wherefore this being it, that represented Fortitude in the dance described by Sir Thomas Eliot: far was it from his meaning to make your measures, your sober measures, warlike motions; or compare a wooer treading them, to Fortitude. As far, as to compare a boy doing the same in maidens likeness, to Temperance. Which, if you had otherwise expressed his sense rightly, yet should you have forborne to apply to yours for the observing of decorum, a thing that you commend so in Homer, and your self aim at: sith those maids and wooers, intended both by Homer and you, to be wantons, must use lascivious dances; and the man (if you will needs have such resemblances) be compared rather to Mollitude, or Cowardnes, the woman to Incontinence. Beside that, the praise which that learned Knight giveth unto dancing, he giveth it not simply;
You adde, that you have seene the booke, and you remember hee vseth this comparison in it. But did you not remember the name of the booke too? or was it for some speciall cause that you concealed it? your woordes might giue a man occasion to thinke, that he had written a booke in the praise of dansing: which that he did, I qfinde not. I guesse you meane therefore his booke entituled the Governour. Wherein rhe prayseth Dansing, and vttereth somewhat like to that avouched by you, and streateth of circumstances (a point you touch also) which being all observed, dansing may be honestlie and honorably vsed: But his speech of Fortitude and Temperance represented by men and maidens in a danse, commeth nothing neere your maides and wooers measures, whereto you would stretch it. For, among diverse maners and kindes of dansing vsed in ancient time, he rehearseth one, wherein (as tLucian saith, translated woord for woorde by him in a maner) 8dansed young men and maidens; the man going before, and expressing 9such motions as he might afterward vse in warre; the maiden following him modestly and shamefastlie; so that it represented a pleasant coniunction of temperance & fortitude. Now those warlike motions were (as vPlato sheweth, speaking of the like danse) gestures which resembled, partlie the avoiding all sortes of woundes and blowes by 1bending aside, by 2going backe, by 3leaping vp, by 4bowing downe; partlie ⟨p. 137⟩the enforcing of enimies by shooting 5
(for he saith xsome dances, do corrupt the minds of them that dance, and provoke sin:) but with limitation, to wit, ybeing used and continued in such form, and with such observations and rules, as he specifieth. Whereof the first (to name one for example) is, that, by the courtesy or reverent inclination made at beginning of dancing, the dancers and beholders should mark and remember this to be signified, that at the beginning of all our acts, we should do due honour to God, which is the root of prudence. And in deed if dancers in treading of their measures had such regards and meditations: then not Sir Thomas Eliot only, but the Fathers would praise dancing too. For, when godly Bishops assembled in the Councils of zLaodicea, and aIlarda, decreed that Christians ought not to dance at marriages; when St bChrysostom blamed women for so doing, as being a stain unto their sex; when St cAmbrose cited and averred that of dTully, that such as dance are drunk, or mad; when St eAustin said that it were better to spend the Sabbath day in digging & delving, then in dancing: they meant not to restrain men from marking, and remembering, that at the beginning of all their acts, they should do due honour to God; but they thought that dancers have commonly their minds on things of an other ⟨p. 138⟩quality. Which if your wooers and maidens also had; as (I am persuaded) them selves will not deny, and you seem to have thought by touching so nicely, or rather scarcely touching, the circumstances that you say should be observed in dancing: you abuse the name of that learned Knight, in urging his praise of a good dance that might be, against my dispraise of an ill dance that is. It had been more reason, that when his conceit carried him a little out of the way sometimes, as in that fhe praiseth Lucians stage-dancer, who danced the adultery of Mars and Venus with resembling of 8every act therein, (which I hope, your self would not allow on your stage;) you should have acknowledged that through too great a love of dancing, he liked too well of Lucians treatise: though otherwise he fancied not the author much; as ghe well declareth by noting of *his ribaldry, and his too much scorning; and by saying farther, It were better that a child should never read any part of Lucian, then all Lucian. Or, if the sentence of a Knight, so worthy, had such credit with you;
(for he saith xsome danses, doe corrupt the mindes of them that danse, and provoke sinne:) but with limitation, to weete, ybeing vsed and continued in such forme, and with such observations and rules, as hee specifieth. Whereof the first (to name one for example) is, that, by the curtesie or reverent inclination made at beginning of dansing, the dansers and beholders should marke and remember this to be signified, that at the beginning of all our actes, we should doe due honour to God, which is the roote of prudence. And in deede if dansers in treading of their measures had such regards and meditations: then not Syr Thomas Eliot onely, but the Fathers would praise dansing too. For, when godly Bishops assembled in the Councells of zLaodicea, and aIlarda, decreed that Christians ought not to danse at mariages; when St bChrysostome blamed women for so doeing, as being a staine vnto their sexe; when St cAmbrose cited and averred that of dTullie, that such as danse are drunke, or madde; when St eAustin said that it were better to spend the Sabbat day in digging & delving, then in dansing: they meant not to restraine men from marking, and remembring, that at the beginning of all their actes, they should doe due honour to God; but they thought that dansers haue commonlie their mindes on thinges of an other ⟨p. 138⟩qualitie. Which if your wooers and maidens also had; as (I am perswaded) them selves will not deny, and you seeme to have thought by touching so nicely, or rather scarcelie touching, the circumstāces that you say should be observed in dansing: you abuse the name of that learned Knight, in vrging his prayse of a good danse that might bee, against my disprayse of an ill danse that is. It had bene more reason, that when his conceit caried him a litle out of the way sometimes, as in that f
why did you not consider hhis religious wish, that the names of idols, of Paynim Gods and Goddesses, were not used at this day in ballads and ditties, to the corrupting of many good wits with godless fantasies? For though his reproof do specially touch the most vile idols, Venus, and Bacchus, remembered so in dancing-songs as if the dance were to their honour and memory; a matter most abhorring from Christs religion, and savouring of the ancient error of Paganism: yet as the iScripture, the ground of his reproof, doeth generally condemn such naming of other Gods, semblably he showeth, that, if you had attributed so much to his judgement, you should have eschewed that fault in your tragedy. At least, where the words are uttered as it were in your own person: as kthose of 9the Gods enlightened or beautified by Homers fables are. Perhaps, where players of other mens persons also speak: as lUlysses, and mEumaeus, adoring spirits of 1Devils, or of dead 2men, and 3women, with sacrifices and prayers; nTelemachus 4swearing by Jupiter; oPhilaetius, first 5blaspheming GOD under Jupiter's name, then 6confessing to him that there are Gods in heaven. Chiefly seeing that these speeches are delivered ⟨p. 139⟩by the flower of those persons, by whose parts (you say) no hurt could come to any man: and Sir Thomas Eliot thought that such speeches, savouring of Paganism, might corrupt good wits. But howsoever you shall distinguish your Poem from the ballads and ditties, in which he controlleth this irreligious custom of giving the honour of God to vile idols: your self do bear witness that he commendeth not the dancing of Eurymachus & the rest of your wooers with their Melanthos on the stage. For among the parts of their dissolute behaviour imagined to be done within, you rehearse their 7dancing: and that in the person, not of a carping Momus, but of wise pTelemachus. Now look what was imagined to be done within, the same was expressed on the stage in part, by your own confession: as Telemachus also saith, that in 8their manners at home they kept their wont, Their dancing on the stage then, your self acknowledge, was unhonest dancing. And the dancing praised by Sir Thomas Eliot is honest dancing, you say. Therefore you do manifest wrong unto us both, in alleging him as praising that which I dispraised.
why did you not consider hhis religious wish, that the names of idoles, of Paynim Gods and Goddesses, were not vsed at this day in balades and dities, to the corrupting of many good wittes with godlesse fantasies? For though his reproofe doe specially touch the most vile idoles, Venus, and Bacchus, remembred so in dansing-songs as if the danse were to their honour and memorie; a matter most abhorring from Christes religion, and savouring of the ancient errour of Paganisme: yet as the iScripture, the ground of his reproofe, doeth generallie condemne such naming of other Gods, semblably he sheweth, that, if you had attributed so much to his iudgement, you should haue eschewed that fault in your tragedie. At least, wher the woords are vttered as it were in your owne person: as kthose of 9the Gods enlightned or beautificd by Homers fables are. Perhaps, where players of other mens persons also speake: as lUlysses, and mEumaeus, adoring spirits of 1Devills, or of dead 2men, and 3women, with sacrifices and prayers; nTelemachus 4swearing by Iuppiter; oPhilaetius, first 5blaspheming GOD vnder Iuppiters name, then 6confessing to him that there are Gods in heaven. Chieflie seeing that these speeches are delivered ⟨p. 139⟩
Tullies iudgement: much lesse should they be made well acquainted with Plautus; and lesse yet with Rivales. If they should not be suffered to peruse writings of base & filthy qualitie, nor to cast their eyes, as it were, vpon them: much lesse should they engraue them by heart in their remembrance, expresse them with voice, commend them with action, deliver them with boldnes.
dLimone, apud Dona•ū in vita Teren•.Limone, apud Dona•ū in vita Teren•.
his censure, who, for the generall drift thereof, approoveth them. At least you shall be forced to yeeld by your owne wordes, in as much as having compared our reproofe of your expense in playes to
their speech who saide of the costly ointment powred vpon Christes head, what needed this wast? and being tolde the difference of that fact from yours; you say, that though you knowe there is an infinite difference betwene yours and the action against the which it was hypocritically first vsed: yet you thinke it may also bee applyed against, either the niggardise, or the hypocrisie of any Momus, that shall condemne all expense as cast away, that is sometimes moderatly bestowed vpon honest sports and pastimes. For how can it be chosen but to compare your charges on playes to those on Christ, must needes exceede the compasse of any tolerable resemblance:
are faultie even in youth too. So both mine owne woords, and the autour I cited, doe manifestlie shew, that whē you tooke vpō you to prayse honest dansing, and said you saw no cause in charitie or reason why dansing should simply be condemned, you could not but in reason and charitie see cause, why you should have dealt more simply and honestly, then so calumniouslie to raise a false surmise of me. You know what creature it is, whom the
generalitie of his wordes, exemplified by Nero, maketh plaine.
single. Which how much, & why, it is more allowable, then men and women to danse together: I wish you to consider, by weighing, with examples mentioned in
Divines thereon. So shall you perceiue, that Homer in the eight booke of his Odyssea, hath no sufficient warrant for Melantho to danse together with Eurymachus, the maides with the wooers; no not though they were maides and Melantho in deede; much lesse for boyes attired like Melantho, & maides, to danse with men vpon a stage. The later of your autours you alleage directlie; and, that learned Knight Syr Thomas Eliot, say you, among other things that he writeth in a booke of his, in the prayse of dansing, compareth the man treading the measures, to Fortitude, and the woman on his hande, to Temperance.
all sortes of wounds. Wherfore this being it, that represented Fortitude in the danse described by Syr Thomas Eliot: farre was it frō his meaning to make your measures, your sober measures, warlike motions; or compare a wooer treading them, to Fortitude. As farre, as to compare a boy doeing the same in maidens likenes, to Temperance. Which, if you had otherwise expressed his sense rightlie, yet should you haue forborne to apply to yours for the observing of decorum, a thing that you commend so in Homer, and your selfe aime at: sith those maides and wooers, intended both by Homer and you, to be wantons, must vse lascivious danses; and the man (if you will needes haue such resemblances) bee compared rather to Mollitude, or Cowardnes, the woman to Incontinencie. Beside that, the praise which that learned Knight geveth vnto dansing, he giveth it not simply;
〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
he prayseth Lucians stage-danser, who dansed the adulterie of Mars and Venus with resembling of
every act therein, (which I hope, your selfe would not allow on your stage;) you should haue acknowledged that through too great a love of dansing, he liked too well of Lucians treatise: though otherwise he fansied not the autour much; as
his ribaudrie, and his too much scorning; and by saying farther, It were better that a childe should never read any part of Lucian, then all Lucian. Or, if the sentence of a Knight, so woorthy, had such credit with you;
by the flower of those persons, by whose partes (you say) no hurt could come to any man: and Syr Thomas Eliot thought that such speeches, savouring of Paganisme, might corrupt good wittes. But howsoever you shall distinguish your Poëme from the balades and dities, in which he controlleth this irreligious custome of giving the honour of God to vile idoles: your selfe doe beare witnesse that he commēdeth not the dansing of Eurymachus & the rest of your wooers with their Melanthos on the stage. For among the partes of their dissolute behaviour imagined to be doon within, you rehearse their
Telemachus. Now looke what was imagined to bee doon within, the same was expressed on the stage in part, by your owne confession: as Telemachus also saith, that in
their maners at home they kept their wont, Their dansing on the stage then, your self acknowledge, was vnhonest dansing. And the dansing praysed by Syr Thomas Eliot is honest dansing, you say. Therefore you doe manifest wrong vnto vs both, in alleaging him as praysing that which I dispraysed.
Quos jam reliqui more viventes suo, Tumultuantes, atque saltantes domi.