Unto this master D. Gager replying and desiring Master Rainoldes to forbear, Master Rainoldes did rejoin as followeth.Vnto this maister D. Gager replying and desiring Maister Rainoldes to forbeare, Maister Rainoldes did reioine as followeth.
pp. 29–163154 passagespart 3 of 4
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
But you, to cut the cable of my chiefest anchor, 1the sacred anchor, as they term it, which is, the generality of the law it self, pronouncing all abominable who change their raiment so, betake your self at the last to this desperate refuge, that though the proposition be a general affirmative, All men are abomination who put on woman's apparel, yet in your cases it suffereth exception. I call this refuge desperate, because your own handling thereof doeth seem to argue, that when you came unto it, you did tread on thorns; and felt that you should be pitifully pricked, if you stood long upon it. For when, unto the rules of law which I cited, that every special is suspended when the general is suspended, and he who forbiddeth the general will not have the special practised, you had replied that these rules are to be understood of those generals that absolutely command, and necessarily comprehend their specials sub potestate sua, not those which must endure controlment as it were, & suffer exceptions to restrain their power; you give this reason of it: For general propositions, both in Divinity, and Law, do usually ⟨p. 99⟩admit particular exceptions and limitations, quae derogant generalitati: of which sort this proposition, that we have in hand, is; as there are many mo of like nature, which you could allege (you say) to illustrate these rules, but that they are plain to me, and you are weary already, and have a great way yet to go, and fear that I am stark tired with your tedious discourse. It is recorded by ahistorians that the Parthians used to fly from their enemies, & withal to strike them with arrows shot backward. Whereupon bHorace, affirming that he wrote no verses at all, when he wrote many, doeth compare himself to 2them, who fought most, when they pretended flight. You resemble the Parthians in your 3courageous flying: you will not seem to withdraw yourself, as overcome, but as weary with killing, & having other exploits to do, and taking pity of me. Only you differ from them, in that you shoot no arrows while you are flying away; which else I might be afraid of, as
soldiers were. For your axiom urged in manner of a proof, that general propositions both in Divinity, and Law, do usually admit particular exceptions; proveth just nothing:
But you, to cutt the cable of my cheefest anker, 1the sacred anker, as they terme it, which is, the generalitie of the lawe it selfe, pronouncing all abominable who change their raiment so, betake your selfe at the last to this desperate refuge, that though the proposition be a generall affirmatiue, All men are abomination who put on womans apparell, yet in your cases it suffereth exception. I call this refuge desperat, because your owne handling thereof doeth seeme to argue, that when you came vnto it, you did treade on thornes; and felt that you should bee pitifully pricked, if you stoode long vpon it. For when, vnto the rules of law which I cited, that every speciall is suspended when the generall is suspended, and hee who forbiddeth the generall will not haue the speciall practised, you had replied that these rules are to bee vnderstoode of those generals that absolutely command, and necessarily comprehend their specials sub potestate sua, not those which must endure controlment as it were, & suffer exceptions to restraine their power; you giue this reason of it: For generall propositions, both in Divinitie, and Law, doe vsually ⟨p. 99⟩admitt particular exceptions and limitations, quae derogant generalitati: of which sort this proposition, that we haue in hand, is; as there are many mo of like nature, which you could alleage (you say) to illustrate these rules, but that they are plaine to me, and you are weary already, and haue a great way yet to goe, and feare that I am starke tyred with your tedious discourse. It is recorded by ahistorians that the Parthians vsed to flye frō their enemies, & withal to strike thē with arrows shot backward. Whervpō bHorace, affirming that he wrote no verses at al, when he wrote many, doeth compare himself to 2them, who fought most, when they pretēded flight. You resemble the Parthiās in your 3couragious flying: you will not seeme to withdraw yourselfe, as overcome, but as weary with killing, & having other exploits to doe, and taking pitie of me. Only you differ frō them, in that you shoote no arrowes while you are flying away; which else I might be afraid of, as cHorace saith their 4souldiers were. For your axiome vrged in maner of a proofe, that generall propositions both in Divinitie, and Law, doe vsually admitt particular exceptions; prooveth iust nothing:
1[Greek or Hebrew], Chrys. homil. 4. de Lazaro.〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Chrys. homil. 4. de Lazaro.
aAppian. de bellis Parth. Plutarch. vita Crassi.
bEpistol. lib. 2. epist. 1.
2Ipse ego qui nullos me affirmo scribere versus, Invenior Parthis mendacior.
3Versis animosum equis Parthum. Horat. carm. lib. 1. od 19.
unless peradventure you think that in good Logic this argument will hold: Some general propositions, for the word usually betokeneth some not all; some therefore do admit particular exceptions; Ergo the proposition we have in hand doeth so. A shaft so unshapen without head or feather, that although the steal, I mean the antecedent thereof, be well wrought, & many examples might you allege to illustrate it, if need were: yet your self durst not as much as make a show of nocking, and drawing it, to shoot it of with an Ergo. But I of the contrary side will so encounter this devise of yours, that there shall no more life be left therein, then there was in dAhab the evening after he was wounded. And that by means of this argument. No particular exception is good against a general proposition in Divinity, save only such as Scripture maketh and warranteth. But your asseveration, that men may put on women's raiment in stage-plays, is a particular exception not warranted by Scripture, against the general proposition that all who do so are abominable. Therefore mens wearing of women's raiment on stages can not be good in Divinity. ⟨p. 200⟩The major of which syllogism the Law (to go no further) matched with Divinity by your self in this case of rules and limitations, propositions & exceptions, will approve unto you. For if against a general rule and proposition, as for example sake, that eright ought always to be done, a man of fCaesars mind should by way of exception and limitation say, that it ought in deed, save when a kingdom may be gotten by doing injury and wrong: must we allow this exception? No. And why? Because it is not warranted by any text of Law. Hence is it that gBartolus, and Glossa communis after him, affirming absolutely that where the law distinguisheth not, we may not distinguish, do show that they mean this, not of any one law, but of the whole body, to wit, that 5we may not distinguish upon a law, unless that law by some other law be so distinguished.
vnlesse peradventure you thinke that in good Logicke this argument will hold: Some generall propositions, for the word vsually betokeneth some not all; some therfore doe admit particular exceptions; Ergo the proposition we haue in hande doeth so. A shaft so vnshapen without head or feather, that although the stele, I meane the antecedēt therof, be wel wrought, & many examples might you alleage to illustrate it, if need were: yet your self durst not as much as make a shew of nocking, and drawing it, to shoote it of with an Ergo. But I of the contrary side will so encounter this devise of yours, that there shall no more life be left therein, then there was in dAchab the evening after he was wounded. And that by meanes of this argument. No particular exception is good against a generall proposition in Divinitie, saue onely such as Scripture maketh and warranteth. But your asseveration, that men may put on wemens raiment in stage-playes, is a particular exception not warranted by Scripture, against the generall proposition that all who doe so are abominable. Therefore mens wearing of wemens raiment on stages can not bee good in Divinitie. ⟨p. 200⟩The major of which syllogisme the Lawe (to goe no farder) matched with Divinitie by your selfe in this case of rules and limitations, propositions & exceptions, wil approove vnto you. For if against a generall rule and proposition, as for example sake, that eright ought alwayes to bee done, a man of fCaesars minde should by way of exception and limitation say, that it ought in deede, save when a kingdome may bee gotten by doeing injurie and wrong: must wee allow this exception? No. And why? Because it is not warranted by any text of Lawe. Hence is it that gBartolus, and Glossa communis after him, affirming absolutely that where the law distinguisheth not, we may not distinguish, doe shew that they meane this, not of any one lawe, but of the whole body, to weete, that 5wee may not distinguish vpon a law, vnlesse that law by some other law be so distinguished.
eD. de just. & jure. lib. 10. Cic. de Offic. lib 1.D. de iust. & iure. lib. 10. Cic. de Offic. lib 1.
fCic. de Offi. lib. 3. Sueto. Julio Caes. cap. 30.Cic. de Offi. lib. 3. Sueto. Iulio Caes. cap. 30.
gIn si. 11. D. de in jus vocando.In si. 11. D. de in ius vocando.
5Ubi lex non distinguit, nos non debemus distinguere, nisi illa lex distinguatur per aliam.Vbi lex non distinguit, nos non debemus distinguere, nisi illa lex distinguatur per aliam.
Likewise, in Divinity, if against the doctrine of hdoing righteousness at all times (to press the same example) a woman like iJezebel, or men like the Elders and Governors, whom she wrote to, should say that general rules may admit exceptions, and righteousness is requisite to be done at all times, save when land may be gotten by suborning false witnesses, or a king pleased by shedding innocent blood: this might be very justly called a 6cursed gloss, because the Scripture doeth not teach in any place that it is lawful to do evil for advantage, or gratifying of Princes. Neither could the kApostle rightly praise the Scripture, as serving to furnish a man of God perfectly unto all good works, if a work therein commanded or forbidden generally, as good or naught, were contrariwise abominable or allowable in particulars not declared by Scripture. Which moved S. Austin, among lessons given for the right expounding thereof, to make this one, that ldoubtful points of Scripture ought to be cleared by the Scripture it self, because mall such things as touch faith and manners are set down plainly in the Scripture. True it is therefore that no particular exception, in Divinity, may be admitted against a general proposition, unless the Scripture warrant it: which was the first part of my syllogism. The next, that your assertion touching mens wearing of women's raiment in stage-plays, is a particular exception not warranted ⟨p. 101⟩by Scripture against a general proposition: must needs be granted also. Specially by you: who, having talked thereof with Divines, both many, and excellently learned, perceive that none of them could bring forth any warrant out of Scripture for it. Wherefore, the conclusion, against your stage-play-women, may cause both them and you to dye your faces with that colour, which a nPhilosopher termed well 7the colour of virtue: and I pray God it do.
Likewise, in Divinitie, if against the doctrine of hdoeing righteousnes at all times (to presse the same example) a woman like iIezabel, or men like the Elders and Governours, whom shee wrote to, should say that generall rules may admitt exceptions, and righteousnes is requisit to be done at all times, save when land may bee gotten by suborning false witnesses, or a king pleased by shedding innocent blood: this might be very iustly called a 6cursed glosse, because the Scripture doeth not teach in any place that it is lawfull to doe evill for advantage, or gratifying of Princes. Neither could the kApostle rightly praise the Scripture, as serving to furnish a man of God perfitly vnto all good workes, if a worke therein commanded or forbidden generallie, as good or naught, were contrariwise abominable or allowable in particulars not declared by Scripture. Which mooved S. Austin, among lessons given for the right expounding therof, to make this one, that ldoutfull points of Scripture ought to be cleared by the Scripture it selfe, because mall such thinges as touch faith and maners are sett downe plainly in the Scripture. True it is therefore that no particular exception, in Divinitie, may be admitted against a generall proposition, vnlesse the Scripture warrant it: which was the first parte of my syllogisme. The next, that your assertion touching mens wearing of wemens raiment in stage-playes, is a particular exception not warranted ⟨p. 101⟩by Scripture against a generall proposition: must needes be graunted also. Specially by you: who, having talked therof with Divines, both many, and excellently learned, perceaue that none of them could bring foorth any warrant out of Scripture for it. Wherefore, the conclusion, against your stage-play-wemen, may cause both them and you to dye your faces with that colour, which a nPhilosopher termed well 7the colour of vertue: and I pray God it doe.
So the commandment, that a man shall not put on woman's raiment, being proved to reach unto all in general, even such, as for the saving of honour, wealth, or life, do it, much more whom nothing moveth thereto but a playing humour: it followeth to be sifted whether there be truth and weight in that you add, that your players did not wear women's raiment. A thing avouched by you in like sort almost, as if oAhab being wounded to death with an arrow sticking in his side, should have said, I am not hurt. But this, which, if he had brought reason to persuade men, he might have seemed desirous to be mad with reason, you labour to confirm, saying that you may not in deed be said at all to wear women's apparel, because wearing implieth a custom and a common use of so doing: whereas you do it for an hour, or two, or three, to represent an others person, by one that is openly known to be as he is in deed. For answer whereunto, first, passing over your idle addition concerning the 8end and 9circumstance of your using it; which I term idle, because if men should use it still to whatsoever end, and openly known to be the same they are, as pSporus was, they may indeed be said to wear it, you will grant: but first if it be only for an hour, or two, or three, that you do it; where are your women dressed? by whom? at what time? all at the same moment they come upon the stage? and hath none been dressed at noon, to play at night? and hath it not been towards midnight, ere some plays ended? Next, if it be true, that wearing implieth a custom and a common use of so doing: then belike it may not be said that Nero the Emperor did ever wear any garment. For 1he did never put on any garment twice, as qSuetonius writeth: and therefore had no custom and common ⟨p. 102⟩use of any. Furthermore, suppose that you might not be said to wear women's apparel; yet are you not the nearer to that which you intend: sith the Scripture saith, that a man shall not put on woman's raiment, and you do put it on (I trow) when you play, whether you wear it, or no. Finally, the Prophets 2word, betokening this in the original text, is the very same with that whereby rthe armour of Saul is described to have been put on David. Now if David who put off Sauls armour by and by, within half an hour, a quarter, or less much; yet had it put on, after the phrase of Scripture:
So the commandement, that a man shall not put on womans raiment, being prooved to reach vnto all in generall, even such, as for the saving of honour, wealth, or life, doe it, much more whom nothing moveth thereto but a playing humour: it foloweth to be sifted whether there bee truth and weight in that you adde, that your players did not weare wemens raiment. A thing avouched by you in like sort almost, as if oAchab being wounded to death with an arrow sticking in his side, should haue said, I am not hurt. But this, which, if hee had brought reason to perswade men, he might haue seemed desirous to bee madde with reason, you labour to confirme, saying that you may not in deede be said at all to weare wemens apparell, because wearing implieth a custome and a common vse of so doing: whereas you doe it for an hower, or two, or three, to represent an others person, by one that is openly knowne to be as hee is in deede. For aunswer wherevnto, first, passing over your idle addition concerning the 8ende and 9circumstance of your vsing it; which I terme idle, beecause if men should vse it still to whatsoever ende, and openly knowne to be the same they are, as pSporus was, they may indeede bee said to weare it, you will graunt: but first if it be onely for an hower, or two, or three, that you doe it; where are your wemen dressed? by whom? at what time? all at the same moment they come vpon the stage? and hath none bene dressed at noone, to play at night? and hath it not bene towards midnight, ere some playes ended? Next, if it be true, that wearing implieth a custome and a common vse of so doeing: then belike it may not be said that Nero the Emperour did ever weare any garment. For 1hee did never put on any garment twise, as qSuetonius writeth: and therefore had no custome and common ⟨p. 102⟩vse of any. Furthermore, suppose that you might not bee said to weare wemens apparell; yet are you not the neerer to that which you intend: sith the Scripture saith, that a man shall not put on womans raiment, and you doe put it on (I trow) when you play, whether you weare it, or no. Finally, the Prophets 2
may it not be said, that they, who went in women's raiment certain hours, did that which Scripture speaketh of, English it as you list, put on, or wear such raiment? Alas, 3in how miserable plight is he, saith sTully, who can not deny that, which to confess it is most shameful? I, with a little change of his sentence, must lament your case, who dare not confess that which to deny it is most shameful. For how many hundreds are there of eye-witnesses, that your Euryclea, Melantho, Penelope, Phaedra, Nais, others, did wear women's raiment? Howe many did observe, and with mislike have mentioned, that Penelope's maids did not only wear it, but also sate in it among true women in deed, longer then David wore Sauls armour? neither were more known to them to be men, then Achilles was at first to Deidamia; until they suspected it, seeing them entreated by the wooers to rise and dance upon the stage. I wish there had not been so bad a token to convince you; nor so many beholders to testify thereof: though I am glad withal that they had such mislike of the thing testified. And this commodity by it besides, that I might fear else, least you, who did before deny that men playing on your stage, are stage-players; and do deny here that the players of women's parts wear women's raiment; would at length deny that you had any plays at all; and so accuse me of slandering your friends for being on the stage, when they were in their studies.
may it not be said, that they, who went in wemens raiment certaine howres, did that which Scripture speaketh of, English it as you list, put on, or weare such raiment? Alas, 3in how miserable plight is he, saith sTullie, who can not deny that, which to confesse it is most shamefull? I, with a litle change of his sentence, must lament your case, who dare not confesse that which to deny it is most shamefull. For how many hundreds are there of eye-witnesses, that your Euryclea, Melantho, Penelope, Phoedra, Nais, others, did weare wemens raiment? Howe many did obserue, and with mislike haue mentioned, that Penelopes maides did not onely weare it, but also sate in it among true wemen in deed, longer then David woare Sauls armour? neither were more knowne to them to bee men, then Achilles was at firste to Deidamia; vntill they suspected it, seeing them entreated by the wooers to rise and danse vpon the stage. I wish there had not bene so bad a token to convince you; nor so many beholders to testifie thereof: though I am glad withall that they had such mislike of the thing testified. And this commoditie by it besides, that I might feare else, least you, who did before deny that men playing on your stage, are stage-players; and doe deny here that the players of wemens partes weare wemens raiment; would at length deny that you had any playes at all; and so accuse me of slaundering your friendes for being on the stage, when they were in their studies.
3Quam miserum est id negare nō posse quod sit turpissimum con fiteri?Quam miserum est id negare nō posse quod sit turpissimum cō fiteri?
The third head of reasons, knit up under the title of losing time in tyour speech, but containing loss of better things then time, I declared the strength of, chiefly by this argument. To ⟨p. 103⟩imitate and resemble wantonness, scurrility, impudency, drunkenness, or any other misbehaviour, is a thing unlawful: But sundry misbehaviours were imitated and resembled by Penelope's wooers, her maids, Rivals, mariners, Phaedra, the Nurse, the Nymph, and others in the playing of your tragedies and comedy: The playing therefore of them is to be misliked. Whereagainst you say not much for the major. Only, for as much as I, beside a number both of divine authorities, and humane, avouching it, alleged your own consent too, in that you affirm that 4it beseemeth not men to follow women's manners: you say your meaning was, that it doth not beseem them to follow women's manners in the common course of life, to the perverting of the law of nature, honesty, and comeliness; or for any evil purpose; yet a boy, by way of representation only, may, not indecently, imitate may denlie or womanly demeanour. Which answer though it seemeth to deny your approving of my reproof in part, about young mens imitating of the manners of women: yet the greatest part thereof doeth it approve. For I found most fault with imitating the manners of strumpets and bawds, Melantho, Phaedra, the Nurse: and, I trust, you will not say that the demeanour of such unmaidenly maidens, & unwomanly women, is either maidenly or womanly. But whatsoever you say touching your own sentence, and after your common course of distinguishing interpret it as meant in the common course of life, to the perverting of the law of nature, honesty and comeliness, or for any evil purpose: it sufficeth me, that you durst not apply these distinctions to the Scriptures, Fathers, or foreign writers, by which I confirmed the major of mine argument and you acknowledge it to be truly confirmed. The minor is the hedge, whereat, as the lowest, you were in hope that you might leap over with less difficulty. And in this confidence you ask What proportion there is between those things, which I enlarge in my major; and those things which in particular application against you, are used in my minor?
The third head of reasons, knit vp vnder the title of losing time in tyour speech, but containing losse of better things then time, I declared the strength of, chiefly by this argument. To ⟨p. 103⟩imitate and resemble wantonnes, scurrilitie, impudēcie, drunkennes, or any other misbehaviour, is a thing vnlawfull: But sundry misbehaviours were imitated and resembled by Penelopes wooers, her maides, Rivales, mariners, Phaedra, the Nurse, the Nymph, and others in the playing of your tragedies and comedie: The playing therefore of them is to bee misliked. Whereagainst you say not much for the maior. Onely, for as much as I, beside a number both of divine autorities, and humane, avouching it, alleaged your owne consent too, in that you affirme that 4it beseemeth not men to folow wemens maners: you say your meaning was, that it doth not beseeme them to folow wemens maners in the common course of life, to the perverting of the law of nature, honestie, and comelines; or for any evill purpose; yet a boy, by way of representation onely, may, not indecently, imitate may denlie or womanlie demeanour. Which aunswer though it seemeth to deny your approoving of my reproofe in part, about young mens imitating of the maners of wemen: yet the greatest part thereof doeth it approoue. For I founde most fault with imitating the manners of strumpets and bawdes, Melantho, Phaedra, the Nurse: and, I trust, you will not say that the demeanour of such vnmaidenly maidens, & vnwemenly wemen, is either maidenly or womanly. But whatsoever you say touching your owne sentence, and after your common course of distinguishing interpret it as meant in the common course of life, to the perverting of the law of nature, honestie and comelines, or for any evill purpose: it sufficeth mee, that you durst not apply these distinctions to the Scriptures, Fathers, or forein writers, by which I confirmed the major of mine argument and you acknowledge it to be truly confirmed. The minor is the hedge, whereat, as the lowest, you were in hope that you might leape over with lesse difficultie. And in this confidence you aske What proportion there is betweene those thinges, which I enlarge in my maior; and those thinges which in particular application against you, are vsed in my minor?
To the which question I will make no answer, till you have considered and told me what proportion there is between an Elephant, and Maximinus the Emperor. But the minor of mine argument, whereto I must ⟨p. 104⟩hold you, and not give you leave thus to run at riot upon every wandering conceit of proportions; the minor of mine argument, I say, is most certain, & true, in every branch thereof. Though neither is your cunning and art, by the way, to be passed over, that whereas I having in general disclosed the hurt of amatory dancing, did note in particular your wooers dancing with their minions: you reply that they danced only two solemn measures, without any lighter galliard; and hereupon you ask me, What Herod could be inflamed? What Propertius ravished? what flame of lust kindled thereby in mens hearts? what wounds of love imprinted? whose senses could be moved, or affections delighted more then ought to be, or may honestly be? What enemies of chastity made by this sight? what strong or constant heart vanquished; nay, what reed shaken thereby? What so much as flax or tow set on fire? Great cry, and little wool: as who say that I had applied all these things to dancing alone; and not diverse of them to amatory kissing, amatory embracing, and amatory pangs expressed in most effectual sort, together with it. Or, as who say farther, that none could be touched with any spark of lust by seeing the supposed gentlewomen dance so small a time, so gravely with gallant lusty younkers; because you, a marvellous indifferent judge, & well seen in things of this quality, do pronounce that none could. vLactantius, controlling a sentence, wherein xTully had magnified the force of fortune, and given edge thereto with an interrogation, 5Who knoweth not that Fortune is of great force both ways, either to prosperity, or to adversity? forsooth, sayeth he, I know it not. In like sort they whose judgement herein is so much sounder, less dazzled with affection and prejudice, then yours, as in matters touching God and true Religion, Lactantius was then Tullies, may answer your demands, that many Herods might be inflamed, many a Propertius ravished thereby.
To the which question I will make no aunswer, till you haue considered and tolde me what proportion there is betwene an Elephant, and Maximinus the Emperour. But the minor of mine argument, whereto I must ⟨p. 104⟩holde you, and not giue you leaue thus to runne at riott vpon every wandring conceit of proportions; the minor of mine argument, I say, is most certaine, & true, in every branch thereof. Though neither is your cunning and arte, by the way, to bee passed over, that wheras I having in generall disclosed the hurt of amatorie dansing, did note in particular your wooers dansing with their minions: you reply that they dansed onely two solemne measures, without any lighter galliard; and herevpon you aske me, What Herod could be inflamed? What Propertius ravished? what flame of lust kindled thereby in mens heartes? what wounds of loue imprinted? whose senses could bee moved, or affections delited more then ought to bee, or may honestly bee? What enemies of chastitie made by this sight? what strong or constant heart vanquished; nay, what reede shaken thereby? What so much as flaxe or towe sett on fire? Great crye, and litle wooll: as who say that I had applied all these things to dansing alone; and not diverse of them to amatorie kissing, amatorie embracing, and amatorie pangs expressed in most effectuall sort, togither with it. Or, as who saye farther, that none could be touched with anie sparke of lust by seeing the supposed gentlewemen danse so small a time, so grauelie with galant lustie yoonkers; because you, a marvellous indifferent iudge, & well seene in thinges of this qualitie, doe pronounce that none could. vLactantius, controlling a sentence, wherein xTullie had magnified the force of fortune, and giuen edge thereto with an interrogatiō, 5Who knoweth not that Fortune is of great force both wayes, either to prosperitie, or to adversitie? forsooth, saieth hee, I know it not. In like sort they whose iudgement herein is so much sounder, lesse daseled with affection and preiudice, then yours, as in matters touching God and true Religion, Lactantius was then Tullies, may answer your demaundes, that manie Herods might be inflamed, many a Propertius ravished thereby.
For your partiality and weakness of sight doeth bewray it self, in that, where I had noted how your new Nymph, by lively expressing of amorous pangs, brought fuel enough to heat & melt a hart of ice or snow: you reply, that she hath been worse reported of to me a great deal, then she did deserve, as I and the ⟨p. 105⟩world shall one day see. Now she was so reported of to me by Lactantius, I mean, a man whose word I offer you no wrong if I believe before yours; a man, that deserveth to be as well esteemed of, as he, for sundry causes, & for some, better, a man, who did report it, not of surmise, but of knowledge; not of hear-say, but of sight; not of that which might be, but which had happened in senses and affections moved and tickled with it. And the thing which the world and I should one day see, whereby your meaning showed in the words ensuing, is, that she did proffer honest, lawful, virtuous, marriage-meaning love, as 6her speech committed now to print declareth; doeth not prove that he reported worse a great deal to me of her expressing those pangs, then she deserved. For that very 7action, which she did insinuate her self to be 8enraged & 9burn with desire of, is yhonest, and lawful, belonging unto virtuous and marriage-meaning love. Yet if one should say, that the open doing of it, like a zCynic, or using of sweet words and gestures tending to it, like aBacchus and Ariadne, can not shake a reed, much less surprise or wound a strong and constant heart: he might seem unworthy to be talked withal by men of ingenuous modesty and judgement. Wherefore sith the proffer of nothing else but honest and marriage-meaning love, made in words only by a hansom boy apparelled like a woman did ravish a Propertius, and inflame an Herod; notwithstanding you thought that it could not possibly work any such effect, as I and the world also should perceive: your thick interrogations wherewith you come upon me, as with so many foins and pricks of a sword, to make me yield that youths attired in women's raiment, & dancing a few solemn measures like bSempronia, can not set flax on fire; in show they do brave it, as if no way but one; in deed they draw not so much blood, as a needle would.
For your partialitie and weaknes of sight doeth bewray it selfe, in that, where I had noted how your new Nymph, by liuely expressing of amorous panges, brought fewell enough to heate & melt a hart of yce or snow: you reply, that shee hath bene woorse reported of to me a great deale, then shee did deserue, as I and the ⟨p. 105⟩world shall one day see. Now shee was so reported of to mee by Lactantius, I meane, a man whose woord I offer you no wrong if I beleeue before yours; a man, that deserueth to be as well esteemed of, as he, for sundrie causes, & for some, better, a man, who did report it, not of surmise, but of knowledge; not of heare-say, but of sight; not of that which might be, but which had hapned in senses and affections mooved and tickled with it. And the thing which the world and I should one day see, whereby your meaning shewed in the wordes ensuing, is, that shee did profer honest, lawfull, vertuous, mariage-meaning love, as 6her speech committed now to print declareth; doeth not proove that he reported worse a great deale to me of her expressing those panges, then shee deserved. For that very 7action, which shee did insinuate her selfe to be 8enraged & 9burne with desire of, is yhonest, and lawfull, belonging vnto vertuous and mariage-meaning loue. Yet if one should say, that the open dooing of it, like a zCynicke, or vsing of sweete woordes and gestures tending to it, like aBacchus and Ariadne, can not shake a reed, much lesse surprise or wound a strong and constant heart: hee might seeme vnwoorthie to be talked withall by men of ingenuous modestie and iudgement. Wherefore sith the profer of nothing else but honest and mariage-meaning love, made in woords only by a hansom boy apparelled like a woman did ravish a Propertius, and inflame an Herode; notwithstanding you thought that it could not possibly worke anie such effect, as I and the world also should perceive: your thicke interrogations wherewith you come vpon mee, as with so manie foines and prickes of a sword, to make me yeelde that youthes attired in wemens raiment, & dansing a few solemne measures like
6Panniculus Hippolyto See necae tragaediae assutus Append Meleagr.Panniculus Hippolyto Se necae tragaediae assutus Append Meleagr.
7Jugalem pariter ineamus torum Libamina ad te prima seruatae affero Famae, & juventae: tu pariter ad me tua Affer; & uterque carpas utriusque hanc rosam Primā integramque.Iugalem pariter ineamus torum Libamina ad te prima seruatae affero Famae, & iuventae: tu pariter ad me tua Affer; & vterque carpas vtriusque hanc rosam Primā integramque.
8Miserere amorem Naidis fassae gravem, Nunquamque fassurae, nisi hanc furor ultimus vocem expulisset.Miserere amorem Naidis fassae gravem, Nunquamque fassurae, nisi hanc furor vltimus vocem expulisset.
But be it as be may, for the forcible operation and working of the poison, which neither I affirmed to be altogether so quick in every branch of the minor, concerning your players, as in some alleged for proof of the major; nor do you rightly judge of, who acknowledging it to be as poison in the major for bad effects of such plays, would have it ⟨p. 106⟩treacle in the minor for good effects of yours: the minor of mine argument, as I said, is certain and true in every branch thereof. One alone, amongst all that I specified, you take exception at; which is the Nymphs part. And therein I mistook a circumstance, I grant. How be it I must tell you withal that I mistook it so, and such a circumstance, that the righting of it doth not only not diminish the certainty and truth of my minor, but rather much increaseth it. For when the grave and godly man, whom I spake of, had showed me his mislike of amorousness and drunkenness expressed in your plays; and namely, for the former, had noted the mischief of the representing those pangs so effectually by the Nymph, a new part inserted into Seneca: I not being further inquisitive thereof, did think that you supposing the person of a bawd was not set forth lively and skilfully enough by Seneca in Phaedra's Nurse, had brought in a Nymph to persuade Hippolytus that which the Nurse could not; and thereupon I mentioned the Nurses and the Nymphs bawdry. Now, by your publishing of that which you inserted, I perceive you added a new bawd in deed, but a man bawd, Pandarus; and gave the Nymph an other part almost as shameful: so that, I confess, I was, through some negligence, doubly overseen; first, in naming Titius, or rather Titia, for Seius; again, in imagining one naughty part added by you unto Seneca, whereas you added two. For, whatsoever you say of your Nymphs wooing and proffer to Hippolytus: S. cAmbrose, on the dScripture touching Rebecca's spousals, saith that a woman should give unto her parents the choice of her husband, 1least she be reputed too malapert and wanton, if she take upon her to make her own choice: 2for she must rather seem to be desired by a man, then to desire a man her self. And you should have noted, that eErasmus words, alleged by your self to justify the Nymphs action, are, Si res honesta est matrimonium, & procum agere honestum est.
But be it as be may, for the forcible operation and working of the poyson, which neither I affirmed to be altogether so quicke in every branch of the minor, concerning your players, as in some alleadged for proofe of the maior; nor doe you rightlie iudge of, who acknowledging it to be as poyson in the major for bad effectes of such playes, would haue it ⟨p. 106⟩triacle in the minor for good effectes of yours: the minor of mine argument, as I saide, is certaine and true in euery braunch thereof. One alone, amongst all that I specified, you take exception at; which is the Nymphes part. And therein I mistooke a circumstance, I graunt. How be it I must tell you withall that I mistooke it so, and such a circumstance, that the righting of it doth not onely not diminish the certaintie and truth of my minor, but rather much encreaseth it. For when the graue and godly man, whom I spake of, had shewed me his mislike of amorousnes and drunkēnes expressed in your playes; and namely, for the former, had noted the mischief of the representing those pangs so effectually by the Nymph, a new part inserted into Seneca: I not being farder inquisitiue thereof, did thinke that you supposing the person of a bawde was not set foorth lively and skilfully enough by Seneca in Phaedras Nurse, had brought in a Nymph to perswade Hippolytus that which the Nurse could not; and therevpon I mentioned the Nurses and the Nymphes bawderie. Nowe, by your publishing of that which you inserted, I perceave you added a new bawd in deed, but a man bawde, Pandarus; and gaue the Nymph an other part almost as shamefull: so that, I confesse, I was, through some negligence, doubly overseene; first, in naming Titius, or rather Titia, for Seius; againe, in imagining one naughty part added by you vnto Seneca, whereas you added two. For, whatsoever you say of your Nymphes wooing and profer to Hippolytus: S. cAmbrose, on the dScripture touching Rebeccas spousals, saith that a woman should giue vnto her parents the choise of her husband, 1least shee bee reputed too malapert and wanton, if she take vpon her to make her owne choise: 2for shee must rather seeme to be desired by a man, then to desire a man her selfe. And you should haue noted, that eErasmus words, alleaged by your selfe to iustifie the Nymphes action, are, Si res honesta est matrimonium, & procum agere honestum est.
Procum agere, he saith, of the masculine gender; not of the feminine, Procam. A thing, from allowing whereof he was so far; much more from terming them tetrica ingenia & ab omnibus Gratiis aliena, who do disallow it; though you, not contented ⟨p. 107⟩to adjoin this also, enlarge it with comparison of your speech to Momus; as if Erasmus likewise blamed us for 3accounting all matters touching love, and pleasant mirth, unchaste, jump as your self do for 4calling that unhonest and wanton, which is merry and light: but Erasmus was so far from allowing a maid to be a wooer, or wooesse, what shall I name it? that in express words fhe disalloweth it as 5unseemly. By the judgment therefore of your own witness it was a misbehaviour in Nais to be wooing. What? And was it not a misbehaviour also in her to be railing? to say unto Hippolytus, that his mother was a 6tiger, his father was a 7bull, him self a 8proud, a cruel, a barbarous savage man? to ban him? to curse him? to wish him the most horrible kind of death that might be? and all because he would not leave his lawful liberty to satisfy her lust? Or would your Erasmus have reproved me as 9rigorous, to say no more, for blaming this in a maiden; and him self have liked it, gwho misliked in men that they feign and spread lewd reports of such as yield not to their wooing? Truly, for mine own part, albeit Nais had not transgressed any duty with so foul language, and might without impeachment of maidenly modesty, have sued to be Hippolytus bedfellow: yet should I have thought it a thing unbeseeming a youth of tender years to be inured, and taught, how he may by amorous speeches, looks, and gestures, woo for a husband, or a wife. But seeing she did that which can not be cleared of wantonness and scurrility: my minor (notwithstanding the circumstance I mistook) is most true and certain for the branch concerning her. Yea, it is as certain and true, with alteration of the name only, even for the very crime too wherewith I charged her in stead of her brother Pandarus: that is to say, for bawdry. Which word why you should censure by terming it the broad name of bawdry, I know not: sith the Latin words, leno, and lena, have none in our English correspondent to them (for ought that I know) but a bawd; and lenocinium, bawdry.
Procum agere, hee saith, of the masculine gender; not of the feminine, Procam. A thing, from allowing whereof hee was so farre; much more from terming them tetrica ingenia & ab omnibus Gratiis aliena, who doe disallow it; though you, not contented ⟨p. 107⟩to adioyne this also, enlarge it with comparison of your speech to Momus; as if Erasmus likewise blamed vs for 3accounting all matters touching love, and pleasant mirth, vnchast, iumpe as your selfe doe for 4calling that vnhonest and wanton, which is merry and light: but Erasmus was so farre from allowing a maide to bee a wooer, or wooesse, what shall I name it? that in expresse wordes fhe disalloweth it as 5vnseemely. By the iudgment therefore of your owne witnesse it was a misbehauiour in Nais to be wooing. What? And was it not a misbehaviour also in her to be railing? to say vnto Hippolytus, that his mother was a 6tiger, his father was a 7bull, him selfe a 8proud, a cruell, a barbarous savage man? to banne him? to curse him? to wishe him the most horrible kind of death that might be? and all because he would not leave his lawfull libertie to satisfie her lust? Or would your Erasmus haue reprooved me as 9rigorous, to say no more, for blaming this in a maiden; and him selfe haue liked it, gwho misliked in men that they faine and spread lewde reportes of such as yeeld not to their wooing? Truelie, for mine owne part, albeit Nais had not transgressed anie dutie with so fowle language, and might without impeachment of maidenly modestie, haue sued to be Hippolytus bedfellow: yet should I haue thought it a thing vnbeseeming a youth of tender yeares to be inured, and taught, how hee may by amorous speeches, lookes, and gestures, wooe for a husband, or a wife. But seeing she did that which can not be cleered of wantonnes and scurrilitie: my minor (notwithstanding the circumstance I mistook) is most true and certame for the branch concerning her. Yea, it is as certaine and true, with alteration of the name only, even for the very crime too wherewith I charged her in steede of her brother Pandarus: that is to say, for bawderie. Which worde why you should censure by terming it the brode name of bawderie, I know not: sith the Latin wordes, leno, and lena, haue none in our English correspondent to them (for ought that I know) but a bawde; and lenocinium, bawderie.
3Quibus impudicum videtur quicquid amicu• est ac festirū.Quibus impudicum videtur quicquid amicu• est ac festirū.
4Qui turpe, laetum, ludicrum, petulans vocat.
fChristiani matrimon. institut.
5Turpe non est juvenibus ambire sponsam, quod vir ginibus sit indecorum.
How cometh it to pass then that my use of the English name should be faulty: where hyou do use the iLatin without fault, I trust, and that in the person of modest, chaste, Hippolytus? The truth is ⟨p. 108⟩that I should have spoken broader, so to term it, and used words of greater eagerness and sharpness. For his practise is bawdry, who enticeth any to single fornication. What is it farther to adultery? What farther yet, to incest? And to do this simply, as incestuous iAmnon did, were abominable. What, to do it in such sort, as the 2Nurse in Seneca? but chiefly as your 3Pandarus? My speech was too mincing, when I named bawdry. If I had termed it most filthy beastly bawdry, my words had been broader, though not broad enough yet. But to return to mine argument, the major and the minor being thus confirmed, the conclusion followeth necessarily, and should have been granted by you in my judgement.
How commeth it to passe then that my vse of the English name should be faultie: where hyou doe vse the iLatin without fault, I trust, and that in the person of modest, chast, Hippolytus? The truth is ⟨p. 108⟩that I should haue spoken broder, so to terme it, and vsed wordes of greater eagernes and sharpnes. For his practise is bawderie, who entiseth any to single fornication. What is it farther to adulterie? What farther yet, to incest? And to doe this simply, as incestuous iAmnon did, were abominable. What, to doe it in such sort, as the 2Nurse in Seneca? but chiefly as your 3Pandarus? My speech was too minsing, when I named bawderie. If I had termed it most filthy beastly bawderie, my wordes had bene broder, though not brode enough yet. But to returne to mine argument, the maior and the minor beeing thus confirmed, the conclusion foloweth necessarily, and should haue bene graunted by you in my iudgement.
3Amoris expers forma cui prodest nitens? &, Nata fit cervo patri conjux: & utero dama quein peperit, subit. Quanquam feruntur esse quoque gentes, ubi Et nata patri nubit, & nato parens; Et juncta crescit vinculo pietas duplo. Panic. assut. Sen. act. 2.Amoris expers forma cui prodest nitens? &, Nata fit cervo patri conjux: & vtero dama quein peperit, subit. Quanquam feruntur esse quoque gentes, vbi Et nata patri nubit, & nato parens; Et juncta crescit vinculo pietas duplo. Pannic. assut. Sen. act. 2.
So many heads, so many wits: your fancy lead you an other way. And therefore, according to the young Scholars axiom, that always when both the premises are true, the conclusion must be denied: You deny that the playing of your tragedies and comedy is to be misliked and censured as unlawful. To the fine persuading whereof you take advantage by somewhat that I said: and the point of my sword, which pierceth through the heart of your defence of plays, you strive (though in vain, for want of strength) to draw out, and turn against my self. For, because I amplified the unlawfulness of the thing by the inconvenience and hurt which it breedeth, principally to the actors, in whom the earnest care of lively representing the lewd demeanour of bad persons doeth work a great impression of waxing like unto them; next, to the spectators, whose manners are corrupted by seeing and hearing such matters so expressed: you encounter me herein with two disputes; one, that neither the spectators of your plays, nor the actors, could receive any hurt thereby; an other, that no evil affections could be stirred up thereby, but rather good. Which points it is a world to see how you struggle to prove by shows of reason; and it will not fadge. Besides, were they proved: my conclusion standeth nevertheless entire, because neither of them doeth touch a hear of the premises. The shows of reason first, whereby you would prove that neither the spectators, nor actors could receive any hurt by your plays, are these; that for your penning ⟨p. 109⟩you are base and mean, as I see, (so you tell me) and specially for womanly behaviour you were so careless, that when one of your actors should have made curtsy like a woman, he made a leg like a man; and your spectators could not greatly charge your actors with any such diligence in meditation and care to imprint any passions. Of which three assertions the last is already disproved in part by Nais: and your self, qualifying it with the word greatly, declare that in your conscience your actors might be charged with earnest meditation and care to imprint passions, though not greatly charged. The middest, of one actor forgetting his woman hood, doeth no more argue that you were earelesse for womanly behaviour, and for other also, but specially for womanly:
So many heads, so many wittes: your fansie lead you an other way. And therefore, according to the young Scholers axiome, that alwayes when both the praemisses are true, the conclusion must be denied: You deny that the playing of your tragedies and comedie is to bee misliked and censured as vnlawfull. To the fine perswading whereof you take advantage by somewhat that I said: and the point of my sworde, which pearceth through the heart of your defense of playes, you striue (though in vaine, for want of strength) to draw out, and turne against my selfe. For, because I amplified the vnlawfulnes of the thing by the inconvenience and hurt which it breedeth, principally to the actors, in whom the earnest care of liuely representing the lewde demeanour of bad persons doeth worke a great impression of waxing like vnto them; next, to the spectators, whose maners are corrupted by seeing and hearing such matters so expressed: you encounter mee herein with two disputes; one, that neither the spectators of your playes, nor the actors, could receve any hurt thereby; an other, that no evill affections could bee stirred vp thereby, but rather good. Which points it is a worlde to see how you struggle to proove by shewes of reason; and it will not fadge. Besides, were they prooved: my conclusion standeth neverthelesse entier, because neither of them doeth touch a heare of the praemisses. The shewes of reason firste, wherby you would proove that neither the spectators, nor actors could receue any hurt by your playes, are these; that for your penning ⟨p. 109⟩you are base and meane, as I see, (so you tell mee) and specially for womanly behaviour you were so carelesse, that when one of your actors should haue made courtsie like a woman, hee made a legge like a man; and your spectators could not greatly charge your actors with any such diligence in meditation and care to imprint any passions. Of which three assertions the last is already disprooved in part by Nais: and your selfe, qualifying it with the worde greatly, declare that in your conscience your actors might bee charged with earnest meditation and care to imprint passions, though not greatly charged. The middest, of one actor forgetting his woman hoode, doeth no more argue that you were earelesse for womanly behaviour, and for other also, but specially for womanly:
then the oversight of a kGreek stage-player, who, when he said, O God, pointed to the ground; when he said, O earth, cast up his hand to heaven ward, doeth argue that the Romans, Roscius, Aesopus, but specially the Greeks, were careless for seemly gesture on the stage. The foremost, like the rest; and worthy to be their ringleader for untruth, or trifling. For neither do I see, that in your penning you are base and mean, if you speak of all, and comprise love-speeches too, as 4that of Nais: neither if you were so, is it any proof that you could not hurt; for base and mean writers may utter evil speeches, & levil speeches corrupt good manners: and, beside your own, you played Seneca too, whose penning neither mScaliger, nor nLipsius, nor oyour self, do vilify as base; so that the very stile of somewhat, which you played, might work strong impressions by your own verdict. Wherefore when of those three assertions you infer, that neither the spectators, nor actors, could receive any hurt by your plays: you dispute in like sort, as if to control pSuetonius and qTacitus, who say, that, when Rome was burnt in Neros time, some did of purpose fire it, one should reason thus: The stuff which those incendiaries did use, was 5tow and firebrands scarce kindled, as you see: and specially for certain of them, who brought that stuff, they were so careless of setting fire on houses, that 6they fell to pillage, carrying things away out of houses unburnt; & such as they robbed and spoiled with sword and fire could not greatly ⟨p. 110⟩charge them with any such diligence in pains and care to burn the city: and so neither the city suffered hurt by them, nor they did any hurt. Strange, that Suetonius and Tacitus should say the contrary. But sometimes good Homer him self will fall a slumbering. Now as you have proved thus, that neither actors nor spectators could receive hurt by your plays: semblably you prove that no evil affections could be stirred up thereby, but rather good. For in Ulysse reduce (say you) who did not love tho fidelity of Eumaeus; and Philaetius, towards their master; and hate the contrary in Melanthius? who was not moved to compassion to see Ulysses, a great Lord, driven so hardly, as that he was fain to be a beggar in his own house? who did not wish him well, and all ill to the wooers;
then the oversight of a kGreeke stage-player, who, when he said, O God, pointed to the ground; when he said, O earth, cast vp his hand to heaven ward, doeth argue that the Romans, Roscius, Aesopus, but specially the Greekes, were carelesse for seemely gesture on the stage. The formost, like the rest; and worthy to bee their ringleader for vntruth, or trifling. For neither doe I see, that in your penning you are base and meane, if you speake of all, and comprise loue-speeches too, as 4that of Nais: neither if you were so, is it any proofe that you could not hurt; for base and meane writers may vtter evill speeches, & levill speeches corrupt good maners: and, beside your owne, you played Seneca too, whose penning neither mScaliger, nor nLipsius, nor oyour selfe, doe vilifie as base; so that the very stile of somewhat, which you played, might worke strong impressions by your own verdict. Wherefore when of those three assertions you inferre, that neither the spectators, nor actors, could receaue any hurt by your playes: you dispute in like sort, as if to controll pSuetonius and qTacitus, who say, that, when Rome was burnt in Neros time, some did of purpose fire it, one should reason thus: The stuffe which those incendiaries did vse, was 5towe and firebrands scarse kindled, as you see: and specially for certaine of them, who brought that stuffe, they were so carelesse of setting fire on houses, that 6they fell to pillage, carying things away out of houses vnburnt; & such as they robbed and spoyled with sword and fire could not greatly ⟨p. 110⟩charge them with any such diligence in paines and care to burne the citie: and so neither the citie suffred hurt by them, nor they did any hurt. Strange, that Suetonius and Tacitus should say the contrarie. But sometimes good Homer him selfe will fall a slumbering. Now as you haue prooved thus, that neither actors nor spectators could receiue hurt by your playes: semblably you proove that no evill affections could be stirred vp therby, but rather good. For in Ulysse reduce (say you) who did not love tho fidelitie of Eumaeus; and Philaetius, towardes their maister; and hate the contrary in Melanthius? who was not mooved to compassion to see Ulysses, a great Lord, driven so hardly, as that hee was faine to be a begger in his owne house? who did not wish him well, and all ill to the wooers;
kPhilostrat. vit. sophistar. in Polem:
4Hippolyte nescis quod fugis vitae bonum: Hippolyte, nescis. Sed uror intus. Libamin• prima. Rosam primam. Mutua uramur face. O quam juvaret igne tam pulchro mori! & quae sequunturHippolyte nescis quod fugis vitae bonum: Hippolyte, nescis. Sed vror intus. Libamin• prima. Rosam primam. Mutua vramur face. O quam juvaret igne tam pulchro mori! & quae sequuntur
and think them worthily slain for their bloody purpose against Telemachus, and other dissolute behaviour, not so much expressed on the stage, as imagined to be done within? And so you go forward with a troupe of questions, urging it as certain that all your spectators did admire the constancy of Penelope, and dispraise the lightness and bad nature of Melantho, and think her justly hanged for it; all did praise the patience, wisdom and secrecy of Ulysses, & Telemachus his son; all were glad to see Ulysses restored to his wife; and goods, and his mortal enemies overthrown and punished: again, that in Rivates, all might be delighted to see the fond behaviour of country-wooing, expressed by civill men, or the vanity of a bragging soldier; all might detest drunkenness by seeing the deformity of drunken mariners actions: that in Hippolytus likewise all young men did wish them selves to be as chaste as Hippolytus was; all the spectators detested the love of Phaedra; approved the grave counsel of the Nurse to her in secret; none of them could be the worse for her wooing Hippolytus in so general terms; all did wish that Theseus had not been so credulous; and were sorry for the cruel death of Hippolytus. The most of which things you affirm they did, not meaning to pronounce of their secret thoughts, but that your plays were naturally to work these effects: as appeareth by that in some of the branches you say that the spectators might do so, or so; yea, could not be the worse. And the same appeareth farther, by that you add, that these & ⟨p. 111⟩such like passions were, or might be moved in your plays, without hurt, at the least, to any man: as in other tragedies, who doeth not hate (say you) the fury of Medea; the revenge of Atreus; the treason of Clytaemnestra, and Aegisthus; and the cruelty of Nero? Contrariwise who doeth not pity the rage, and death of Hercules; the calamity of Hecuba and her children; the infortunat valour of Oedipus; the murder of Agamemnon; the banishment of Octavia; and such like? You take your self therefore hereby to have proved that no evil affections could be stirred up by your plays in any: at the least, no evil; and many good perhaps.
and thinke them woorthily slaine for their bloody purpose against Telemachus, and other dissolute behaviour, not so much expressed on the stage, as imagined to bee done within? And so you goe forward with a troupe of questions, urging it as certaine that all your spectators did admire the constancie of Penelope, and dispraise the lightnes and bad nature of Melantho, and thinke her iustlie hanged for it; all did prayse the patience, wisedome and secrecie of Ulysses, & Telemachus his sonne; all were glad to see Vlysses restored to his wife; and goods, and his mortall enimies ouerthrowne and punished: againe, that in Rivates, all might be delited to see the fond behaviour of country-wooing, expressed by civill men, or the vanitie of a bragging souldier; all might detest drunkennes by seeing the deformitie of drunken mariners actions: that in Hippolytus likewise all yong men did wish them selues to be as chast as Hippolytus was; all the spectators detested the love of Phoedra; approved the grave coūsell of the Nurse to her in secret; none of them could be the woorse for her wooing Hippolytus in so generall termes; all did wish that Theseus had not bene so credulous; and were sory for the cruell death of Hippolytus. The most of which things you affirme they did, not meaning to pronounce of their secret thoughts, but that your playes were naturallie to woorke these effectes: as appeareth by that in some of the branches you say that the spectators might doe so, or so; yea, could not be the worse. And the same appeareth farther, by that you adde, that these & ⟨p. 111⟩such like passions were, or might be mooved in your playes, without hurt, at the least, to any man: as in other tragedies, who doeth not hate (say you) the furie of Medea; the revenge of Atreus; the treason of Clytaemnestra, and Aegysthus; and the crueltie of Nero? Contrariwise who doeth not pitie the rage, and death of Hercules; the calamitie of Hecuba and her children; the infortunat valour of Oedipus; the murder of Agamemnon; the banishment of Octavia; and such like? You take your selfe therefore hereby to haue prooved that no evill affections could bee stirred vp by your playes in any: at the least, no evill; and many good perhaps.
But why in the particular point touching Hippolytus, in which it most behooved you (because of your new piece of Pandarus and Nais) to show that good affections might be stirred up by his part in all, and no evil in any: Why demanded you, what young man did not wish himself to be as chaste, as Hippolytus was, if he were not so already? Why asked you not generally, as in the rest, who did not? was it because you thought, that some elder men did not wish them selves as chaste, as he was: but were stirred up by Phaedra's pangs, and Pandarus reasons, to wish the like motion had been made to them? Or, that any maidens were upon the stage, who could have been contented to become unchaste in yielding to Hippolytus that which he would not grant to Nais 7chastely? As for the young men of our University who were present at it, I am heartily glad if they were so minded: and do reap my self the greater comfort of it, the more rI have commended his example to them. But if they wished so, when they saw your play: it came more of somewhat which they brought thither, then which they found there. For, by your instruction, the death of Hippolytus should have served to teach them, that they must never deny unto a Nais, or Phaedra, such requests: as syour self tell them, on speech concerning women; Quas ne quis unquam spernere dehinc audeat, Hippolytus ecce horribile documentum dedit; Impunè temnat nemo terrestres Deas. And what if all, who were present, not the young men only, did admire the constancy of Penelope? Could no evil affection be therefore stirred in any by seeing a boy play so chaste a part? ⟨p. 112⟩Happy would Lucretia then have thought her self. For she was not inferior in chastity to Penelope: and when Tarquin saw her, he saw 8her employed as a tmost virtuous woman. Yet, for all the wonderment he had of her virtue: he was more inflamed with love of her beauty. Yea, 9the very sight of her chaste behaviour stirred up his wicked lust. Moreover, if Ulysses begging in his own house, did move all the spectators to have compassion of him, and thereby grew no hurt to them: yet into the actor might there grow some hurt by acquainting him self with hypocritical feigning of vlies, xhunger, beggary, ywrath, and shedding of blood.
But why in the particular point touching Hippolytus, in which it most behooved you (because of your new peece of Pandarus and Nais) to shewe that good affections might be stirred vp by his part in all, and no evill in any: Why demanded you, what young man did not wish himselfe to bee as chast, as Hippolytus was, if he were not so already? Why asked you not generally, as in the rest, who did not? was it because you thought, that some elder men did not wish them selves as chast, as hee was: but were stirred vp by Phaedras pangs, and Pandarus reasons, to wish the like motion had bene made to them? Or, that any maidens were vpon the stage, who could haue bene contented to become vnchast in yeelding to Hippolytus that which he would not graunt to Nais 7chastlie? As for the young men of our Vniversitie who were present at it, I am hartilie glad if they were so minded: and doe reape my self the greater comfort of it, the more rI haue commended his example to them. But if they wished so, when they saw your play: it came more of somewhat which they brought thither, then which they found there. For, by your instruction, the death of Hippolytus should haue serued to teach them, that they must never denie vnto a Nais, or Phaedra, such requestes: as syour self tell them, on speech concerning wemen; Quas ne quis vnquam spernere dehinc audeat, Hippolytus ecce horribile documentum dedit; Impunè temnat nemo terrestres Deas. And what if all, who were present, not the young men only, did admire the constancie of Penelope? Could no evill affection bee therefore stirred in anie by seeing a boy play so chast a part? ⟨p. 112⟩Happy would Lucretia then haue thought her selfe. For shee was not inferiour in chastitie to Penelope: and when Tarquin saw her, he saw 8her employed as a tmost vertuous woman. Yet, for all the wonderment he had of her vertue: he was more inflamed with loue of her beautie. Yea, 9the very sight of her chast behauiour stirred vp his wicked lust. Moreouer, if Vlysses begging in his owne house, did move all the spectators to have compassion of him, and thereby grew no hurt to them: yet into the actor might there grow some hurt by acquainting him self with hypocriticall faining of
7Amore nempe Thesei casto furis? Sen. Hippolyt.Amore nēpe Thesei casto furis? Sen. Hippolyt.
As zAesopus 1playing the part of Atreus in a tragedy (one of your examples of passions moved, without hurt, at the least, to any man) grew to such a rage by thinking and advising how he might wreak his anger, and be revenged on Thyestes; that with 2his Mace royal he struck one of the servants running by, and slew him. And beside this hurt that possibly might grow, there did grow the suffering of such things at Melanthius and Antinous hands, or 3one of their heels rather, as a 4poor wretch in Terence thought too contumelious and base for him to suffer; & a 5Parasite in Plautus counted a piece of his trade. Which reproachful patience if you think, I say not, that all who saw it, praised it (in saying so you blemish your spectators much;) but, that is was no hurt unto your actor of Ulysses, because (as you distinguished on 6Juvenal's words thereof) he is a poor Scholar: you are not of 7Tertullians, and 8Nazianzenes mind, who note it for a stain in 9what soever players, even in rascal Heathens; how much more would they, if not in Scholars, yet in Christians, whom Saint Paul exhorteth to ado only those things which badorn & set them out with comely gravity? Now, if some might be the worse for beholding or playing of the best parts, the parts of Ulysses, and Penelope: what harm might they receive by the parts of the Wooers; of Melanthius, of Melantho, ⟨p. 113⟩of a bragging soldier, of the drunken mariners, of the Nurse, of Phaedra? In some of which number your general propositions, that all the spectators must needs be moved thus or thus thereby, are untrue. In the rest, nay, in these too, manifest is the weakness of your particular conclusions, that because good thoughts might be stirred up in all the spectators by this or that part, therefore those parts could hurt no man. Besides, if by those parts no hurt could come to any, yet might there much by other which here you mention not: and so you come short of your conclusion general, that no hurt could come to any by the passions that were moved in your plays. Your general propositions do fail in the women: of whom you speak in such sort, that as csome by putting away a good conscience, made shipwreck of their faith: so it may be feared that you, by putting trueth and singleness away, will hazard the shipwreck of common sense and reason.
As zAesopus 1playing the part of Atreus in a tragedie (one of your examples of passions mooved, without hurt, at the least, to any man) grew to such a rage by thinking and advising how he might wreake his anger, and be revenged on Thyestes; that with 2his Mace royall hee strooke one of the servants running by, and slew him. And beside this hurt that possibly might grow, there did grow the suffering of such things at Melanthius and Antinous handes, or 3one of their heeles rather, as a 4poore wretch in Terence thought too contumelious and base for him to suffer; & a 5Parasite in Plautus counted a peece of his trade. Which reprochfull patience if you thinke, I say not, that all who saw it, praised it (in saying so you blemish your spectators much;) but, that is was no hurt vnto your actor of Ulysses, because (as you distinguished on 6Iuuenals wordes thereof) hee is a poore Scholler: you are not of 7Tertullians, and 8Nazianzenes minde, who note it for a staine in 9what soeuer players, even in rascall Heathens; how much more would they, if not in Scholers, yet in Christians, whom Saint Paul exhorteth to adoe only those things which badorne & set them out with coomly gravitie? Now, if some might be the woorse for beholding or playing of the best partes, the partes of Vlysses, and Penelope: what harme might they receaue by the parts of the Wooers; of Melanthius, of Melantho, ⟨p. 113⟩of a bragging souldier, of the drunken mariners, of the Nurse, of Phoedra? In some of which number your generall propositions, that all the spectators must needes bee mooved thus or thus thereby, are vntrue. In the rest, nay, in these too, manifest is the weaknes of your particular conclusions, that because good thoughts might be stirred vp in all the spectators by this or that part, therefore those parts could hurt no man. Besides, if by those partes no hurt could come to any, yet might there much by other which here you mention not: and so you come short of your conclusion generall, that no hurt could come to any by the passions that were mooved in your playes. Your generall propositions doe faile in the wemen: of whom you speake in such sort, that as
zPlutarc. vit. Ciceronis.
1[Greek or Hebrew].〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
2[Greek or Hebrew]〈non-Latin alphabet〉
3Ulyssem calce ferit.Vlyssem calce ferit.
4At ego infelix neque ridiculus esse, neque plagas pat• possum. Ter. Eunucho
5Nisi qui colaphos perpeti potis parasitus, frangique aulas in caput. Plaut. Captiv.
6Mamercorū alapas.Mamercorū alapas.
7Faciem contumeliis alaparum sic obijcit, quasi de praecepto Domini ludat. Docet scilicet & Diabolus verberandam maxillam patienter offerre. Tert. de spectac. cap. 23.
8[Greek or Hebrew]. Gregor. Naz. orat. in laud. Basilii Magni.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Gregor. Naz. orat. in laud. Basilii Magni.
For when married women do commit adultery, all are not displeased with their lightness and bad nature, nor think them worthy of death for it. David had an other opinion of Bathsheba, in the dsacred story; the fool in the eProverbs, of the strange woman; the Trojans, in fyour Homers, gIlias, of Helena: and in his hOdyssea, the supposed Gods, that is to say, great persons, specially Mercury, thought otherwise of Venus. How can it be then, that all should not only dispraise the bad nature and lightness of Melantho, an unmarried harlot, but also account her justly hanged for it? whom it is more likely that some would have stepped forth to beg from the gallows, at least the loving wooer, who had said unto her; 1O most fair Melantho, 2O sweet Melantho; if he had thought that she should have been hanged in earnest. Like probability hath it, that all would approve the Nurses grave counsel given to Phaedra in secret: when the counsel given openly to men, by the iProphets, by the kApostles, yea, by lChrist him self, wherewith this 3hypocrites counsel deserveth not for gravity to be named the same day, was not approved by all. As for that concerning Phaedra you demand; who could be the worse for her wooing Hippolytus in so general terms: ask mCaracallus the Emperor; in whose sight when his stepmother ⟨p. 114⟩Julia, being mad with the same love to him-ward, that Phaedra to Hippolytus, did uncover and make bare, as it were through negligence, the most of her body, his heart conceived fire straight, 4his tongue disclosed it; and by her wooing of him 14in more general terms, then Phaedra wooed Hippolytus, his consent was won to her incestuous lust. But of all absurd speeches in this matter, that may bear the bell, that having asked who could be the worse for her wooing Hippolytus in so general terms, you infer thereon: The drift whereof if it had been to procure an honest honourable marriage, as it was covertly to allure him to incest, he might very well have listened to it. As if one of them, unto whom nSolomon attributeth this speech, Cast in thy lot among us, we will all have one purse, should say that none could be the worse for his enticing in so general terms: the drift whereof if it had been to draw men to lawful war against enemies, as it was to unlawful spoiling of the innocent, they might very well have listened to it.
For when maried women doe committ adulterie, all are not displeased with their lightnes and bad nature, nor thinke them woorthie of death for it. David had an other opinion of Bathseba, in the dsacred storie; the foole in the eProverbes, of the strange woman; the Trojans, in fyour Homers, gIlias, of Helena: and in his hOdyssea, the supposed Gods, that is to say, great persons, specially Mercurie, thought otherwise of Uenus. How can it bee then, that all should not onelie dispraise the bad nature and lightnes of Melantho, an vnmaried harlot, but also account her iustlie hanged for it? whom it is more likely that some would haue stepped foorth to begge from the gallowes, at least the loving wooer, who had said vnto her; 1O most faire Melantho, 2O sweet Melantho; if hee had thought that shee should haue bene hanged in earnest. Like probabilitie hath it, that all would approove the Nurses grave counsell given to Phoedra in secret: when the counsell giuen openlie to men, by the iProphetes, by the kApostles, yea, by lChrist him selfe, wherwith this 3hypocrites counsell deserveth not for gravitie to be named the same day, was not approved by all. As for that concerning Phoedra you demaund; who could be the worse for her wooing Hippolytus in so generall termes: aske mCaracallus the Emperour; in whose sight when his stepmother ⟨p. 114⟩Iulia, being madde with the same love to him-ward, that Phoedra to Hippolytus, did vncover and make bare, as it were through negligence, the most of her body, his heart conceived fyre straight,
3So players are termed in Greek writers commonly; sometime in Latin also. And perhaps dissemblers in faith & religion had that name by a metaphor drawn from the stage: as if they were playing other mens persons.So players are termed in Greek writers commonlie; sometime in Latin also. And parhaps dissemblers in faith & religion had that name by a metaphor drawne from the stage: as if they were playing other mens persons.
Your particular conclusions do fail both in the women (for a surplusage of your former default concerning them) & in the men also. For although Melanthos lightness and bad nature had been dispraised by all: yet some might be corrupted by Melanthos looseness and 6bad lascivious talk, unless Saint oPaul erred. And the grave counsel given unto Phaedra by the Nurse in secret, might hurt unwary lovely youths, as doeth a scorpion, with the 7rail thereof. And Phaedra's general terms might be as pJoabs right hand, wherewith he took Amasa by the beard to kiss him: when her special drift being no more covered than Joabs sword was, might in the mean season wound Amasa to death, and shed his bowels to the ground. The same is apparent in the scurrility of Melanthius, the lewd or fond tricks of the wooers, the vanity of the bragging soldier, the beastliness of the drunken mariners. For qAristotle wishing a law to be made in all well ordered cities, that 8young men should neither see tragedy ⟨p. 115⟩played, nor Comedy, until in riper years they be past danger of being hurt thereby, groundeth his advise on reason and experience; because things which young men receive, do stick fast by them: and therefore sith principal care ought to be taken that they may prove virtuous, 9they should be kept from hearing any ill speeches, and seeing any ill deeds; chiefly such deeds and speeches, as are lewd or hateful. So that, where you tell us in defence of the spectacle of your drunken mariners, that it was not possible that any man should be provoked to drunkenness thereby: albeit this were true, whereof yet I doubt, or rather I doubt not, considering that many are overprone to follow any vice or evil, which they see or hear, as an rauthor praised by your self observeth out of daily experience in children swearing great oaths, and speaking lascivious and unclean words by such example of other; but if it were true, there might nevertheless a dew of that poison, which Aristotle mentioneth, infect some tender buds, and annoy their fruit by the drunken songs, by the drunken speeches, by the drunken gestures of those drunken beasts. The greater is your fault, who say, the Lacedaemonians are commended for causing their slaves, being drunk in deed, to be brought before their children, that they seeing the beastly usage of such men, might the more loth that vice:
Your particular conclusions doe faile both in the women (for a surplusage of your former default concerning them) & in the men also. For although Melanthos lightnes and bad nature had bene dispraised by all: yet some might be corrupted by Melanthos loosenes and 6bad lascivious talke, vnlesse Saint oPaul erred. And the graue counsell given vnto Phoedra by the Nurse in secret, might hurt vnwarie lovely youthes, as doeth a scorpion, with the 7raile therof. And Phoedras generall termes might bee as pIoabs right hand, wherewith he tooke Amasa by the beard to kisse him: when her speciall drift being no more covered thē Ioabs sword was, might in the meane season wound Amasa to death, and shed his bowells to the ground. The same is apparant in the scurrilitie of Melanthius, the lewde or fonde trickes of the wooers, the vanitie of the bragging souldier, the beastlines of the drunken mariners. For qAristotle wishing a lawe to be made in all well ordered cities, that 8young men should neither see tragedie ⟨p. 115⟩played, nor Comedie, vntill in riper yeares they be past danger of being hurt thereby, groundeth his advise on reason and experience; because things which young men receave, doe sticke fast by them: and therefore sith principall care ought to bee taken that they may proove vertuous, 9they should be kept frō hearing any ill speeches, and seeing any ill deedes; chieflie such deedes and speeches, as are lewde or hatefull. So that, where you tell vs in defense of the spectacle of your drunken mariners, that it was not possible that anie man should be provoked to drunkennes thereby: albeit this were true, whereof yet I doubt, or rather I dout not, considering that many are overprone to folow anie vice or evill, which they see or heare, as an rautour praised by your selfe observeth out of dailie experience in childrē swearing great oathes, and speaking lascivious and vncleane wordes by such example of other; but if it were true, there might neuerthelesse a deaw of that poyson, which Aristotle mentioneth, infect some tender buddes, and anoy their fruit by the drunken songs, by the drunken speeches, by the drunken gestures of those drunken beastes. The greater is your fault, who say, the Lacedemonians are commended for causing their slaves, beeing drunke in deede, to be brought before their children, that they seeing the beastlie vsage of such men, might the more loth that vice:
6Domina Penelope sibi Dum nescio quā gloriam captat levē, Quot illa noctes perdidit flendo bonas? Momenta pulchri corporis spolium auferunt, Fragilisque res est forma: dum licet, utter, & Arce quū Dana• procos Arceret alta, quum fores clausae undique In imbre venit Jupiter tandem aureo, Praedam que victor abstulit: nulla aureo Resistet imbri: ferreas aurum trabes, Nedum puellas frangit ac sternit soloDomina Penelope sibi Dum nescio quā gloriam captat levē, Quot illa noctes perdidit flēdo bonas? Momēta pulchri corporis spolium auferunt, Fragilisque res est forma: dum licet, vtere, & Arce quū Dana• procos Arceret alta, quum fores clausae vndique In imbre venit Iuppiter tandē aureo, Praedam que victor abstulit: nulla aureo Resistet imbri: ferreas aurum trabes, Nedum puellas frāgit ac sternit solo
8[Greek or Hebrew] he saith, meaning such speeches (used to be expressed in that kind of verse) as there are a number uttered by Antinous, Eruymachus, with the like, in your Ulysses redux, and commonly in all tragedies. Aristot. de poet.〈non-Latin alphabet〉 hee saith, meaning such speeches (vsed to bee expressed in that kinde of verse) as there are a number vttered by Antinous, Eruymachus, with the like, in your Vlysses redux, and commonly in all tragedies. Aristot. de poet.
9[Greek or Hebrew].〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
rSir. Thomas Eliot in the Governor, lib. 1. cap. 4. & 6.
but you much better expressing the same intent, not with drunken, but with sober men, counterfeiting such unseemly manners, are the less therefore to be reprehended. Wherein how overthwarthly you affirm your selves to have done much better then the Lacedaemonians, whose fact is commended; and yet conclude that you are the less therefore to be reprehended, as if your conscience told you that either your fact is not like to theirs, or hath some notable difference whereby it is made worse and worthy of reproof, though of the less reproof, the liker it is to theirs in part: we shall the more easily perceive, if we consider how the commender of it (why signified you not his name, or place?) Plutarch, sdoeth likewise by and by thereupon con mend them for that 1they neither heard Comedy nor Tragedy, least they should in earnest, or jest, lend ear to those who gain said the laws. For hereby I gather, that they did not purposely ⟨p. 116⟩make their slaves drunken; against ttheir laws had that been: but 2when the slaves were drunk, they turned the example to their children's benefit, that, by seeing swine wallowing in the mire of vomit, and so forth, they might detest drum kens. As with us when thieves are hanged, or whores carted, we show them to our children, to breed a detestation of theft and whoredom in them. Whereupon if Seius should say, it were much better that true men should feign them selves to be thieves, display some thievish prank of theirs upon a stage, and seem to be hanged for it; or that chaste maidens and young men should counterfeit the misdemeanour of whores & knaves, and openly representing the filthy act of their uncleanness, be taken in it, and putt to shame: your self, I am persuaded, would judge his better to be worse; at least in the latter point of knaves and whores, because the shame, that lighteth on them after the fact done, may profit the beholders; but the doing of it, and of things tending to it, hath turpitude that may corrupt them. Which censure if you will apply to your fact compared with the example of the Lacedaemonians, you may see their drunken slaves do little help to justify your mariners:
but you much better expressing the same intent, not with drunken, but with sober men, counterfeiting such vnseemelie manners, are the lesse therefore to be reprehended. Wherein how overthwarthly you affirme your selues to haue done much better then the Lacedaemonians, whose fact is commended; and yet conclude that you are the lesse therefore to be reprehended, as if your conscience tolde you that either your fact is not like to theirs, or hath some notable difference whereby it is made worse and woorthy of reproofe, though of the lesse reproofe, the liker it is to theirs in part: we shall the more easilie perceaue, if we consider how the commender of it (why signified you not his name, or place?) Plutarch, sdoeth likewise by and by therevpon cō mend them for that 1they neither heard Comedie nor Tragedie, least they should in earnest, or iest, lende eare to those who gain said the lawes. For hereby I gather, that they did not purposely ⟨p. 116⟩make their slaves drunken; against ttheir lawes had that bene: but 2when the slaves were drunke, they turned the example to their childrens benefite, that, by seeing swine wallowing in the myre of vomit, and so foorth, they might detest drū kennes. As with vs when theeves are hanged, or hoores carted, we shew them to our children, to breede a detestation of theft and hoordome in them. Wherevpon if Seius should say, it were much better that true men should faine them selves to be theeves, display some theevish pranke of theirs vpō a stage, and seeme to be hanged for it; or that chast maidens and yong men should coūterfeit the misdemeanour of hoores & knaves, and openly representing the filthy act of their vncleannes, bee taken in it, and putt to shame: your selfe, I am perswaded, would iudge his better to be woorse; at least in the latter point of knaves and hoores, because the shame, that lighteth on thē after the fact done, may profit the beholders; but the doeing of it, and of things tending to it, hath turpitude that may corrupt them. Which censure if you will apply to your fact compared with the example of the Lacedaemonians, you may see their drunken slaves doe little helpe to iustifie your mariners:
sAntiq. Lacedaemon•or. institut.
1[Greek or Hebrew].〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
tXenophon. de repub. Lacedaem.
2[Greek or Hebrew] Pl•tar. saith, and not, [Greek or Hebrew].〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Pl•tar. saith, and not, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
because the 3rotten or stinking talk (as vScripture termeth it) which your mariners used before and at their quaffing, would not have been suffered among the Lacedaemonians to be sung or said in their children's hearing, no not by interlude-players. Neither have you greater reason to commend and extol the worthy play-fellows of your mariners by Catos name and credit, in that you ask; What Cato might not be delighted to see the fond behaviour of Country-wooing expressed by civill men, or the vanity of a bragging soldier? For Cato, not the younger, whose Stoical austerity xTully findeth fault with, but whom without such note yhe praiseth, the elder, zdid put out of the number of Senators one Manilius, because in the day time he had kissed his wife in his daughters sight: & him self took no less heed of speaking filthy words in his sons presence, then he would have done in presence of the Vestal virgins; nor ever would enter into the bathe with him, least his son should see him naked. And can you think that any of this ⟨p. 117⟩mans disposition, what delight soever him self might have taken in that which could not taint his gravity and constancy, would have been delighted, delighted? nay, contented to behold the filth of your country-wooers in the mouths & actions of Scholars like his son, before so great a company both of sons and daughters; in whose 4ears, & eyes, a aPoet, no way comparable with Cato for severity and care of virtuous nurturing & training up of youth, detesteth the expressing of any one such foolery, as your country-wooers did express a number?
because the 3rotton or stinking talke (as vScripture termeth it) which your mariners vsed before and at their quaffing, would not haue bene suffered among the Lacedaemonians to be soong or said in their childrens hearing, no not by enterlude-players. Neither haue you greater reason to commende and extoll the woorthy play-felowes of your mariners by Catos name and credit, in that you aske; What Cato might not bee delited to see the fond behaviour of Country-wooing expressed by civill men, or the vanitie of a bragging soldier? For Cato, not the younger, whose Stoicall austeritie xTullie findeth fault with, but whom without such note yhe prayseth, the elder, zdid put out of the number of Senatours one Manilius, because in the day time he had kissed his wife in his daughters sight: & him selfe tooke no lesse heed of speaking filthy woords in his sonnes presence, then he would haue done in presence of the Uestall virgins; nor ever would enter into the bathe with him, least his sonne should see him naked. And can you thinke that any of this ⟨p. 117⟩mans disposition, what delite soever him selfe might haue taken in that which could not taint his gravitie and constancie, would haue bene delited, delited? nay, contented to beholde the filth of your country-wooers in the mouthes & actions of Scholers like his sonne, before so great a companie both of sonnes and daughters; in whose 4eares, & eyes, a aPoët, no way comparable with Cato for severitie and care of vertuous nurturing & training vp of youth, detesteth the expressing of any one such foolerie, as your country-wooers did expresse a number?
As for the vanity of your bragging soldier, I marvel that intending to prove there could no evil affection be stirred up thereby in any, you durst mention Cato: when I had showed that bPlautus, a far looser person, and better experienced in matters of this kind, doeth note that 5mens manners are wont to be corrupted and made worse by plays which have a bawd, or boor, or bragging soldier in them. The dissolute behaviour of your courtly-wooers, you say, was not so much expressed on the stage, as imagined to be done within. Not so much on the stage: much on the stage therefore; and in deed too much. Yet this would prove, I grant, that small harm could be done by the playing of their parts, unless that were true which the Scripture saith: cHow great a pile of wood how little fire kindleth? Melanthius alone of all the sorts, or varlets, whom you namely specify, hath no amplification of Lacedaemonians, or Cato; no extenuation of not so much on the stage, to grace the ungraciousness of his foul scurrility. The likelier is Aristotle's sentence and authority to prevail with you, that young men might be stained by hearing of his railing, his 6Jambicall speeches, as Aristotle termeth them. At least Sir Thomas Eliots dwords of playing at football, that therein is nothing but beastly fury, & extreme violence, whereof proceedeth hurt, and consequently rancour & malice do remain with them that be wounded, may move you to think that there was danger of annoying our youth by Melanthius action, 7striking and girding (like Silenus 8ass) at Ulysses with his heel. For boys affecting football, will argue peradventure, that seeing such horseplay was used by Melanthius, & he might strike Ulysses body with his ⟨p. 118⟩foot; more lawful should it be for them to strike a ball so: and what Cato would not be delighted to see them break one an others shins? or who was that vicechancellour, what a convocation, that made our University statute to the contrary? Thus are your particular conclusions overthrown, even by those passions which the parties mentioned might imprint in others. How much more in them selves?
As for the vanitie of your bragging souldiour, I marvell that intending to proove there could no evill affection bee stirred vp thereby in anie, you durst mention Cato: whē I had shewed that bPlautus, a farre looser person, and better experienced in matters of this kinde, doeth note that 5mens maners are woont to be corrupted and made worse by playes which haue a bawde, or boore, or bragging souldier in them. The dissolute behaviour of your courtly-wooers, you say, was not so much expressed on the stage, as imagined to be doon within. Not so much on the stage: much on the stage therefore; and in deed too much. Yet this would proove, I graunt, that small harme could be done by the playing of their partes, vnlesse that were true which the Scripture saith: cHow great a pile of wood how litle fire kindleth? Melanthius alone of all the sorts, or varlets, whom you namelie specifie, hath no amplification of Lacedaemonians, or Cato; no extenuation of not so much on the stage, to grace the vngratiousnes of his fowle scurrilitie. The likelier is Aristotles sentence and autoritie to prevaile with you, that yong men might be stained by hearing of his railing, his 6Iambicall speeches, as Aristotle termeth them. At least Syr Thomas Eliots dwordes of playing at footeball, that therein is nothing but beastly furie, & extreeme violence, whereof proceedeth hurt, and consequentlie rancour & malice doe remaine with them that be wounded, may moove you to thinke that there was daunger of anoying our youth by Melanthius action, 7striking and girding (like Silenus 8asse) at Vlysses with his heele. For boyes affecting footebale, will argue peradventure, that seeing such horseplay was vsed by Melanthius, & he might strike Vlysses body with his ⟨p. 118⟩foote; more lawfull should it bee for them to strike a ball so: and what Cato would not be delited to see them breake one an others shinnes? or who was that vicechancellour, what a convocation, that made our Vniversitie statute to the contrarie? Thus are your particular conclusions overthrowne, euen by those passions which the parties mentioned might imprint in others. How much more in them selues?
bIn prologue. Capuvor.In prolog. Capuuor.
5Profectò expediet fabulae huic operam dare. Hic neque pe•iurus leno est, nec meretrix mala, Neque miles gloriosus.
Whose minds in what danger they are of infection, by meditating and studying sundry days, or weeks, how to express the manners of wantons, or drunkards, or country-wooers lively, the seeing whereof played but an hour, or two, might taint the spectators: I wish with all my hart, that I may rather seem in vain to have feared, then they should by experience feel. Your conclusion general faileth more and more yet, because evil affections might be stirred up by other parts then these: as namely, by your new parts of Pandarus and Nais. The former, after a sort confessed by your self, in that you demand; who could be the worse for Phaedra's wooing Hippolytus in so general terms? For this doeth insinuate that through Pandarus wooing him i• special terms, so special, that incestuous 9Myrrha went no further (as eOvid thought fit to describe it) not in her secret 1thoughts, some might be the worse. The later, most evident by that which is frecorded to have come to pass in the City of Abdêra. Where, when at midsummer, in very hot weather, Andromeda (a Tragedy of Euripides) being played, many brought home a burning ague from the theatre: about the seventh day following, they were rid thereof, some by much bleeding, some by sweating, but all, as soon as they were abroad out of their beds, did fall into a strange distemper and passion of a light frenzy. The which exciting them to say & cry aloud such things as were sticking freshly in their memory, and had affected most their mind, 2they grew all to Tragedy-playing, and full lustily they sounded out 3Jambicall speeches: their tongues harping chiefly on Euripides, Andromeda, and the 4melodious words of Perseus touching love. So that the whole city was full of pale and thin folk, pronouncing like stage-players, and braying with a loud voice. ⟨p. 119⟩5But O Cupido, prince of Gods and men, with the rest of that part: until at length the winter and cold, waxing great, assuaged their distemper, and eased them of their frantic folly. A word to a wise man is enough. That speech, But O Cupido, Prince of Gods and men, uttered under Perseus, that is, a mans person, was of all likely hood less piercing and pathetical, then yours, O quàm juvaret igne tam pulchro mori, uttered by Nais, a woman, and a Nymph. It was well that she played in winter, not in summer.
Whose mindes in what danger they are of infection, by meditating and studying sundrie dayes, or weekes, how to expresse the manners of wantons, or drunkards, or country-wooers lively, the seeing wherof played but an hower, or two, might taint the spectators: I wish with all my hart, that I may rather seeme in vaine to have feared, then they should by experience feele. Your conclusion generall faileth more and more yet, because evill affections might be stirred vp by other partes then these: as namelie, by your new parts of Pandarus and Nais. The former, after a sort confessed by your selfe, in that you demaund; who could be the woorse for Phoedras wooing Hippolytus in so generall termes? For this doeth insinuate that through Pandarus wooing him i• speciall termes, so speciall, that incestuous 9Myrrha went no farder (as eOvid thought fitt to describe it) not in her secret 1thoughts, some might be the woorse. The later, most evident by that which is frecorded to haue come to passe in the Citi• of Abdêra. Where, when at midsummer, in very hottweather, Andromeda (a Tragedie of Euripides) being played, manie brought home a burning ague from the theater: about the seventh day folowing, they were ridde thereof, some by much bleeding, some by sweating, but all, as soone as they were abroade out of their beddes, did fall into a strange distemper and passion of a light phrensie. The which exciting them to say & cry aloude such things as were sticking freshly in their memorie, and had affected most their minde, 2they grewe all to Tragedie-playing, and full lustilie they sounded out 3Iambicall speeches: their toungs harping chieflie on Euripides, Andromeda, and the 4melodious woords of Perseus touching love. So that the whole citie was full of pale and thinne folke, pronouncing like stage-players, and braying with a loude voice. ⟨p. 119⟩5But O Cupido, prince of Gods and men, with the rest of that part: vntill at length the winter and colde, waxing great, asswaged their distemper, and eased them of their frantike follie. A woorde to a wise man is enough. That speech, But O Cupido, Prince of Gods and men, vttered vnder Perseus, that is, a mans person, was of all likely hoode lesse pearcing and patheticall, then yours, O quàm iuvaret igne tam pulchro mori, vttered by Nais, a woman, and a Nymph. It was well that shee played in winter, not in summer.
9Fit equo sua filia coniux, Quasque credit, init pecudes caper. &, Gentes tamen esse fe•ntur, in qui bus & nato genitrix, & data parenti Jungitur; ut pietas geminato crescat amore.Fit equo sua filia coniux, Quasque cre•it, init pecudes caper. &, Gentes tamen esse fe•ntur, in qui bus & nato genitrix, & •ata parenti Iungitur; vt pietas geminato crescat amore.
eMetamorph. lib. 10.
1Et secū, Quò mente feror? quid molior? inquit. &c.Et secū, Quò mente feror? quid molior? inquit. &c.
For gPerseus loved Andromeda in the way of marriage too, as Nais did Hippolytus. But the force of love-pangs, and the care of lawfulness, join not their dwelling houses together still in all hearts. Wherefore you are so far off from having proved that no evil affection could be stirred up in any by your plays: that I can hardly remember any evil affection, which might not be stirred up thereby in many; not only in the actors, but the spectators also. And I think your self, if you peruse advisedly this which I have written, and diligently compare it with your Ulysses redux, Rivals, and Hippolytus, will take time of respite before you name as much as one inordinate passion; whereto I shall not quote, at least one players part, perhaps two, or three, that may be as oil unto the fire. Howbeit, had you proved the contrary hereof, yet is my conclusion entire, as I said, and your plays unlawful: because it is unlawful to imitate and resemble any misbehaviour; and your self can not deny but sundry lewdnesses were imitated and resembled in each of your plays.
For gPerseus loved Andromeda in the way of mariage too, as Nais did Hippolytus. But the force of love-pangs, and the care of lawfulnes, ioyne not their dwelling houses together still in all heartes. Wherefore you are so farre off from having prooved that no evill affection could bee stirred vp in anie by your playes: that I can hardlie remember any evill affection, which might not be stirred vp thereby in many; not onely in the actors, but the spectators also. And I thinke your selfe, if you peruse advisedly this whiche I haue written, and diligentlie compare it with your Vlysses redux, Rivales, and Hippolytus, will take time of respitt before you name as much as one inordinate passion; whereto I shall not quote, at least one players part, perhaps two, or three, that may be as oile vnto the fire. Howbeit, had you prooved the contrarie hereof, yet is my conclusion entier, as I said, and your playes vnlawfull: because it is vnlawfull to imitate and resemble any misbehaviour; and your selfe can not denie but sundry lewdnesses were imitated and resembled in eche of your playes.
Herein is that confuted withal by the way, which otherwhere you mention as an intent sufficient to justify & warrant your coming on the stage: namely that you do it to practise your style, either in prose or verse; to be well acquainted with Seneca, or Plautus; honestly to embolden your youth; to try their voices, & confirm their memories, to frame their speech; to conform them to convenient action; to try what metal is in every one, and of what disposition they are. For although you aimed at all these things, and hit them, which as I have showed in one branch to be false, so must you grant it in some other; unless you will say, that to arm a youth with a hwhores ⟨p. 120⟩forehead, is honestly to embolden him; or, by trying what metal is in every one, you mean the occasioning of them to give proof whether their ibrows be made of brass; but admitting all were even as you pretend: yet your stage-playing being convicted of unlawfulness, your pretences for it are grinded all to powder; kjust is their damnation, who say, Let us do evil that good may come thereof. Our great and first parents, lseduced by the serpent, did eat of the fruit of the forbidden tree: to the intent that they might become like to God, and know both good and evil. The mknowledge of good and evil, is to be wished: but because the nmeans was joined with disobedience, it had been better for them to have lacked that knowledge. Among the Lacedaemonians, oboys by their public order were instructed, and through want of vitals were provoked to steal meat: that being occasioned thereby to watch at night, while others were sleeping, and to lye in wait by day time for their pray, they might be the skilfuller to circumvent & spoil their enemies in war.
Herein is that confuted withall by the way, which otherwhere you mention as an intent sufficient to iustifie & warrant your coming on the stage: namely that you doe it to practise your style, either in prose or verse; to bee well acquainted with Seneca, or Plautus; honestly to embolden your youth; to trie their voices, & cōfirme their memories, to frame their speech; to conforme them to convenient action; to trie what mettall is in everie one, and of what disposition they are. For although you aimed at all these things, and hitt them, which as I haue shewed in one branche to bee false, so must you graunt it in some other; vnlesse you will saye, that to arme a youth with a hwhoores ⟨p. 120⟩forehead, is honestly to embolden him; or, by trying what metta• is in every one, you meane the occasioning of thē to giue proofe whether their ibrowes bee made of brasse; but admitting all were even as you pretend: yet your stage-playing being convicted of vnlawfulnes, your pretēses for it are grinded all to powder; kiust is their damnation, who say, Let vs doe evill that good may come thereof. Our great and first parents, lseduced by the serpent, did eate of the fruit of the forbidden tree: to the intent that they might become like to God, and knowe both good and evill. The mknowledge of good and euill, is to be wished: but because the nmeanes was ioyned with disobedience, it had bene better for them to haue lacked that knowledge. Among the Lacedaemonians, oboyes by their publike order were instructed, and through want of vittalls were provoked to steale meat: that being occasioned thereby to watch at night, while others were sleeping, and to lye in wait by day time for their pray, they might be the skilfuller to circumvent & spoile their enemies in warre.
The end good and commendable, as he who ptaught David to fight, assureth us: but qDavid was not taught it by pilfering and stealing. Parmeno in rTerence telleth what commodity Chaerea might purchase by coming into Thais ho•se: to be acquainted with the nature and manners of harlots, that knowing them betime he might for ever hate them. To hate them, is a quality sbeseeming virtuous persons: but who so by acquaintance with them do seek to hate them, are likely to be evil qualified; for tcan a man go upon coals, and his feet not be burnt? But here you will reply percase that in Chaerea, beside the good effect which Parmeno did boast of, some bad effects might fall out, vthrough the seeing of Jupiters picture with Danaë, and being near to Pamphila: which in your plays can not be feared. But I have prevented this reply by showing that 6your Danaë's picture with Melanthos talk may breed some bad effects in a Chaerea too, though he were a beholder only of your plays, much more if he be a player him self. Wherefore if a dead fly doeth cause the sweet ointment of the Apothecary to stink, as the xwise man saith: what a loathsome savour ⟨p. 121⟩must needs so great store of such carrion breed in the perfume of eloquence, into the which you cast it? Beside that, to come nearer you, the ointment and perfume itself commended by you, hath a rammish smell, and stinketh like a goat: as a good Apothecary, and of very quick sent, 7Quintilian, I mean, acknowledgeth and avoucheth. For he, yrequiring 8chiefly that young and tender minds 9should not only learn such things as are well uttered, but, & that much rather, such things as are honest; forbiddeth them to read at all any poems of 1amatory fancies, at least, 2till they be grown to greater maturity of years, and strength of age. In which sort he alloweth them to read Menanders Comedies also, and others, 3When they be past danger of having their manners corrupted. And their zstyle he willeth to be exercised in common places, either against vices, or touching doubtful questions; in praising good, dispraising evil: in reporting trueth; in defence of innocency; and the like matters that may serve an 4honest man in use of life. Their amemory he wisheth to be confirmed by learning without book, sometime somewhat of their own, well penned;
The end good and commendable, as he who ptaught David to fight, assureth vs: but qDavid was not taught it by pilfering and stealing. Parmeno in rTerence telleth what commoditie Chaerea might purchase by cōming into Thais ho•se: to bee acquainted with the nature and manners of harlots, that knowing them betime he might for ever hate them. To hate thē, is a qualitie sbeseeming vertuous persons: but who so by acquaintance with them doe seeke to hate them, are likelie to be evill qualified; for tcan a man goe vpon coales, and his feete not be burnt? But here you will reply percase that in Chaerea, beside the good effect which Parmeno did boast of, some bad effects might fall out, vthrough the seeing of Iupiters picture with Danaë, and being neere to Pamphila: which in your playes cā not be feared. But I have prevented this reply by shewing that 6your Danaes picture with Melanthos talke may breede some bad effectes in a Chaerea too, though he were a beholder onely of your playes, much more if he be a player him selfe. Wherefore if a dead flye doeth cause the sweet ointment of the Apothecarie to stinke, as the xwise man saith: what a lothsome savour ⟨p. 121⟩must needs so great store of such caraine breed in the perfume of eloquence, into the which you cast it? Beside that, to come neerer you, the ointment and perfume itselfe commended by you, hath a rammish smell, and stinketh like a goate: as a good Apothecarie, and of verie quicke sent, 7Quintilian, I meane, acknowledgeth and avoucheth. For he, yrequiring 8
but principally, places elected and chosen out of orations, or stories, or other kind of 5writings worthy that care and study; that they 6may accustom themselves to the best, and have their style holpen many ways thereby. Finally, for bframing of speech, voice, and gesture, he would not have them imitate the voice of Women, or old men; nor express the faults of drunkenness; nor be taught to play the slaves; nor learn the affection and passion of love, of covetousness, of fear. Which things are neither necessary, saith he, 7for an orator; and 8they do corrupt the mind, in childhood specially, while it is tender yet and unacquainted with things; because 9such as those are whom we imitate much, such our selves become. Behold the great difference between a heathen mans conceit of the instructing of orators for civill causes: & yours, of Christian Preachers, or what soever place your Students shall be called to in Church or Common weal, at least of honest men and Christians.
but principally, places elected and chosen out of orations, or stories, or other kind of 5writings worthy that care and studie; that they 6may accustome themselves to the best, and have their style holpen manie wayes thereby. Finallie, for bframing of speech, voice, and gesture, he would not haue them imitate the voice of Women, or old men; nor expresse the fautes of drunkennes; nor be taught to play the slaves; nor learne the affection and passion of love, of couetousnes, of feare. Which things are neither necessarie, saith he, 7for an oratour; and 8they doe corrupt the minde, in childhoode specially, while it is tender yet and vnacquainted with things; because 9such as those are whom we imitate much, such our selves become. Behold the great difference betweene a heathen mans conceit of the instructing of oratours for civill causes: & yours, of Christian Preachers, or what soeuer place your Studentes shall be called to in Church or Common weale, at least of honest men and Christians.
5Dignorum ea cura voluminum.
6Assuescent optimis.
bLib. 1. ca. 19
7Oratori.
8Mentem, praecipuè in aetate prima teneram adhuc & rudem inficiunt.
9Frequens imitatio transis in mores.Frequēs imitatio transis in mores.
He would have no amatory poems, neither Comedies, no not cMenanders, that is, the 1best of all to be read by his ⟨p. 122⟩youth: you, as if Phaedra's amorous speech expressed by Seneca were nothing without a pe•ce of menstruous cloth sowed to it, do occasion yours to make them selves familiar and well acquainted with Plautus, done far beneath the best. He would have his youth to practise their style in good things, as in 2weapons, which they may use when need shall be: you practise yours in speeches enticing men to Venery, to ribaldry, to scurrility, to whoredom, to incest, to other abominations. He would have his youth to commit most excellent things and words to memory; you pester yours with filth, such filth in Rivals (I am ashamed to rehearse it) as can not be matched, I think, sure very hardly, throughout all Plautus. He would not have his youth 3to counterfeit a woman's voice: you procure Minerva, Penelope, Euryclea, Antonoë, Eurynome, Hippodamia, Melantho, Phaedra, the Nurse, the Nymph, besides I know not whom in the unprinted Comedy, to be played by yours. He would 4not have his youth to represent the faults of drunkenness: yours must flaunt it out in most unmodest guise, with unseemly barbarous carousing songs and speeches, and be defended too by the brave example of Lacedaemonian slaves. He would 5not have his youth to be imbrued and tainted with slavish behaviour: for yours it is an ornament to play the goatherd Melanthius, or a bragging soldier, or a clownish wooer. In fine, he would 6not have his youth to learn the passion of amorousness and love; 7nor to be stage-player-like in action and gesture: you breed yours in stage-playing, as conforming them to convenient action; and teach them to resemble the pangs of love in manner of most amorous Nymphs, with 8burning exclamations, and 9fancies of Poetical fables. St eAustin reproving the course of the world which traineth up their children in Poets wanton tales of Jupiters adulteries, and useth to defend their custom by saying, Hence are words learned, hence is eloquence gotten:
Hee would haue no amatorie poëmes, neither Comedies, no not cMenanders, that is, the 1best of all to be read by his ⟨p. 122⟩youth: you, as if Phaedras amorous speech expressed by Seneca were nothing without a pe•ce of menstruous cloth sowed to it, doe occasion yours to make them selves familiar and well acquainted with Plautus, done farre beneath the best. He would haue his youth to practise their style in good things, as in 2weapons, which they may vse when neede shall be: you practise yours in speeches entising men to Uenerie, to ribauderie, to scurrilitie, to hoordom, to incest, to other abominations. He would haue his youth to commit most excellent thinges and wordes to memorie; you pester yours with filth, such filth in Rivales (I am ashamed to reherse it) as can not be matched, I thinke, sure very hardly, throughout all Plautus. Hee would not haue his youth 3to counterfeit a womans voice: you procur• Minerva, Penelope, Euryclea, Antonoë, Eurynome, Hippodamia, Melantho, Phaedra, the Nurse, the Nymph, besides I know not whom in the vnprinted Comedie, to bee played by yours. Hee would 4not have his youth to represent the faults of drunkennes: yours must flant it out in most vnmodest guise, with vnseemely barbarous carousing songes and speeches, and be defended too by the brave example of Lacedaemonian slaves. Hee would 5not haue his youth to bee imbrued and tainted with slavish behaviour: for yours it is an ornament to play the goteheard Melanthius, or a bragging souldier, or a clownish wooer. In fine, hee would 6not haue his youth to learne the passion of amorousnes and loue; 7nor to bee stage-player-like in action and gesture: you breede yours in stage-playing, as conforming them to convenient action; and teach them to resemble the panges of loue in maner of most amorous Nymphes, with
cLib. 10. ca. 1.
1Omnibus •iusdem operis autoribus abstulit nomen.
dHorat. de art. poet. vives lib. 3. de tratend. disciplin Scalig. poetic. lib. 6. cap. 3.
2Arma sunt hac quodammo do praeparā da semper, ut his, quum res poscet, utaris.Arma sunt hac quodāmo do praeparā da semper, vt his, quum res poscet, vtaris.
forsooth, saith he, belike we could not know these words, imbrem aureum, and gremium, and fucum, and templa caeli, and the rest there written, unless f Terence had brought in a lewd young man proposing Jupiter to him self for an example of whoredom, while he beholdeth on the ⟨p. 123⟩wall a certain painted table, wherein was this picture; how Jupiter sent a 1golden shower, they say, of old time into the 2lap of Danaë, 3under the colour thereof to beguile a woman. And see how he stirreth up himself to lust as it were by the instruction of a heavenly master. But what God? saith he. Even that God which shaketh 4the sanctuaries of heaven with thunder. Should not I, who am a mortal wretch, do the same? Yes in deed I did it, and gladly. 5No, no, saith S. Austin, those words are not learned the more conveniently by means of this dishonesty: but this dishonesty is wrought the more confidently by means of those words. Thus did that discreet and godly Father judge of causing such devises of Poets to be learned by children yea although the Poets were as good as Terence and the children as well inclined as himself. For him self it is, of whom ghe confesseth that 6he learned many profitable words in vain, Poetical fancies; but such as both may be learned in things not vain, & that is a safe way wherein children ought to walk. On which consideration sundry men of note in our memory also, not only among professors of purer religion, but even among the Papists, have advised Schoolmasters & instructors of youth either not to read Terence to their Scholars, or if they will read him, not to read him all. hLudovicus Vives, having declared in general out of iPlutarch touching the reading of Poets, that, unless you use it most warily, it hurteth; and therefore, if a child may be allowed to meddle with it, their writings would be purged first, & filthy matters be wholly cut out of them: Doth wish the same concerning Terence in special for those things which might defile the minds of children with such faults and vices, as naturally we are prone to.
forsooth, saith hee, belike wee could not know these wordes, imbrem aureum, and gremium, and fucum, and templa caeli, and the rest there written, vnlesse f Terence had brought in a lewde young man proposing Iupiter to him selfe for an example of hooredome, while hee beholdeth on the ⟨p. 123⟩wall a certaine painted table, wherein was this picture; how Iupiter sent a 1golden shower, they say, of olde time into the 2lappe of Danaë, 3vnder the colour thereof to beguile a woman. And see how he stirreth vp himselfe to lust as it were by the instruction of a heavenly maister. But what God? saith hee. Even that God which shaketh 4the sanctuaries of heaven with thunder. Should not I, who am a mortall wretch, doe the same? Yes in deed I did it, and gladly. 5No, no, saith S. Austin, those wordes are not learned the more conveniently by meanes of this dishonestie: but this dishonestie is wrought the more confidently by meanes of those wordes. Thus did that discreete and godly Father iudge of causing such devises of Poëts to bee learned by children yea although the Poëts were as good as Terence and the childrē as well inclined as himselfe. For him selfe it is, of whom ghee confesseth that 6hee learned many profitable wordes in vaine, Poëticall fansies; but such as both may bee learned in thinges not vaine, & that is a safe way wherein children ought to walke. On which consideration sundry men of note in our memorie also, not onely among professors of purer religion, but even among the Papists, haue advised Scholemasters & instructors of youth either not to read Terence to their Scholers, or if they will read him, not to read him all. hLudovicus Uives, having declared in generall out of iPlutarch touching the reading of Poëts, that, vnlesse you vse it most warily, it hurteth; and therefore, if a childe may be allowed to meddle with it, their writinges would be purged first, & filthy matters be wholly cut out of them: Doth wish the same concerning Terence in speciall for those thinges which might defile the mindes of children with such faultes and vices, as naturally wee are prone to.
1Imbrem • reum.
2Gremium.
3Fucum.
4Templa […]Templa 〈…〉
5Non omnin• per hanc turpitudinē verba ista commodius discuntur; sed per haec verba turpitudo ista confidē tius perpetraturNon omnin• per hanc turpitudinē verba ista commodius discuntur; sed per haec verba turpitudo ista confidē tius perpetratur
gAug. confess. lib. 1. cap. 15
6Didici in […] multa verba utilia: sed & quae in […] non vanis disci possunt; & ea via […] est in qua pu•ri ambularent.Didici in 〈…〉 multa verba vtilia: sed & quae in 〈…〉 non vanis disci possunt; & ea via 〈…〉 est in qua pu•ri ambularent.
Ignatius Loyola, a man no worse minded in certain points then were the old Jewish kPharisees, whose lsect in his offspring of Jesuits he hath renewed, mdid forbid Terence to be read in schools (unless he were purged) least he should more annoy their manners by his wantonness, then by his Latin help their wits. nGeorgius Fabricius, not seeing how he may be well purged to this purpose, because the conditions of fond or bad persons, as of lovers, •oores, murmurers, misers, fretters, ruffians, varlets, flatterers, ⟨p. 124⟩boasters, bawds, and sycophants, that is, the most of those things which Comedies entreat of, belong to stronger minds, and to an age confirmed and stayed with some judgement, not to unskilful children, before whom they are better omitted and concealed; Fabricius therefore grounding him self upon the judgement of oAristotle, and pQuintilian, both applied to Terence, resolveth that he is not to be read at all to youths of tender years. Whereunto a light of our university and country, D. Humphrey, subscribeth and agreeth, in that upon occasion of showing how Noblemen's children and Gentlemen's should be brought up in learning, qhe saith that they may have Terence read unto them, but them, when they shall be grown in age and judgement. Though doubting least even then too the 7poison of his filthiness may be more forcible then the counter-poison to be used against it he addeth that he would not grant him this place neither in their education, but that Tully had made good account of him, and profited in eloquence by him. Now the same reasons, that, in choice of authors to be read by us, exclude so fine a Poet, and send us unto purer fountains of good literature: do likewise in the practise of style, the frame of speech, and employment of memory, exclude such points and matters as Terence is excluded for, and commend unto us more commendable arguments to exercise our wits, our tongues, our pens in. Which the wise Founders and Governors of the worthy Colleges and companies of Students here among us did very well consider: taking order therefore that by rendering and rehearsing of Aristotle; or Tully;
Ignatius Loiola, a man no worse minded in certaine pointes then were the olde Iewish kPharises, whose lsect in his ofspring of Iesuits hee hath renued, mdid forbidde Terence to bee reade in schooles (vnlesse he were purged) least hee should more anoy their maners by his wantonnes, then by his Latin helpe their wittes. nGeorgius Fabricius, not seeing how he may be well purged to this purpose, because the conditions of fond or bad persons, as of lovers, •oores, murmurers, mizers, fretters, ruffians, varlets, flatterers, ⟨p. 124⟩boasters, bawdes, and sycophants, that is, the most of those things which Comedies entreate of, belong to stronger mindes, and to an age confirmed and stayed with some judgement, not to vnskilfull children, before whom they are better omitted and concealed; Fabricius therefore grounding him selfe vpon the iudgement of oAristotle, and pQuintilian, both applyed to Terence, resolveth that hee is not to bee read at all to youths of tender yeares. Wherevnto a light of our vniversitie and country, D. Humfrye, subscribeth and agreeth, in that vpon occasion of shewing how Noblemens children and Gentlemens should bee brought vp in learning, qhe saith that they may haue Terence reade vnto them, but them, when they shall be growen in age and iudgement. Though douting least even then too the 7poyson of his filthines may be more forcible then the coūter-poyson to be vsed against it he addeth that hee would not graunt him this place neither in their education, but that Tullie had made good account of him, and prosited in eloquence by him. Now the same reasons, that, in choise of autours to be read by vs, exclude so fine a Poët, and send vs vnto purer fountaines of good literature: doe likewise in the practise of style, the frame of speech, and imployment of memorie, exclude such points and matters as Terence is excluded for, and commend vnto vs more commendable arguments to exercise our wittes, our tounges, our pennes in. Which the wise Founders and Governours of the worthy Colleges and companies of Students here among vs did very well consider: taking order therefore that by rendring and rehearsing of Aristotle; or Tullie;
by writing, pronouncing, declaiming, disputing, of questions in sundry faculties and arts, the use whereof may serve them afterward to purpose, young men should be made the readier and fitter to confirm the truth, to confute errors, to dehort from evil things, and instruct to good. Neither doeth your subtle matching and comparing of these scholastical exercises with interludes and plays, in as much as you tell me that if I had but said that your plays are toys, unnecessary, vain it had been no more perhaps then is, in strictness, true, because runum modò necessarium; and he, that had tried all things, of his own wise experience pronounceth, svanitas ⟨p. 125⟩vanitatum, & omnia vanitas, yea, even learning, and wisdom, and all things else, except the fear of God which endureth for ever, & you have heard a godly & a learned Preacher in the pulpit affirm, that our declamations, oppositions, suppositions, and such scholastical exercises, are no better then vain things: but these three authorities, wherein you saw not strength sufficient to persuade you that your plays are certainly unnecessary and vain, (your speech concerning them you lay in water with perhaps;) do not convince in deed our disputations, declamations, with the like exercises, to be so. For when our Saviour said that 8one thing is needful, speaking of tthe good part which Mary had chosen in that vshe heard 9his preaching, the word of God preached by him: he did not by commending the needfulness of the end, condemn the means, as needless, whereby the end is attained to. Nay, he did imply rather that the means are consequently needful: as if a natural man should say, We must live, his meaning were that we must have sustenance to live by. And how shall men xhear the word of GOD preached, unless there be Preachers to expound it? How can Preachers expound it, unless they learn the way of ycutting it aright and applying it? How can they learn the way ordinarily: unless they be trained up in Logic and Rhetoric? The necessary use whereof for the sound interpreting of Scripture, it may be that you heard zme show against the Brownists, as well as you heard the Preacher whom you speak of: or if you did not, Saint aAustin, or bHyperius, may serve to inform you. The a•tes then of Rhetoric & Logic are requisite to preaching of the word.
by writing, pronouncing, declaiming, disputing, of questions in sundry faculties and artes, the vse whereof may serue them afterward to purpose, young men should bee made the readier and fitter to confirme the truth, to confute errours, to dehort from evill things, and instruct to good. Neither doeth your suttle matching and comparing of these scholasticall exercises with enterludes and playes, in as much as you tell mee that if I had but said that your playes are toyes, vnnecessarie, vaineit had bene no more perhaps then is, in strictnes, true, because rvnum modò necessarium; and hee, that had tried all things, of his owne wise experience pronounceth, svanitas ⟨p. 125⟩vanitatum, & omnia vanitas, yea, even learning, and wisedome, and all thinges else, except the feare of God which endureth for ever, & you haue heard a godly & a learned Preacher in the pulpitt affirme, that our declamations, oppositions, suppositions, and such scholasticall exercises, are no better then vaine things: but these three autorities, wherein you saw not strength sufficient to perswade you that your playes are certainlie vnnecessarie and vaine, (your speech cōcerning them you lay in water with perhaps;) doe not convince in deede our disputations, declamations, with the like exercises, to be so. For when our Saviour said that 8one thing is needfull, speaking of tthe good part which Marie had chosen in that vshee heard 9his preaching, the word of God preached by him: he did not by commending the needfulnes of the ende, condemne the meanes, as needlesse, wherby the ende is attained to. Nay, hee did imply rather that the meanes are consequentlie needfull: as if a naturall man should say, We must liue, his meaning were that wee must haue sustenance to live by. And how shall men xheare the word of GOD preached, vnlesse there be Preachers to expound it? How can Preachers expound it, vnlesse they learne the way of ycutting it aright and applying it? How can they learne the way ordinarilie: vnlesse they be trained vp in Logike and Rhetorike? The necessarie vse whereof for the sound interpreting of Scripture, it may be that you heard
And the exercises of declaiming, answering, opposing, do help to breed ripeness in those arts. Our Saviours sentence therefore that one thing is needful, argueth not these exercises to be unnecessary. No more doth Solomon's saying that all things are vanity, prove them to be vain. For out of 1those all things him self doeth except, the cfear of God (as you note) and (as you should have noted) the keeping of Gods commandments. Wherefore sith our Students be commanded by God dto employ the pieces of money that he hath given them, in trade and traffic as it were, to make gai•e thereof; ⟨p. 126⟩and the trade, wherein they must employ their time, is, to get them selves all instruments of learning, by which they emay be able to 2exhort with wholesome doctrine; and 3convince such as gainsay it: their practise of exhortatory and convincing faculties, of declamations, of elenches, of oppositions and suppositions, can not be condemned, as vain, by his word, by whom fthe evil servant is condemned, as gunprofitable, for hhiding his talent in the earth. Well may you have heard a Preacher in the pulpit affirm that which you mention: but I doubt whether you understood him well. For you allege him so, as if he had pronounced those exercises simply, & in them selves, vain: Which it were injurious to think, that a learned and a godly Preacher (such do you report him; and I, not knowing who it was, do believe you) should purpose to affirm: seeing Christ; iwhose mouth was never defiled with toy or any vain thing, used certain of them, as oppositions namely. For what are koppositions but arguments objected against a point in question? What was it but an argument objected so by Christ, when against the lSadducees, denying the resurrection, mhe urged a text of Moses? and against the nPharisees, holding no more of Christ but that he was Davids son, a otestimony of David? Yea, in this later he did that which of all things in our disputations might seem to be most vain, object pagainst a trueth, although with purpose for the trueth. It is not to be thought then, that the Preacher, terming our exercises vain, meant that they are such simply and in them selves; but as they are used by us, by many of us, to sundry fruitless ends, not to make us fitter for the qgood and 4need full edifying of men:
And the exercises of declaiming, answering, opposing, doe helpe to breede ripenes in those artes. Our Saviours sentence therefore that one thing is needfull, argueth not these exercises to be vnnecessarie. No more doth Salamons saying that all things are vanitie, proove them to be vaine. For out of 1those all things him selfe doeth except, the cfeare of God (as you note) and (as you should haue noted) the keeping of Gods commaundements. Wherefore sith our Students be commaunded by God dto employ the pieces of moony that hee hath given them, in trade and traficke as it were, to make gai•e therof; ⟨p. 126⟩and the trade, wherein they must employ their time, is, to gett them selves all instrumentes of learning, by whiche they emay be able to 2exhort with wholesome doctrine; and 3convince such as gainsay it: their practise of exhortatorie and convincing faculties, of declamations, of elenches, of oppositions and suppositions, can not be condemned, as vaine, by his woord, by whom fthe evill servant is condemned, as gvnprofitable, for hhyding his talent in the earth. Well may you haue heard a Preacher in the pulpitt affirme that which you mention: but I doubt whether you vnderstoode him well. For you alleage him so, as if he had pronoūced those exercises simply, & in them selves, vaine: Which it were iniurious to thinke, that a learned and a godli• Preacher (such doe you report him; and I, not knowing who it was, doe beleeve you) should purpose to affirme: feing Christ; iwhose mouth was never defiled with toy or anie vaine thing, vsed certaine of them, as oppositions namely. For what are
1Heb. HACCOL with HE (an article as it were) expressed & expounded by Tremellius & Junius, Eccl. 1. 2. & 12. 10Heb. HACCOL wt HE (an article as it were) expressed & expounded by Tremellius & Iunius, Eccl. 1. 2. & 12. 10
nor to advance rgodliness profitable for all things, but to increase or make a show of sthat knowledge, which therefore is called tvanity by the wise man, because it hath vno permanent and lasting commodity, xnor bringeth us salvation and eternal life. Whereof it doeth no more follow that the exercises are vain, as you conclude; then if one should reason that the fear of God, (which you except) is vain, upon that place of Isaiah, yTheir f•are toward me is taught by the precept of men. For, if, notwithstanding that zthe Jews worshipped and feared God in vain, ⟨p. 127⟩fearing him amiss according to the precepts of men, not to his word, yet the fear of God is most beneficial, and awas to some among the Jews too: then may declamations, supposititions, oppositions, and such scholastical exercises be profitable & fruitful, even unto some among us also, though many of us make them vanity of vanities, as vain as that bstrife is which Saint Paul reproveth, I mean, both 5void of wholesome juice, & 6full of poison. But to what purpose are these discourses, will you say, of exercises fit for scholars, and Terence not to be read unto them, till they be of riper years & judgement? To let you understand, that whereas you tell us, you come upon the stage to practise your style, to acquaint your selves with Plautus, to embolden your youth, to try their voices, confirm their memories, frame their speech and action; you are so far from justifying your plays by this defence, that you condemn them more. For if the tale of Jupiter with Danaë, in Eunuchus, should not be read to such as your Melantho and Nais: much less should they be taught the same tale 7urged farther, in Ulysses •edux; and less yet another tale of cwanton Salmacis 8with her boy; in Hippolytus. If they should not as much as salute Terence, the finest Comical Poet, for pureness of the Latin tongue in dTullies judgement: much less should they be made well acquainted with Plautus; and less yet with Rivals. If they should not be suffered to peruse writings of base & filthy quality, nor to cast their eyes, as it were, upon them: much less should they engrave them by heart in their remembrance, express them with voice, commend them with action, deliver them with boldness.
nor to advance rgodlines profitable for all things, but to encrease or make a shew of sthat knowledge, which therfore is called tvanitie by the wise man, because it hath vno permanent and lasting commoditie, xnor bringeth vs salvation and eternall life. Whereof it doeth no more folow that the exercises are vaine, as you conclude; then if one should reason that the feare of God, (which you except) is vaine, vpon that place of Esay, yTheir f•are toward me is taught by the precept of men. For, if, notwithstanding that zthe Iewes worshipped and feared God in vaine, ⟨p. 127⟩fearing him amisse according to the precepts of men, not to his woord, yet the feare of God is most beneficiall, and awas to some among the Iewes too: then may declamations, supposititions, oppositions, and such schol•sticall exercises be profitable & fruitfull, even vnto some among vs also, though many of vs make them vanitie of vanities, as vaine as that bstrife is which Saint Paul reprooveth, I meane, both 5voide of wholesome iuice, & 6ful of poyson. But to what purpose are these discourses, will you say, of exercises fitt for scholers, and Terence not to be read vnto them, till they be of riper yeares & iudgement? To let you vnderstand, that whereas you tell vs, you come vpon the stage to practise your style, to acquaint your selues with Plautus, to embolden your youth, to trye their voices, confirme their memories, frame their speech and action; you are so farre from iustifying your playes by this defense, that you condemne thē more. For if the tale of Iupiter with Danaë, in Eunuchus, should not be read to such as your Melantho and Nais: much lesse should they be taught the same tale
If they should not exercise their style, their speech, their memory, but in honest, virtuous, and commendable matters, which in use of life may serve them to good purpose: much less should they meditate how they may inflame & tender youth with love; entice him to dalliance, to whoredom, to incest; inure their minds and bodies to uncomely, dissolute, railing, boasting, knavish, foolish, brainsick, drunken conceits, words, and gestures. Wherefore to the Timothees, that are among your Students, I must say in like sort as Saint Paul to Timothy: eConsider what I say; and the Lord give you ⟨p. 128⟩understanding in all things.
If they should not exercise their style, their speech, their memorie, but in honest, vertuous, and commendable matters, which in vse of lise may serve them to good purpose: much lesse should they meditate how they may inflame & tender youth with loue; entise him to daliance, to hoordom, to incest; inure their mindes and bodyes to vncoomly, dissolute, railing, boasting, knavish, foolish, brainsicke, drunken conceits, woordes, and gestures. Wherefore to the Timothees, that are among your Students, I must say in like sort as Saint Paul to Timothee: eConsider what I say; and the Lord giue you ⟨p. 128⟩vnderstanding in all things.
Now, the inconveniences and mischiefs of your plays being so notorious and manifold, as I have showed: the rest of mine answer opposed to your reasons devised for their defence, will easily deliver it self from your cavils. For where you having said that your Students did not misspend their time therein, because they spent no more time then useth to be spent in sports, sleep, talk, and learned releasing of the mind from study; and having added thereto that, sith there is a time for sports, plays, dances, and man consisting not of one part alone doeth need recreation, therefore you may be stage-players; I answered to the former, that by the like reason a student haunting a dicing house, or tavern, or stews, might prove that he did not misspend his time thereat; to the later, that recreation is necessary for Scholars, yet would it not beseem them to play at stool-ball among wenches, nor at Mumchance or Maw with idle lost companions; nor at trunks in Guile-halls, nor to dance about Maypoles, nor to rifle in alehouses, nor to carouse in Taverns, nor to steal Deere, nor to rob Orchards: you reply that to compare your plays to these things, it exceedeth the compass of any tolerable resemblance; and thereupon eftsoons you surname them hard and incomparable comparisons. Wherein how incomparably you lavish out of measure, and exceed the compass of any reasonable speech, you may quickly see, now that I have proved your plays to be evil: si•h these things being likewise evil and disorderly, and so agreeing with them in a general point, it is clear they may be resembled thereunto.
Now, the inconveniences and mischiefes of your playes being so notorious and manifold, as I haue shewed: the rest of mine answer opposed to your reasons devised for their defense, will easilie deliver it selfe from your cavills. For where you having said that your Students did not misspend their time therein, because they spent no more time then vseth to be spent in sports, sleepe, talke, and learned releasing of the minde from studie; and having added thereto that, sith there is a time for sportes, playes, danses, and man consisting not of one part alone doeth neede recreation, therefore you may be stage-players; I answered to the former, that by the like reason a student haunting a dicing house, or taverne, or stewes, might proove that he did not misspend his time thereat; to the later, that recreation is necessarie for Schollers, yet would it not beseeme them to play at stoole-ball amonge wenches, nor at Mumchance or Maw with idle lost companions; nor at trunkes in Guile-halls, nor to danse about Maypoles, nor to rifle in alehouses, nor to carowse in Tavernes, nor to steale Deere, nor to robbe Orchyards: you reply that to compare your playes to these things, it exceedeth the compasse of any tollerable resemblance; and therevpon eftsoones you surname them hard and incomparable comparisons. Wherein howe incomparably you lavish out of measure, and exceede the compasse of any reasonable speach, you may quickly see, now that I haue prooved your playes to be evill: si•h these things being likewise evill and disorderlie, and so agreeing with them in a generall point, it is cleere they may be resembled therevnto.
The Scripture compareth four Saviour to an 9usurer, who desireth gain by the money he lendeth; gthe children of light to an unjust steward, who maketh him self friends with his masters goods against a time of need, hthe coming of the Lorde• day to a thief in the night, who cometh suddenly and unlooked for. Comparisons not tolerable, if the special qualities of usurers, of unjust men, of thieves, should be meant: but very good and fit, if we mark the general points that they are matched in. Or, if Scripture-eloquence, which yet St iAustin magnifieth, seem base in your eyes; though, seem it never so ⟨p. 129⟩base, I trust you will not say that to compare our Saviour, and so forth, to these things, it exceedeth the compass of any tolerable resemblance: but the eloquence, the learning, the authority of Homer, whose wit (k you say) 1enlightened both men and Gods together, whose 2majesty you worship with 3prayer and 4thanksgiving, to 5whom you wish eternal glory, and call him 6the eternal old man, will suffice to open your eyes and stop your mouth. For he compareth lvaliant Ajax to an ass, that being in a corn-field will not be driven out with any cudgels of boys till he have filled his belly; the m Grecians and Trojans about Sarpedon's carcass, to flies about a milk-pail in a warm spring-time, all busy and loth to leave it. There are nwho find fault with these comparisons, I grant, as overbase and abject: but your adoration of Homer doeth persuade me, that you will make more of ohis censure, who, for the general drift thereof, approveth them. At least you shall be forced to yield by your own words, in as much as having compared our reproof of your expense in plays to ptheir speech who said of the costly ointment poured upon Christs head, what needed this wast? and being told the difference of that fact from yours; you say, that though you know there is an infinite difference between yours and the action against the which it was hypocritically first used: yet you think it may also be applied against, either the niggardise, or the hypocrisy of any Momus, that shall condemn all expense as cast away, that is sometimes moderately bestowed upon honest sports and pastimes. For how can it be chosen but to compare your charges on plays to those on Christ, must needs exceed the compass of any tolerable resemblance:
The Scripture compareth four Saviour to an 9vsurer, who desireth gaine by the moony hee lendeth; gthe children of light to an vniust steward, who maketh him selfe frendes with his maisters goods against a time of neede, hthe coming of the Lorde• day to a thiefe in the night, who cometh suddenly and vnlooked for. Comparisons not tollerable, if the speciall qualities of vsurers, of vniust men, of the•ves, should bee meant: but very good and fitt, if wee marke the generall points that they are matched in. Or, if Scripture-eloquence, which yet St iAustin magnifieth, seeme base in your eyes; though, seeme it never so ⟨p. 129⟩base, I trust you will not say that to compare our Saviour, and so foorth, to these things, it exceedeth the compasse of any tolerable resemblance: but the eloquence, the learning, the autoritie of Homer, whose witt (k you say) 1enlightned both men and Gods together, whose 2maiestie you worshippe with 3prayer and 4thankesgiuing, to 5whom you wish eternall glorie, and call him 6the eternall olde man, will suffice to open your eyes and stoppe your mouth. For he compareth lvaliant Aiax to an asse, that being in a corne-field will not bee driven out with any cudgels of boyes till he haue filled his belly; the m Grecians and Troians about Sarpedons carkasse, to flies about a milke-paile in a warme spring-time, all busy and loth to leaue it. There are
unless things agreeing in a general point, as you suppose (though falsely) these to do in honesty, may be very well resembled each to other? And 7why should you reprove it in me as a hard incomparable deed: when you think it comparable and soft in your own case? Chiefly, sith you know, that even in the degree of honest matters too, whereon expenses are made, there is an infinite difference between the actions, which you match: I can not say so of those that I compare. Nay, some of the things that I compare your stage-plays with, are less evil; as namely, ⟨p. 130⟩for scholars to play at stoolball among wenches: which to do by day light, in open streets, in their own likeness, were not so unmeet and inconvenient for them, as to be attired in women's raiment, by women, within doors, in the night time, to go to and fro, and come upon the stage, and play Melantho, or Nais. Contrariwise, the action wherewith you match yours; was infinitely better, as your self acknowledge: and had, as you must also acknowledge, 8less bestowed thereon, then yours had. So that your consequution doeth halt here again; It was no wast to be at lesser cost in working a good work on Christ; Ergo it is no wast to be at greater charges in setting forth of plays. But mine is unreprovable; It beseemeth not scholars to play at stoolball among wenches, though modest and chaste; Therefore it beseemeth them not to play wanton women on the stage. The same may I say of the two comparisons, which herewithall you check; the former, alleged out of Salvianus, or out of Scripture rather; the later, adjoined by me for illustrating and opening the former: to wit, that with the players of lewd and naughty parts it fareth as with a fool committing wickedness in pastime; and they are like a mad man, who casteth firebrands, arrows, and mortal things, and saith, was I not in sport? For a mad man casting firebrands, and the like, endangereth bodies only: the players of lewd parts do endanger souls. And a fool committing wickedness in pastime hath seldom many admirers and followers to hurt: the players have as many, as a great Theatre holdeth, and can hear them say, But O Cupido, or, O quàm juvaret.
vnlesse things agreeing in a generall point, as you suppose (though falsly) these to doe in honestie, may be very well resembled eche to other? And 7why should you reproove it in me as a hard incomparable deede: when you thinke it comparable and soft in your own case? Chiefly, sith you know, that even in the degree of honest matters too, whereon expenses are made, there is an infinite difference betwene the actions, which you match: I can not say so of those that I compare. Nay, some of the thinges that I compare your stage-playes with, are lesse evill; as namelie, ⟨p. 130⟩for scholers to play at stooleball among wenches: which to doe by day light, in open streetes, in their owne likenes, were not so vnmeete and inconvenient for them, as to be attired in wemens raiment, by wemen, within doores, in the night time, to goe to and fro, and come vpon the stage, and play Melantho, or Nais. Contrariwise, the action wherewith you match yours; was infinitely better, as your selfe acknowledge: and had, as you must also acknowledge, 8lesse bestowed thereon, then yours had. So that your consequution doeth halt here againe; It was no wast to bee at lesser cost in woorking a good woorke on Christ; Ergo it is no wast to bee at greater charges in setting foorth of playes. But mine is vnreprooveable; It beseemeth not scholers to play at stooleball among wenches, though modest and chast; Therefore it beseemeth them not to play wanton wemen on the stage. The same may I say of the two comparisons, which herewithall you checke; the former, alleaged out of Salvianus, or out of Scripture rather; the later, adioyned by mee for illustrating and opening the former: to weete, that with the players of lewde and naughty parts it fareth as with ae foole committing wickednes in pastime; and they are like a mad man, who casteth firebrands, arrowes, and mortall thinges, and saith, was I not in sport? For a mad man casting firebrandes, and the like, endangereth bodies onely: the players of lewde parts doe endanger sowles. And a foole commiting wickednesse in pastime hath seldome many admirers and folowers to hurt: the players haue as many, as a great Theater holdeth, and can heare them say, But O Cupido, or, O quàm juvaret.
7Quis tule• Gracchos d• sedition que rents? Juvenal. sat. […].Quis tule• Gracchos d• seditione que rentes? Iuvenal. sat. 〈…〉.
8[Greek or Hebrew], or [Greek or Hebrew], it was esteemed by them, who amplified it to the uttermost. Mark. 14. 5. Joh. 12 5. And that may amount to nine or ten pound of our money.〈non-Latin alphabet〉, or 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, it was esteemed by thē, who amplified it to the vttermost. Mark. 14. 5. Ioh. 12 5. And that may amount to nine or ten pound of our moony.
Wherefore when you amplify hereupon, and tell me, you could have wished that such comparisons had been forborne, if not for the plays them selves, though also they ought for the plays them selves, being things that savour of some wit, learning, and judgement; yet in respect of the actors, your whole house, the spectators, approvers, authors, writers; all which points you load with pathetical circumstances otherwhere entreated of: you force me to say I could have wished also that you had forborne these Galba-tricks of seeking to prejudice the trueth and equity of causes with partial affections and respect of persons, a qthing ⟨p. 131⟩condemned by Scripture; and that you had considered that if plays savouring of some wit learning, and judgement, ought not to be compared to such things as I mentioned, then your self did ill in praising and allowing that part of my discourse, wherein the fool and mad man served for comparisons. For you gave testimony thereof, that I had written copiously and truly against the bad effects of stage-plays in general. Yea, specifying the proofs that I made by sundry examples and authorities, among which the authority of Salvianus was, you soothed it as containing a truth, and well handled. But the stage-plays spoken of by Salvianus, did savour of some wit, learning, and judgement: as what play doeth nor? at least of all those that any ancient Poet wrote. Your reason therefore brought from the savour of wit learning, and judgement, to cross my comparisons; doeth cross your own allowance of that which you acknowledged to be well spoken against the bad effects of stage-plays in general. And thus, as rLycurgus the Thracian imagining that he was hewing down a vine with his hatchet, is said to have slain his son, and maimed him self: likewise you intending to show that my comparisons are hard and incomparable, and exceed the compass of any tolerable resemblance, and should have been forborne, have wounded unawares your eternal old man, and your self grievously.
Wherefore when you amplifie herevpon, and tell me, you could haue wisht that such comparisons had bene forborne, if not for the playes them selves, though also they ought for the playes them selves, being thinges that savour of some witt, learning, and iudgement; yet in respect of the actors, your whole house, the spectators, approovers, autours, writers; all which points you loade with patheticall circumstances otherwhere entreated of: you force me to say I could haue wisht also that you had forborne these Galba-trickes of seeking to preiudice the trueth and equitie of causes with partiall affections and respect of persons, a qthing ⟨p. 131⟩condemned by Scriptire; and that you had considered that if playes savouring of some witt learning, and iudgement, ought not to be compared to such things as I mentioned, then your selfe did ill in praysing and allowing that part of my discourse, wherein the foole and mad man served for comparisons. For you gaue testimonie therof, that I had written copiously and truly against the bad effects of stage-playes in generall. Yea, specifying the proofes that I made by sundry examples and autorities, among which the autoritie of Salvianus was, you soothed it as containing a truth, and well handled. But the stage-playes spoken of by Salvianus, did savour of some witt, learning, and iudgement: as what play doeth nor? at least of all those that any ancient Poët wrote. Your reason therfore brought from the savour of witt learning, and iudgement, to crosse my comparisons; doeth crosse your owne allowance of that which you acknowledged to be well spoken against the bad effects of stage-playes in generall. And thus, as rLycurgus the Thracian imagining that hee was hewing downe a vine with his hatchet, is said to have slaine his sonne, and maimed him selfe: likewise you intending to shew that my comparisons are hard and incomparable, and exceede the compasse of any tolerable resemblance, and should haue bene forborne, haue wounded vnawares your eternall olde man, and your selfe greevously.
A more grievous wound have you given your self in saying that you presumed your plays to be lawful, when you made your simple assertion (so you term it) that there is a needful time for sports. For this is in effect as much as if you said, that you played the sSophister, 9begging the point in question, and taking it as granted. The which kind of dealing, if it had any sinews to grapple with an adversary, the Jesuits might trouble us, by saying that the Catholic faith must be kept; and they presume that Popery is the Catholic faith. Likewise the meanest advocate in a court of law might speed all his clients, by saying that such as have wrong offered them, ought to be relieved; and he presumeth his clients have so. Neither had you needed to write so long a reply of twelve leaves to me: twelve words might have sufficed, that you presume my cause is naught, and ⟨p. 132⟩naughty things must not be credited. But your self acknowledge that this proveth not the lawfulness of your plays. So that, in affirming you did presume them to be lawful, and calling it a simple assertion which you avowed concerning sports, you speak more trueth then you intended. For it is a simple assertion in deed to say that sports are needful, against a mans arguments who saith that stage-plays are unlawful. And he may be justly noted of presumption, who, being unable to prove a thing he fancieth, condemneth them as Momes that are minded otherwise and bring sound proof against it.
A more greevous wound haue you giuen your selfe in saying that you presumed your playes to be lawfull, when you made your simple assertion (so you terme it) that there is a needfull time for sports. For this is in effect as much as if you saide, that you played the sSophister, 9begging the point in question, and taking it as granted. The which kinde of dealing, if it had any sinewes to graple with an adversarie, the Iesuits might trooble vs, by saying that the Catholike faith must be kept; and they presume that Poperie is the Catholike faith. Likewise the meanest advocate in a court of law might speede all his clients, by saying that such as haue wrong offered them, ought to be releeved; and hee presumeth his clients haue so. Neither had you needed to write so long a reply of twelue leaves to me: twelue wordes might haue sufficed, that you presume my cause is naught, and ⟨p. 132⟩naughty things must not be credited. But your selfe acknowledge that this prooveth not the lawfulnes of your playes. So that, in affirming you did presume them to bee lawfull, and calling it a simple assertion which you avowed concerning sports, you speake more trueth then you intended. For it is a simple assertion in deede to say that sports are needfull, against a mans arguments who saith that stage-playes are vnlawfull. And hee may be iustly noted of presumption, who, beeing vnable to proove a thing he fansieth, condemneth them as Momes that are minded otherwise and bring sound proofe against it.
sAristo. de • prehē. Soph.Aristo. de • prehē. Soph.
Howbeit, had you kept your self within the compass of such oversights, you were more excusable. But it is a greater fault to play the slanderer by falsifying mens words, and fathering upon them an erroneous sentence, which never came into their minds, nor fell out of their mouths or pens. And what do you else, when having said that I use many words against dancing, you reply that you love to see honest dancing; and, you see no cause in reason, charity, or Christian liberty, why dancing should simply be condemned. For hereby you insinuate, or pronounce rather, that I condemned dancing simply, and honest dancing: whereas my words were that dances of Penelope's wooers, of Melantho, of other of her maids, and simply all stage-dancing do savour of dishonesty. Which differeth as much from that you father on me, as the speech of Christ, tDestroy ye this temple, & in three days I will raise it up again, meaning of his body, did differ from that which vthe false witnesses affirmed him to have said of the temple of God, xthe temple made with hands. Nay, it surpasseth that of the false witnesses: it differeth as much as if, where Christ said, that yall ungodly men shall perish, they had fathered on him that all men shall perish. And your crime herein is the more blameworthy, because I had so plainly excepted certain dancing, that you can not seem to have mistaken my words, and read all dancing, for all stage-dancing; but wilfully and advisedly to have misreported me. For I said expressly, I meant those dances that I specified, and not zDavids dancing, which St aAmbrose doeth well distinguish from them. Now St Ambrose saith that Davids religious and ⟨p. 133⟩godly dancing is decent: but 1the dangerous dancing practised by players, and the 2foolish toys, the dotages, of the stage; 3are faulty even in youth too. So both mine own words, and the author I cited, do manifestly show, that when you took upon you to praise honest dancing, and said you saw no cause in charity or reason why dancing should simply be condemned, you could not but in reason and charity see cause, why you should have dealt more simply and honestly, then so calumniously to raise a false surmise of me. You know what creature it is, whom the bscripture nameth a 4calumniator.
Howbeit, had you kept your selfe within the compasse of such oversights, you were more excusable. But it is a greater fault to play the sclanderer by falsifying mens wordes, and fathering vpon them an erroneous sentence, which never came into their mindes, nor fell out of their mouths or pennes. And what doe you else, when having saide that I vse many wordes against dansing, you reply that you loue to see honest dansing; and, you see no cause in reason, charitie, or Christian libertie, why dansing should simply be condemned. For hereby you insinuate, or pronounce rather, that I condemned dansing simply, and honest dansing: whereas my wordes were that danses of Penelopes wooers, of Melantho, of other of her maides, and simply all stage-dansing do savour of dishonestie. Which differeth as much from that you father on me, as the speech of Christ, tDestroy ye this temple, & in three dayes I will raise it vp againe, meaning of his body, did differ from that which vthe false witnesses affirmed him to haue said of the temple of God, xthe temple made with handes. Nay, it surpasseth that of the false witnesses: it differeth as much as if, where Christ saide, that yall vngodly men shall perish, they had fathered on him that all men shall perish. And your crime herein is the more blamewoorthy, because I had so plainly excepted certaine dansing, that you can not seeme to haue mistaken my wordes, and reade all dansing, for all stage-dansing; but wilfully and advisedly to haue misreported mee. For I said expressely, I meant those danses that I specified, and not zDavids dansing, which St aAmbrose doeth well distinguish from them. Now St Ambrose saith that Davids religious and ⟨p. 133⟩godly dansing is decent: but 1the dangerous dansing practised by players, and the 2foolish toyes, the dotages, of the stage; 3
Beside, as you offend in charging me with that I said not: so in going about to overthrow that which I said. For whereas I affirmed that dancing of Penelope's wooers with her maids, and simply all stage-dancing, is disallowed by the light of nature; and for proof thereof did allege the testimonies, of Romans putt by Nero, of Philistines putting Samson to it, and of all ancient 1laws in a manner, yea of reason it self, as Arias Montanus noteth: you, avouching two mens opinions to the contrary, do add, that to apply, either the dancing of those noble Romans, whom Nero enforced to dance so publicly; or, Samsons dancing among the Philistines; or, the note of Arias Montanus, against your dancing only of two sober measures, is a comparison without all measure. Wherein first, through negligence of marking my words, or desire of crossing them before you understood them, you misreport my drift: and say that I applied those things against your dancing only of two sober measures, (you mean, the wooers dancing with the maids,) which I applied not against it alone, but against the rest of your stage-dancing also, that is, all your stage-playing. For this did I betoken by the name of stage-dancing, the better to express the sentence, that I had in hand, of Saint Ambrose, who by 5dancing noteth all histrionical motions and playings on the stage, in like sort as cHorace saith, 8one was requested to dance Polyphemus, meaning to play his part; and 7Plancus danced Glaucus, in dUelleius story; and g stage-players danced Oedipus, and Hercules, in eMacrobius; and fArnobius speaketh of 9dancing Europa, Leda, Ganymedes. Neither was it hard for you to perceive that I meant ⟨p. 134⟩thus much, if you had better weighed the branches of my speech, & proofs thereto answering, concluded with the note of Arias Montanus, touching not only dancers, but persons of such shows & spectacles. Chiefly if you had looked on the author him self, and marked that in the persons of such shows and spectacles, he compriseth stage-players; as the 1generality of his words, exemplified by Nero, maketh plain.
Beside, as you offend in charging me with that I said not: so in going about to overthrow that which I said. For whereas I affirmed that dansing of Penelopes wooers with her maides, and simply all stage-dansing, is disallowed by the light of nature; and for proofe thereof did alleage the testimonies, of Romans putt by Nero, of Philistines putting Samson to it, and of all ancient 1lawes in a manner, yea of reason it selfe, as Arias Montanus noteth: you, avouching two mens opinions to the contrarie, doe adde, that to apply, either the dansing of those noble Romans, whom Nero enforced to danse so publikely; or, Samsons dansing among the Philistines; or, the note of Arias Montanus, against your dansing onely of two sober measures, is a comparison without all measure. Wherein first, through negligence of marking my words, or desire of crossing them before you vnderstood them, you misreport my drift: and say that I applyed those thinges against your dansing onely of two sober measures, (you meane, the wooers dansing with the maides,) which I applyed not against it alone, but against the rest of your stage-dansing also, that is, all your stage-playing. For this did I betoken by the name of stage-dansing, the better to expresse the sentence, that I had in hand, of Saint Ambrose, who by 5dansing noteth all histrionicall motions and playings on the stage, in like sort as cHorace saith, 8one was requested to danse Polyphemus, meaning to play his part; and 7Plancus dansed Glaucus, in dUelleius storie; and g stage-players dansed Oedipus, and Hercules, in eMacrobius; and fArnobius speaketh of 9dansing Europa, Leda, Ganymedes. Neither was it hard for you to perceiue that I meant ⟨p. 134⟩thus much, if you had better weighed the branches of my speech, & proofes therto answering, concluded with the note of Arias Montanus, touching not onely dansers, but persons of such shewes & spectacles. Chiefly if you had looked on the autour him selfe, and marked that in the persons of such shewes and spectacles, he compriseth stage-players; as the
16 Pastorē saltaret uti Cyclopa, rogabat: Nil illi larva, aut tragicis opus esse cothurnis.6 Pastorē saltaret vti Cyclopa, rogabat: Nil illi larva, aut tragicis opus esse cothurnis.
5Saltationis lubricae histrionicos motus & scenae deliramenta.
9Si Europa, fi Leda, si Ganymedes fuerit saltatus, aut Dana. compescit motum irarum Jupiter?Si Europa, fi Leda, si Ganymedes fuerit saltatus, aut Dana. cōpescit motum irarum Iuppiter?
1Hujus generis actions ingenuo homine indigniffimas duxerunt, qui de virtute vera, deque corruptis hominū moribus prudenter loq•ti sunt. Ut ille de Nerone: In scena nunquā cantavit Orestes. &c. Juv. sat. 8Hujus generis actiones ingenuo homine indigniffimas duxerunt, qui de virtute vera, deque corruptis hominū moribus prudēter loq•ti sunt. Vt ille de Nerone: In scena nunquā cantavit Orestes. &c. Iuv. sat. 8
word, betokening this in the originall text, is the very same with that whereby
the armour of Saul is described to haue bene put on David. Now if David who put off Sauls armour by and by, within halfe an howre, a quarter, or lesse much; yet had it put on, after the phrase of Scripture:
some by putting away a good conscience, made shipwracke of their faith: so it may bee feared that you, by putting trueth and singlenes away, will hazard the shipwracke of common sense and reason.
in more generall termes, then Phoedra wooed Hippolytus, his consent was woon to her incestuous lust. But of all absurd speeches in this matter, that may beare the bell, that having asked who could be the woorse for her wooing Hippolytus in so generall termes, you inferre thereon: The drift whereof if it had bene to procure an honest honorable mariage, as it was covertlie to allure him to incest, he might very well haue listned to it. As if one of them, vnto whom
Salomon attributeth this speech, Cast in thy lott among vs, wee will all haue one purse, should say that none could bee the worse for his entising in so generall termes: the drift whereof if it had bene to draw men to lawfull warre against enemies, as it was to vnlawfull spoiling of the innocent, they might very well haue listned to it.
Vellem, si lic•et.
14Si libet, licet. An nescis •e imperatorem •se; & leges dare, non accipere?
should not onely learne such things as are well vttered, but, & that much rather, such things as are honest; forbiddeth them to reade at all any poëmes of
till they bee growen to greater maturitie of yeares, and strength of age. In which sort hee alloweth them to reade Menanders Comedies also, and others,
style he willeth to be exercised in commō places, either against vices, or touching doubtfull questions; in praysing good, dispraysing evill: in reporting trueth; in defense of innocencie; and the like matters that may serve an
Austin reprooving the course of the world which traineth vp their children in Poëts wanton tales of Iupiters adulteries, and vseth to defend their custome by saying, Hence are wordes learned, hence is eloquence gotten:
against a trueth, although with purpose for the trueth. It is not to be thought then, that the Preacher, terming our exercises vaine, meant that they are such simply and in them selves; but as they are vsed by vs, by many of vs, to sundry fruitlesse endes, not to make vs fitter for the
Tullies iudgement: much lesse should they be made well acquainted with Plautus; and lesse yet with Rivales. If they should not be suffered to peruse writings of base & filthy qualitie, nor to cast their eyes, as it were, vpon them: much lesse should they engraue them by heart in their remembrance, expresse them with voice, commend them with action, deliver them with boldnes.
dLimone, apud Dona•ū in vita Teren•.Limone, apud Dona•ū in vita Teren•.
his censure, who, for the generall drift thereof, approoveth them. At least you shall be forced to yeeld by your owne wordes, in as much as having compared our reproofe of your expense in playes to
their speech who saide of the costly ointment powred vpon Christes head, what needed this wast? and being tolde the difference of that fact from yours; you say, that though you knowe there is an infinite difference betwene yours and the action against the which it was hypocritically first vsed: yet you thinke it may also bee applyed against, either the niggardise, or the hypocrisie of any Momus, that shall condemne all expense as cast away, that is sometimes moderatly bestowed vpon honest sports and pastimes. For how can it be chosen but to compare your charges on playes to those on Christ, must needes exceede the compasse of any tolerable resemblance:
are faultie even in youth too. So both mine owne woords, and the autour I cited, doe manifestlie shew, that whē you tooke vpō you to prayse honest dansing, and said you saw no cause in charitie or reason why dansing should simply be condemned, you could not but in reason and charitie see cause, why you should have dealt more simply and honestly, then so calumniouslie to raise a false surmise of me. You know what creature it is, whom the