A14095:718
A discovery of D. Jacksons vanity. Or A perspective glass, whereby the admirers of…A discovery of D. Iacksons vanitie. Or A perspective glasse, wherby the admirers of…
A discovery of D. Jacksons vanity. Or A perspective glass, whereby the admirers of D. Jacksons profound discourses, may see the vanity and weakness of them, in sundry passages, and especially so far as they tend to the undermining of the doctrine hitherto received. Written by William Twice, Doctor of Divinity, as they say, from whom the copy came to the pressA discovery of D. Iacksons vanitie. Or A perspective glasse, wherby the admirers of D. Iacksons profound discourses, may see the vanitie and weaknesse of them, in sundry passages, and especially so farre as they tende to the undermining of the doctrine hitherto received. Written by William Twisse, Doctor of Divinitie, as they say, from whom the copie came to the presse
Amsterdam: printed by the successors of Giles Thorp, 1631
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Yet let us see how well you perform that you undertake. Your syllogism is this. Whatsoever God hath decreed must of necessity come to pass, but God hath decreed contingency as well as necessity, therefore of necessity there must be contingency. And for the better strengthening of your discourse or argumentation, you make a motion that an additional to the Major which is this, Nothing can come to pass otherwise then God hath decreed it shall or may come to pass. Now the judge, or Chancellor in Logical Courts to whom such a motion should be made, would cry out shame upon it. For that proposition ⟨p. 270⟩is an universal affirmative, and you desire that an universal negative should be added to it to make up an entire Major proposition, which were like a sixth finger upon an hand. And indeed in that case it were neither Categorical nor Hypothetical. For though two propositions with a copulative have place in some Hypothetical syllogisms, yet it is always by way of negation thus, Non & dies est, & nox: sed dies est, ergo non nox, Againe upon a second consideration, the motion would be rejected as being altogether without wit. For as much as the conclusion intended is well enough inferred without it, and this additional confers no strength to improve the inference. I appeal to every scholars judgment in this.
Yet let us see how well you performe that you undertake. Your syllogisme is this. Whatsoever God hath decreed must of necessity come to passe, but God hath decreed contingency as well as necessity, therefore of necessity there must be contingency. And for the better strengthning of your discourse or argumentation, you make a motion that an additionall to the Maior which is this, Nothinge can come to passe otherwise then God hath decreed it shall or may come to passe. Now the judge, or Chancelour in Logicall Courts to whome such a motion should be made, would cry out shame upon it. For that proposition ⟨p. 270⟩is an universall affirmative, and you desire that an universall negative should be added to it to make up an entire Maior proposition, which were like a sixt finger upon an hand. And indeed in that case it were neither Categoricall nor Hypotheticall. For though two propositions with a copulative have place in some Hypotheticall syllogismes, yet it is alwayes by way of negation thus, Non & dies est, & nox: sed dies est, ergo non nox, Againe upon a second consideration, the motion would be rejected as being altogether without witt. For as much as the conclusion intended is well enough inferred without it, and this additionall conferres no strength to improve the inference. I appeale to every schollars judgment in this.