A14350:3707
The common places of the most famous and renowned divine Doctor Peter Martyr divided into four principal parts: with a large addition of many theological and necessary discourses, some never extant before. Translated and partly gathered by Anthony Marten, one of the sewers of her Majesties most honourable chamber.The common places of the most famous and renowmed diuine Doctor Peter Martyr diuided into foure principall parts: with a large addition of manie theologicall and necessarie discourses, some neuer extant before. Translated and partlie gathered by Anthonie Marten, one of the sewers of hir Maiesties most honourable chamber.
Imprinted at London : In Pater noster Rowe, by Henry Denham and Henry Middleton at the costs and charges of Henry Denham, Thomas Chard, William Broome, and Andrew Maunsell, 1583Imprinted at London : In Pater noster Rovve, by Henry Denham and Henry Middleton at the costs and charges of Henrie Denham, Thomas Chard, VVilliam Broome, and Andrew Maunsell, 1583
No title page in the transcription: set from the catalogue record.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
134 Now must I dissolve those arguments, which we objected on the other part. Wherefore (say they) is he more reproved now, than he was before, when he went unto the Moabites? I answer, that the consideration was otherwise, both of the time, of Davids mind, and of the nation. §1For first, he did not then draw so many soldiers with him. Secondly, he went not with the mind to war on the Moabites side; but that he might place among them his old father and mother. Neither had he as yet received the word of the Lord, to return: for there he was first admonished by Gad [the prophet] that he should return into Jewry. Neither were the Moabites so strange unto the Jews, as were the Philistines: 2for they were of the posterity of Lot. And God, 3in the second chapter of Deuteronomy, had strictly commanded the Jews, that they should not meddle with their fields: wherefore the reason is not alike. But whether David did well, in going to the Moabites; I do not here dispute. Certainly, it appeareth that the same journey pleased not GOD very well; in that he afterward willed him to be called back by Gad. §2But he was urged, both by the persecution of Saul, and by the treason of his own kindred; that of necessity, either he was to die, or else to fly unto the Philistines. Nay rather, by this flight he did not avoid danger, but he changed one for another: for he cast himself into a more dangerous state among the Philistines, than if he had tarried still in Judea. But it is not the part of a wise or godly man, through fear and feeble courage, to take in hand or do those things, which are not convenient for his person.
134 Now must I dissolue those arguments, which we obiected on the other part. Wherefore (saie they) is he more reprooued now, than he was before, when he went vnto the Moabites? I answer, that the consideration was otherwise, both of the time, of Dauids mind, and of the nation. §1For first, he did not then drawe so manie soldiers with him. Secondlie, he went not with the mind to warre on the Moabites side; but that he might place among them his old father and mother. Neither had he as yet receiued the word of the Lord, to returne: for there he was first admonished by Gad [the prophet] that he should returne into Iewrie. Neither were the Moabites so strange vnto the Iewes, as were the Philistines: 2for they were of the posteritie of Lot. And God, 3in the second chapter of Deuteronomie, had strictlie commanded the Iewes, that they should not meddle with their féelds: wherefore the reason is not alike. But whether Dauid did well, in going to the Moabites; I doo not here dispute. Certeinlie, it appéereth that the same iournie pleased not GOD verie well; in that he afterward willed him to be called backe by Gad. §2But he was vrged, both by the persecution of Saule, and by the treason of his owne kindred; that of necessitie, either he was to die, or else to flie vnto the Philistines. Naie rather, by this flight he did not auoid danger, but he changed one for another: for he cast himselfe into a more dangerous state among the Philistines, than if he had taried still in Iudaea. But it is not the part of a wise or godlie man, through feare and féeble courage, to take in hand or doo those things, which are not conuenient for his person.
Saul pursueth thee: The Ziphits betray thee, but God hath bewrayed their lying in wait unto thee; so as they shall not be able to hurt thee: Saul again and again cometh into thy danger. But it is a grievous thing thus to live perpetually. Admit it be so; yet God by these kind of chastisements, frameth thee to be a king in time to come. Briefly; These things thou doest, either for the mistrust thou hast in God; or else in hatred of the cross. If for mistrust sake, refer thy self unto the promises of God; and consider what he hath before time done for thy sake. If in hatred of the cross, rather lament thou this infirmity of flesh, which so cleaveth to our nature, as it may not be removed, no not from the most holy men. As touching that argument, wherein it is said, that either we must fly, or else suffer death: it is weak and unperfect. For add a third point; namely, that thou tarry there, where the Lord hath placed thee, and thou shalt hope that he will no less be present now with thee, than he hath been before time. §3Thou sayest that it behooved David, not only to have a regard unto himself; but also unto the six hundred soldiers, which he had with him. The Jews would not of their own accord give him any thing; to wring from them by violence, it was not lawful for him: but the mind was to be elevated unto God; he had promised that he would bring help, and ⟨p. 295⟩that he would stand to his covenants. He should not in any wise have departed from his station, wherein God had placed him. Further, there was no need, that either he should have used violence, or expected the liberality of his own countrymen. The Philistines were borderers, being enemies unto the name of the Jews, and already condemned of God: from them it was lawful to take preys; for so he did before, and God did prosper his endeavours.
Saule pursueth thée: The Ziphits betraie thée, but God hath bewraied their lieng in wait vnto thée; so as they shall not be able to hurt thée: Saule againe and againe commeth into thy danger. But it is a gréeuous thing thus to liue perpetuallie. Admit it be so; yet God by these kind of chastisements, frameth thée to be a king in time to come. Bréeflie; These things thou dooest, either for the mistrust thou hast in God; or else in hatred of the crosse. If for mistrust sake, refer thy selfe vnto the promises of God; and consider what he hath before time doone for thy sake. If in hatred of the crosse, rather lament thou this infirmitie of flesh, which so cleaueth to our nature, as it may not be remooued, no not from the most holie men. As touching that argument, wherein it is said, that either we must flie, or else suffer death: it is weak and vnperfect. For adde a third point; namelie, that thou tarrie there, where the Lord hath placed thée, and thou shalt hope that he will no lesse be present now with thée, than he hath béen before time.
Consideration was to be had of friends, who because they seemed to favour David that was banished, were ill entreated by Saul. Certainly, friends ought not rashly to be contemned: but we must take heed, least while thou wouldst deliver them, thou bring not a greater infamy upon them. For it was a far more grievous thing, that David fled unto the Philistines, than that he was condemned by Saul: but thou must rather suffer death, than that others should come in peril for thy sake. But we must not always respect that which is magnifical and glorious, but that which is pleasing unto God. The occasion offered, was not to be contemned. §5I answer: He doth those things, that we may the more easily suffer adversities. Further, it had been his part, to hope that GOD will not always suffer the better sort to be afflicted; or that the church should be oppressed with continual might. §6This should a wise man think. If he had done otherwise, it had been to have tempted God. No verily, he should rather have put his trust in God, & have tarried in that place, whereunto God had called him.
Consideration was to be had of fréends, who bicause they séemed to fauour Dauid that was banished, were ill intreated by Saule. Certeinlie, friends ought not rashlie to be contemned: but we must take héed, least while thou wouldst deliuer them, thou bring not a greater infamie vpon them. For it was a farre more gréeuous thing, that Dauid fled vnto the Philistines, than that he was condemned by Saule: but thou must rather suffer death, than that others should come in perill for thy sake. But we must not alwaies respect that which is magnificall and glorious, but that which is pleasing vnto God. The occasion offered, was not to be contemned. §5I answere: He doth those things, that we may the more easilie suffer aduersities. Further, it had béene his part, to hope that GOD will not alwaies suffer the better sort to be afflicted; or that the church should be oppressed with continuall might. §6This should a wise man thinke. If he had doone otherwise, it had béene to haue tempted God. No verelie, he should rather haue put his trust in God, & haue taried in that place, wherevnto God had called him.
He had promised to help him. But the promise of God maketh not men to be as stocks or blocks, that it should not be lawful for any man to provide for himself. I grant it doth not: howbeit, we ought by faith to wait for the help of God; we must not step back through fear and mistrust. If there were no surety to live in the court of Saul, much less safety was it to live among the Philistines. §8Christ went unto the men of Tyre and Sidon, and to the Samaritans. I know he did: but that was not to take their part against the Jews; but to teach them the Gospel, that he might bring them to God, & heal them, and bestow benefits upon them. §9Some end was once to be appointed unto the sins of Saul: but yet not so, as thou shouldst cast thy self into greater sins. Many fond and miserable men will have Masses and Dirges to be said for the souls of them that be dead. But while they would deliver them out of purgatory, let them take heed, that they themselves run not headlong into hell. Paul warneth, that We ought not to do evil, 1that good may come thereof. Wherefore this fact was neither godly, nor yet beseeming for the person of David. So that we confess, he sinned as well in this, as in other things.
He had promised to helpe him. But the promise of God maketh not men to be as stocks or blocks, that it should not be lawfull for anie man to prouide for himselfe. I grant it doth not: howbeit, we ought by faith to wait for the helpe of God; we must not step backe through feare and mistrust. If there were no suretie to liue in the court of Saule, much lesse safetie was it to liue among the Philistines. §8Christ went vnto the men of Tyre and Sidon, and to the Samaritans. I know he did: but that was not to take their part against the Iewes; but to teach them the Gospell, that he might bring them to God, & heale them, and bestowe benefits vpon them. §9
35 But Augustine upon the psalms, saith; that Sin is of two sorts; one of necessity, 1and another (as he himself speaketh) of abundance & plenty. If question be asked of many, wherefore they steal: they will answer, that necessity constraineth them, to the intent they may have wherewith to maintain their wife and children. In deed this is some necessity, yet it is not absolute; it is but only by supposition: if a man be of that mind, that he will in any wise live and maintain himself, by what means so ever it be. Others there are, who being rich, yet they never cease pilling of the poor: and that not of any necessity that they have, but of an insatiable covetousness. The sin of David belonged unto the former sort. Neither do I speak this, to extenuate his sin; but only that it may be understood, unto what kind his sin ought to be referred. In explaining of all the arguments, we have showed what we are to do, if perhaps we fall into the like trouble. Now let us see, what, by this fact of David, 2may be gathered for our edifying. First, we ought here as in a glass, to behold our own infirmity: for God would have that to be known to us, not that we should the more freely sin, but that we should bewail our own state, and sigh towards heaven.
35 But Augustine vpon the psalmes, saith; that Sinne is of two sorts; one of necessitie, 1and another (as he himselfe speaketh) of abundance & plentie. If question be asked of manie, wherefore they steale: they will answer, that necessitie constraineth them, to the intent they may haue wherewith to maintaine their wife and children. In déed this is some necessitie, yet it is not absolute; it is but onelie by supposition: if a man be of that mind, that he will in anie wise liue and maintaine himselfe, by what means so euer it be. Others there are, who being rich, yet they neuer cease pilling of the poore: and that not of anie necessitie that they haue, but of an insatiable couetousnesse. The sinne of Dauid belonged vnto the former sort. Neither doo I speake this, to extenuate his sinne; but onelie that it may be vnderstood, vnto what kind his sinne ought to be referred. In explaning of all the arguments, we haue shewed what we are to doo, if perhaps we fall into the like trouble. Now let vs sée, what, by this fact of Dauid,
Moreover, we see of what sincerity the holy scriptures be: for they do not only set forth unto us the virtues of holy men, but also their errors and sins; least we should trust in our own selves, as though we are to determine of our own strength. Augustine in his 49. sermon De tempore; After we shall be come (saith he) to another life, we shall stand firmly; for we shall see the chief felicity, from the which we cannot be drawn by any vile and mortal goods. But here we only see, as through a glass, and in a dark saying. Wherefore when other good things are set before us, we be oftentimes drawn away, and do fall: so that it is our part in this life, to wrestle so much as we can. But especially we must take heed, that we fly not to them, which be enemies to the Gospel: for; 1He which having once tasted the good gift of God, & virtues of the spirit, falleth away again, there remaineth unto him no more sacrifice for sin; but a fearful waiting for the judgement of God. And seeing the devil is a most grievous enemy of God, we must take heed that we fly not unto him with our powers. These things by the doing of David, may be transferred unto us. To fly away and war on the enemies part, is in no wise lawful.
Moreouer, we sée of what sinceritie the holie scriptures be: for they doo not onlie set foorth vnto vs the vertues of holie men, but also their errors and sinnes; least we should trust in our owne selues, as though we are to determine of our owne strength. Augustine in his 49. sermon De tempore; After we shall be come (saith he) to another life, we shall stand firmelie; for we shall sée the chéefe felicitie, from the which we cannot be drawen by anie vile and mortall goods. But here we onelie sée, as through a glasse, and in a darke saieng. Wherfore when other good things are set before vs, we be oftentimes drawen awaie, and doo fall: so that it is our part in this life, to wrestle so much as we can. But especiallie we must take héed, that we flie not to them, which be enimies to the Gospell: for; 1He which hauing once tasted the good gift of God, & vertues of the spirit, falleth awaie againe, there remaineth vnto him no more sacrifice for sinne; but a fearefull waiting for the iudgement of God. And séeing the diuell is a most gréeuous enimie of God, we must take héed that we flie not vnto him with our powers. These things by the dooing of Dauid, may be transferred vnto vs. To flie away and war on the enimies part, is in no wise lawfull.
136 But some do marvel, that holy men, which are accounted just in the holy scriptures, suffered adversities with a slender courage; and that they made not that show of fortitude, which many of the Ethnics made semblance of. We read that Horatius Pulvillus, 2when he was dedicating of a temple, was not amazed to hear of the death of his son, but held fast the post, and performed his dedication. Anaxagoras, when he heard that his son was dead; I knew (saith he) that I begat a mortal man. Paulus Aemilius, having obtained prosperous success, at the time that his sons died, said, that he was favourably heard of the gods immortal: for that he made this petition, That if any calamity were near at hand, the same should be turned, not upon the people of Rome, but upon his house. Brutus executed his own sons: so did Torquatus. Wherefore did not God grant these things to his saints? Why do they seem to be of so base mind in affliction, seeing they know it is laid upon them by God? It seemeth to be a goodly question: but I will in few words absolve it. When I do consider thereof, that cometh to my remembrance, which happened in the ship wherein was carried Aristippus, and a certain other hardy fellow, but unlearned. There arose a grievous tempest, so as the ship was well near sunk: the philosopher was sore afraid. When the tempest was ceased, the other man said; What meantest thou (philosopher) to be so afraid? Surely, I which have not studied philosophy, was not afraid, but with a valiant courage looked for shipwreck. The philosopher somewhat pleasantly answered; Thou oughtest not to be careful for the life of a varlet, I saw the life of Aristippus the philosopher in danger.
136 But some doo maruell, that holie men, which are accounted iust in the holie scriptures, suffered aduersities with a slender courage; and that they made not that shew of fortitude, which manie of the Ethniks made semblance of. We read that Horatius Puluillus, 2when he was dedicating of a temple, was not amazed to heare of the death of his sonne, but held fast the post, and performed his dedication. Anaxagoras, when he heard that his sonne was dead; I knew (saith he) that I begat a mortall man. Paulus Aemilius, hauing obteined prosperous successe, at the time that his sonnes died, said, that he was fauourablie heard of the gods immortall: for that he made this petition, That if anie calamitie were néere at hand, the same should be turned, not vpon the people of Rome, but vpon his house. Brutus executed his owne sonnes: so did Torquatus. Wherefore did not God grant these things to his saints? Why doo they séeme to be of so base mind in affliction, séeing they knowe it is laid vpon them by God? It séemeth to be a goodlie question: but I will in few words absolue it. When I doo consider thereof, that commeth to my remembrance, which happened in the ship wherein was caried Aristippus, and a certeine other hardie fellowe, but vnlearned. There arose a gréeuous tempest, so as the ship was well néere soonke: the philosopher was sore afraid. When the tempest was ceased, the other man said; What meantst thou (philosopher) to be so afraid? Surelie, I which haue not studied philosophie, was not afraid, but with a valiant courage looked for shipwracke. The philosopher somewhat pleasantlie answered; Thou oughtest not to be carefull for the life of a varlot, I sawe the life of Aristippus the philosopher in danger.
Even so do I consider, that it should be no marvel, if holy men and Ethnics behave them selves after a sundry manner; for there is great difference between them. For the Ethnics thought, 1as touching adversities, that they happened through a necessity of nature; or should be abidden without consideration, and that after this life there should remain no life. They had not regard unto the providence of God that governeth all things: or else, if they were of the better sort, they professed the Stoical sect, they followed an *immoveablenes of passions, and *a lack of pain. Because they could not deny, but that they were sometimes troubled with sudden evils; they did *things that came naturally of themselves, *and things that came not of nature, which were taken before hand, even from their childhood: for that those things are laid before us, which we would desire, and which at the first motion we would refuse. And they said, that we must wrestle, not as did the Peripatetics, to moderate affections, but to root them out. But in that wrestling they say, that reason and affection strive for the possession of man. Wherefore they did therein wholly apply themselves. Howbeit, our cause is far otherwise: we do not weigh those adversities themselves, according to their own nature; but we fly unto the cause. We consider, that God is author, and that we have given the cause of that affliction: those be causes of mourning. There faith is stirred up, and the earnester it is, the more sorrow we have for the things which we have committed.
Euen so doo I consider, that it should be no maruell, if holie men and Ethniks behaue them selues after a sundrie maner; for there is great difference betwéene them. For the Ethniks thought, 1as touching aduersities, that they hapned through a necessitie of nature; or should be abidden without consideration, and that after this life there should remaine no life. They had not regard vnto the prouidence of God that gouerneth all things: or else, if they were of the better sort, they professed the Stoicall sect, they followed an
We add, 1that these affections are not altogether stayed by godly men, because they know, that in their own nature they are not evil: for God grafted them in men, at the creation. God saw that all things which he had made were good. He made the soul of man perfect, that it might have both the upper and the grosser parts where these affections be: they be the matter of virtues, and do help them. And to speak of anger, it is the whetstone of fortitude; it helpeth men to do honest things with a valiant courage. There is no affection, which hath not some utility unto honest things. They which go about to extinguish affections, do nothing else, but as they should take away the nature of man. Wherefore the Stoics were foolish men, which therein were wholly bent, that they might take away all affections. Rather ought the apostles to be heard, which say, that they should be moderated. Paul in the first to the Thessalonians, the fourth chapter; 2I would not that ye should sorrow as others which have no hope. He taketh not away mourning, but he giveth a mean.
We adde, 1that these affections are not altogither staied by godlie men, bicause they knowe, that in their owne nature they are not euill: for God graffed them in men, at the creation. God sawe that all things which he had made were good. He made the soule of man perfect, that it might haue both the vpper and the grosser parts where these affections be: they be the matter of vertues, and doo helpe them. And to speake of anger, it is the whetstone of fortitude; it helpeth men to doo honest things with a valiant courage. There is no affection, which hath not some vtilitie vnto honest things. They which go about to extinguish affections, doo nothing else, but as they shuld take awaie the nature of man. Wherefore the Stoikes were foolish men, which therein were wholie bent, that they might take awaie all affections. Rather ought the apostles to be heard, which saie, that they should be moderated. Paule in the first to the Thessalonians, the fourth chapter; 2I would not that ye should sorrowe as others which haue no hope. He taketh not awaie moorning, but he giueth a meane.
37 What is the mean that ought to be used? The Peripatetics reason many things as touching mediocrity: they say, That mean must be used, which a wise man showeth in his life. But mans wisdom is foolishness before God. 1All men are liars. That same mediocrity must be determined by the word of God. If we have sinned, and do live in adversities; let us be sorrowful, but yet so, that we depart not from the word of GOD. Let us do nothing against his word, let us not be alienated from God, nor suffer faith, hope, and charity to be put away. God requireth of us, that valiant courage, 2which the Stoics boasted of, but yet according to right reason. He would not that we should be unreasonable or senseless, as the Stoics would have men to be. Wherefore Crantor in the third book ⟨p. 297⟩of Tusculan questions, thus speaketh; To live altogether without sorrow, happeneth not without unsensiblenes of the mind, and blockishness of the body. But he speaketh tauntinglie. Augustine De civitate Dei, the 14. book, and ninth chapter, writeth; that This unsensiblenes, whereby those affections are cast away, is worse than all vices. Neither is that required, which Aulus Gellius, in the twelve book, the 15. chapter, showeth of a certain sword-player, who while his wounds were lanced by the physicians, did laugh. This is a brutish kind of fortitude. This hath God otherwhile given unto martyrs, that in flames, and other deadly punishments, they would be of a cheerful countenance, 3and would sing. Howbeit, this was given them by an extraordinary way, to the intent that tyrants might be moved, and the standers by be held with admiration: [but] we ought to follow the ordinary way appointed by God.
37 What is the meane that ought to be vsed? The Peripatetiks reason manie things as touching mediocritie: they saie, That meane must be vsed, which a wise man sheweth in his life. But mans wisedome is foolishnes before God. 1All men are liers. That same mediocritie must be determined by the word of God. If we haue sinned, and doo liue in aduersities; let vs be sorrowfull, but yet so, that we depart not from the word of GOD. Let vs doo nothing against his word, let vs not be alienated from God, nor suffer faith, hope, and charitie to be put awaie. God requireth of vs, that valiant courage,
Paul, in the second epistle to the Corinthians, did rightly and wisely express what is to be done in these cases; 1We are afflicted on every side, but yet we faint not; we labour in all things, but are not destitute; even in the persecutions themselves we are not forsaken; we are cast down, but we perish not. Thus fare the minds of the saints: they are afflicted with those sorrows, they are not senseless; yet do they not so sorrow as they will despair. Thus also must we do. Wherefore they, which have brought in a Stoical reason, seem that they would have dealt with blocks; but not have instructed men: they represented unto us a show of wisdom, the which we cannot see expressed any where; neither doth it concur with humane nature. But there be some, which think it to be a wicked thing for godly men to sigh, to groan, or to be sad. 2But these be [Greek or Hebrew]; to wit, such things as are strange, both from the word of God, and from humane nature. We must have an eye unto the word of God.
Paule, in the second epistle to the Corinthians, did rightlie and wiselie expresse what is to be doone in these cases; 1We are afflicted on euerie side, but yet we faint not; we labour in all things, but are not destitute; euen in the persecutions themselues we are not forsaken; we are cast downe, but we perish not. Thus fare the minds of the saints: they are afflicted with those sorrowes, they are not senselesse; yet doo they not so sorrowe as they will despaire. Thus also must we doo. Wherefore they, which haue brought in a Stoicall reason, séeme that they would haue dealt with blocks; but not haue instructed men: they represented vnto vs a shew of wisedome, the which we cannot sée expressed anie where; neither dooth it concurre with humane nature. But there be some, which thinke it to be a wicked thing for godlie men to sigh, to grone, or to be sad. 2But these be 〈non-Latin alphabet〉; to wit, such things as are strange, both from the word of God, and from humane nature. We must haue an eie vnto the word of God.
1Christ saith; The world shall rejoice, and ye shall sorrow; they shall laugh, and ye shall weep. Yea, and he set forth a decree; Blessed are they which mourn, 2for they shall receive comfort. Undoubtedly Paul accounteth those [Greek or Hebrew], 3to wit, they which are without affection, and which be delivered up even to a reprobate sense. In the psalm David saith, under the person of Christ; 4I looked for some man to be sorrowful with me. Paul commandeth us To mourn with them that mourn, 5and rejoice with them that rejoice. The same apostle said; that He greatly longed to see the Romans, 6that he might have some fruit among them. He was jealous over the Corinthians, 7he would have had them not to be seduced by false prophets. He said, 8that He sorrowed for his brethren the Israelites, and wished to be separated from Christ for their sakes. Those affections were in him most vehement. He saith that he wrote unto the Corinthians with many tears, 9not with common affection. Peter bitterly wept, when he had denied Christ. 10But why seek we examples of the apostles? Let us have regard to Christ the author of our salvation. 11He was many times moved with pity, when he saw them hungry, which followed him; 12when he saw the Israelites wander like sheep without a shepherd;
38 But they marvel at Christ, 1how he could be troubled with such affections, seeing his soul was blessed, and had always the divine nature joined with him, and in his sight. But it is to be understood, that Christ was not only very God, but also very man: and he had not been very man, unless he had also had a perfect soul, that is to wit, adorned with upper and grosser parts, in the which these affections be. 2Whereupon Augustine, in the place above alleged; Neither had he a counterfeit humane affection, seeing he had the body and soul of a man. Hereupon Ambrose worthily saith; that Christ took upon him, not a show of incarnation, but a truth; and therefore truly had affections. And he added, that this undoubtedly was convenient, that he might overcome sorrow and sadness; but not exclude them. He addeth, saying; Neither is that fortitude commendable, which bringeth in an unsensiblenes of wounds, not a grief. If there be any that know they have so unsensible a body, as they feel not wounds, they have not the commendation of fortitude or valiant courage: but those [have it] which overcome the griefs which they feel. 3Wherefore Hilary must be advisedly read, in his 10. book De Trinitate, who speaketh dangerously of the body of Christ, and of those affections. He affirmeth, that the Lord had a body to suffer, but not to feel pain. And he saith, that the cross, sword, and nails put upon Christ the violence of a passion, 4but not a grief. And he useth a similitude, to wit, that it fared, even as if one would attempt with a sword to thrust through water, fire, or air: he should do violence against these elements, and the sword of his own nature would put to grief; but those bodies be not of that nature, as they can suffer a wound. These things are not ⟨p. 298⟩agreeable to the scripture, and to a true humane body.
38 But they maruell at Christ, 1how he could be troubled with such affections, séeing his soule was blessed, and had alwaies the diuine nature ioined with him, and in his sight. But it is to be vnderstood, that Christ was not only verie God, but also verie man: and he had not béene verie man, vnlesse he had also had a perfect soule, that is to wit, adorned with vpper and grosser parts, in the which these affections be.
On this wise may we argue, that Christ had grief. 1To the feeling of grief in any man, two things are chiefly required: which things being appointed, grief doth follow; first, that the body should be hurt; secondly, that there shall be a feeling of that hurt. But the body of Christ was hurt; being whole, it was broken. The soul of Christ was most perfect, it had sense; Ergo, it was not without feeling. The self same are we to judge as touching sadness. This is the nature thereof, 2that if in the cogitation or imagination we perceive any hurtful thing, that is like to happen, or is present; then it showeth it self. Such cogitations had Christ. Those things were repugnant unto nature; wherefore there followed a sadness: howbeit, that followed not which had sin joined with it. They were perfect motions, they went not beyond the rule of Gods word: they had the nature of a punishment, but not of an offence. Our affections be unpure. What cause of difference is there? Augustine, 3in the place above recited, showeth the reason; because the affections of Christ were derived of power, ours of infirmity. Christ had that power, that he could use these affections, when and as often as he would; but ours do now spring of infirmity, yea and they rise against us whether we will or no. We can not bridle them, wherefore they be troublous; but Christs be clear: not only as they were by institution given unto Adam; but also as they were adorned by the grace of God, they presumed nothing, but so long, and so much as it behooved.
On this wise may we argue, that Christ had gréefe. 1To the féeling of gréefe in anie man, two things are chéeflie required: which things being appointed, gréefe dooth followe; first, that the bodie shuld be hurt; secondlie, that there shall be a féeling of that hurt. But the bodie of Christ was hurt; being whole, it was broken. The soule of Christ was most perfect, it had sense; Ergo, it was not without féeling. The selfe same are we to iudge as touching sadnes. This is the nature thereof, 2that if in the cogitation or imagination we perceiue anie hurtfull thing, that is like to happen, or is present; then it sheweth it selfe. Such cogitations had Christ. Those things were repugnant vnto nature; wherefore there followed a sadnesse: howbeit, that followed not which had sinne ioined with it. They were perfect motions, they went not beyond the rule of Gods word: they had the nature of a punishment, but not of an offense. Our affections be vnpure. What cause of difference is there? Augustine,
39 So then we may assign three differences between Christs affections and ours. The first, as touching the objects; the motions and affections of Christ never declined unto sin, but ours do very often. The second, Christ (as saith Augustine) used, when he judged that they should be used; as when he would that man should be, man was made: it doth not so happen with us; they break forth even against our wills. Thirdly, those perturbations be sometimes so forcible in us, as they disquiet reason it self, and do hinder faith: but it was not thus in Christ. 1Wherefore Jerome upon Matthew, in the handling of that sentence, [He that shall look upon a woman to lust after her, 2&c.] distinguisheth and saith, that There is [Greek or Hebrew], and [Greek or Hebrew], which may be called, suffering, & foresuffering. That [Greek or Hebrew] is always taken in the the ill part, when they vanquish and overcome us. But [Greek or Hebrew] be the first motions, which although they be held under the name of an offence; yet are they not crimes, they do not overcome. But what the difference is between a crime and a sin, Augustine in the 41. 3treatise upon John showeth; Crimes be grievous sins, which have accusation, and deserve condemnation; but sins are of less weight. Wherefore the apostle, when he speaketh touching the ordaining of pastors, will have them to be without crime; not without sin: otherwise he should exclude all men from the ministry.
39 So then we may assigne thrée differences betweene Christs affections and ours. The first, as touching the obiects; the motions and affections of Christ neuer declined vnto sinne, but ours doo verie often. The second, Christ (as saith Augustine) vsed, when he iudged that they should be vsed; as when he would that man should be, man was made: it dooth not so happen with vs; they breake foorth euen against our wils. Thirdlie, those perturbations be sometimes so forcible in vs, as they disquiet reason it selfe, and doo hinder faith: but it was not thus in Christ. 1Wherefore Ierom vpon Matthew, in the handling of that sentence, [He that shall looke vpon a woman to lust after hir,
1Christ saith; The world shall reioise, and ye shall sorrowe; they shall laugh, and ye shall weepe. Yea, and he set foorth a decrée; Blessed are they which moorne, 2for they shall receiue comfort. Vndoubtedlie Paule accounteth those 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, 3to wit, they which are without affection, and which be deliuered vp euen to a reprobate sense. In the psalme Dauid saith, vnder the person of Christ; 4I looked for som man to be sorowfull with me. Paule commandeth vs To moorne with them that moorne, 5and reioise with them that reioise. The same apostle said; that Hee greatlie longed to see the Romans, 6that hee might haue some fruit among them. He was gelous ouer the Corinthians, 7he would haue had them not to be seduced by false prophets. He said, 8that He sorrowed for his brethren the Israelites, and wished to be separated from Christ for their sakes. Those affections were in him most vehement. He saith that he wrote vnto the Corinthians with manie teares, 9not with common affection. Peter bitterlie wéeped, when he had denied Christ. 10But why séeke we examples of the apostles? Let vs haue regard to Christ the author of our saluation. 11He was manie times mooued with pitie, when he sawe them hungrie, which followed him; 12when he sawe the Israelits wander like shéepe without a shepheard; 13when he sawe a mother following the corse of hir onelie sonne. He wept at the sepulchre of Lazarus; 14he wept when he looked vpon Ierusalem, 15and considered that it should be destroied; I haue earnestlie (saith he) desired to eate this passeouer with you. 1617In the garden he was mooued with sadnes, sorrowe caused him to sweat blood. Esaie spake of him; He bare our sorrowes, &c. 18These things are rather to be followed, than the rigorous saiengs of the Stoiks.