An answer to the Ten reasons of Edmund Campian the Jesuit in confidence whereof…An ansvvere to the Ten reasons of Edmund Campian the Iesuit in confidence wherof…
An answer to the Ten reasons of Edmund Campian the Jesuit in confidence whereof he offered disputation to the ministers of the Church of England, in the controversy of faith. Whereunto is added in brief marginal notes, the sum of the defence of those reasons by John Duræus the Scot, being a priest and a Jesuit, with a reply unto it. Written first in the Latin tongue by the reverend and faithful servant of Christ and his Church, William Whitakers, Doctor in Divinity, and the Kings Professor and public reader of Divinity in the University of Cambridge. And now faithfully translated for the benefit of the unlearned (at the appointment and desire of some in authority) into the English tongue; by Richard Stock, preacher in London. ...An ansvvere to the Ten reasons of Edmund Campian the Iesuit in confidence wherof he offered disputation to the ministers of the Church of England, in the controuersie of faith. Whereunto is added in briefe marginall notes, the summe of the defence of those reasons by Iohn Duræus the Scot, being a priest and a Iesuit, with a reply vnto it. Written first in the Latine tongue by the reuerend and faithfull seruant of Christ and his Church, William Whitakers, Doctor in Diuinitie, and the Kings Professor and publike reader of Diuinitie in the Vniuersitie of Cambridge. And now faithfully translated for the benefit of the vnlearned (at the appointment and desire of some in authoritie) into the English tongue; by Richard Stocke, preacher in London. ...
William Whitaker 1548–1595London: printed by Felix Kyngston for Cuthbert Burby and Edmund Weaver, 1606London: printed by Felix Kyngston for Cuthbert Burby and Edmund Weauer, 1606
[40], 326 p. · 97k words · STC 25360 · ESTC S119870
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
A Great controversy for the keeping of the ceremonies of the old law, which in the Primitive Church much moved the minds of faithful people, was by a Council gathered together, of the Apostles and some elders decided. Children then believed their Parents, and sheep their Shepherds, charging them in this sort:a It hath pleased the holy Ghost, and us; after this there were holden four general ⟨p. 90⟩Councils of ancient Fathers, for the rooting out of heresy, which budded up abundantly in every age, which were of such authority aboveb 1000. years ago, that* great honour was attributed unto them, as though it had been unto the four Gospels. I will seek no further; even here in our own Country by anc act of Parliament, the self same Councils do retain still their former force, and pure authority: which said act I will here allege: And call thee, thy self O England, my most loving Country, to witness. If thou reverence, as thou pretendest, those Councils,5 then wilt thou yield up the supremacy to the Bishop of the chief sea, that is, to Saint Peter. Then wilt thou acknowledge upon the altar, the unbloody sacrifice of the body and blood of Christ. Then wilt thou pray the blessed Martyrs and all the Saints in Heaven to make intercession to Christ for thee. Then wilt thou restrain these lecherous Apostates from their filthy carnal copulation, and open incest. Then wilt thou build up many things, which now thou pullest down, and wish many things undone, which now thou doest. Moreover, I promise and undertake, as occasion and time shall serve, to prove, that the* Councils holden at other times, and namely the Council of Trent, have been of equal authority and credit with the four first Councils. Wherefore then should I not come to this place of trial, securely and courageously, to mark into what corner my enemy will creep, seeing I am
aided with the valiant and piked garrison of all the Councils? For I will allege both most manifest matter which he shall not be able to wrest aside, and also most substantially proved, which he dare not contemptuously reject. He will perhaps go about to trifle out the time, with multiplying of many words: but if you be the men that I have always taken you for, you will take so good heed unto him, that he shall neither rob you of your ears nor eyes.
AGreat controuersie for the keeping of the ceremonies of the old law, which in the Primitiue Church much moued the minds of faithfull people, was by a Councell gathered together, of the Apostles and some elders decided. Children then beleeued their Parents, and sheepe their Sheepheards, charging them in this sort:a It hath pleased the holy Ghost, and vs; after this there were holden foure generall ⟨p. 90⟩Councels of auncient Fathers, for the rooting out of heresie, which budded vp aboundantly in euery age, which were of such authoritie aboueb 1000. yeeres agoe, that* great honour was attributed vnto them, as though it had been vnto the foure Gospels. I will seeke no further; euen here in our owne Countrey by anc acte of Parliament, the selfe same Councels doe retaine still their former force, and pure authoritie: which said acte I will heere alleadge: And call thee, thy selfe O England, my most louing Countrey, to witnesse. If thou reuerence, as thou pretendest, those Councels,5 then wilt thou yeeld vp the supremacie to the Bishop of the chiefe sea, that is, to Saint Peter. Then wilt thou acknowledge vpon the altar, the vnbloodie sacrifice of the bodie and blood of Christ. Then wilt thou pray the blessed Martyrs and all the Saints in Heauen to make intercession to Christ for thee. Then wilt thou restraine these leacherous Apostataes from their filthie carnall copulation, and open incest. Then wilt thou build vp many things, which now thou pullest downe, and wish many things vndone, which now thou doest. Moreouer, I promise and vndertake, as occasion and time shall serue, to proue, that the* Councels holden at other times, and namely the Councell of Trent, haue been of equall authoritie and credit with the foure first Councels. Wherefore then should I not come to this place of triall, securely and couragiously, to marke into what corner my enemie will creepe, seeing I am* ayded with the valiant and piked garrison of all the Councels? For I will alleadge both most manifest matter which he shall not be able to wrest aside, and also most substantially prooued, which he dare not contemptuously reiect. He will perhaps goe about to trifle out the time, with multiplying of many words: but if you be the men that I haue alwaies taken you for, you will take so good heed vnto him, that he shall neither rob you of your eares nor eyes.
If there shall be any at all so mad, as to oppose himself against the sages of all Christendom, ⟨p. 91⟩and those, such men as for holiness of life learning and antiquity, are too great to be challenged; I would willingly behold that brazen face, the which when I shall show you, I will leave the rest to your imaginations. In the mean while, I will give you this caveat, that whosoever affirmeth, that a general Council,* duly and orderly kept, and finished, is of no force or authority, the same man seemeth to me, to be one of no judgement, nor of any wit; and not only an ass in divinity, but also void of discretion in worldly policy. If ever the spirit of God illuminated the Church, surely then that time is most fit to send down the holy Ghost, when the religion, perfection, knowledge, wisdom and honour of all Churches dispersed throughout all Christendom, are assembled together into one City: and using all means both divine and humane, whereby the truth may be searched out,2 they call upon the holy Ghost, promisede by God unto them, that by his assistance, they may establish godly laws, for the safe and wise government of the Church. Now let there some petty peart heretical Doctor leap out, let him look up stately, let him scorn and mock, let him lay all shame aside, let him saucily give judgement of his own judges, what game, what pastime shall he make; we have spied out such a one, even Martin fLuther, who saith, that he more esteemeth of the voices of two honest and learned men (ye may well imagine his own, and Philip Melanchthon's) if they come together in Christs name, then he did of all general Councils. O worthy company! We have found out also, another of the same crew, to witg Kemnitius, who hath undertaken to examine the Council of Trent, by his own unreasonable giddy brain: what hath he gained? an evil name: so that he, except he prevent it by recanting, shall be buried for an heretic with Arrius: whereas the Council of Trent, the elder it waxeth, by so much more it shall flourish daily and continually.*
If there shall be any at all so mad, as to oppose himselfe against the sages of all Christendome, ⟨p. 91⟩and those, such men as for holines of life learning and antiquitie, are too great to be challenged; I would willingly behold that brazen face, the which when I shall sh•w you, I will leaue the rest to your imaginations. In the meane while, I will giue you this caueat, that whosoeuer affirmeth, that a generall Councell,* duly and orderly kept, and finished, is of no force or authoritie, the same man seemeth to me, to be one of no iudgement, nor of any wit; and not onely an asse in diuinitie, but also voide of discretion in worldly policie. If euer the spirit of God illuminated the Church, surely then that time is most fit to send downe the holy Ghost, when the religion, perfection, knowledge, wisdome and honour of all Churches dispersed throughout all Christendome, are assembled together into one Citie: and vsing all meanes both diuine and humane, whereby the truth may be searched out,2 they call vpon the holy Ghost, promisede by God vnto them, that by his assistance, they may establish godly lawes, for the safe and wise gouernement of the Church. Now let there some pettie peart hereticall Doctor leape out, let him looke vp stately, let him scorne and mocke, let him lay all shame aside, let him saucily giue iudgement of his owne iudges, what game, what pastime shall he make; we haue spied out such a one, euen Martin fLuther, who saith, that he more esteemeth of the voices of two honest and learned men (ye may well imagine his owne, and Philip Melancthons) if they come together in Christs name, then he did of all generall Councels. O worthy companie! We haue found out also, another of the same crue, to witg Kemnitius, who hath vndertaken to examine the Councell of Trent, by his owne vnreasonable giddie braine: what hath he gained? an euill name: so that he, except he preuent it by recanting, shall be buried for an heriticke with Arrius: whereas the Councell of Trent, the elder it waxeth, by so much more it shall flourish daily and continually.*
*The Councell of Trent was neither a full Councell, nor lawfully held. And so both the Emperor and the French King have judged. Sleidan. anno 1551. lib. 33. The assembly of certain men.The Councell of Trent was neither a full Councell, nor lawfully held. And so both the Emperor and the French King haue iudged. Sleidan. anno 1551. lib. 33. The assemblie of certaine men.
O good Lord, with what diversity of people out of all countries, with what ⟨p. 92⟩choice of Bishops throughout all Christendom, with what excellency of Kings and Common-weals, with what profound divines, with what* devotion, with what lamentations, with what abstinence and fasting, with what flowers of Universities, with what knowledge of strange tongues, with what sharp wits, with what study, with what endless reading, with what store of virtues and exercises was that sacred place replenished? I heard with my own ears Bishops rejoice, being men of great birth and very well learned, of which, one was Anthony Archbishop of Prague (who created me Priest) for that they had been brought up certain years in that famous School; so that they acknowledged no benefit that ever the Emperor Ferdinando bestowed on them (to whom otherwise also they thought themselves no little beholding) to be more princely and bountiful, then this was, that by him being sent in Embassage from Pannonia, they sate in the Council of Trent, together with the rest of the Fathers there present. This thing the Emperor full well perceived, who greeted them in this sort at their return: We have maintained you in an exceeding good School, why made the adversaries no hast hither, being promised to go and come safe; that they might openly have confuted them, against whom they croak like Toads out of their holes. They have broken promise (say they) with Huss and Hierome, who? the heads of the Council of Constance. That is a lye:2 for they made them no promise. And yet Huss had not been put to death; if that he, false and treacherous villain as he was, not only by an escape, which the Emperor Sigismundus had forbidden him upon pain of death; and being taken, was brought back again: but also by* breaking certain covenants which he had made in writing with the Emperor had not lost the benefit of that safe conduct: Huss was hedged in for his hasty knavery; for whereas at his country in Bohem, he had stirred up barbarous tumults, and was therefore commanded to appear before the general ⟨p. 93⟩Council at Constance, he contemned the prerogative of the Council, and made suite for a safe conduct to the Emperor. The* Emperor sealed him one; all Christendom, which is greater then the Emperor, unsealed it again: the arch heretic would not recant, and therefore he was burnt:5
O good Lord, with what diuersitie of people out of all countries, with what ⟨p. 92⟩choice of Bishops throughout all Christendome, with what excellencie of Kings and Common-weales, with what profound diuines, with what* deuotion, with what lamentations, with what abstinence and fasting, with what flowers of Ʋniuersities, with what knowledge of strange tongues, with what sharpe wits, with what studie, with what endlesse reading, with what store of vertues and exercises was that sacred place replenished? I heard with my owne eares Bishops reioyce, being men of great birth and very well learned, of which, one was Anthony Archbishop of Prage (who created me Priest) for that they had been brought vp certaine yeeres in that famous Schoole; so that they acknowledged no benefite that euer the Emperour Ferdinando bestowed on them (to whom otherwise also they thought themselues no little beholding) to be more princely and bountifull, then this was, that by him being sent in Embassage from Pannonia, they sate in the Councell of Trent, together with the rest of the Fathers there present. This thing the Emperour full well perceiued, who greeted them in this sort at their returne: We haue maintained you in an exceeding good Schoole, why made the aduersaries no hast hither, being promised to goe and come safe; that they might openly haue confuted them, against whom they croke like Toads out of their hoales. They haue broken promise (say they) with Husse and Hierome, who? the heads of the Councell of Constance. That is a lye:2 for they made them no promise. And yet Husse had not been put to death; if that he, false and treacherous villaine as he was, not only by an escape, which the Emperour Sigismundus had forbidden him vpon paine of death; and being taken, was brought backe againe: but also by* breaking certaine couenants which he had made in writing with the Emperor had not lost the benefit of that safe conduct: Husse was hedged in for his hastie knauerie; for whereas at his countrie in Bohem, he had stirred vp barbarous tumults, and was therfore commanded to appeare before the generall ⟨p. 93⟩Councel at Constance, he contemned the prerogatiue of the Councell, and made suite for a safe conduct to the Emperor. The* Emperour sealed him one; all Christendome, which is greater then the Emperour, vnsealed it again: the arch heretike would not recant, and therfore he was burnt:
*Two Bishops were taken in adultery and put to death. Illyric.Two Bishops were taken in adulterie and put to death. Illyric.
As for Hierome of Prague, he came privately without any safe conduct at all to the Council of Constance, and being apprehended did appear, and had liberty to say what he could, and was very courteously entreated, and suffered to go abroad at his pleasure. He was cured of his disease, and abjured his heresy, he fell again, and therefore was burnt. But wherefore do they so often inculcate and call to memory, this one example amongst six hundred?1 Let them peruse their chronicles: Martin Luther, one hated both of God and man, personally appeared at Augusta before the Cardinal Caietane, and did he not belch forth of his venomous gorge, what poisoned speeches he could, and at length being protected with the Emperor Maximilian's safe conduct, went he not safe away?2 The same Martin Luther being sent for, to come to Worms, though he had both the Emperor, and almost all the Princes of the Empire his Enemies, did he not upon the Emperors word come and go safe? Finally, did not the ring-leaders of the Lutherans and Zwinglians in the presence of Charles the fifth, the open enemy to all heretics, Conqueror, and sovereign, upon a truce granted them, exhibit at an assembly at Augusta,3 the confession of their faith, which before they had so often altered, and went they not without hurt away? Likewise the council of Trent provided for the adversary most large warrants to come and go safe, but he would not use the same. He beasteth forsooth of himself in corners, where when he can utter three greek words, he may seem to be a great learned man: He flies from the light, which would make a slender scholar to be accounted learned, and so advance him to seats of great dignity. Let them purchase for ⟨p. 94⟩us English Catholics, if they love their souls health,* such a safe conduct in writing: we will not allege Huss for our excuse, but make our speedy repair to the court, putting our whole trust in the Queens Majesties word. But that I may return thither from whence I digressed: All general Councils are on my side, the first, the last, the rest; these shall be my weapons. Let the adversary expect, a well headed dart, which he shall never be able to shake off. God grant that Satan in him may be quite overthrown, and Christ revined.
As for Hierome of Prage, he came priuately without any safe conduct at all to the Councell of Constance, and being apprehended did appeare, and had libertie to say what he could, and was verie curteously intreated, and suffered to goe abroad at his pleasure. Hee was cured of his disease, and abiured his heresie, hee fell againe, and therefore was burnt. But wherefore do they so often inculcate and call to memorie, this one example amongst sixe hundred?1 Let them peruse their chronicles: Martin Luther, one hated both of God and man, personallie appeared at Augusta before the Cardinall Caietane, and did he not belche forth of his venemouse gorge, what poysoned speeches he could, and at length being protected with the Emperour Maximilians safe conduct, went he not safe away?2 The same Martin Luther being sent for, to come to Wormes, though hee had both the Emperour, and almost all the Princes of the Empire his Enemies, did hee not vpon the Emperours word come and goe safe? Finally, did not the ring-leaders of the Lutherans and Zuinglians in the presence of Charles the fifth, the open enemie to all heretikes, Conqueror, and soueraigne, vpon a truce graunted them, exhibit at an assemblie at Augusta,3 the confession of their faith, which before they had so often altered, and went they not without hurt away? Likewise the councell of Trent prouided for the aduersarie most large warrants to come and goe safe, but he would not vse the same. He beasteth forsooth of himselfe in corners, where when he can vtter three greeke words, he may seeme to bee a great learned man: He flies from the light, which would make a slender scholler to bee accounted learned, and so aduance him to seates of great dignitie. Let them purchase for ⟨p. 94⟩vs English Catholikes, if they loue their soules health,* such a safe conduct in writing: wee will not alleadge Husse for our excuse, but make our speedie repaire to the court, putting our whole trust in the Queenes Maiesties word. But that I may returne thither from whence I digressed: All generall Councels are on my side, the first, the last, the rest; these shalbe my weapons. Let the aduersarie expect, a well headed dart, which he shall neuer be able to shake off. God graunt that Satan in him may be quite ouerthrowne, and Christ reuined.
THE next place is concerning Councils, not much differing from the former; for what is a Council but the flower, and as it were a little model of the whole Church? And therefore whatsoever may be said of Coū cels, it appertaineth to the nature of the Church; but when as these for more plainness sake, are sometimes distinguished, I do easily permit you to propound them distinctly.a Now the name of Councils is honourable, their credit singular, and their authority of ⟨p. 95⟩great esteem, and you do never more insolently brag, then in this place: for when you do but name Councils, you think that you have sufficiently confuted your adversaries, and promise unto your self assured victory. Neither will I go about to extenuate the dignity of Councils, wondering thatb Nazianzene, 3should so unjustly judge, and so injuriously write of them. For he saith, that he had deliberated with himself and fully resolved to avoid Episcopal Convocations, because he had never seen a good issue of any Synod. Which howsoever it hath bin true of many, which by reason of the ambition, and busy meddling of some, have not taken away ancient controversies, but rather have sowed the seed of new contentions: yet many Councils have been approved and commended by their most wished event. Whereas therefore you appeal to Councils, we will follow you in many, & in their most weighty censures and decrees: for in all neither do you your selves judge it necessary. But let us now hear you discoursing concerning Councils.
THE next place is concerning Councels, not much differing from the former; for what is a Councell but the flower, and as it were a little modell of the whole Church? And therefore whatsoeuer may be said of Coū cels, it appertaineth to the nature of the Church; but when as these for more plainnes sake, are sometimes distinguished, I doe easily permit you to propound them distinctly.a Now the name of Councels is honorable, their credit singular, and their authority of ⟨p. 95⟩great esteeme, and you doe neuer more insolently bragge, then in this place: for when you doe but name Councels, you thinke that you haue sufficiently confuted your aduersaries, and promise vnto your selfe assured victory. Neither will I go about to extenuate the dignity of Councels, wōdering thatb Nazianzene, 3should so vniustly iudge, and so iniuriously write of them. For he saith, that he had deliberated with himselfe and fully resolued to auoid Episcopall Conuocations, because he had neuer seene a good issue of any Synode. Which howsoeuer it hath bin true of many, which by reason of the ambition, and busie medling of some, haue not taken away auncient controuersies, but rather haue sowed the seed of new contentions: yet many Councels haue been approued and commended by their most wished euent. Whereas therefore you appeale to Councels, we will follow you in many, & in their most weighty censures and decrees: for in all neither do you your selues iudge it necessary. But let vs now heare you discoursing concerning Councels.
aDVR. But you coutemne the authority of the holy Ghost, speaking by Councels, which all the ancient Fathers have had in singular respect. WHIT. pag. 290. You accuse us falsely, for howsoever we assent not with you, who make them shoulder the Scriptures with equal authority; because we know that both they might, and also have grossly erred in many things, as the Fathers have confessed, and ye your selves cannot deny; yet wherein they are consonant with the Scriptures, we embrace their authority▪ and have them in singular respect, and estination. And in preferring the Scripture before them, we follow but the example of the Fathers. August. de Baptis. contra Donat. lib. 2. cap. 3. idem contra Maxim. lib. 3▪ cap. 14. & de unitat. Eccle. cap. 16. Hieron. in Galatas. Ambros. Epist. 32.DVR. But you coutemne the authority of the holy Ghost, speaking by Councels, which al the auncient Fathers haue had in singular respect. WHIT. pag. 290. You accuse vs falsely, for howsoeuer we assent not with you, who make them shoulder the Scriptures with equall authority; because we know that both they might, and also haue grossely erred in many things, as the Fathers haue confessed, and yee your selues cannot deny; yet wherein they are consonant with the Scriptures, we embrace their authority▪ and haue them in singular respect, and estination. And in preferring the Scripture before them, we follow but the example of the Fathers. August. de Baptis. contra Donat. lib. 2. cap. 3. idem contra Maxim. lib. 3▪ cap. 14. & de vnitat. Eccle. cap. 16. Hieron. in Galatas. Ambros. Epist. 32.
bDVR. Nazianzene d•d not judge inturiously nor writeth bitterly of Councels, as you suppose; but only affirmed that the fraud and malice of the heretics of those times, hindered the assembling of lawful Councels. WHIT. pag. 264. It seemeth you have not read his Epistle, or but very sle•gtly, •eeing he therein plainly set•eth down two reasons why he absented himself from the Councell, when he was called: f••st the weakness of his body, and secondly, his judgment concerning Councels: which was, that he thought such assemblies were to be avoided, because he had seen no good of any Synod, and that hereby occasions of evils were rather increased then taken away. DVR. Yea but he hath shened his contrary judgment writing his Cledonius. WHIT. Nothing less: but only he affirmeth that he would subscribe to the Apollinarian heretics, if they could prove that they were received of the west Councell; which he knew they could not.
A weighty question, (say you) concerning lawful cere•••ies, was cleared in a Council of the Apostles and Fld•rs assembled together. The children believed their Parents, and the Sheep their Shepherd, commanding in this form of speech; It bath pleased the holy Ghost and us. Where you make mention of a Council most excellent, and above all exceptions: in which nothing was done rashly, perversely, and factiously (as sometimes in other Councils ⟨p. 96⟩it hath been accustomed) but all things divinely, and by the authority of the holy Ghost himself. and therefore if we did not believe this Council, we were unworthy of the name, either of children or of sheep. This Council resolved that important question concerning ceremonies, and freed the necks of Christians from that most grievous yoke of Mosaical rites: whereby the greater cause of grief is offered us by you, who have imposed upon the Church, contrary to the express commandment of this Council, another yoke much more intolerable, then that of Moses. For this is clear and manifest, that the ceremonies brought into the Church by you, and imposed upon the consciences of men, are twice as many, as those which in time past Moses by Gods express commandment enjoined unto the people of Israel.1 And this is that of whichc Augustine long agone complained, namely that by the multitudes of ceremonies, the state of Christians, was become worse then the state of the Jews themselves, which if Augustine spake of the ceremonies of his time, how much more would he have thus complained, had he seen the great multitudes, which were afterwards added to them. But if the Apostles and Elders according to the meaning & judgment of the holy Ghost, did determine that those ceremonies which the Lord himself had ordained, were to be abolished, how intolerable is your boldness, who contrary to the decree ⟨p. 97⟩of this spirit, and Council have obtruded, upon Christians your innumerable traditions and needles ceremonies. Did the Lord therefore abolish his own ceremonies, that he might establish yours? did he abroga•• a few, that he might bring in a multitude? did he ease us of lighter, that he might impose heavier. Whereby it appeareth that the divine institution of this Council, which, as it was before all other in time, so above all other in excellency, is most wickedly by you violated.
A waighty question, (say you) concerning lawfull cere•••ies, was cleared in a Councell of the Apostles and Fld•rs assembled together. The children beleeued their Parents, and the Sheepe their Sheph•ard, commaunding in this forme of speech; It bath pleased the holy Ghost and vs. Where you make mention of a Councell most excellent, and aboue all exceptions: in which nothing was done rashly, peruersely, and factiously (as sometimes in other Councels ⟨p. 96⟩it hath been accustomed) but al things diuinely, and by the authority of the holy Ghost himself. and therfore if we did not beleeue this Councell, we were vnworthy of the name, either of children or of sheep. This Councel resolued that important question concerning ceremonies, and freed the neckes of Christians from that most grieuous yoke of Mosaicall rites: whereby the greater cause of griefe is offered vs by you, who haue imposed vpon the Church, contrarie to the expresse commandement of this Councell, another yoke much more intolerable, then that of Moses. For this is cleare and manifest, that the ceremonies brought into the Church by you, and imposed vpon the consciences of men, are twice as many, as those which in time past Moses by Gods expresse commaundement inioyned vnto the people of Israell.1 And this is that of whichc Augustine long agone complained, namely that by the multitudes of ceremonies, the state of Christians, was become worse then the state of the Iewes themselues, which if Augustine spake of the ceremonies of his time, how much more would he haue thus complained, had he seene the great multitudes, which were afterwards added to them. But if the Apostles and Elders according to the meaning & iudgment of the holy Ghost, did determine that those ceremonies which the Lord himselfe had ordeined, were to be abolished, how intolerable is your boldnes, who contrary to the decree ⟨p. 97⟩of this spirit, and Councell haue obtruded, vpon Christians your innumerable traditions and needles ceremonies. Did the Lord therfore abolish his owne ceremonies, that he might establish yours? did he abroga•• a few, that he might bring in a multitude? did he ease vs of lighter, that he might impose heauier. Whereby it appeareth that the diuine institution of this Councel, which, as it was before all other in time, so aboue all other in excellency, is most wickedly by you violated.
1August. ad Januar.August. ad Ianuar.
cDVR. Angustine when he writ this, did not after your manner carp at Ecclesiastical ceremonies, but showeth that be would not have them instituted at every mans pleasure. For in his first Epistle to Januariu• he thus writeth. If the whole Church use any of these, it i• insolent madness to dispute, whether such a thing is to be done or no? WHIT. pag. 296. Augustine condemneth the multitude of ceremonies in his time, and would have us rest contented with those few ceremonies, which are commended unto us in the Scriptures. Ad Januar. Epist. 118. cap. 1. & Epist. 119.19. His words which you allege, I willingly embrace; for we use and esteem those ceremonies, which all Churches have received as necessary for order and comeliness. But of this kind yours are not, neither can you wrest those speeches concerning the ceremonies of the Church to approve your Traditions: seeing the Church of Rome long since ceased to be the Church of Christ.DVR. Angustine vvhen he vvrit this, did not after your manner carpe at Ecclesiasticall ceremonies, but shevveth that be vvould not haue them instituted at euery mans pleasure. For in his first Epistle to Ianuariu• he thus vvriteth. If the vvhole Church vse any of these, it i• insolent madnes to dispute, vvhether such a thing is to be done or no? WHIT. pag. 296. Augustine condemneth the multitude of ceremonies in his time, and vvould haue vs rest contented vvith those few ceremonies, vvhich are commended vnto vs in the Scriptures. Ad Ianuar. Epist. 118. cap. 1. & Epist. 119.19. His vvords vvhich you alleage, I vvillinglie embrace; for vve vse and esteeme those ceremonies, vvhich all Churches haue receiued as necessary for order and comelinesse. But of this kind yours are not, neither can you vvrest those speeches concerning the ceremonies of the Church to approue your Traditions: seeing the Church of Rome long since ceased to be the Church of Christ.
And is it to be thought possible, that you, who have demeaned your selves so impiously towards these Parents and Pastors, will be more respective towards others? Nay there is not any Council, which you have not long ago trodden under feet, so that every one of you, are enfolded in a thousand excommunications. And dare you, Campian, notwithstanding make mention of Councils, which if they were in any force, surely you should no more be tolerated in the Church, then Publicans and Pagans. There followeth this, say you, for the rooting out of heresy, the four general Councils of the ancient Fathers, which were of such strength and authority, that a thousand years since, they were had in singular account even as Gods word it self. And we likewise do freely confess, that the authority of those four Councils was good and profitable.1 Read what learned Luther hath writ of those four general Councils, and so also you may know our judgement of them. Notwithstanding there is no reason why we should assent unto Gregory, 2who professeth that he doth embrace and reverence these four Councils, as the four books of the holy Gospel. For this were rather to violate the Gospel, then to reverence the Councils. Although as I take it, Gregory's meaning was, that what was decreed and concluded in these four Councils, out of Gods word against Arrive, Eu••onius, Macedonius, Nestorius, Eutyches, and Diosc•ru•, that he firmly embraced, and would not suffer ⟨p. 98⟩these decreet, which are approved by the Evangelical writings, and in which this impious heresy is condemned, to be revoked and repealed no more then the Gospel it self, neither can I imagine that it was Gregory's purpose to affirm this of all these Councils, that the Council of Nice, Constantine ple, Ephesus and Chalced•n, were fully equal unto the holy Gospel in authority and dignity. And so we our selves do not doubt, that those things which these Fathers have determined against those heretics, before named concerning the consubstantial subsistence of the Father and the Son, of the divinity of the holy Ghost, of the one person of Christ in two natures, are as true as the Gospel it self; not because these Councils so judged and concluded, but because in the Gospel, the self same doctrine of faith is delivered.
And is it to be thought possible, that you, who haue demeaned your selues so impiously towards these Parents and Pastors, will be more respectiue towards others? Nay there is not any Councell, which you haue not long ago trodden vnder feete, so that euery one of you, are infoulded in a thousand excōmunications. And dare you, Campian, notwithstanding make mention of Councels, which if they were in any force, surely you should no more be tolerated in the Church, then Publicans and Pagans. There followeth this, say you, for the rooting out of heresie, the foure general Councels of the auncient Fathers, which were of such strength and authority, that a thousand yeares since, they were had in singular account euen as Gods word it selfe. And we likewise doe freely confesse, that the authority of those foure Councels was good and profitable.1 Reade what learned Luther hath writ of those foure generall Councels, and so also you may know our iudgement of them. Notwithstanding there is no reason why we should assent vnto Gregorie, 2who professeth that he doth imbrace and reuerence these foure Councels, as the foure bookes of the holy Gospell. For this were rather to violate the Gospell, then to reuerence the Councels. Although as I take it, Gregories meaning was, that what was decreed and concluded in these foure Councels, out of Gods word against Arriu•, Eu••onius, Macedonius, Nostorius, Eutyches, and Diosc•ru•, that he firmely embraced, and would not suffer ⟨p. 98⟩these decreet, which are approued by the Euangelicall writings, and in which this impious heresie is condemned, to be reuoked and repealed no more then the Gospell it selfe, neither can I imagine that it was Gregories purpose to affirme this of all these Councels, that the Councell of Nice, Constantin• ple, Ephesus and Chalced•n, were fully equall vnto the holy Gospell in authority and dignity. And so we our selues do not doubt, that those things which these Fathers haue determined against those heretikes, before named concerning the consubstantiall subsistence of the Father and the Sonne, of the diuinity of the holy Ghost, of the one person of Christ in two natures, are as true as the Gospel it selfe; not because these Councels so iudged and concluded, but because in the Gospell, the selfe same doctrine of faith is deliuered.
Further you say, That also i•••r own country, by our Parliaments, the same Councils retain their ancient right. It is true indeed, that in these and all other things, which they propound, if they be consonant to the holy Scriptures, they do still retain their ancient right and dignity. But lest you should suppose that we did ever attribute thus much to these Councils, that we judge all that to be necessarily embraced, whatsoever they have decreed; hear you now what our Church hath thought and ordained of these general Councils. Councils, not only may err, but also sometimes have erred, 1and that in these things, which belong to the rule of piety, and therefore whatsoever by them is decreed as necessary to salvation, hath no virtues nor authority, unless it may be showed that it is taken ou• of the holy Scriptures. Cite you now these words, and then contest (as you call it) your sweet country. And in like manner, this your most dear country in which you were borne, brought up and graced, doth contest, entreat, and beseech you, by all those things, which are unto you most swee•e and best esteemed, that you desist any more in this b•dde ⟨p. 99⟩cause to be troublesome unto her; that you will no• corrupt her children with an impious and strange religion; that you will make more precious account of her dignity, then of a foreign enemy: and that you would at length return thither, from whence you have stra•ed. And surely you would not contemn this speech of your country, if you could, even for a little space, lay aside, that prejudicate opinion which you have sucked from Rome, and brought with you hither into England.
Further you say, That also i•••r owne country, by our Parliaments, the same Councels retaine their auncient right. It is true indeed, that in these and all other things, which they propound, if they be consonant to the holy Scriptures, they doe still retaine their auncient right and dignity. But lest you should suppose that we did euer attribute thus much to these Councels, that we iudge all that to be necessarily embraced, whatsoeuer they haue decreed; heare you now what our Church hath thought and ordained of these generall Councels. Councels, not only may erre, but also sometimes haue erred, 1and that in these things, which belong to the rule of piety, and therfore whatsoeuer by them is decreed as necessary to saluation, hath no vertus nor authority, vnlesse it may be shewed that it is taken ou• of the holy Scriptures. Cite you now these words, and then contest (as you call it) your sweet coūtry. And in like māner, this your most deare countrie in which you were borne, brought vp and graced, doth contest, intreat, and beseech you, by all those things, which are vnto you most swee•e and best esteemed, that you desist any more in this b•dde ⟨p. 99⟩cause to be troublesome vnto her; that you will no• corrupt her children with an impious and strange religion; that you will make more preciou• account of her dignity, then of a forraine enemie: and that you would at length returne thither, from whence you haue stra•ed. And surely you would not contemne this speech of your country, if you could, euen for a litle space, lay aside, that preiudicate opinion which you haue sucked from Rome, and brought with you hither into England.
But let us hear, what is this your contestation? If, say you, you will re•erence these four• Councils, you will chiefly honour the Bishop of the chief• S••, that is Peter. And so do we ascribe great honour, unto Peter, and that worthily; neither do we contend with you about him; but this affirm, that those things which were proper unto Peter, cannot in any wise appertain to your Pope, who was never like either Peter or Paul. And in truth what madness is this, so insolently to brag of Peters great virtues, when in the mean time, you cannot prove that your Popes are endued with any such? Do you suppose that any man that is in his right wits, will think that Peters faith, piety, and all the rest of his virtues, have bin derived to your Pope by a lineal descent, from so many other Popes, of whom a great number, were not men, but monsters? This doubtless is a gross dotage, and fit to be taken away,1 with the mad mans purge, and as one saith, for those diseases, reprehension is the best ma•••r of cure. Should I entitle your Gregori• the 13. who now governeth at Rome, with the name of Peter? doth he teach? doth he feed Christs sheep? surely he cannot. Doth he perform the duty of an Apostle, or of a Bishop? nothing less. How therefore doth he demean himself? Sitting in the Vatican, he provoketh to war, moveth seditions, armeth subjects against their Princes, and filleth the whole world with upro••••▪ Did Peter thus behave himself? is ⟨p. 100⟩this to be Peter? can you deny that these things be true, and shall I then yield unto him the like honour, that is due to Peter, being so unlike him in conditions? But let us further examine your words; You will (say you) chiefly honour the Bishop of the chief Sea, that is Peter; but by what Council do you prove that necessary? you allege the Council of Nice Can. 6. In which there is not so much as any mention of the Bishop of the chief Sea, or of Peter; neither in truth could any thing be produced of greater force against your Bishop, then that decree of Nicene Synod: for it matcheth all Metropolitans and Patriarchs in an equal rank of honour with the Bishop of Rome; neither doth it attribute any more to him, then unto the Metropolitans of Antioch, Alexandria, and the rest of the other Provinces. If you please, you shall hear the words of the Council:2
But let vs heare, what is this your contestation? If, say you, you will re•erence these four• Councels, you will chiefely hon•r the Bishop of the chief• S••, that is Peter. And so do we ascribe great honour, vnto Peter, and that worthily; neither doe we contend with you about him; but this affirme, that those things which were proper vnto Peter, cannot in any wise appertaine to your Pope, who was neuer like either Peter or Paul. And in truth what madnes is this, so insolently to bragge of Peters great vertues, when in the meane time, you cannot proue that your Popes are indued with any such? Do you suppose that any man that is in his right wits, will thinke that Peters faith, piety, and all the rest of his vertues, haue bin deriued to your Pope by a lineall descent, from so many other Popes, of whom a great number, were not men, but monsters? This doubtlesse is a grosse dotage, and fit to be taken away,1 with the mad mans purge, and as one saith, for those diseases, reprehension is the best ma•••r of cure. Should I entitle your Gregori• the 13. who now gouerneth at Rome, with the name of Peter? doth he teach? doth he feed Christs sheepe? surely he cannot. Doth he performe the duty of an Apostle, or of a Bishop? nothing lesse. How therfore doth he demeane himselfe? Sitting in the Vatican, he prouoketh to warre, moueth seditions, armeth subiects against their Princes, and filleth the whole world with vpro••••▪ Did Peter thus behaue himselfe? is ⟨p. 100⟩this to be Peter? can you deny that these things be true, and shall I then yeeld vnto him the like honor, that is due to Peter, being so vnlike him in conditions? But let vs further examine your words; You will (say you) chiefely honor the Bishop of the chiefe Sea, that is Peter; but by what Councell doe you proue that necessary? you alleage the Councell of Nice Can. 6. In which there is not so much as any mention of the Bishop of the chiefe Sea, or of Peter; neither in truth could any thing be produced of greater force against your Bishop, then that decree of Nicene Synode: for it matcheth all Metropolitanes and Patriarkes in an equall ranke of honor with the Bishop of Rome; neither doth it attribute any more to him, then vnto ye Metropolitanes of Antioch, Alexandria, and the rest of the other Prouinces. If you please, you shall heare the words of the Councell:
dLet the ancient custom be in force, which was in Egypt, Libya, and Pentapolis, that the Bishop of Alexandria have the chief dignity, over all these things: because also this was the custom of the Bishop of Rome: and in like manner at Antioch, and in the rest of the Provinces, let the Primacy and authority be received unto the Churches.
dLet the ancient custome be in force, which was in Aegypt, Libya, and Pentapolis, that the Bishop of Alexandria haue the chiefe dignity, ouer all these things: because also this was the custome of the Bishop of Rome: and in like manner at Antioch, and in the rest of the Prouinces, let the Primacy and authority be receiued vnto the Churches.
dDVR. This cause by you alleged maketh much for establishing the authority of the Roman Sea over all Churches. For when as the Fathers to prove the authority of the Bishop of Alexandria, allege the custom of the Church of Rome, they show hereby that Alexandria dependeth upon Rome; as the mother Church from which she hath all her authority. And that this was their mind appeareth by the words of Paschasmus the Popes Legate in the Councell of Chalcedon, & is also proved by the 39. Canon translated out of Arabic into Latin. The same Fathers likewise assembled at Sardis approved the Supremacy of the Roman Sea. WHIT. pag. 299. Nothing could be alleged more direct against the Romish Supremacy then this Canon, wherein their own proper limits of jurisdiction are assigned to every Metropolitan. For if the Pope should rule over the whole Church, it had bin absur'd to limit every one their own borders, wherein they should have supreme authority according to the custom of the Church of Rome. Neither doth this prove the supremacy of the Romish Church, because they allege her custom and example, as you ignorantly infer: seeing an example may be taken aswell from an equal or inferior, as from a superiors. It is no marvel if Paschasinus, being the Popes Legate, spake for the supremacy of the Roman Sea, neither is his testimony to be regarded, being a party. Your Arabic Canon is merely Arabic, and not Nicene; for of this Councel there were only 20. Canons written in Greek, and not in the Arabian tongue. The Canon of the Councell of Sardis helpeth you not, seeing the Councell of Africa testifieth that i• was counterfeit.DVR. This cause by you alleadged maketh much for establishing the authority of the Romane Sea ouer all Churches. For vvhen as the Fathers to proue the authority of the Bishop of Alexandria, alleage the custome of the Church of Rome, they shew hereby that Alexandria dependeth vpon Rome; as the mother Church frō which she hath all her authority. And that this was their mind appeareth by the words of Paschasmus the Popes Legat in the Councell of Chalcedon, & is also proued by the 39. Canon translated out of Arabicke into Latin. The same Fathers likevvise assembled at Sardis approued the Supremacy of the Romane Sea. WHIT. pag. 299. Nothing could be alleadged more direct against the Romish Supremacy then this Canon, wherin their own proper limits of iurisdiction are assigned to euery Metropolitane. For if the Pope should rule ouer the whole Church, it had bin absur'd to limit euery one their owne borders, wherein they should haue supreame authority according to the custome of the Church of Rome. Neither doth this proue the supremacy of the Romish Church, because they alleadge her custome and example, as you ignorantly inferre: seeing an example may be taken aswell from an equall or inferiour, as from a superious. It is no maruell if Paschasinus, being the Popes Legate, spake for the supremacy of the Romane Sea, neither is his testimony to be regarded, being a party. Your Arabicke Canon is meerely Arabicke, and not Nicene; for of this Councel there were only 20. Canons written in Greek, and not in the Arabian tongue. The Canon of the Councell of Sardis helpeth you not, seeing the Councell of Africke testifieth that i• was counterfeite.
You see (Campian) I suppose that no extraordinary prerogative hath been given to the Bishop of Rome: and that his Province and Jurisdiction hath been circumscribed within determined bounds and borders.1 And after this same manner doth Ruffinus, (if you do not credit us) interpret this Canon. This Ancient custom is observed at Alexandria, and in the city of Rome, that the Bishop of Alexandria take the charges of Egypt, and the Bishop of Rome of the Churches of the cities near adjoining. And therefore let the Bishop of Rome take care of the bordering Churches of the neighbour cities, with which the Nicene Synod hath enjoined him to rest satisfied; and hereafter let him not trouble himself, with the care of our Churches, which appertain not unto his charge. And so you see, that if you had been well advised, you would never have mentioned this Council.2 But you adjoin also unto this the Council ofe Chalcedon, that thereby you may prove that the ⟨p. 102⟩chief honour is to be ascribed unto the Bishop of the chief sea, that is unto Peter. I grant, Campian, that this sea in time past, was had in the chief place of honour, and I know very well that the chief dignity was attributed to the Bishop of this sea; the reason whereof you may easily perceive out of the self same Council. For this was not done by any commandment of Christ, that the Church of Rome should excel in dignity, all other Churches of the world: but the Fathers testify, that the cause why that City was invested with greater privilege than others, was this, because it was the chief seat of the Empire. You may find the words themselves in the same act which you cite.4 But if (as you say) the Church of Rome ought to have the preeminence above all other Churches in the world, in divine authority, what then meant the Chalcedonian Fathers, to affirm that there were some prerogatives granted unto that Church, for this cause alone; in that Rome was the head of the Empire, and therefore they thought that the Bishop of that City, which was the Empress of the world, was worthy of some more honour than others? And this honour to speak of was only this; that the Bishop of Rome should have the preeminence of place in Councils, the priority of speech in delivering his opinion, and the precedence in rank and place.
You see (Campian) I suppose that no extraordinary prerogatiue hath been giuen to the Bishop of Rome: and that his Prouince and Iurisdiction hath been circumscribed within determined bounds and borders.1 And after this same manner doth Ruffinus, (if you do not credit vs) interpret this Canon. This Auncient custome is obserued at Alexandria, and in the citie of Rome, that the Bishop of Alexandria take the charges of Aegypt, and the Bishop of Rome of the Churches of the cities neire adioyning. And therefore let the Bishop of Rome take care of the bordering Churches of the neighbour cities, with which the Nicene Synode hath enioyned him to rest satisfied; and hereafter let him not trouble himselfe, with the care of our Churches, which appertaine not vnto his charge. And so you see, that if you had been well aduised, you would neuer haue mentioned this Councell.2 But you adioyne also vnto this the Councell ofe Chalcedon, that thereby you may proue that the ⟨p. 102⟩chiefe honour is to be ascribed vnto the Bishop of the chiefe sea, that is vnto Peter. I graunt, Campian, that this sea in time past, was had in the chiefe place of honour, and I know very well that the chiefe dignitie was attributed to the Bishop of this sea; the reason whereof you may easilie perceiue out of the selfe same Councell. For this was not done by any commaundement of Christ, that the Church of Rome should excell in dignitie, all other Churches of the world: but the Fathers testifie, that the cause why that Citie was inuested with greater priuiledge than others, was this, because it was the chiefe seate of the Empire. You may finde the words themselues in the same acte which you cite.4 But if (as you say) the Church of Rome ought to haue the preheminence aboue all other Churches in the world, in diuine authoritie, what then ment the Chalcedonian Fathers, to affirme that there were some prerogatiues graunted vnto that Church, for this cause alone; in that Rome was the head of the Empire, and therefore they thought that the Bishop of that Citie, which was the Empresse of the world, was worthie of some more honour than others? And this honour to speake of was onely this; that the Bishop of Rome should haue the preheminence of place in Councels, the prioritie of speech in deliuering his opinion, and the precedence in rancke and place.
eDVR. The Councell of Chalcedon standeth so directly for the supremacy of the Roman Sea, that you ca with no shifts avoid it. For therein Dioscorus, as for diver, other faults, so especially for excommunstating the Pope, was deprived of Episcopal authority, Act. 3. Besides they writ thus to Pope Leo. He extē death his madness against him, unto whom the custody of the vineyard is committed by our Saviour, and against thee who labourest to unite the body of the Church. Again, they desire that their decrees should be confirmed of the same Pope. And Paschasinus saith that the Pope of Rome, whichus head of all the Churches, deprived him; because as Lucentius addeth, he presumed to call a Councell without the authority of the Apostolic Sea. WHIT. pag. 302. This councell is so far from confirming the Popes supremacy, that it plainly overthroweth it: for though Pope Leo with all earnestness opposed against the honour and dignity of the Bishop of Constantinople, yet he obtein•• of the Councell that degree of honour which he desired, which he could not have done if the Councell had acknowledged the Popes supremacy. Concerning Dioscorus, he was deprived for many notable crimes, as murder, blasphemy against the Trinity burglary, adultery and excommunicating the Pope; and you make this last a special cause of his deprivation, as though it were a more heinous crime then murder, adultery and blasphemy. Therein advancing your Pope, as your manner is, above the blessed Trinity. The committing of the vineyard to Peter, maketh nothing for your Pope, who is not Peter, nor any thing like him. Prove that it was committed to the Pope and you say something. The confirmation of the decrees was not a thing proper to the Pope, but also appertained to the other Patriarchs and Metropolitans; yea to the Emperors. Paschasinus and Lucentius accusing Dioscorus, say not a word of the Popes supremacy, although they were the Popes Legates. And whereas he calleth Rome the head of all the Churches, his meaning was, that it was the first, greatest, and most famous Church.DVR. The Councell of Chalcedon standeth so directly for the supremacy of the Romane Sea, that you ca with no shifts auoid it. For therein Dioscorus, as for diuer, other faults, so especially for excommunstating the Pope, vvas depriued of Episcopall authority, Act. 3. Besides they writ thus to Pope Leo. He extē deth his madnes against him, vnto whom the custody of the vineyard is committed by our Sauiour, and against thee who labourest to vnite the body of the Church. Againe, they desire that their decrees should be confirmed of the same Pope. And Paschasinus saith that the Pope of Rome, vvhichus head of all the Churches, depriued him; because as Lucentius addeth, hee presumed to call a Councell vvithout the authority of the Apostolike Sea. WHIT. pag. 302. This councell is so far from confirming the Popes supremacy, that it plainly ouerthroweth it: for though Pope Leo with all earnestnes opposed against the honor and dignity of the Bishop of Constantinople, yet he obtein of the Councell that degree of honor which he desired, which he could not haue done if the Councell had acknovvledged the Popes supremacy. Concerning Dioscorus, he was depriued for many notable crimes, as murther, blasphemy against the Trinity burglary, adultery and excommunicating the Pope; and you make this last a speciall cause of his depriuation, as though it were a more heinous crime then murther, adultery and blasphemy. Therein aduauncing your Pope, as your manner is, aboue the blessed Trinity. The committing of the vineyard to Peter, maketh nothing for your Pope, who is not Peter, nor any thing like him. Proue that it was committed to the Pope and you say something. The confirmation of the decrees was not a thing proper to the Pope, but also appertained to the other Patriarckes and Metropolitanes; yea to the Emperors. Paschasinus and Lucentius accusing Dioscorus, say not a word of the Popes supremacy, although they were the Popes Legates. And whereas he calleth Rome the head of all the Churches, his meaning was, that it was the first, greatest, and most famous Church.
And thus neither do we our selves, now much envy this honour to the Roman Bishop, but that if so it please him, he may enjoy it; so that he do not (because he hath the chief place) imperiously tyrannize over his brethren, as he hath done for many ages, and persuadeth himself that he may do it lawfully. But seeing it pleaseth you to object unto us, the Council of Chalcedon, that you may challenge the chief honour, as due to your Bishop of the chief Sea, before I proceed further, I would gladly you ⟨p. 103⟩should resolve me in this question, why thef Fathers of this Council, made the Sea of Constantinople, equal to the Sea of Rome? for so they decree, and definitively determine: that seeing great privileges were granted to the Church of Rome, in respect of the Empire of the city, they thought it a matter of great equity, that the new Rome that was now graced with the Empire and Senate, should enjoy the same privileges which old Rome had done. And although the Bishop of Rome did most earnestly contend and labour, that the Bishop of Constantinople might not be made his equal, yet he could not by his best means effect his desire, but that the decree of the Council prevailed, which had equalised the Bishop of Constantinople, with the Bishop of Rome. And therefore me thinks you have but ill defended the honour and dignity of your Bishop, when you allege the decree of that Council. Moreover, the Council ofg Constantinople which you also cite,3 decreed no other thing for the Roman Sea, then that the Bishop of Constantinople should have the prerogative of honour next to the Bishop of Rome. And this we also confess, that in times past the Provinces were so distributed, that Rome had the chief, Constantinople ⟨p. 104⟩the next, and so every one in their own order. But what maketh that to this cause, which we have now in hand? For this is not the honour which the Bishop of Rome challengeth unto himself: this not the height of power and majesty which he so often arrogateth.4 The Council also ofh Ephesus is alleged by you with as little reason, seeing it ascribeth nothing to the Bishop of Rome, which did not also agree to other Bishops: for if you take hold on this, that Celestinus the Bishop of Rome, was called the holy president, & most reverend Father, because he threatened to excommunicate Nestorius, unless he abjured his heresy;
And thus neither doe we our selues, now much enuie this honour to the Romane Bishop, but that if so it please him, he may enioy it; so that he doe not (because he hath the chiefe place) imperiouslie tyranize ouer his brethren, as he hath done for many ages, and perswadeth himselfe that he may doe it lawfully. But seeing it pleaseth you to obiect vnto vs, the Coūcel of Chalcedon, that you may challenge the chiefe honor, as due to your Bishop of the chiefe Sea, before I proceed further, I would gladly you ⟨p. 103⟩should resolue me in this question, why thef Fathers of this Councell, made the Sea of Constantinople, equall to the Sea of Rome? for so they decree, and diffinitiuely determine: that seeing great priuiledges were graunted to the Church of Rome, in respect of the Empire of the citie, they thought it a matter of great equity, that the new Rome that was now graced with the Empire and Senate, should enioy the same priuiledges which old Rome had done. And although the Bishop of Rome did most earnestly contend and labour, that the Bishop of Constantinople might not be made his equall, yet he could not by his best meanes effect his desire, but that the decree of the Councell preuailed, which had equalised the Bishop of Constantinople, with the Bishop of Rome. And therefore me thinkes you haue but ill defended the honor and dignity of your Bishop, when you alleadge the decree of that Councell. Moreouer, the Councell ofg Constantinople which you also cite,3 decreed no other thing for the Romane Sea, then that the Bishop of Constantinople should haue the prerogatiue of honor next to the Bishop of Rome. And this we also confesse, that in times past the Prouinces were so distributed, that Rome had the chiefe, Constantinople ⟨p. 104⟩the next, and so euery one in their owne order. But what maketh that to this cause, which we haue now in hand? For this is not the honor which the Bishop of Rome challengeth vnto himselfe: this not the height of power and maiestie which he so often arrogateth.4 The Councell also ofh Ephesus is alleadged by you with as litle reason, seeing it ascribeth nothing to the Bishop of Rome, which did not also agree to other Bishops: for if you take hold on this, that Celestinus the Bishop of Rome, was called the holy president, & most reuerend Father, because he threatned to excommunicate Nestorius, vnlesse he abiuted his heresie;
fDVR. This was not the judgement of the whole Coū cell, but of certain men. Neither did the Constantinopolitanes require that their Sea should be of equal authority with the Sea of Rome, but that it should have the like sovereignty in Ecclesiastical matters, and obtain• the next place to it. WHIT. pag. 306. This was the judgment of the whole Councell, except the Popes own Legates Paschasinus, Bonefacius, and Lucentius, who in vain opposed: for the decree runneth thus. These things we all say, these things please us all. And contrary to your assertion, these Fathers decreed that the Bishop of Constantinople should be matched in equal privilege, with the Bishop of Rome; which equality of privileges, cannot stand with the unequality of authority. Neither did priority of place prove, that the Bishop of Rome had any priority of authority, s••ing this was only for orders sake: otherwise by the same reason the Bishop of Constantinople should have had the like authority over the Bishop of Alexandria, because he sate above him.DVR. This was not the iudgement of the whole Coū cell, but of certeine men. Neither did the Constantinopolitanes require that their Sea should be of equall authority with the Sea of Rome, but that it should haue the like soueraignty in Ecclesiasticall matters, and obtain• the next place to it. WHIT. pag. 306. This was the iudgment of the whole Councell, except the Popes owne Legates Paschasinus, Bonefacius, and Lucentius, who in vaine opposed: for the decree runneth thus. These things we all say, these things please vs all. And contrary to your assertion, these Fathers decreed that the Bishop of Constantinople should be matched in equall priuiledge, with the Bishop of Rome; which equality of priuiledges, cannot stand with the vnequality of authority. Neither did prioritie of place proue, that the Bishop of Rome had any priority of authoritie, s••ing this was only for orders sake: otherwise by the same reason the Bishop of Constātinople should haue had the like authority ouer the Bishop of Alexandri•, because he sate aboue him.
gDVR. The filth Canon of the Councell of Constantinople, ascribed greater honour to the Roman Sea, then to any other. WHIT. pag. 311. This honour was only of precedence and place, and not of authority; as plainly appeareth in the words of the Councell it self•. Chap. •8. and in that the like prerogative was granted in the next place to the Bishop of Constantinople, and therefore by the like reason he might rrog authority over the whole Church.
these things are common unto the Bishop of Rome with others: neither was he only entitled reverend, neither could he alone pronounce judgment against heretics. But if these would rather please you; This is the faith of the Catholic and Orthodoxall Church, unto which all the Orthodoxall Bishops give their assent; you interpret these words amiss. For in these words all the Orthodoxall Bishops are said not to assent to the Church, but to the faith: and that faith, which the Fathers in those their letters embraced, all Orthodoxall Bishops in every place have approved, and we also do defend.
these things are cōmon vnto the Bishop of Rome with others: neither was he only intitled reuerend, neither could hee alone pronounce iudgment against heretikes. But if these would rather please you; This is the faith of the Catholike and Orthodoxall Church, vnto which all the Orthodoxall Bishops giue their assent; you interpret these words amisse. For in these words all the Orthodoxall Bishops are said not to assent to the Church, but to the faith: and that faith, which the Fathers in those their letters embraced, all Orthodoxall Bishops in euery place haue approued, and we also do defend.
But what now followeth in your contestation? Thou wilt (say you) acknowledge the unbloody sacrifice of the body and blood of Christ on the Altar. And for this you cite the 14. Canon of the Nicene Coū cell, in which there is not so much as any mention made neither of unbloody, nor ofi sacrifice, nor of ⟨p. 105⟩Altar. But Deacons are there prohibited to arrogate so much unto themselves, that Bishops or Priests being present, they should take upon them to administer the Sacrament of the Lords supper, because it was not lawful for Deacons to deliver the Lords body unto Priests. Now it is an usual thing to call bread the Lords body, because it is a Sacrament of the Lords body; neither in the mean time do I deny that the supper of the Lord is called by many of thek ancient Fathers, an unbloody sacrifice: both because we retain the mysteries of Christs death without any blood, & also offer up praises & thanksgiving as it were for sacrifices unto God; and therefore Cyril joineth in the supper, these together, unbloody sacrifices and praises. 3And Eusebius writeth, that we build an Altar to the Lord, of unbloody and reasonable sacrifices, according to the new mysteries. Now if you ask what manner of unbloody sacrifice this is, let Eusebius himself answer you in his own words. He hath delivered unto us, a lmemorial of his death, which we offer unto him in place of a Sacrifice. Again, you propound the eleventh act of the Council of Chalcedon, which containeth nothing at all, which appertaineth to this matter in hand, neither that place of Socrates which you quote.5 You might have dealt better and more simply, if you would have cited the ⟨p. 106⟩words themselves, and not only quoted uncertain and confused notes in the margin: but you feared lest you might have bin too easily discovered, unless you had masked your self under the visor of deceit.
But what now followeth in your contestation? Thou wilt (say you) acknowledge the vnbloody sacrifice of the body and blood of Christ on the Altar. And for this you cite the 14. Canon of the Nicence Coū cell, in which there is not so much as any mention made neither of vnbloody, nor ofi sacrifice, nor of ⟨p. 105⟩Altar. But Deacons are there prohibited to arrogate so much vnto themselues, that Bishops or Priests being present, they should take vpon them to administer the Sacrament of the Lords supper, because it was not lawfull for Deacons to deliuer the Lords body vnto Priests. Now it is an vsuall thing to call bread the Lords body, because it is a Sacrament of the Lords body; neither in the meane time do I deny that the supper of the Lord is called by many of thek auncient Fathers, an vnbloody sacrifice: both because wee retaine the mysteries of Christs death without any blood, & also offer vp praises & thanksgiuing as it were for sacrifices vnto God; and therefore Cyrill ioyneth in the supper, these together, vnbloody sacrifices and praises. 3And Eusebius writeth, that we build an Altar to the Lord, of vnbloody and reasonable sacrifices, according to the new mysteries. Now if you aske what manner of vnbloody sacrifice this is, let Eusebius himself answer you in his own words. He hath deliuered vnto vs, a lmemoriall of his death, which we offer vnto him in place of a Sacrifice. Again, you propound the eleuenth act of the Councell of Chalcedon, which conteineth nothing at all, which appertaineth to this matter in hand, neither that place of Socrates which you quote.5 You might haue dealt better and more simply, if you would haue cited the ⟨p. 106⟩words themselues, and not only quoted vncertaine and confused notes in ye margent: but you feared lest you might haue bin too easily discouered, vnles you had masked your selfe vnder the vizard of deceite.
iDVR. The word Sacrifice is in the 14. Canon of the Nicene Councell. And in the institutions of this Councell, it is said that the Lamb of God is on the holy table, which is offered of the Priests without blood, &c. WHIT pag. 316. It is not to be found in the words of the Councell in the Greek, but they are your words of the Translator. And concerning the institutions, their authority was always doubtful in the Church, neither do they make for you, seeing we grant that in the right use of the Sacrament we receive the Lamb of God, Sacramentally.DVR. The word Sacrifice is in the 14. Canon of the Nicene Councell. And in the institutions of this Councell, it is said that the Lambe of God is on the holy table, which is offered of the Priests without blood, &c. WHIT pag. 316. It is not to be found in the words of the Councell in the Greeke, but they are your words of the Trāslator. And cōcerning the institutiōs, their authority was alwaies doubtfull in the Church, neither do they make for you, seeing we grant that in the right vse of the Sacrament we receiue the Lambe of God, Sacramentally.
kDVR. The testimonies of the Fathers which you allege, wherein the Sacrament is called an unbloody sacrifice, make nothing for you: seeing that with them is called unbloody, not that is without blood but without effusion of blood. WHIT pag. 318. The word [Greek or Hebrew], unbloody, used by them, signifieth such a thing as hath no blood in it. If therefore this be [Greek or Hebrew], an unbloody sacrifice, as the Fathers call it, then it is a Sacrifice without blood, and not only without shedding of blood. Again if it be a sacrifice wherein no blood is spilt, then is it not the sacrifice of Christ; for in this blood was shed: nor any true sacrifice, for there is no sacrifice that hath blood without the shedding thereof. Heb. 9.22.DVR. The testimonies of the Fathers which you alleadge, vvherein the Sacrament is called an vnbloody sacrifice, make nothing for you: seeing that vvith them is called vnbloody, not that is vvithout blood but vvithout effusion of blood. WHIT pag. 318. The word 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, vnbloody, vsed by them, signifieth such a thing as hath no blood in it. If therefore this be 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, an vnbloody sacrifice, as the Fathers call it, then it is a Sacrifice without blood, and not only without shedding of blood. Againe if it be a sacrifice wherin no blood is spilt, then is it not the sacrifice of Christ; for in this blood was shed: nor any true sacrifice, for there is no sacrifice that hath blood without the shedding therof.
But let us examine the remainder of your contestation: Thou wilt pray (say you) unto the Martyrs and all the Saints, that they would mediate for thee unto Christ. Thou wilt restrain effeminate Apostates from wicked copulation. Whether the Martyrs and heavenly Saints pray unto Christ for us or no,m we know not: but certain it is, that they aren ignorant of those things we do. And therefore we rather go untoo Christ, and pray unto him alone, who ⟨p. 107⟩both knoweth our wants, and also will and can grant unto us such things as we desire. You if you please may seek after the purling streams, but we will draw out of the fountain it self, neither do we regard the inveterate custom of praying unto saints (for though this custom is ancient; nevertheless, it hath flowed from the well-head of humane superstition, and not from divine authority:) and whereas you adjoin your conceit concerning the restraining effeminate Apostates from wicked copulation; and for this purpose allege some Canons of the Council of Chalcedon:4 in this you follow your old wont: for there is only one Canon to be found against ministering widows, which after they had taken upon them the office of ministration, married again: but how unjust this law is, it may easily appear.5 For when as Saint Paul would have these widows to bep sixty years old at least; this Canon doth admit of those who are but forty: and yet notwithstanding permitteth them not to marry. But you will say they have vowed single life: First, prove that they ought to make any such vow, and then, that if they shall perceive, they can by no means ⟨p. 108⟩perform their vow, that they have done otherwise then they should when they married.q To make a vow in things indifferent, which you cannot possibly perform, is to mock God, and to commit the crime of impious temerity: but to persist in this wicked vow is a double sin. And therefore that which the law prescribeth is to be embraced: The best course in evil promises made, is not to observe them; and we are so to behave our selves, as Bernard counselleth his sister. In evil promises keep not touch. 8rIn a dishonest vow change thy purpose. Do not perform that which thou hast vowed unadvisedly; for that promise is impious which is wickedly performed.
But let vs examine the remainder of your contestation: Thou wilt pray (say you) vnto the Martyrs and all the Saints, that they would mediate for thee vnto Christ. Thou wilt restraine effeminate Apostataes from wicked copulation. Whether the Martyrs and heauenly Saints pray vnto Christ for vs or no,m we know not: but certaine it is, that they aren ignorant of those things we doe. And therefore we rather goe vntoo Christ, and pray vnto him alone, who ⟨p. 107⟩both knoweth our wants, and also will and can grant vnto vs such things as we desire. You if you please may seeke after the pirling streames, but wee will draw out of the fountaine it selfe, neither doe we regard the inueterate custome of praying vnto saints (for though this custome is auncient; neuerthelesse, it hath flowed from the well-head of humane superstition, and not from diuine authoritie:) and whereas you adioyne your conceit concerning the restraining offeminate Apostataes from wicked copulation; and for this purpose alleadge some Canons of the Councell of Chalcedon:4 in this you follow your olde wont: for there is only one Canon to be found against ministring widowes, which after they had taken vpon them the office of ministration, married againe: but how vniust this law is, it may easilie appeare.5 For when as Saint Paul would haue these widowes to bep sixtie yeares old at least; this Canon doth admit of those who are but fortie: and yet notwithstanding permitteth them not to marrie. But you will say they haue vowed single life: First, proue that they ought to make any such vowe, and then, that if they shall perceiue, they can by no meanes ⟨p. 108⟩performe their vowe, that they haue done otherwise then they should when they married.q To make a vow in things indifferent, which you cannot possibly performe, is to mocke God, and to commit the crime of impious temeritie: but to persist in this wicked vowe is a double sinne. And therefore that which the law prescribeth is to be embraced: The best course in euill promises made, is not to obserue them; and we are so to behaue our selues, as Bernard counselleth his sister. In euill promises keepe not touch.
mDVR. You can not be ignorant of this, that the Saints pray for us, if in the doctrine of faith you insist in the steps of the Fathers. WHIT. p. 328. We are ignorant thereof because there is no such thing contained in the Canonical Scriptures, which should not have bin omitted if the spirit of God had thought this knowledge necessary. Neither is it con••oversed what the Fathers thought of it; not doth it follow because they have care of us, they pray for us; neither if they do pray, therefore we should pray unto them.DVR. You cā not be ignorant of this, that the Saints pray for vs, if in the doctrine of faith you insist in the steps of the Fathers. WHIT. p. 328. We are ignorāt therof because there is no such thing cōteined in the Canonical Scriptures, which should not haue bin omitted if the spirit of God had thought this knowledge necessary. Neither is it con••ouersed what the Fathers thought of it; not doth it follow because they haue care of vs, they pray for vs; neither if they do pray, therefore we should pray vnto them.
nDVR. We know the blessedness of the Saints in heaven, and therefore they are not ignorant of our misery in earth. Again, Christ hath revealed unto the Saints living on the earth, divine and heavenly things, and therefore he revealeth to the Saints in heaven, what is done in earth. WHIT. pag 330. Although we generally know that the Saints in heaven are blessed, yet we know not their particular state, their actions, the manner & degree of their happiness: and therefore if your argument be good, it confuteth your self; seeing therefore it followeth, that they likewise are ignorant of our particular state & actions. Moreover Christ revealed to the Saints on earth, heavenly things, but not what was done in heaven, only he made those divine mysteries know unto them, which were necessary to salvation; whereof it followeth not that he revealeth to the Saints in heaven, what is particularly done on earth, unless you can prove that there is the like necessity of this knowledge.DVR. We knovv the blessednes of the Saints in heauen, and therefore they are not ignorant of our misery in earth. Againe, Christ hath reueiled vnto the Saints liuing on the earth, diuine and heauenly things, and therefore he reueileth to the Saints in heauen, vvhat is done in earth. WHIT. pag 330. Although we generally know that the Saints in heauen are blessed, yet we know not their particular state, their actions, the manner & degree of their happines: and therefore if your argument be good, it confuteth your self; seeing therfore it followeth, that they likwise are ignorant of our particular state & actions. Moreouer Christ reueiled to the Saints on earth, heauenly things, but not what was done in heauen, only he made those diuine mysteries knowe vnto them, which were necessary to saluation; whereof it followeth not that he reuealeth to the Saints in heauen, what is particularly done on earth, vnles you can proue that there is the like necessity of this knowledge.
DVR. Nazianzene d•d not iudge inturiously nor writet• bitterly of Councels, as you suppose; but only a•fi•med that the fraud and malice of the heretikes of those times, hindred the assembling of lawfull Councels. WHIT. pag. 264. It seemeth you haue not read his Epistle, or but very sle•gtly, •eeing he therein plainly set•eth downe two reasons why he absented himselfe from the Councell, when he was called: f••st the weaknes of his body, and secondly, his iudgment concerning Councels: which was, that he thought such assemblies were to be auoided, because he had seene no good of any Synode, and that hereby occasions of euils were rather increased then taken away. DVR. Yea but he hath shened his contrary iudgment vvriting his Cledonius. WHIT. Nothing lesse: but only hee affirmeth that he vvould subscribe to the Apollinarian heretikes, if they could proue that they vvere receiued of the vvest Councell; vvhich hee knevv they could not.
3Nazianz. Epist. 4•. ad Procop. [Greek or Hebrew].Nazianz. Epist. 4•. ad Procop. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
DVR. The filth Canon of the Councell of Constantinople, ascribed greater honor to the Romane Sea, then to any other. WHIT. pag. 311. This honor was only of precedence and place, and not of authority; as plainly appeareth in the words of the Councell it self•. Chap. •8. and in that the like prerogatiue was graunted in the next place to the Bishop of Constantinople, and therefore by the like reason he might •rrog••• authority ouer the whole Church.
3Canon. 5.
4Ephes. Conc. in Epist. ad Nestor.
hDVR. In the Councell of Ephesus divers things are contained, which approve the supremacy of the Sea of Rome, &c. WHIT. pag. 313. Campian cited the Epistle of the Councell to Nestorius, wherein there is nothing which any way favoureth the Popes supremacy; the which you perceiving, do rake together other fragments concerning things which are not in controversy, and leave out those points which make against you.DVR. In the Councell of Ephesus diuers things are conteined, vvhich approue the supremacy of the Sea of Rome, &c. WHIT. pag. 313. Campian cited the Epistle of the Councell to Nestorius, wherein there is nothing which any way fauoureth the Popes supremacy; the which you perceiuing, do rake together other fragments concerning things which are not in controuersie, and leaue out those points which make against you.
lDVR. Eusebius doth not call it a sacrifice, because it is a sole & bare memorial of the new Testament, as you suppose: but because we offer an unbloody socrifice, for a memorial of a bloody sacrifice. WHIT. pag. 323. Neither do I affirm it, for this is not a bare memorial, seeing the thing it self, thereby signified, is therein contained in the right use of it. But withal I deny that this memorial is the same sacrifice which Christ offered, as you would have it; for how can a sacrifice be ye self same with it of which it is a memorial? If therefore this be an unbloody sacrifice, thē it is not the Sacrifice which Christ offered, which was bloody, & the memorial of no other sacrifice. See Eus. de Demon. l. 1.DVR. Eusebius doth not call it a sacrifice, because it is a sole & bare memoriall of the new Testament, as you suppose: but because vvee offer an vnbloody socrifice, for a memoriall of a bloody sacrifice. WHIT. pag. 323. Neither doe I affirme it, for this is not a bare memoriall, seeing the thing it selfe, thereby signified, is therin cōteined in the right vse of it. But withall I deny that this memoriall is the same sacrifice which Christ offered, as you would haue it; for how can a sacrifice be ye self same with it of which it is a memorial? If therfore this be an vnbloody sacrifice, thē it is not the Sacrifice which Christ offered, which was bloody, & the memorial of no other sacrifice. See Eus. de Demon. l. 1.
In a dishonest vowe change thy purpose. Doe not performe that which thou hast vowed vnaduisedly; for that promise is impious which is wickedly performed.
oDVR. S. Paul desireth the Romans and Corinthians to pray for him, and therefore we may desire the same of the Saints in heaven. We know that we obtain all in the name of Christ, but seeing all are not in like grace with God, the Fathers and we have made choice of those who are most gracious. WHIT. pag. 336. The first part of your answer confuteth the latter, unless you will say that Paul was less gracious with God, then the Romans and Corinthians; and both are weak & of no value: for first Paul prayeth not to them as you do to Saints, but only desireth them to perform a mutual Christian duty, which the Saints living, who are acquainted with one anothers estate and wants, ought not to neglect: if he had made the likesuite to a Prophet departed, John Baptist, or James slain by Herod, you had somewhat to say. Lastly if those are to be made choice of for mediators, who are in greatest grace with God, to whom should we go but unto Christ his dearly beloved Sonne, in whom God is well pleased and we reconciled? Eph. 16. Matth. 3.17. Joh. 14.6. 1. Tim. 2.5.DVR. S. Paul desireth the Romans and Corinthians to pray for him, and therfore vve may desire the same of the Saints in heauen. We knovv that vve obtaine all in the name of Christ, but seeing all are not in like grace vvith God, the Fathers and vve haue made choise of those vvho are most gratious. WHIT. pag. 336. The first part of your answere confuteth the latter, vnles you will say that Paul was lesse gratious with God, then the Romans and Corinthians; and both are weake & of no value: for first Paul praieth not to them as you do to Saints, but only desireth them to performe a mutual Christian duty, which the Saints liuing, who are acquainted with one anothers estate and wants, ought not to neglect: if he had made the likesuite to a Prophet departed, Iohn Baptist, or Iames slaine by Herode, you had somewhat to say. Lastly if those are to be made choise of for mediators, who are in greatest grace with God, to whom should we goe but vnto Christ his dearely beloued Sonne, in whom God is well pleased and we reconciled? Eph. 16. Matth. 3.17. Ioh. 14.6. 1. Tim. 2.5.
pDVR. There is nothing determined in the Scriptures concerning the age of widows. That which S. Paul writeth, was profitable for the insancie of the Church; but when the Gospel had taken deeper •oot in mens harts, they began to prefer contivency before marriage. WHIT. pag. 337. Your impudency is to be admired, seeing S. Paul hath plainly determined that they should be fixtie years of age at the least, 1. Tim. 5.9. neither were such Apostolical constitutions to endure only for a time, but until the coming of Christ, as appeareth. 1. Tim. 6.14. And whereas you say the Gospel after the Apostles times, took deeper root in mens minds, it is merely false; it was indeed further propagated, but the Church was never in after ages endued with the like measure of grace, and extraordinary gifts, as it was in the Apostles times, when they received the first fruits of the spirit. And I would pray the Reader to consider that Duraeus doth confess, that in the first age of the Church single life was not so much desired of most, and in later times they only beg•n to prefer continency before matriage. But how much better it had been to have kept the Apostolic institutions, and to have changed compelled continency for lawful and holy marriage, the lamentable event hath sufficiently proved.DVR. There is nothing determined in the Scriptures concerning the age of vviddovves. That vvhich S. Paul vvriteth, vvas profitable for the insancie of the Church; but vvhen the Gospell had taken deeper •oot in mens harts, they began to preferre cōtiuency before marriage. WHIT. pag. 337. Your impudency is to be admired, seeing S. Paul hath plainly determined that they should bee fixtie yeares of age at the least, 1. Tim. 5.9. neither were such Apostolicall constitutions to indure only for a time, but vntill the comming of Christ, as appeareth. 1. Tim. 6.14. And whereas you say the Gospell after the Apostles times, tooke deeper roote in mens minds, it is meerely false; it was indeed further propagated, but the Church was neuer in after ages indued with the like measure of grace, and extraordinarie giftes, as it was in the Apostles times, when they receiued the first fruits of the spirit. And I would pray the Reader to consider that Duraeus doth confesse, that in the first age of the Church single life was not so much desired of most, and in later times they onely beg•n to preferre continency before matriage. But how much better it had been to haue kept the Apostolike institutions, and to haue chaunged compelled continency for lawfull and holy marriage, the lamentable euent hath sufficiently proued.
qDVR. You say, to vow that which we cannot perform, is to mock God; but this we may perform, seeing God bestoweth the virtue of continency upon those, who seek it by fasting and prayer: and seeing the vestal Nuns and Egyptian Priests attained unto it, and wines also, when their husbands are long absent upon necessary occasion. WHIT. pag. 340. God granteth not all things we pray for, but those things which he hath promised, as appeareth in the example of S. Paul 2. Cor. 12.8. But we have no promise of the gift of continency; yea contrariwise Christ hath taught us, that all are not capable of it, but those only to whom it is given Matth. 19.11. & the Apostle saith that it is a gift proper to some only. 1. Cor. 7.7. and therefore we have no ground absolutely to pray for it with assurance of being heard. The vestal Nuns & Egyptian Priests are fit examples for your imitation, who lived single, but not chaste: and yet the Vestals might marry when they were past thirty years old; and some Egyptian Priests, as appeareth, Gen. 41.45. Concerning the chastity of wives in their husbands necessary absence, the reason is not alike; for it is one thing to impose upon our selves a voluntary necessity, and another to undergo it when it is imposed by God. God will keep us in our ways, Psal. 90.14. but not when we rashly thrust our selves into needless difficulties.DVR. You say, to vovv that vvhich vve cannot performe, is to mocke God; but this vve may performe, seeing God bestovveth the vertue of continencie vpon those, vvho seeke it by fasting and prayer: and seeing the vestall Nuns and Aegyptian Priests atteined vnto it, and vvines also, vvhen their husbands are longe absent vpon necessary occasion. WHIT. pag. 340. God granteth not all things wee pray for, but those things which hee hath promised, as appeareth in the example of S. Paul 2. Cor. 12.8. But we haue no promise of the gift of continency; yea cōtrariwise Christ hath taught vs, that all are not capable of it, but those only to whō it is giuen Matth. 19.11. & the Apostle saith that it is a gift proper to some onely. 1. Cor. 7.7. and therefore wee haue no ground absolutely to pray for it with assurance of being heard. The vestall Nuns & Aegyptian Priests are fit examples for your imitation, who liued single, but not chast: and yet the Vestals might marrie when they were past thirtie yeares old; and some Aegyptian Priests, as appeareth, Gen. 41.45. Concerning the chastitie of wiues in their husbands necessary absence, the reason is not alike; for it is one thing to impose vpon our selues a voluntary necessitie, and another to vndergoe it when it is imposed by God. God will keepe vs in our waies, Psal. 90.14. but not when wee rashly thrust our selues into needlesse difficulties.
8Bernard. ad Soror. de modo bene vivendi Serm. 62.Bernard. ad Soror. de modo bene viuendi Serm. 62.
rDVR. Bernard writeth not against the vow of virginity, but only willeth us to break a dishonest vow, neither is this book, you know, thought to be his. WHIT. pag. 342. It is not much material who was the author, but his judgement is to be embraced: seeing then that is a dishonest vow, the performance whereof is joined with dishonesty, it followeth that the vow of single life is such, when as it causeth men to burn in the flame of lust, and therefore is rather to be broken then observed.DVR. Bernard vvriteth not against the vovv of virginity, but only vvilleth vs to breake a dishonest vovv, neither is this booke, you knovv, thought to be his. WHIT. pag. 342. It is not much materiall who was the author, but his iudgement is to be embraced: seeing then that is a dishonest vow, the performance whereof is ioyned vvith dishonestie, it follovveth that the vovv of single life is such, vvhen as it causeth men to burne in the flame of lust, and therefore is rather to be broken then obserued.