REASONS OF CAMPIANS CHALLENGE RENDERED AND GIVEN TO THE Students of the English Universities.REASONS OF CAMPIANS CHALLENGE RENDRED AND GIVEN TO THE Students of the English Vniuersities.
pp. 17–326288 passagespart 1 of 8
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
My principal reasons are ten,
1. Holy Scriptures.
2. True meaning of the holy Scriptures.
3. Nature of the Church.
4. General Councils.
5. Fathers.
6. Sure ground of the Fathers.
7. History.
8. Paradoxes of the Adversaries.
9. Sophisms of the Adversaries.
10. All manner of witnesses.
My principall reasons are ten,
1. Holy Scriptures.
2. True meaning of the holie Scriptures.
3. Nature of the Church.
4. Generall Councels.
5. Fathers.
6. Sure ground of the Fathers.
7. Historie.
8. Paradoxes of the Aduersaries.
9. Sophismes of the Aduersaries.
10. All manner of witnesses.
Whereas there are many things. which evidently open the Adversaries mistrust in the cause, yet nothing so much, as the majesty of Gods books, by them most filthily*
corrupted. For they, who after that they have rejected the voices and testimonies of all other witnesses, and are nevertheless,
⟨p. 18⟩
driven to so narrow shifts, that they cannot defend their cause to be good, except they lay violent hands upon the holy Scriptures also, assuredly show themselves to be in great distress, and all other helps failing and fainting, must now try the last and uttermost shift. What cause had the Manichees to cancel
Ebionites to abandon all S. Pauls Epistles? Desperation: for so long as these kept their authority, Circumcision is abolished, which they had brought back again. What enforced
Oracles they be expressly convinced, as often as they dispute against the defence of Angels, as often as they dispute against Free-will, as often as they dispute against praying for the dead, as often as they dispute against praying to Saints. Is it so indeed? Is there such frowardness, is there such presumption amongst men? when they had trodden under foot the authority of the Churches, Councils * Seas, Fathers, Martyrs, Emperors, People, Laws, Universities, Histories, all Monuments of Antiquity & holiness; & had openly proclaimed, that they would have all controversies decided by the written word of God only;
WHereas there are many things. which euidently open the Aduersaries mistrust in the cause, yet nothing so much, as the maiestie of Gods bookes, by them most filthilie* corrupted. For they, who after that they haue reiected the voyces and testimonies of all other witnesses, and are neuerthelesse, ⟨p. 18⟩driuen to so narrow shifts, that they cannot defend their cause to be good, except they lay violent hands vpon the holy Scriptures also, assuredly shew themselues to be in great distresse, and all other helps failing and fainting, must now trie the last and vttermost shift. What cause had the Manachies to cancela S. Matthewes Gospell, and the Acts of the Apostles? Desperation: for they were tormented with these bookes, both because they had denied Christ to beb borne of a Ʋirgin, and also had falsely affirmed, that then the holyc Ghost came first downe from heauen amongst Christians, when theird Paraclete, that most wicked Persian leapt out. What made thee Ebionits to abandon all S. Paules Epistles? De•peration: for so long as these kept their authoritie, Circumcision is abolished, which they had brought backe againe. What enforcedf Luther that most wicked Apostata, to call the Epistle of S. Iames, *contentious, proud, barren, rushy, and iudge it to be vnworthy an Apostolike spirit? Desperation:g For by this Epistle that miserable caitife affirming our iustification to be by faith* only, is vtterly confuted & cōfounded what incensedh Luthers whelpes, on a suddaine to put out of the* true Canon of Scripture, Tobias, Ecclesiasticus, & the two bookes of the Macchabees; & in despight of them many otheri bookes, vnto which they picked the like quarrell? Desperation: for by these heauenlyk Oracles they be expresly conuinced, as often as they dispute against the defence of Angels, as often as they dispute against Free-will, as often as they dispute against praying for the dead, as often as they dispute against praying to Saints. Is it so indeed? Is there such frowardnes, is there such presumption amongst mē? when they had trodden vnder foot the authority of the Churches, Coūcels * Seas, Fathers, Martyrs, Emperours, People, Lawes, Ʋniuersities, Histories, all Monuments of Antiquitie & holines; & had openly proclamed, that they would haue all controuersies decided by the written word of God only;
*It is false: for we have corrupted no part of the Bible.It is false: for we haue corrupted no part of the Bible.
aAug. lib. 28. contra Faust. cap. 2 & de utilit. cre. c. 3.Aug. lib. 28. contra Faust. cap. 2 & de vtilit. cre. c. 3.
fPraefat in Epist. Jac. vide etiam lib. de capt. Babyl. & centur. 2.Praefat in Epist. Iac. vide etiam lib. de capt. Babyl. & centur. 2.
*This is most false, for Luther greatly approveth of this Epistle, neither ever did he call it a contentious, swelling, barren, or strawne Epistle.This is most false, for Luther greatly approueth of this Epistle, neither euer did he call it a contentious, swelling, barren, or strawne Epistle.
gJaco. ca. 2.Iaco. ca. 2.
*This is false: for the place maketh nothing at all against Justification by faith only.This is false: for the place maketh nothing at all against Iustification by faith only.
hBibl. Geneu.
*It is false, th•se books were never accounted part of the true Canon.It is false, th•se bookes were neuer accounted part of the true Canon.
would they then have dismembered the ⟨p. 19⟩very same word, which only remained, by cutting out of the whole body, so many, so good, and so excellent parts thereof. For the Calvinists have cut out of the old Testamentl seven whole books, besides certain other small pieces, which I let pass unspoken of The Lutherans likewise have cut off S. James Epist & for spite of it,m five others, which some where else also were once called in question. To these also, do the late Genevans add the book of Esther, & a great part of the third chapter, & all the two last chapters of Daniel, which the Anabaptists their school-fellows had a little before condemned, & laughed to scorn; But how much more modest lie dealt S. Austin, who making a Catalogue of the books of holy Scriptures, took for his rule neither the Hebrew Alphabet, as the Jews do, nor yet his own private spirit, as Heretics use to do; but that spirit wherewith Christ quickeneth the whole body of his Church, which Church being not Lady (as Heretics do cavil) but only keeper of this gage, hath by old* ancient Councils, openly challenged this whole and entire treasure of the books of Scripture, which the late Council of Trent also hath embraced? The self-same S. Augustine, entreating particularly of one parcel of Scripture, could not persuade himself, that the book of Wisdom, should by any mans rashness, or secret false suggestion, be thrust out of the Canon of Scripture, which even in his time, by judgement of the Church, process of time, testimony of ancient writers, and instruction of faithful men, had kept his authority, as a sound and Canonical book; what would he say if he were now living upon the earth again, and should see the Lutherans and Calvinists to be Bible makers, who with their sine and smooth stile, have raced both the old and new Testament, and put out of the Canon of holy Scriptures, not only the book of Wisdom, but many books more also? so that, that which shall not be uttered out of their shops, must by their brain-sick decree be rejected as a thing most rude and loath some. They that are driven to this horrible and ⟨p. 20⟩detestable shift, though their Arms be blazed never so far abroad, by their own disciples, though they buy and sel• benefices, though in their Sermons, they cry out against Catholics, though they procure them the sword, rack.
would they then haue dismembred the ⟨p. 19⟩very same word, which only remained, by cutting out of the whole body, so many, so good, and so excellent partes therof. For the Caluinists haue cut out of the old Testamentl seauen whole bookes, besides certaine other small peeces, which I let passe vnspoken of The Lutherans likewise haue cut off S. Iames Epist & for spight of it,m fiue others, which some where els also were once called in questiō. To these also, do the late Geneuans adde the booke of Hester, & a great part of the third chapter, & al the two last chapters of Daniel, which the Anabaptists their school-fellowes had a little before cōdemned, & laughed to scorne; But how much more modest lie delt S. Austine, who making a Catologue of the books of holy Scriptures, tooke for his rule neither the Hebrew Alphabet, as the Iewes do, nor yet his owne priuate spirit, as Heretikes vse to do; but that spirit wherewith Christ quickneth the whole body of his Church, which Church being not Lady (as Heretickes do cauil) but only keeper of this gage, hath by old* auncient Councels, openly challenged this whole and entire treasure of the bookes of Scripture, which the late Coūcell of Trent also hath embraced? The self-same S. Augustine, intreating particularly of one parcell of Scripture, could not perswade himselfe, that the booke of Wisdome, should by any mans rashnes, or secret false suggestion, be thrust out of the Canon of Scripture, which euen in his time, by iudgement of the Church, processe of time, testimonie af auncient writers, and instruction of faithfull men, had kept his authoritie, as a sound and Canonicall booke; what would he say if he were now liuing vpon the earth againe, and should see the Lutherans and Caluinists to be Bible makers, who with their sine and smooth stile, haue raced both the old and new Testament, and put out of the Canon of holy Scriptures, not only the booke of Wisdome, but many bookes more also? so that, that which shall not be vttered out of their shops, must by their brain-sicke decree be reiected as a thing most rude and loath some. They that are driuen to this horrible and ⟨p. 20⟩detestable shift, though their Armes be blazed neuer so farre abroad, by their owne disciples, though they buy and sel• benefices, though in their Sermons, they cry out against Catholikes, though they procure them the sword, racke.
mEpistol. ad Hebr. Epist Jud. Epist. 2. Pet. Ep. 2 & 3. Johannis. it a censent Luth. in praefat. Mag. Cent. 1. lib. 2. cap 4. Kem. in exam. con. Tri. Ses. 4. De doct. chr. lib. 2. cap. 8. Ses. 4. vide Mel. Can. lib. 2. de Loc. Theol. cap. 9.10.11. de praedest. Sanct. cap. 14.Epistol. ad Hebr. Epist Jud. Epist. 2. Pet. Ep. 2 & 3. Iohannis. it a censent Luth. in praefat. Mag. Cent. 1. lib. 2. cap 4. Kem. in exam. con. Tri. Ses. 4. De doct. chr. lib. 2. cap. 8. Ses. 4. vide Mel. Can. lib. 2. de Loc. Theol. cap. 9.10.11. de praedest. Sanct. cap. 14.
*This is false, for the Laodicene Councel doth so number the books of the Scriptures as we do, and not as the Councell of Trent doth.This is false, for the Laodicene Councel doth so number the bookes of the Scriptures as we do, and not as the Councell of Trent doth.
and gallows, yet are they overcome, naught set by, horrible in mens sight, and quite overthrown. For as much as the taking upon them the authority of Censors and sitting as honourable Judges, do dash out at their pleasure such holy Scriptures, as they found would not serve their turn; is there any body though never so simple, which can fear these subtle sleights of the Adversaries, who, as soon as they should enter within your assembly that are learned men, and fly unto such their usual shifts, as it were unto their familiar spirit, should, though not with reproach full words, yet at the least with trampling of your feet be thrust out of your schools? I would demand of them, (for example sake) b• what authority they maim and rob the corps of the Bible? They answer they do not cut out any true Canonical Scriptures but cull out only such as are not Canonical, that have been foisted into the Bible, and are indeed but counterfeits. Who shall be judge? the* holy Ghost; for this very answer dotho Calvin give, thereby to escape the judgement of the Church, by whose authority all spirits are tried; why then do some of you cut off certain books, and others of your crew, allow the same, seeing you all vaunt of the self-same spirit? The Calvinists spirit alloweth of six Epistles, which the Lutheran spirit doth disallow, and yet both of you (as you say) have the holy spirit. Thep Anabaptists do call the history of Job a fable interlaced with tragical and Comical metres: how know they that? by the spirit that instructeth them.q Castalio, that lecherous varlet made no more account of that mystical book of Solomon, commonly called Cantica canticorum (which the Catholics do as highly esteem as a Paradise of the soul, as that heavenly food Manna, which was laid up and kept in the tabernacle, ⟨p. 21⟩and as delicate dainties in Christ) then he did of a* bawdy song, and ribald tab of a Courtly waiting maid with her lover; where had he this? of the spirit? In the Apocalypse ofr S. John, every little title whereof S. Hierome affirmeth to contain some high and notable mystery; yet nevertheless, theses severe Judges, Luther, Brentius and Kemnitius find I know not what lacking shooting all at this mark, that the book might be defaced, and be of no authority: whom did they ask? the spirit.*
and gallowes, yet are they ouercome, naught set by, horrible in mens sight, and quite ouerthrowne. For as much as the taking vpon them the authoritie of Censorors and sitting as honorable Iudges, do dash out at their pleasure such holy Scriptures, as they found would not serue their turne; is there any body though neuer so simple, which can feare these sub•tle sleights of the Aduersaries, who, assoone as they should enter within your assemiblie that are learned men, and flie vnto such their vsuall snifts, as it were vnto their familiar spirit, should, though not with reproach full words, yet at the least with trampling of your feet be thrust out of your schooles? I would demaund of them, (for example sake) b• what authoritie they mayme and robbe the corpes of the Bible? They answere they doe not cut out any true Canonicall Scriptures but cull out only such as are not Canonicall, that haue been forsted into the Bible, and are indeed but counterfeits. Who shall be iudge? the* holy Ghost; for this very answere dotho Caluin giue, thereby to escape the iudgement of the Church, by whose authoritie all spirits are tried; why then do some of you cut off certaine bookes, and others of your crew, allow the same, seeing you all vaunt of the self-same spirit? The Caeluinists spirit alloweth of six Epistles, which the Lutheran spirit doth d•sallow, and yet both of you (as you say) haue the holie spirit. Thep Anabaptists doe call the historie of Iob a fable interlaced with tragicall and Comicall meeters: how know they that? by the spirit that instructeth them.q Castalio, that lecherous varlet made no more account of that mysticall booke of Salomon, commonly called Cantica canticorum (which the Catholikes do as highly esteeme as a Paradise of the soul, as that heauenly food Manna, which was laid vp and kept in the tabernacle, ⟨p. 21⟩and as delicate dainties in Christ) then he did of a* baudie song, and ribaudous ta•be of a Courtly wayting mayd with her louer; where had he this? of the spirit? In the Apocalyps ofr
*Campian refuseth the holy Ghost as Judge.Campian refuseth the holy Ghost as Iudge.
o1. Lib. Inst. cap. 7.
pXistus Sen. lib. 7.
qPraefat. in Cant.
*This is falsoe for Castalio in his preface hath no such word.
rEpist. ad Paul.
sPraef. in Apoc.
*This is most false: read the answer to it.This is most false: reade the answere to it.
Luther upon a preposterous zeal casteth a bone amongst theg four Evangelists, and preferring S. Pauls Epistles far before the three former Gospels, in the end concludeth, that the one only Gospel of S. John is from henceforth to be taken, for the gay, for the true, and the principal Gospel; as one that as much as in him lay would gladly have made the Apostles also partakers of his brawling in religious matters: who was his Tutor? the spirit. Besides this, that peevishu Fryer was so malapert, as to endeavour to make* S. Lukes Gospel to be suspected to be written in a wanton style, because therein good works are often commended unto us: whom hath he consulted with? the spirit. Theodorus Beza was so bold as to reprehend that mystical word taken out of the 22. Chapterx of S. Luke, Hic est Calix novum Testamentum in sanguine meo, qui (calix) pro vobis fundetur: This is the Cup of the new Testament in my blood, which (Cup) shall be sh•dde for you: as very corrupt and evilly placed there; because this sentence cannot admit any interpretation, but of the* wine of the Cup changed into the very true blood of Christ: where learned he that? of the spirit. Finally, when every man committeth every thing to his private spirit, they belie the name of the holy Ghost most blasphemously. Do not these fellows which deal thus, bewray themselves, and show what they are? are they not easily confuted? are they not in the assembly of such men, as you of both the Universities be, quickly perceived, and soon repressed: Ought I to fear ⟨p. 22⟩disputations with these in defence of the Catholic faith, who with much falsehood have handled the very word not of man, but of God himself? Here I pass over such things, as they have depraved in their false translations, though there be intolerable matters wherewith I may well charge them. I am very loath to take away any part of the matter, either from my old College fellow Master Gregory Martin, a man of excellent great knowledge in the three tongues,y which will handle this matter far more learnedly and copiously then I can; or from some others, which (as I understand) have already undertaken this matter. The matter that I now write of, is far more heinous and horrible.
Luther vpon a prepostorous zeale casteth a bone amongst theg foure Euangelists, and preferring S. Paules Epistles farre before the three former Gospels, in the end concludeth, that the one only Gospell of S. Iohn is from henceforth to be taken, for the gay, for the true, and the principall Gospell; as one that asmuch as in him lay would gladly haue made the Apostles also partakers of his brawling in religious matters: who was his Tutor? the spirit. Besides this, that peeuishu Fryer was so malapert, as to endeuor to make* S. Lukes Gospell to be suspected to be written in a wanton style, because therein good workes are often commended vnto vs: whom hath he consulted with? the spirit. Theodorus Beza was so bold as to reprehend that mysticall word taken out of the 22. Chapterx of S. Luke, Hic est Calix nouum Testamentum in sanguine meo, qui (calix) pro vobis fundetur: This is the Cup of the new Testament in my blood, which (Cup) shall be sh•dde for you: as very corrupt and euilly placed there; because this sentence cannot admit any interpretation, but of the* wine of the Cup changed into the very true blood of Christ: where learned he that? of the spirit. Finally, when euery man committeth euery thing to his priuate spirit, they belie the name of the holy Ghost most blasphemously. Do not these fellowes which deale thus, bewray themselues, and shew what they are? are they not easily confuted? are they not in the assemblie of such men, as you of both the Vniuersities be, quickly perceiued, and soone represt: Ought I to feare ⟨p. 22⟩disputations with these in defence of the Catholike faith, who with much falshood haue handled the very word not of man, but of God himselfe? Here I passe ouer such things, as they haue depraued in their false translations, though there be intolerable matters wherewith I may well charge them. I am very loath to take away any part of the matter, either from my old Colledge fellow Master Gregory Martin, a man of excellent great knowledge in the three tongues,y which will handle this matter farre more learnedly and copiously then I can; or from some others, which (as I vnderstand) haue already vndertaken this matter. The matter that I now write of, is farre more heynous and horrible.
gPraefat. in novum Test.Praefat. in nouum Test.
uSer. de Pharis & Publican.
*This is false: for Luther never spake saucily of S. Luke.This is false: for Luther neuer spake saucily of S. Luke.
xLuc. C. 22. [Greek or Hebrew].Luc. C. 22. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
*This is false: for by no means can he endure thi• exposition.This is false: for by no meanes can he endure thi• exposition.
There were lately discovered certain petty Doctors, that upon a drunken pang laid violent hands upon the divine Scriptures, and have condemned them, as corrupted, as maimed, as falsified, as craftily foisted in, in sundry places; some parts thereof they have corrected, some they have raced, and some they have quite pulled out. And lastly they have changed, as the fortress of this authentical writing of Gods own hand, wherewith before it was fenced, unto certain Lutheran spirits, as though it were into vain bulwarks of their own imaginations, or into bare painted walls, least peradventure they should have bin mum for want of matter, when they should stumble at such places of Scripture, as are plain against their heresies. Of which nevertheless, they could no sooner shift their hands, then sup up hot coals or eat hard stones. Then this first reason seemed to me urgent and just, which when it had evidently laid before mine eyes, that the Adversaries side was but counterfeited and feeble, truly it encouraged me much, being both a Christian, and also somewhat beaten in this kind of study, in defence of the everlasting Kings Charter, to encounter with the remnants of these discomfited enemies.
There were lately discouered certaine pettie Doctors, that vpon a drunken pange laid violent hands vpon the diuine Scriptures, and haue condemned them, as corrupted, as maymed, as falsified, as craftily foisted in, in sundrie places; some parts thereof they haue corrected, some they haue raced, and some they haue quite pulled out. And lastly they haue changed, as the fortresse of this authenticall writing of Gods owne hand, wherewith before it was fenced, vnto certaine Lutherane spirits, as though it were into vaine bulwarkes of their owne imaginations, or into bare painted walles, least peraduenture they should haue bin mum for want of matter, when they should stumble at such places of Scripture, as are plaine against their heresies. Of which neuerthelesse, they could no sooner shift their hands, then suppe vp hot coales or eate hard stones. Then this first reason seemed to me vrgent and iust, which when it had euidently laid before mine eyes, that the Aduersaries side was but counterfeited and feeble, truely it incouraged me much, being both a Christian, and also somewhat beaten in this kind of studie, in defence of the euerlasting Kings Charter, to encounter with the remnaunts of these discomfited enemies.
That Campian, which made you most cheerful in the cause you have undertaken, and boulder then a Jesuit (being newly come out of your den or cabin where you have lurked these divers years) to proclaim war against us all, and challenge to the combat the most valiant of us; that, you say, was the evident apprehension of our distrust and diffidence in our cause. But what manhood is this for so valorous a man as you make show to be, to provoke and with sharp war to pursue so timorous adversaries, who are ready to betake themselves to their heels, not daring to stand to it, but distrusting their own strength? But tell us in what things our distrust hath bin so sensible. There are many things, say you, which evidently bewray the adversaries mistrust in the cause. Verily if boldness in oppugning and withstanding Religion were of as great force, as usually it is in making of war, and scaling the enemies walls, and racing his towns, we might well fear your furious and desperate attempts: for whatsoever could be compassed by rage, fury, and cruelty, that hath not in this combat and contention been wanting. But such weapons cannot dare religion and truth, neither can they displace it. Let it be granted, we have not been so cheerful and ready in the defence of a good cause as we ought, and as the cause it self well deserved, neither have we put to flight your forces ⟨p. 24⟩so soon as we ought to have vanquished them, yet we never gave ground, we never turned our backs upon you, neither ever sled out of the field.a For tell us Campian if you can, and remember the bypast times. Did we ever cunningly avoid any disputation? did we ever refuse any combat? did we ever shift off any of your offers and challenges? But how often have we publicly entered the combat with you? how often have we refuted your oft iterated Sophistications? what writing of yours is yet unanswered by us? or what course of disputation have we not yielded to? Are not all those disputations held at Wittenberg, Ratesbone, Augusta, Spire, Worms, Bearne, Possia, London, Cambridge, Oxford, most plentiful and pregnant witnesses, with what spirits, with what learning, with what truth we defended our Religion? what show or sign of fear, or diffidence found you amongst us? nay rather how true and singular confidence did there appear in us?
THat Campian, which made you most cheerefull in the cause you haue vndertaken, and boulder then a Iesuite (being newlie come out of your den or cabbine where you haue lurked these diuers yeeres) to proclame warre against vs all, and challenge to the combate the most valiant of vs; that, you saie, was the euident apprehension of our distrust and diffidence in our cause. But what manhood is this for so valourous a man as you make shew to be, to prouoke and with sharpe warre to pursue so timerous aduersaries, who are readie to betake themselues to their heeles, not daring to stand to it, but distrusting their owne strength? But tell vs in what things our distrust hath bin so sensible. There are many things, say you, which euidently bewray the aduersaries mistrust in the cause. Verelie if boldnes in oppugning and withstanding Religion were of as great force, as vsually it is in making of warre, and scaling the enemies walles, and racing his townes, we might well feare your furious and desperate attempts: for whatsoeuer could be compassed by rage, furie, and crueltie, that hath not in this combate and contention been wanting. But such weapons cannot dare religion and truth, neither can they displace it. Let it be graunted, we haue not been so cheerefull and readie in the defence of a good cause as we ought, and as the cause it selfe well deserued, neither haue we put to flight your forces ⟨p. 24⟩so soone as we ought to haue vanquished thē, yet we neuer gaue ground, we neuer turned our backs vpon you, neither euer sled out of the field.a For tell vs Campian if you can, and remember the bypast times. Did we euer cūningly auoid any disputation? did we euer refuse any combate? did we euer shift off any of your offers and challenges? But how often haue we publikely entred the combate with you? how often haue we refuted your oft iterated Sophistications? what writing of yours is yet vnanswered by vs? or what course of disputation haue we not yeelded to? Are not all those disputations held at Wittenberge, Ratesbone, Augusta, Spire, Wormes, Bearne, Possia, London, Cambridge, Oxford, most plentifull and pregnant witnesses, with what spirits, with what learning, with what truth we defended our Religion? what shew or signe of feare, or diffidence found you amongst vs? nay rather how true and singular confidence did there appeare in vs?
aDVR. You boats much of your valour. but whether think you is he valorous or fearful, who dare not otherwise buckle with his adversary, but upon condition he may forbid him what weapons he list, and choose for himself what he list? Now here is your valour, you forbid us the weapons of the Church, Councels, Fathers. You only leave us the weapons of the Scriptures? WH. Pag. 4. He that will overcome in this cause must only use those weapons, which are allowed in this kind of sight. For it is not lawful here, as in war, to take any weapon, by which you can wound your enemy. But weapons must be fetched out of the armoury of the Scriptures, and the spirit of God, or else there vvill be no foiling of an adversary. And this is that which the Scriptures do warrant; and Constantine commanded the Fathers of the Nicene Councel to use against the Arians, and to end controversies; the books of the Evangelists and Apostles, and the oracles of the old Prophets. Theodoret. lib. 2. cap. 6. And the like teacheth Hillarie de Trinit. lib. 7. August. Epist. 3. and contr. litre. Petil. Donat. lib. 3. cap. 6. and in divers other places. Why do you then repove this thing in us? Tell me, whose cause think you is best? whether ours, who are content with the Scriptures alone, and being armed with them can defend our own, and refel others; or yours, which in no case can be safe, if the cause must be tried by the Scripture only. Therefore at the fi•st you are forced to confess that you must come into the field unarmed and naked, if no weapons vvill be afforded you besides the Scriptures.DVR. You boats much of your valour. but vvhether thinke you is he valorous or fearefull, vvho dare not othervvise buckle vvith his aduersarie, but vpon condition he may forbid him what weapons he list, and choose for himselfe vvhat he list? Now here is your valour, you forbid vs the vveapons of the Church, Councels, Fathers. You only leaue vs the weapons of the Scriptures? WH. Pag. 4. He that will ouercome in this cause must onely vse those weapons, which are allowed in this kind of sight. For it is not lawfull heere, as in warre, to take any weapon, by which you can wound your enemie. But weapons must be fetched out of the armorie of the Scriptures, and the spirit of God, or else there vvill be no foyling of an aduersary. And this is that which the Scriptures doe warrant; and Constantine commanded the Fathers of the Nicene Councel to vse against the Arrians, and to end controuersies; the bookes of the Euangelists and Apostles, and the oracles of the old Prophets. Theodoret. lib. 2. cap. 6. And the like teacheth Hillarie de Trinit. lib. 7. August. Epist. 3. and contr. liter. Petil. Donat. lib. 3. cap. 6. and in diuers other places. Why doe you then repoue this thing in vs? Tell me, vvhose cause thinke you is best? vvhether ours, vvho are content vvith the S•riptures alone, and being armed vvith them can defend our ovvne, and refel others; or yours, vvhich in no case can be safe, if the cause must be tried by the Scripture only. Therefore at the fist you are forced to confesse that you must come into the field vnarmed and naked, if no vveapons vvill be afforded you besides the Scriptures.
you it is, and not we, when it comes to a trial indeed that begins to sweat, change countenance, tremble every joint of you, and bewray your deep distrust and the naughtiness of your cause. Wherefore, Campian, take it from me, ⟨p. 25⟩if you think our distrustfulness will help you any thing, you much deceive your self, for if we have with courage stood against your predecessors so far surpassing you, we will not yield a hair to you? nor fear your manner of conflict, being so childish in the judgement of all men. But this diffidence, you so cast in our dish, tell us what it is, and how it appears so clearly, Forsooth we distrust our hold in the Scriptures, and the majesty of Gods books we have most filthily corrupted. This indeed is a very great crimination you object to us, and an undoubted proof of our distrust: for they who are not able to maintain the Religion they profess, unless they lay violent hands upon the Scriptures, and impeach the sacred authority of those heavenly books, the cause on their side must be very naught and desperate indeed. Therefore I grant unto you, that it was very fearful desperation, which made the Manichees renounce the old Testament wholly, and cancel part of the new: the same also made Ebion reject all Pauls Epistles, and other heretics to do so too: for there was nothing fitter for them to uphold those their monstrous opinions, then by denying those books of holy Scripture.
you it is, and not we, when it comes to a trial indeed that begins to sweat, chaunge countenance, tremble euery ioynt of you, and bewray your deepe distrust and the naughtines of your cause. Wherefore, Campian, take it from me, ⟨p. 25⟩if you thinke our distrustfulnes will helpe you any thing, you much deceiue your selfe, for if we haue with courage stood against your predecessors so far surpassing you, we will not yeeld a haire to you? nor feare your manner of conflict, being so childish in the iudgement of all men. But this diffidence, you so cast in our dish, tell vs what it is, and how it appeares so clearely, Forsooth we distrust our hold in the Scriptures, and the maiestie of Gods bookes we haue most filthilie corrupted. This indeed is a very great crimination you obiect to vs, and an vndoubted proofe of our distrust: for they who are not able to maintaine the Religion they professe, vnlesse they lay violent hands vpon the Scriptures, and impeach the sacred authoritie of those heauenly bookes, the cause on their side must be very naught and desperate indeed. Therfore I graunt vnto you, that it was very fearefull desperation, which made the Manachies renounce the old Testament wholy, and cancell part of the new: the same also made Ebion reiect all Paules Epistles, and other heretikes to do so too: for there was nothing fitter for them to vphold those their monstrous opinions, then by denying those bookes of holy Scripture.
But I pray you Campian, let us see how these things make for your purpose: or what it is wherein we are so like those forenamed Heretics. Me thinks it little beseemeth your learning and eloquence, to slander us, and to pin upon our sleeves such odious crimes of ancient heretics so undeservedly. If we have shaken hands with the Manichees, if with the Ebionites, tell us wherein? But if we are culpable of no such thing, the Lord shall judge your outrageous and bold slanders, and maintain our uprightness and innocency. For who ever thought and spoke more honourably, reverently and with more due regard of ⟨p. 26⟩the Scriptures then we? who have received and embraced all Scripture given by inspiration, as the very voice of God himself; holding it for the only mystery of our faith and religion, and so resting in it, as that we desire no other help as necessary to salvation? which if we had not with more diligence and devotion defended, then you ever did, long ere this the glory of it had perished, and it had bin counted as a dead letter: For what have we done for these many years with more endeavour and diligence, then maintain the majesty and excellency of the Scriptures, which you have so unworthily violated? And yet you blush not to match us with the Manichees and Ebionites, who have violently laid most impure and villainous hands upon those sacred books. But, say you, Luther that most wicked Apostate, called the Epistle of S. James a contentious, swelling, barren and strawen Epistle, and judged it unworthy the spirit of an Apostle: still the fat would be in the fire, Campian, if you had not one fit of railing at Luther, for this is to show your self a right Jesuit, as indeed you are, shamelessly and audaciously to break out into railing, and specially to tear Luther with most bitter reproaches. This is your faculty and profession, this you have undertaken to do, whatsoever you• leave undone: surely he is an happy man, whom the Lord thus honoureth with the enmity and hatred of such wicked men: for he cannot choose but be an excellent man, whom wicked men do so deadly pursue. But you object against Luther his Apostasy: look to your self Campian, if you may not be more justly accused of this crime: for doubtless you are either an Apostate, or you were a cunning hypocrite. But if it be Apostasy to forsake Apostates, then was Luther such an Apostate.
But I pray you Campian, let vs see how these things make for your purpose: or what it is wherein we are so like those forenamed Heretikes. Me thinkes it little beseemeth your learning and eloquence, to slaunder vs, and to pinne vpon our sleeues such odious crimes of auncient heretikes so vndeseruedly. If we haue shaken hands with the Manachees, if with the Ebionits, tell vs wherein? But if we are culpable of no such thing, the Lord shall iudge your outragious and bold slaunders, and maintaine our vprightnes and innocency. For who euer thought and spoke more honorably, reuerently and with more due regard of ⟨p. 26⟩the Scriptures then we? who haue receiued and imbraced all Scripture giuen by inspiration, as the very voice of God himself; holding it for the only mysterie of our faith and religion, and so resting in it, as that we desire no other helpe as necessary to saluation? which if we had not with more diligence and deuotion defended, then you euer did, long ere this the glorie of it had perished, and it had bin counted as a dead letter: For what haue we done for these many yeeres with more endeuour and diligence, then maintaine the maiesty and excellencie of the Scriptures, which you haue so vnworthily violated? And yet you blush not to match vs with the Manachees and Ebionits, who haue violently laid most impure and villanous hands vpon those sacred bookes. But, say you, Luther that most wicked Apostata, called the Epistle of S. Iames a contentious, swelling, barren and strawen Epistle, and iudged it vnworthy the spirit of an Apostle: still the fatte would be in the fire, Campian, if you had not one fit of rayling at Luther, for this is to shew your selfe a right Iesuite, as indeed you are, shamelessely and audaciously to breake out into rayling, and specially to teare Luther with most bitter reproches. This is your facultie and profession, this you haue vndertaken to do, whatsoeuer you• leaue vndone: surely he is an happy man, whom the Lord thus honoreth with the enmitie and hatred of such wicked men: for he cannot chuse but be an excellent man, whom wicked men do so deadly pursue. But you obiect against Luther his Apostasie: look to your selfe Campian, if you may not bee more iustly accused of this crime: for doubtlesse you are either an Apostata, or you were a cunning hypocrite. But if it be Apostasie to forsake Apostataes, then was Luther such an Apostata.
For he abandoned thieves, heretics, Apostates, and separated himself ⟨p. 27⟩from that Church, in which that daily Apostasy from religion,1 which the Apostle did foretell, was now come to the height: they then who would not be Apostates must fly from the Apostasy of your Church.
For hee abandoned theeues, heretikes, Apostataes, and separated himselfe ⟨p. 27⟩from that Curch, in which that daily Apostasie from religion,1 which the Apostle did foretell, was now come to the height: they then who would not be Apostataes must flie from the Apostasie of your Church.
But say you, Luther spake not so reverently of the Epistle of S. James as was fitting: It is well all you can challenge him with, is touching this Epistle only: he never did by any one word impeach the Gospels of Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John, neither the Epistles of Saint Paul, or Saint Peter; only a little he taxed the Epistle of Saint James. Is Luther alone in this crime? hath all Antiquity received this Epistle of S. James, & Luther only rejected it? undoubtedly, no: neither was Luther ignorant what censure the ancient Church gave of this Epistle:* Eusebius adventured to write expressly of this Epistle thus.b Be it known to all men that this Epistle which is fathered on Saint James, is counterfeit: what can be written more plainly? it may be you will except against Eusebius. But tell us why? therefore not to stand with you,3 will you hear what Hierome saith, who as you well know was an Elder of the Church of Rome? The Epistle of James is held to have been published under his name by some other. The one saith it is counterfeit, the other writeth, that it was thought to be published not by the Apostle, but by some other. Why then ⟨p. 28⟩are you angry with Luther, whom you see not unadvisedly and rashly to doubt of the authority of that Epistle, but therein followeth the judgement and censure of the ancient Church? for from hence it is very clear,c that the first age of the Church doubted somewhat of the credit and authority of this Epistle. But you will say, it was afterwards received, and Hierome witnesseth as much. I inquire not how justly that might be received in a succeeding age, which once was rejected, that the credit and authority it had not in the beginning, it might gain in time by mens calmness in judging: neither will I contend about the authority of this Epistle. Let it be as great as ever any book had; we verily receive it, and put it in the Canon of the Scriptures; for whatsoever Luther or any other may conclude touching this Epistle, or lessen the credit of it any way; yet all our Churches willingly embrace it, and judge it written by the Apostle, or some Apostolic man; and in it do undoubtedly acknowledge the doctrine and spirit of an Apostle.* I, saith Calvin, willingly and without controversy receive this Epistle, because I see no just cause to reject it.
But say you, Luther spake not so reuerently of the Epistle of S. Iames as was fitting: It is well all you can challenge him with, is touching this Epistle only: he neuer did by any one word impeach the Gospels of Matthew, Marke, Luke, and Iohn, neither the Epistles of Saint Paul, or Saint Peter; only a little he taxed the Epistle of Saint Iames. Is Luther alone in this crime? hath all Antiquitie receiued this Epistle of S. Iames, & Luther only reiected it? vndoubtedly, no: neither was Luther ignorant what censure the auncient Church gaue of this Epistle:* Eusebius aduētured to write expresly of this Epistle thus.b Be it knowne to all men that this Epistle which is fathered on Saint Iames, is counterfeit: what can be written more plainely? it may be you will except against Eusebius. But tell vs why? therefore not to stand with you,3 will you heare what Hierome saith, who as you well know was an Elder of the Church of Rome? The Epistle of Iames is held to haue been published vnder his name by some other. The one saith it is counterfeit, the other writeth, that it was thought to be published not by the Apostle, but by some other. Why then ⟨p. 28⟩are you angrie with Luther, whom you see not vnaduisedly and rashly to doubt of the authoritie of that Epistle, but therein followeth the iudgement and censure of the auncient Church? for from hence it is very cleare,c that the first age of the Church doubted somewhat of the credit and authoritie of this Epistle. But you will say, it was afterwards receiued, and Hierome witnesseth as much. I inquire not how iustly that might be receiued in a succeeding age, which once was reiected, that the credit and authoritie it had not in the beginning, it might gaine in time by mens calmnesse in iudging: neither will I contend about the authority of this Epistle. Let it be as great as euer any booke had; we verily receiue it, and put it in the Canon of the Scriptures; for whatsoeuer Luther or any other may conclude touching this Epistle, or lessen the credit of it any way; yet all our Churches willingly imbrace it, and iudge it written by the Apostle, or some Apostolike man; and in it do vndoubtedly acknowledge the doctrine and spirit of an Apostle.* I, saith Caluin, willingly and without controuersie receiue this Epistle, because I see no iust cause to reiect it.
*Lib. 2. c. pa 23.
bDVR. But Eusebius only saith, that this Epistle was thought of divers, not to be written by S. James; and denies not the canonical authority of it. For after he saith: It was received of many Churches. WHIT. Pag. 12. You wrest both the words and sense of Eusebius: for he allegeth not other mens opinions, but his own direct judgement. But if we admit that you say, it must the rather be counterfeit; for if Saint James did not write it, and yet he calleth himself James the servant of God, and of our Lord Jesus Christ: must it not be forced? •ave the pen-men of the Scripture used to take other mens names unto them? If you deny it to be written by Saint James, you must needs confess it to be Apocrypha: and so after your sense, Eusebius hath rejected this Epistle; which thing to him that readeth Eusebius will manifestly appear. And that he saith many Churches receive it, and not all; must needs prove that he thought it was not Canonical.DVR. But Eusebius onely saith, that this Epistle vvas thought of diuers, not to be vvritten by S. Iames; and denies not the canonicall authoritie of it. For after hee saith: It was receiued of many Churches. WHIT. Pag. 12. You wrest both the words and sence of Eusebius: for he alleageth not other mens opinions, but his owne direct iudgement. But if wee admit that you say, it must the rather bee counterfeit; for if Saint Iames did not write it, and yet hee calleth himselfe James the seruant of God, and of our Lord Iesus Christ: must it not bee forced? •aue the pen-men of the Scripture vsed to take other mens names vnto them? If you deny it to bee written by Saint James, you must needes confesse it to be Apocrypha: and so after your sense, Eusebius hath reiected this Epistle; which thing to him that readeth Eusebius will manifestly appeare. And that hee saith many Churches receiue it, and not all; must needs proue that he thought it was not Canonicall.
3Hieronym. in Catalogo.
cDVR. Doth he therefore doubt of the authority of this book; what shall we then say to Calvin, who hath plainly denied that the Epistle to the Hebrews was written by Saint Paul? and if you had not been a deceiver, you would have alleged Hierome wholly: for it followeth. Though by little and little in succeeding ages it obtained authority. WHIT. Pag. 16 He that saith, It is thus held, and neither dislikes nor refures such a suspicion, showeth he not himself also doubtful of it? Calvin had some reason, because that Epistle was not published in the name of Saint Paul, as this was of Saint James. What comparison is there in these two? the Epistle of Saint James hath his name in the beginning of it, as the author of it; so hath not the other the name of Saint Paul: so that he that denies that to be written by Saint James, must needs make it counterfeit. But no such thing here. Therefore may this be held to be canonical, though it be denied to be written by Saint Paul. If you had read but a few lines more, you should find that I used no deceit, neither had you caus to be so bitter. And these words of Hierome prove directly, that the authority of this Epistle was sometimes doubted of.
Therefore object no longer unto us other mens sharp censures and hard speeches, whereof we are no ways guilty: for what is it to us, what other men think of this Epistle, who dispraise no part of it, neither detract any thing from the authority ⟨p. 29⟩thereof? But where I pray you writ Luther any such thing, which you make mention of? let us see the place, that we may perceive how faithfully you deal. You tell us of a Preface he writ upon the Epistle of S. James, such as I think few men know: for it is no where to be found amongest Luther's works: yet by accident I light upon that preface, and read it from the beginning to the ending, in which not any of those things is to be seen which you mention: so that we may easily conjecture what we are like to find of you in the sequel, when in the beginning you are not ashamed to lye so palpably. For Luther begins his preface thus. The Epistle of S. James though rejected of Antiquity, I much commend & hold very fitting & profitable. And in this book of the Babylonish captivity, he thus writeth of this Epistle. I pass over that which many probably affirm, that this was not the Epistle of S. James the Apostle, nor agreeing with the spirit of an Apostle. These things very gravely and modestly hath Luther written concerning this Epistle of S. James; d& never culled it as you affirm, a contentious, barren, swelling, or a strawen Epistle: though I deny not but Luther was of that opinion, that he greatly called in question the Author and Argument of this Epistle. And it had been your part, who condemn his opinion, to have confuted his reasons. Erasmus evidently writeth, that this Epistle hath no taste of Apostolic authority; so that Luther judged more tolerably of this Epistle, then Erasmus. But howsoever the case stand, Luther in his judgment is not without the consent of thee first and purest Churches. And yet to let Luther pass, we have no ⟨p. 30⟩other opinion of this Epistle, then your selves have, and honour it as much, as you think it deserves. And let me promise and avow this for us all; whatsoever in this combat, which you have undertaken, you prove out of this Epistle, we will most willingly embrace, and not shift it off, as you suspect we will. All the sentences of this Epistle, we allow of, and reject not any one.
Therefore obiect no longer vnto vs other mens sharpe censures and hard speeches, whereof we are no wayes guilty: for what is it to vs, what other men thinke of this Epistle, who dispraise no part of it, neither detract any thing from the authority ⟨p. 29⟩thereof? But where I pray you writ Luther any such thing, which you make mention of? let vs see the place, that we may perceiue how faithfully you deale. You tell vs of a Preface he writ vpon the Epistle of S. Iames, such as I thinke few men know: for it is no where to be found amongest Luthers workes: yet by accident I light vpon that preface, and read it from the beginning to the ending, in which not any of those things is to be seene which you mention: so that we may easily coniecture what we are like to find of you in the sequell, when in the beginning you are not ashamed to lye so palpablie. For Luther begins his preface thus. The Epistle of S. Iames though reiected of Antiquitie, I much commēd & hold very fitting & profitable. And in this booke of the Babylonish captiuity, he thus writeth of this Epistle. I passe ouer that which many probablie affirme, that this was not the Epistle of S. Iames the Apostle, nor agreeing with the spirit of an Apostle. These things very grauely and modestly hath Luther written concerning this Epistle of S. Iames; d& neuer culled it as you affirme, a contentious, barren, swelling, or a strawen Epistle: though I deny not but Luther was of that opinion, that he greatly called in question the Author and Argument of this Epistle. And it had been your part, who condemne his opinion, to haue confuted his reasons. Erasmus euidently writeth, that this Epistle hath no tast of Apostolike authoritie; so that Luther iudged more tolerably of this Epistle, then Erasmus. But howsoeuer the case stand, Luther in his iudgment is not without the consent of thee first and purest Churches. And yet to let Luther passe, we haue no ⟨p. 30⟩other opinion of this Epistle, then your selues haue, and honor it as much, as you thinke it deserues. And let me promise and anow this for vs all; whatsoeuer in this combate, which you haue vndertaken, you proue out of this Epistle, we will most willingly imbrace, and not shift it off, as you suspect we will. All the sentences of this Epistle, we allow of, and reiect not any one.
dDVR. Jf you had seen the copy printed at Jena you should see that Luther thus speaketh of this Epistle. WHIT. p. 22. I acknowledge that Luther in a most ancient preface published by himself at Wittenberg 1525. called it a strawen Epistle in comparison of the Epistles of Saint Peter and Saint Paul, but find not that, you affirm any where.DVR. Jf you had seene the copie printed at Jena you should see that Luther thus speaketh of this Epistle. WHIT. p. 22. I acknowledge that Luther in a most auncient preface published by himselfe at Wittenberge 1525. called it a strawen Epistle in comparison of the Epistles of Saint Peter and Saint Paul, but finde not that, you affirme any where.
eDVR. Jf he agreed with the first and purest Churches: you differing from him, do dissent from them. WHIT. I call them the purest Churches, not for their sincere judgement of this Epistle, but for that they flourished in the best and purest times.DVR. Jf he agreed with the first and purest Churches: you differing from him, doe dissent from them. WHIT. I call them the purest Churches, not for their sincere iudgement of this Epistle, but for that they flourished in the best and purest times.
For as for that instance, which you give of sole faith, it is but a silly and lame trick of your sophistry; our doctrine of justification by faith only is most true & holy; which S. Paul also clearly teacheth, though he do notf expressly use these words,2 Faith alone. And the ancient do so expound and interpret S. Paul. Ambrose saith;g They are justified only by faith, it is the gift of God. hBasil saith; They are justified by faith alone in Christ. iNazianzene saith; Righteousness consisteth in faith only. Why should I recite any other sayings of other of the Fathers of the Church? This doctrine is both Evangelical and Apostolical; contrary to this, if James or an Angel from heaven should preach, let him be held as impious, wicked, and accursed. But you will say S. James ⟨p. 31⟩denies justification by faith only, yea affirms that we are justified by works. We answer, that the Apostle speaketh of ak feigned dead, idle, and counterfeit faith, which many boasted of, and falsely persuaded themselves they were just by it. This faith, which we may more truly call a carcass of faith, Saint James denieth to be sufficient for salvation to any, and he that is justified he teacheth must be justified by works, that is, must be proved, and declared to be just: for it must needs be, that faith be living, fruitful and accompanied with good works, that all may clearly perceive and discern, you are endued with true faith. And so doth S. James very fitly accord with S. Paul, while he disputes from the effects; when as S. Paul argueth from the cause. The principal & immediate cause of our justification, S. Paul makes faith; S. James writeth that a man is justified by works, that is, every man by his works as by most pregnant testimonies isl known and acknowledged just, while his invisible faith is witnessed and declared by his visible works. Therefore you see there is no reason why for this cause Luther should either find fault with, or fear the Epistle of S. James. And thus Augustine hath reconciled these two Apostles James ⟨p. 32⟩and Paul, that you may see that we are not broachers of any Novelty. Wherefore, saithm Augustine; 9the judgements of the two Apostles, S. Paul, & S. James, are not contrary each to other, when the one saith a man is justified by faith without works; and the other saith, that it is a vain faith which is without works; because S.
For as for that instance, which you giue of sole faith, it is but a sillie and lame tricke of your sophistry; our doctrine of iustification by faith only is most true & holy; which S. Paul also clearely teacheth, though he doe notf expressely vse these words,2 Faith alone. And the auncient do so expound and interpret S. Paul. Ambrose saith;g They are iustified only by faith, it is the gift of God. hBasil saith; They are iustified by faith alone in Christ. iNazianzene saith; Righteousnes consisteth in faith only. Why should I recite any other sayings of other of the Fathers of the Church? This doctrine is both Euangelicall and Apostolicall; contrary to this, if Iames or an Angell from heauen should preach, let him be held as impious, wicked, and accursed. But you will say S. Iames ⟨p. 31⟩denies iustification by faith only, yea affirmes that we are iustified by workes. We answere, that the Apostle speaketh of ak feigned dead, idle, and counterfeite faith, which many boasted of, and falsly perswaded themselues they were iust by it. This faith, which we may more truly call a carcase of faith, Saint Iames denieth to be sufficient for saluation to any, and he that is iustified he teacheth must be iustified by workes, that is, must be proued, and declared to be iust: for it must needs be, that faith be liuing, fruitfull and accompanied with good works, that all may clearely perceiue and discerne, you are indued with true faith. And so doth S. Iames very fitly accord with S. Paul, while he disputes from the effects; when as S. Paul argueth from the cause. The principall & immediate cause of our iustification, S. Paul makes faith; S. Iames writeth that a man is iustified by workes, that is, euery man by his workes as by most pregnant testimonies isl knowne and acknowledged iust, while his inuisible faith is witnessed and declared by his visible workes. Therefore you see there is no reason why for this cause Luther should either find fault with, or feare the Epistle of S. Iames. And thus Augustine hath reconciled these two Apostles Iames ⟨p. 32⟩
fDVR. Saint Paul never in plain words hath affirmed our justification by faith only. WHIT. pag. 27. When S. Paul saith we are justified by faith, it is as much as by faith alone, because faith respects only mercy, and withal excludeth works: Rom. 3.28 & cap. 4.5.6. & cap. 3.20. Gal. 2.16. and lastly he saith we are freely justified by grace: Eph. 2.7.8. Rom. 3.24. then he affirms that faith only doth justify.DVR. Saint Paul neuer in plaine words hath affirmed our iustification by faith onlie. WHIT. pag. 27. When S. Paul saith we are iustified by faith, it is as much as by faith alone, because faith respects onely mercy, and withall excludeth workes: Rom. 3.28 & cap. 4.5.6. & cap. 3.20. Gal. 2.16. and lastly he saith we are freely iustified by grace: Eph. 2.7.8. Rom. 3.24. then he affirmes that faith only doth iustifie.
gDVR. Ambrose by his sole faith excludeth only the works of the ceremonial law, and so he speaketh in that place. WHIT. pag. 33. It is enough that he affirmeth that this is S. Pauls position: we are justified by faith only. And when he excludeth only the works of the ceremonial law, in that he is against the judgement of Augustine and Hierome and himself also, in lib. 2. cap. 2. de Jacob. & vita beata.DVR. Ambrose by his sole faith excludeth only the workes of the ceremoniall law, and so he speaketh in that place. WHIT. pag. 33. It is enough that he affirmeth that this is S. Paules position: we are iustified by faith only. And when he excludeth only the workes of the ceremoniall law, in that he is against the iudgement of Augustine and Hierome and himselfe also, in lib. 2. cap. 2. de Iacob. & vita beata.
hDVR. Basil excludes only those works which are wrought by the sole power of freewill. WHIT. pag. 38. Basil excludes not only the works wrought by the power of freewill, but even those which proceed from faith and grace; for he produced S. Paul, and Saint Peter whom he denies to have been justified by works, yet had they both faith and grace.
Paul speaketh of works which go before faith: Saint James of works which follow faith; at S. Paul himself showeth in many places. Therefore the Apostle S. James would not, neither ought to detract any thing from the doctrine of justification, which Luther learned from S. Paul. Yea all Papists and Jesuits shall sooner be torn asunder, then this judgement of Luther, touching faith alone, shall either quail or be overthrown.
Paul speak•th of workes which goe before faith: Saint Iames of workes which follow faith; at S. Paul himselfe sheweth in many places. Therefore the Apostle S. Iames would not, neither ought to detract any thing from the doctrine of iustification, which Luther learned from S. Paul. Yea all Papists and Iesuits shall sooner be torne asunder, then this iudgement of Luther, touching faith alone, shall either quaile or be ouerthrowne.
From Luther you turn the edge of your speech to the whelps of Luther: for so you, as an unclean dog, term men famous and flourishing with all good qualities. But why you should so call them, I well conceive not, unless it be, for that they never cease barking against your Bishops and Monks, and other Church robbers, like your self. But let us hear what heinous thing those whelps have committed. They have on a sudden put out of the true Canon of the Scripture, Tobias, Ecclesiasticus, the two books of the Maccabees, and many other books. Say you of a sudden, Campian? Is it true indeed that you are such a stranger in the writings of the ancient Fathers, that you know not that long ago these books were raced out of the Canon? Look I pray you into Hierome, and out of him call to mind what antiquity hath done. That we may know, saithn Hierome, 2Whatsoever ⟨p. 33⟩books are more then these, they are to be accounted among the Apocrypha. Therefore Wisdom, which commonly is called the Wisdom of Solomon, and the book of Jesus the son of Sirach, and Judith, and Tobias, and Pastor, are not in the Canon. Will you that are but a Friar put these books in the Canon, which Hierome following the judgement of the ancient Church, and the truth it self, denieth to be in the Canon? mark well his own words: They are not in the Canon. You say that we have dashed them out; and why should we not so do? For, saith Hierome, they are not in the Canon. Desire you any further testimonies? Epiphanius saith as much as Hierome, who after he had recited divers books, which you say we have put out of the Canon, he thus writeth; as Cornarius renders his words out of the Greek. These books verily are profitable and helpful, 3but they are not reckoned in the number of those which are received. Therefore they are not to be found in Aaron, neither in the ark of the Covenant. But see out of Hierome more manifest and pregnant things.4 As therefore the Church readeth the books of Judith, Tobias, and Maccabees, but accounteth them not Canonical Scripture: so also these two books (he meaneth Wisdom and Ecclesiasticus) it reads for edification of the common sort, not for confirmation of any doctrine of the Church.
From Luther you turne the edge of your speech to the whelpes of Luther: for so you, as an vncleane dogge, terme men famous and flourishing with all good qualities. But why you should so call them, I well conceiue not, vnlesse it be, for that they neuer cease barking against your Bishops and Monkes, and other Church robbers, like your selfe. But let vs heare what heynous thing those whelpes haue committed. They haue on a suddaine put out of the true Canon of the Scripture, Tobias, Ecclesiasticus, the two bookes of the Macchabees, and many other bookes. Say you of a suddaine, Campian? Is it true indeed that you are such a stranger in the writings of the auncient Fathers, that you know not that long agoe these bookes were raced out of the Canon? Looke I pray you into Hierome, and out of him call to mind what antiquitie hath done. That we may know, saithn Hierome, 2Whatsoeuer ⟨p. 33⟩bookes are more then these, they are to be accoūted among the Apochrypha. Therefore Wisdome, which commonly is called the Wisdome of Salomon, and the booke of Iesus the sonne of Syrach, and Iudith, and Tobias, and Pastor, are not in the Canon. Will you that are but a Frier put these bookes in the Canon, which Hierome following the iudgement of the auncient Church, and the truth it selfe, denieth to be in the Canon? marke well his owne words: They are not in the Canon. You say that we haue dashed them out; and why should we not so doe? For, saith Hierome, they are not in the Canon. Desire you any further testimonies? Epiphanius saith as much as Hierome, who after he had recited diuers bookes, which you say we haue put out of the Canon, he thus writeth; as Cornarius renders his words out of the Greeke. These bookes verily are profitable and helpefull, 3but they are not reckoned in the number of those which are receiued. Therefore they are not to be found in Aaron, neither in the arke of the Couenant. But see out of Hierome more manifest and pregnant things.4 As therfore the Church readeth the bookes of Iudith, Tobias, and Macchabees, but accounteth them not Canonicall Scripture: so also these two bookes (he meaneth Wisdome and Ecclesiasticus) it reades for edification of the common sort, not for confirmation of any doctrine of the Church.
nDVR Hierome saith that the former Churches did not receive these books for Canonical: but denies them not to be Canonical. WHIT. pag. 52. Hicrome affirmeth not only that these books were not received of the fore-going Churches for Canonical, but himself o•ten times denies them to be such, and plainly calls them Apocrypha books, which he would never have done if the Church then had taken them for Canonical; yea and as Duraeus confesseth, they were not so taken until •lmo•t 70• years after Christ.DVR Hierome saith that the former Churches did not receiue these bookes for Canonicall: but denies them not to be Canonicall. WHIT. pag. 52. Hicrome affirmeth not only that these bookes were not receiued of the fore-going Churches for Canonical, but himself o•ten times denies them to be such, and plainely cals them Apoch•ypha bookes, which he w•uld neuer haue done if the Church then had taken them for Canonicall; yea and as Duraeus confesseth, they were not so taken vntill •lmo•t 70• ye•res af•er Christ.
If, Campian, you be ignorant of these ancient testimonies you are but a young soldier in that kind of fight, where you would be thought a well experienced Captain; but if you know them, you are too unjust and injurious unto us, to object to us, I know not what desperation, because we admit not those books in the Canon of the Scripture, which Antiquity tells us directly, were never admitted, neither are to be admitted:1 And verily Cardinal Caietan, fears not to avouch that he that writ the book of ⟨p. 34⟩the Maccabees, in a certain prophecy of Daniels, was a liar: but the holy Ghost was never wont to be deceived in the interpreting of the Scripture. Now whereas you imagine that we are convinced by those Oracles, as often as we dispute against the defence of Angels, as often as we dispute against freewill, as often as we dispute against praying to Saints: You must fi•st, before you can convince us, prove that an argument will conclude necessarily out of those books, to confirm the doctrine of the Church, which Hierome deemeth, and you shall never be able to prove, though you call all the Jesuits to a consultation. And seeing you object desperation to us, see ho• you bewray your own miserable desperation; who cannot establish the Articles of your faith by the Canonical Scriptures, but you she to the Apocrypha, whose authority hath bin▪ and for ever shall be doubted of in the Church. The Lord hath committed his Will and Wo•d to writing, and commended it to his Church: Those writings with all diligence and piety we receive and reverence; we are content with them, and we maintain thei• sufficiency; let go then these questionable, obscure, and Apocrypha books, and out of these contend with us about religion. But your religion long ago hath passed beyond the bounds of the sacred Scripture, and hath broken forth into many superstitions. And hence it is that you do the thing, than which nothing can be more malapert and intolerable; that is, make of like authority with holy Scripture, not only the Apocrypha books, but everyo unwritten. Tradition, wheresoever you come by them, at the second or third hand. But what do I telling you of these things, who shamefully have adventured long since to violate and infringe all the laws, both of God and man? ⟨p. 35⟩Take this from me:
If, Campian, you be ignorant of these auncient testimonies you are but a young souldier in that kind of fight, where you would be thought a well experienced Captaine; but if you know them, you are too vniust and iniurious vnto vs, to obiect to vs, I know not what desporation, because wee admit not those bookes in the Canon of the Scripture, which Antiquitie tels vs directly, were neuer admitted, neither are to be admitted:1 And verily Cardinall Caietan, feares not to auouch that he that writ the booke of ⟨p. 34⟩the Macchabees, in a certeine prophesie of Daniels, was a lyer: but the holy Ghost was neuer wont to be deceiued in the interpreting of the Scripture. Now wheras you imagine that we are conuinced by those Oracles, as often as we dispute against the defence of Angels, as often as we dispute against freewill, as often as we dispute against praying to Saints: You must fi•st, before you can conuince vs, proue that an argument will conclude necessarily out of those bookes, to confirme the doctrine of the Church, which Hierome demeth, and you shall neuer be able to proue, though you call all the Iesuits to a consultation. And seeing you obiect desperation to vs, see ho• you bewray your owne miserable •esperation; who cannot establish the Articles of your faith by the Canonicall Scriptures, but you she to the Apoc•ypha, whose authority hath bin▪ and for euer shall be doubted of in the Church. The Lord hath commited his Will and Wo•d to writing, and commended it to his Church: Those writings with all diligence and piety we receiue and reuerence; we are content with them, and we maintaine thei• sufficiency; let goe then these questionable, obscure, and Apochrypha bookes, and out of these contend with vs about religion. But your religion long agoe hath passed beyond the bounds of the sacred Scripture, and hath broken forth into many superstitions. And hence it is that you doe the thing, than which nothing can be more malapert and intolerable; that is, make of like authoritie with holy Scripture, not only the Apochrypha bookes, but eueryo vnwritten. Tradition, whersoeuer you come by them, at the second or third hand. But what do I telling you of these things, who shamefully haue aduentured long since to violate and inf•inge all the lawes, both of God and man?
1Caietan. in cap 24. Mattb.
oDVR. Pag. 5•. ••e do not aff•me Traditions, to be of the same authority with the holy Scriptures. WHIT. pag. 59 Though Duraeus here denieth it, yet the Councell of •rent doth with the like holy affection and reverence receive and honour them, as it doth the books o• the old and new Testament. See Dec•et. 1. Sess. 4.DVR. Pag. 5•. ••e do not aff•me Traditions, to be of the same authority with the holy Scriptures. WHIT. pag. 59 Though Duraeus heere denieth it, yet the Councell of •rent doth with the like holy affection and reuerence receiue and honor them, as it doth the bookes o• the old and new Testam•nt. See Dec•et. 1. Sess. 4.
if you can demonstrate that we have condemned or rejected any one book, or anyp part and portion of any book, which appeareth to have bin written and confirmed by divine authority, I will never contend any longer, but yield you the day, and give up our weapons to you. But if we have ever most faithfully kept the whole corps of the Scriptures, and have severed the true books from false, and have defended the heavenly truth of God, and preserved it uncorrupt, why do you poor silly F•ier cry out of our desperation, when your self is so far plunged in desperation it self, that there is no certainty of your salvation, but by the depravation and corruption of the holy Scriptures?
if you can demonstrate that we haue condemned or reiected any one booke, or anyp part and portion of any booke, which appeareth to haue bin written and confirmed by diuine authoritie, I will neuer contend any longer, but yeeld you the day, and giue vp our weapons to you. But if we haue euer most faithfully kept the whole corpes of the Scriptures, and haue seuered the true bookes from false, and haue defended the heauenly truth of God, and preserued it vncorrupt, why doe you poore silly F•ier cry out of our desperation, when your selfe is so farre plunged in desperation it selfe, that there is no certainty of your saluatiō, but by the deprauation and corruption of the holy Scriptures?
pDVR. Pag. 64. You have raced out these words out of S. John: Every spirit which divideth Christs not of God: •nd the history of the adulterous woman John 8.3. WHIT. pag. 65. We have not raced it out of the scripture; for it is not to be found in the mo•t ancient Greek copies, but as we read it, 1. Joh. 4.3. Cyprian also l. b. 2. cap. 8. testim. contra Judaeos so reads it, and Augustine also ad Po••ent. lib. 2. cap. 7. reads bo h. The history of the woman taken in adultery we race not out: though some of the ancient have done, and Beza though he demurred about it, ve• never dashed it out.DVR. Pag. 64. You haue raced out these words out of S. Iohn: Euery spirit •hich diuideth Christis not of God: •nd the historie of the adulterous woman Iohn 8.3. WHIT. pag. 65. We haue not raced it out of the •cripture; for it is not to be found in the mo•t auncient Greek copies, but as we read it, 1. Ioh. 4.3. Cyprian also l. b. 2. cap. 8. testim. contra Iudaeos so reads it, and Augustine also ad Po••ent. lib. 2. cap. 7. reads bo h. The history of the woman taken in adultery we race not out: though some of the auncient haue done, and Beza though he demurred about it, ve• neuer dashed it out.
Now in that you affirm we are convinced by those oracles: As often as we dispute of the defence of Angels, of freewill, of praying for the dead, and of praying to Saints: they are thing which we have discussed a thousand times, and have exactly determined them out of the true oracles of God. The defence of Angels is taught us in the Scripture, where we are taught that God hath set his Angels over certain people,1 places, and men; and of this in general we nothing doubt, but that Angels have that commission from the Lord, that they must provide for mens safety and salvation. So that we deny them not some kind of ministration, yea we attribute as much to them as the Lord hath taught us we should. And as for yourq Hierarchy and manifold degrees of Angels, we are willingly ignorant of them, and no whit envy your knowledge, who have had the revelation of such great mysteries from your Denis, who ⟨p. 36⟩hath (that I may use the words of S. Paul) advanced himself in those things which he never saw. But it is another patronage of Angels which you defend, and hold that we ought to worship them and call upon them, which the Scripture in plain words forbiddeth, forr S. Paul condemns Worshipping of Angels. 4And the Angel once and again called S. John from this kind of worship.s See thou doest it not, 6I am thy fellow servant, and one of thy brethren: worship God. As for Raphael int Toby, we pass not greatly, neither do acknowledge those seven Angels of whom he speaketh. All that which was spoken of Raphael, or which he speaketh of himself, i• far differing from the holy Scriptures, and it savoureth strongly of superstition. The place of Ecclesiasticus doth not much trouble me, neither should I the sooner believeu free will, though he an hundred times should repeat ⟨p. 37⟩that sentence;9 before man is life and death: seeing that thex Scripture teacheth that man lost his freedom by sin: the same thing teach they Fathers also, and every mans own experience: howsoever these words may be understood of mankind, as he was sometime in Adam. For thus he writeth a little before.12 He made man from the beginning, and left him in the hand of his own counsel; if he speak of the first condition and state of man, and of his perfect and uncorrupt nature, wherein he was created of the Lord, he speaketh very true:
Now in that you affirme we are conuinced by those oracles: As often as we dispute of the defence of Angels, of freewill, of praying for the dead, and of praying to Saints: they are thing which we haue discussed a thousand times, and haue exactly determined them out of the true oracles of God. The defence of Angels is taught vs in the Scripture, where we are taught that God hath set his Angels ouer certaine people,1 places, and men; and of this in general we nothing doubt, but that Angels haue that commission from the Lord, that they must prouide for mens safety and saluation. So that we deny them not some kind of ministration, yea we attribute as much to them as the Lord hath taught vs we should. And as for yourq Hierarchie and manifold degrees of Angels, we are willingly ignorant of them, and no whit enuy your knowledge, who haue had the reuelation of such great mysteries from your Denys, who ⟨p. 36⟩hath (that I may vse the words of S. Paul) aduaunced himselfe in those things whic he neuer saw. But it is another patronage of Angels which you defend, and hold that we ought to worship them and call vpon them, which the Scripture in plaine words forbiddeth, forr S. Paul condemnes Worshipping of Angels. 4And the Angell once and againe called S. Iohn from this kind of worship.s See thou doest it not, 6I am thy fellow seruant, and one of thy brethren: worship God. As for Raphael int Tobie, we passe not greatly, neither do acknowledge those seauen Angels of whom he speaketh. All that which was spoken of Raphael, or which he speaketh of himself, i• far differing from the holy Scriptures, and it sauoureth strongly of superstition. The place of Ecclesiasticus doth not much trouble me, neither should I the sooner beleeueu free will, though he an hundred times should repeate ⟨p. 37⟩
qDVR. Denis •as S Pauls disciple, and he hath manifested such m••teries. WHIT. pag 68. Why did not S. Paul, who wa• rapt up into the third heaven, and saw such great things, declare unto us the hierarchy of Angels? did he bur•e it in silence, and his disciple tell it abroad? But Denis was not the disciple of S. Paul, as shall in another place be proved.DVR. Denys •as S Pauls disciple, and he hath manifested such m••teries. WHIT. pag 68. Why did not S. Paul, who wa• rapt vp into the third heauen, and saw such great things, declare vnto vs the hierarchy of Angels? did he bur•e it in silence, and his disciple tell it abroad? But Denys was not the disciple of S. Paul, as shall in another place be proued.
rDVR. Saint Paul forbids only the offering up of sacrifice to Angels, and making of them new mediators. WHIT pag. 70. S. Paul forbids all worshipping of them, and so prayers, a swell as sacrifice•; they being a part of worship. pag 71. Chrysost. in Coloss. 2. hom. 7. in these words: Occumen. in Coloss. 2. whom you allege, do not interpret them for you, but for our opinion, and as the truth is.DVR. Saint Paul forbids onely the offering vp of sacrifice to Angels, and making of them nevv mediat•rs. WHIT pag. 70. S. Paul fo•bids all worshipping of them, and so prayers, a swell as sacrifice•; they being a part of worship. pag 71. Chrysost. in Coloss. 2. hom. 7. in these words: Occumen. in Coloss. 2. whom you alledge, do not interpret them for you, but for our opinion, and as the truth is.
but if he made it now free for us, as we are natural men, to choose or refuse life or death at our own pleasure; I am not so bound by the authority of this book and testimony, but that I may appeal from his Apocryphal sentence to the tried Oracles of God. Now for your book of thez Maccabees, I make far less account of it, which Hierome, Epiphanius, Athanasius, Cyprian, have hissed out, and the Leodicene Council hath rejected. Moreover that which is therein spoken of the sacrifice offered up for the sins of the dead, is merely matter of supposal, and forced into the text: for neither in Josephus is any such thing to be found in the ⟨p. 38⟩Greek, neither in Josephus the son of Gerion, who yet writ the self-same history in Hebrew, is there any mention of any such sacrifice, neither had thea Jews either by precept, or practise any such custom, to offer sacrifice and prayers for the dead. Lastly in the Greek copy there is that inversion and disordered placing of the words, that you can hardly make any true sense, or any whole sentence hang together. View the place in the Greek text, and if you can fitly translate it so, that all things may hang well together, I will yield, you are a better Grecian then I took you for. Shall I be tied then by the authority and force of this book, place, or sentence, to offer with you prayers and oblations for the dead? you are too too childish, Campian, to think such things can incline the Students of our Universities to like your side: other manner of matter must you bring, and of more force, if you will gain our favourable audience and good conceit: for these things long ago we have distasted and spit out; but who ever said, your self excepted, that this place of the Maccabees doth prove and confirm invocation of Saints? It is one thing to offer sacrifice for the dead, and another thing to say that the Saints departed make intercession for us. As for Judas bdream touching Onia, of which we read 2. Macchab. 15. I pass it over as a dream: but the matter is not great whether you understand the intercession of the dead, or oblations for the dead: both is yours, and both most false. And here again you cry out with great vehemency; Is it true indeed? is there such frowardness, is there such presumption among men? here is neither ⟨p. 39⟩the one, nor the other, Campian• we have done nothing frowardly;
but if he made it now free for vs, as we are naturall men, to chuse or refuse life or death at our owne pleasure; I am not so bound by the authoritie of this booke and testimonie, but that I may appeale from his Apochryphall sentence to the tried Oracles of God. Now for your booke of thez Macchabees, I make far lesse account of it, which Hierome, Epiphanius, Athanasius, Cyprian, haue hissed out, and the Leodicene Councel hath reiected. Moreouer that which is therein spoken of the sacrifice offered vp for the sinnes of the dead, is meerely matter of supposall, and forced into the text: for neither in Iosephus is any such thing to be found in the ⟨p. 38⟩Greeke, neither in Iosephus the sonne of Gerion, who yet writ the self-same history in Hebrew, is there any mention of any such sacrifice, neither had thea Iewes either by precept, or practise any such custome, to offer sacrifice and prayers for the dead. Lastly in the Greeke copy there is that inuersion and disordered placing of the words, that you can hardly make any true sense, or any whole sentence hang together. View the place in the Greeke text, and if you can fitly translate it so, that all things may hang well together, I will yeeld, you are a better Grecian then I tooke you for. Shall I be tied then by the authority and force of this booke, place, or sentence, to offer with you prayers and oblations for the dead? you are too too childish, Campian, to thinke such things can incline the Students of our Vniuersities to like your side: other manner of matter must you bring, and of more force, if you will gaine our fauourable audience and good conceite: for these things long agoe we haue distasted and spit out; but who euer said, your selfe excepted, that this place of the Macchabees doth proue and confirme inuocation of Saints? It is one thing to offer sacrifice for the dead, and another thing to say that the Saints departed make intercession for vs. As for Iudas bdreame touching Onia, of which we read 2. Macchab. 15. I passe it ouer as a dreame: but the matter is not great whether you vnderstand the intercession of the dead, or oblations for the dead: both is yours, and both most false. And heere againe you cry out with great vehemency; Is it true indeed? is there such frowardnes, is there such presumption among men? heere is neither ⟨p. 39⟩the one, nor the other, Campian• we haue done nothing frowardly;
zDVR. No Church ever rejected the book of the Maccabees. WHIT. pag. 83. The Church of the Jews did wholly: and the Church of the Christians as I have showed before. Yea, Gregory, the great, who was Bishop of Rome, in Job. lib. 17. Cap. 16. denies them to be in the Canon. And the Fathers, though they cite them as he did, yet so accounted them for no better. DVR. Augustine placeth them in the Canon. WHIT. pag. 83. Yet Gregory who lived 200. years after him, denies them to be Canonical, besides Augustine so calleth them, because the Church of Christians read them, and did not reject them so as the Jews did. August. de civitat. De• lib. 18. cap. 36. & August. cont. Gauden. lib. 2. cap. 23. further, Duraeus, confesseth that they were neither written by a Prophet, nor confirmed by a Prophet: then certain it is they are not in the Canon. DVR. Christians must be ruled by the judgment of the Catholic Church. WHIT. pag. 85. The Catholic Church cannot make those books which are not Canonical to be Canonical: besides I have showed, that the Catholic Church doth reject them.DVR. No Church euer reiected the booke of the Macchabees. WHIT. pag. 83. The Church of the Iewes did wholy: and the Church of the Christians as I haue shewed before. Yea, Gregory, the great, who was Bishop of Rome, in Iob. lib. 17. Cap. 16. denies them to be in the Canon. And the Fathers, though they cite them as he did, yet so accounted them for no better. DVR. Augustine placeth them in the Canon. WHIT. pag. 83. Yet Gregory vvho liued 200. yeeres after him, denies them to be Canonicall, besides Augustine so calleth them, because the Church of Christians read them, and did not reiect them so as the Ievves did. August. de ciuitat. De• lib. 18. cap. 36. & August. cont. Gauden. lib. 2. cap. 23. further, Duraeus, confesseth that they were neither written by a Prophet, nor confirmed by a Prophet: then certeine it is they are not in the Canon. DVR. Christians must be ruled by the iudgment of the Catholike Church. WHIT. pag. 85. The Catholike Church cannot make those bookes which are not Canonicall to be Canonicall: besides I haue shewed, that the Catholike Church doth reiect them.
aDVR. The Jews Machzor showeth that they do pray and offer sacrifice for the dead. WHIT. pag. 85. I much •egard not what the Jews do now: I affirmed that the old Jews had neither precept nor practise for it.DVR. The Iews Machzor sheweth that they do pray and offer sacrifice for the dead. WHIT. pag. 85. I much •egard not what the Ievves do now: I affirmed that the old Ievves had neither precept nor practise for it.
nothing presumptuously: I wonder at your frowardness and presumption, that those books which God disclaims, as none of his, which reverend antiquity hath put out of the Canon; yet you in your horrible & detestable frowardness & presumption, will bring into the Canon, whether God will or no, the holy Fathers denying them, & the books themselves disclaiming it. The Calvinists, say you, have cut off from the body of the old Testament, 1seven whole books: Why you shameless Friar, did not Hierome a thousand years before Calvin was borne, race them out? Why then slip you over Hierome, and quarrel with Calvin only, when they are both in one predicament? Hear yet again what Hierome saith. Whatsoever is besides these books, is to be accounted Apocrypha: but these seven books which you reckon up, and calumniously avouch that we have raced them out, are besides those Hierome makes mention of; they are then to be accounted Apocrypha. For most of these we have sufficiently answered. For Baruch, Hierome saith, We neither read it, nor find it in the Hebrew; all the other he casteth out of the Canon,2 and writeth freely. Those books which are not to be found in the Hebrew, neither are any of the 24. are to be rejected of those, who are of ripe years and knowledge. But you Jesuits are alway Children, as the Egyptian Priest answered Solon touching the Grecians. I wonder why you say never a word touching the third and fourth book of Esdra: it may be you are ashamed of them, being books, as Hierome writeth, full of dotages: yet your Church hath had them in great account, and the Fathers often times have alleged testimonies out of them; why do you, Campian, suddenly dash these books out of the Canon? If you judge they must be kept in the Canon, why do you not tax the Calvinists, who, as all men ⟨p. 40⟩know, have cut them out of the old Testament? Why when you number up all those sacred books, cut out of the Canon by the Calvinists, omit you these altogether? Or if these be Apocrypha, why should we deem the rest to be Canonical? I am not a little desirous to know, what is your judgement of these books: but you say further:3 The Lutherans have cut off Saint▪ James Epistle, and for spite of it, five others, which somewhere else also were once called in question. That these were once and elsewhere in question, you cannot deny.
nothing presumptuously: I wonder at your frowardnes and presumption, that those bookes which God disclaimes, as none of his, which reuerend antiquitie hath put out of the Canon; yet you in your horrible & detestable frowardnes & presūption, will bring into the Canon, whether God wil or no, the holy Fathers denying them, & the bookes themselues disclaiming it. The Caluinists, say you, haue cut off from the body of the old Testament, 1seauen whole bookes: Why you shamelesse Frier, did not Hierome a thousand yeeres before Caluin was borne, race them out? Why then slippe you ouer Hierome, and quarrell with Caluin only, when they are both in one predicament? Heare yet againe what Hierome saith. Whatsoeuer is besides these bookes, is to be accounted Apocrypha: but these seauen bookes which you reckon vp, and calumniously auouch that we haue raced them out, are besides those Hierome makes mention of; they are then to be accounted Apochrypha. For most of these we haue sufficiently answered. For Baruch, Hierome saith, We neither reade it, nor find it in the Hebrew; all the other he casteth out of the Canon,2 and writeth freely. Those bookes which are not to be found in the Hebrew, neither are any of the 24. are tobe reiected of those, who are of ripe yeeres and knowledge. But you Iesuits are alway Children, as the Egyptian Priest answered Solon touching the Grecians. I wonder why you say neuer a word touching the third and fourth booke of Esdra: it may be you are ashamed of them, being bookes, as Hierome writeth, full of dotages: yet your Church hath had them in great account, and the Fathers often times haue alledged testimonies out of them; why do you, Campian, suddeinly dash these bookes out of the Canon? If you iudge they must be kept in the Canon, why doe you not taxe the Caluinists, who, as all men ⟨p. 40⟩know, haue cut them out of the old Testament? Why when you number vp all those sacred bookes, cut out of the Canon by the Caluinists, omit you these altogether? Or if these be Apocrypha, why should we deeme the rest to be Canonicall? I am not a little desirous to know, what is your iudgement of these bookes: but you say further:3 The Lutherans haue cut off Saint▪ Iames Epistle, and for spite of it, fiue others, which somewhere else also were once called in question. That these were once and elsewhere in question, you cannot deny.
1These are Baruch, Tob•as, Judith, Sufficient a. Ec••ejias•icus. t••o Maccabees. H••ron prae f•t. in Jer.These are Ba•uch, Tob•as, Iud•th, Su••ent a. Ec••ejias•icus. t••o Macchabees. H••ron prae f•t. in Ier.
2Hieron ad Domnion, & Rogatian.
3Epist. Jacob. Ep ad Heb. Epist. Judah. Epist. 2. Pet. Epist. 2. & 3. Joan.Epist. Iacob. Ep ad Heb. Epist. Juda. Epist. 2. Pet. Epist. 2. & 3. Ioan.
The light and evidence of the story hath wrung this from you. But tell us who made question of them? Did heretics only? Then account Eusebius & Hierome amongst heretics, who have reported to us their own judgement of these Epistles, with the judgement of the Church. Can you prove that they were accounted heretics, in the first and pure ages of the Church, who took out of the Canon these Epistles? For the Epistle of Saint James, I have answered sufficiently: we neither reject that, nor any of the other Epistles, which you falsely accuse the Lutherans to have cut out; this is no fault of ours, whom you know to be far from Lutheranism: quarrel then with them: as for us, we never cunningly shifted off the testimonies and allegations of those Epistles. Can you in equity require any more of us? At length then forbear to upbraid us with I know not what desperation, frowardness and presumption: we willingly admit, receive, and allow of your own books, which your self make use of in disputation; to their judgment will we stand, if you can convince us by these you win the field.
The light and euidence of the storie hath wrung this from you. But tel vs who made question of them? Did heretikes onely? Then account Eusebius & Hierome amongst heretikes, who haue reported to vs their owne iudgement of these Epistles, with the iudgement of the Church. Can you prooue that they were accounted heretikes, in the first and pure ages of the Church, who tooke out of the Canon these Epistles? For the Epistle of Saint Iames, I haue answered sufficiently: we neither reiect that, nor any of the other Epistles, which you falsely accuse the Lutherans to haue cut out; this is no fauit of ours, whom you knowe to be farre from Lutheranisme: quarrell then with them: as for vs, we neuer cunningly shifted off the testimonies and allegations of those Epistles. Can you in equitie require any more of vs? At length then forbeare to vpbraide vs with I knowe not what desperation, frowardnes and presumption: wee willingly admit, receiue, and allow of your owne bookes, which your selfe make vse of in disputation; to their iudgment will we stand, if you can conuince vs by these you winne the field.
That which you add of the book of Ester, and of almost three whole chapters of Daniel, is nothing but cavilling. The book of Ester we account Canonical, as much as by Gods authority is ⟨p. 41⟩written inb Hebrew: but those fragments, which commonly are annexed to that holy history of Ester, we cannot so highly account of: as for those three chapters, they are none of Daniels, of which read, if you please,c Hieromes preface upon Daniel. And there you shall find, that not the Anabaptists only, but the ancient Jews have rejected and derided them. But, Campian, why do you trifle thus? were you wont to build much upon the authority of those books? did you in these lay the foundations of your faith? why then do you seek to make us odious by these books, which if they were never so Canonical, would further your cause never a whit the more?
That which you adde of the booke of Ester, and of almost three whole chapters of Daniel, is nothing but cauilling. The booke of Ester we account Canonicall, as much as by Gods authoritie is ⟨p. 41⟩written inb Hebrew: but those fragments, which commonly are annexed to that holy history of Ester, we cannot so highly account of: as for those three chapters, they are none of Daniels, of which read, if you please,c Hieromes preface vpon Daniel. And there you shall find, that not the Anabaptists only, but the auncient Iewes haue reiected and derided them. But, Campian, why doe you trifle thus? were you wont to build much vpon the authority of those bookes? did you in these lay the foundations of your faith? why then do you seeke to make vs odious by these bookes, which if they were neuer so Canonical, would further your cause neuer a whit the more?
bDVR. As if the Hebrew tongue were the rule of the Canon, and of divine authority. WHIT. pag. 90. No book is a part of the new Testament, which is written in Latin, yet is not Greek the rule of the Canon.DVR. As if the Hebrevv tongue were the rule of the Canon, and of diuine authority. WHIT. pag. 90. No booke is a part of the new Testament, which is vvritten in Latin, yet is not Greeke the rule of the Canon.
cDVR. Hicrome to Ruffinus, seemeth to approve those three chapters of Daniel. WHIT. pag. 92. Erasmus noted that Hierome dealt craftily, having in his preface showed he thought otherwise.DVR. Hicrome to Ruffinus, seemeth to approue those three chapters of Daniel. WHIT. pag. 92. Erasmus noted that Hierome delt craftely, hauing in his preface shevved he thought othervvise.
Now you much commend Augustine's modesty. Who, 1say you, hath made a Catalogue of the books of holy Scripture, far better then either the Jews, or Sectaries. I could wish you Jesuits had a little more modesty, that ye might be more like Augustine; for all men speak and cry out of your male pertness and insolency. But Augustine counted those books Canonical, which we do not; true, I deny it not, but what of that? is not Augustine opposite to Hierome? for Hierome expressly denies those books to be numbered in the Canon. And Augustine setting down the whole Canon of the Scripture, doth annex these to it. It seemeth there is a great difference in their judgements: for those which Hierome denies, Augustine affirmeth to be Canonical: both famous men and such as have deserved well of the Church of God; how then may we satisfy Augustine, whom Campian objecteth unto us? No otherwise then as the truth is. The terms of Apocrypha and Canonical Hierome useth in one sense, and Augustine in another: Hierome accounted all these books Apocrypha, which were not written in Hebrew: Augustine though in deed and in truth he differed not, yet he gave this name especially to those books, which ⟨p. 42⟩were not fraught with fables and lies, such as those times afforded very many. For so he writeth lib. 15. cap. 23. de civit. Dei. Though there be some truth found in the Apocrypha books, yet they have no Canonical authority, there being so many lies in them. Therefore he names in the Canon the book of Judith and Toby and Ecclesiasticus, & other of that sort, because there was more truth and sincerity in them, then in those common and divulged fables. Therefore Augustine useth the term of Canonical Scripture more largely then Hierome, and of Apocrypha more strictly: unless happily we will suppose that of set purpose Augustine would differ from Hierome in a thing of that moment. Besides the Romish Cardinal,2 of whom we spake before, writeth that certain Councils with Augustine accounted these books Canonical because they were rules for manners, not for faith and doctrine. And what reason Augustine had to plead for the book of Wisdom, 3least it should be turned out of the Canon, let him look to it himself;
Now you much commend Augustines modestie. VVho, 1say you, hath made a Catalogue of the bookes of holy Scripture, farre better then either the Iewes, or Sectaries. I could wish you Iesuits had a little more modestie, that ye might be more like Augustine; for all men speake and cry out of your male pertnes and insolency. But Augustine counted those bookes Canouicall, which we do not; true, I deny it not, but what of that? is not Augustine opposite to Hierome? for Hierome expressely denies those bookes to be nūbred in the Canon. And Augustine setting downe the whole Canon of the Scripture, doth annex these to it. It seemeth there is a great difference in their iudgements: for those which Hierome denies, Augustine affirmeth to be Canonicall: both famous men and such as haue deserued well of the Church of God; how then may we satisfie Augustine, whom Campian obiecteth vnto vs? No otherwise then as the truth is. The termes of Apochrypha and Canonicall Hierome vseth in one sense, and Augustine in another: Hierome accounted all these bookes Apochrypha, which were not written in Hebrew: Augustine though in deed and in truth he differed not, yet he gaue this name especially to those bookes, which ⟨p. 42⟩were not fraught with fables and lies, such as those times afforded very many. For so he writeth lib. 15. cap. 23. de ciuit. Dei. Though there be some truth found in the Apochrypha bookes, yet they haue no Canonicall authoritie, there being so many lies in them. Therefore he names in the Canon the booke of Iudith and Toby and Ecclesiasticus, & other of that sort, because there was more truth and sinceritie in them, then in those common and diuulged fables. Therefore Augustine vseth the terme of Canonicall Scripture more largely then Hierome, and of Apochrypha more strictly: vnlesse happily we will suppose that of set purpose Augustine would differ from Hierome in a thing of that moment. Besides the Romish Cardinal,2 of whom we spake before, writeth that certeine Councels with Augustine accounted these bookes Canonicall because they were rules for manners, not for faith and doctrine. And what reason Augustine had to plead for the booke of Wisdome, 3least it should be turned out of the Canon, let him looke to it himselfe;
1August. de doctrin. Christ. lib. 2. cap. 8.
2Caietan. in fine comenta. in histor. veter. Testameuti.
this very book Hierom, (whom you Jesuits usually prefer before Augustine) hath by name excluded, and from the self-same place where Augustine confirmeth the authority of this book, every man may gather, that it was not commonly received in the Canon; for when Augustine cited a testimony out of that book. He was taken away, 1least wickedness should alter his understanding, many of the brethren who were present cried out; It was not alleged out of a Canonical book. dNow it is like, they never would have rejected the argument and testimony of this speech, if the authority of that book had been Canonical in the Church. And yet I deny not but that Antiquity might think more reverently of this book, then of other of the books of Apochryphaes. For I ⟨p. 43⟩observe in Eusebius, thatc Melita, the Bishop of Sardis, in a certain Epistle written to Onesimus, wherein he setteth down exactly the number of the sacred books of the old Testament, and accounteth this book as one of the Canon: yet he mentioneth not one of the others which we call Apocrypha, neither Toby, nor Judith, nor the Maccabees, nor Ecclesiasticus, nor yet any of the rest, for which you strive so much; yet he affirmeth that he took great pains to know exactly those ancient books, and professeth that he fully attained his end.4 After, saith he, I had learned exactly what books belong to the old Testament, I sent them here under written unto you. And this it may be induced Augustine to attribute the more to this book, and yet it cannot be proved hence, as you would have it, that this book was Authentical and Canonical by the account of the Church, for Augustine himself witnesseth that it was not allowed as Canonical by the judgement of the Church; neither indeed if the Church would have given it all the allowance she could, could she have made it Authentical, except it had before it own Authenticalnes in it self from above.
this very booke Hierom, (whom you Iesuits vsually preferre before Augustine) hath by name excluded, and from the selfe-same place where Augustine confirmeth the authority of this booke, euery man may gather, that it was not commonly receiued in the Canon; for when Augustine cited a testimony out of that booke. He was taken away, 1least wickednes should alter his vnderstanding, many of the brethren who were present cried out; It was not alledged out of a Canonicall booke. dNow it is like, they neuer would haue reiected the argument and testimony of this speech, if the authoritie of that booke had been Canonicall in the Church. And yet I denie not but that Antiquitie might thinke more reuerently of this booke, then of other of the bookes of Apochryphaes. For I ⟨p. 43⟩obserue in Eusebius, thatc Melita, the Bishop of Sardis, in a certeine Epistle written to Onesimus, wherin he setteth downe exactly the number of the sacred bookes of the old Testament, and accounteth this booke as one of the Canon: yet he mentioneth not one of the others which we call Apochrypha, neither Toby, nor Iudith, nor the Macchabees, nor Ecclesiasticus, nor yet any of the rest, for which you striue so much; yet he affirmeth that he tooke great paines to know exactly those auncient bookes, and professeth that he fully attained his end.4 After, saith he, I had learned exactly what bookes belong to the old Testament, I sent them here vnder written vnto you. And this it may be induced Augustine to attribute the more to this booke, and yet it cannot be proued hence, as you would haue it, that this booke was Authenticall and Canonicall by the account of the Church, for Augustine himselfe witnesseth that it was not allowed as Canonicall by the iudgement of the Church; neither indeed if the Church would haue giuen it all the allowance she could, could she haue made it Authenticall, except it had before it owne Authenticalnes in it selfe from aboue.
1Wisd. 4.11.
dDVR. But you revive not Augustines answer, and how he objected against them, the consent of all Bishops, faithful Laity. &c. WHIT. pag. 97. Augustine doth not accuse them of impudency or sacrilege for denying it, nor reproves them much, only he saith it is better then other treatises; which I acknowledge. And the consents of the former he alleged to prove that a sentence of this book, is not lightly to be rejected, seeing many Churches did read it, though all did not receive it, as himselfe saith de civit. Dei lib. 27. cap. 20.DVR. But you reuiue not Augustines ansvvere, and hovv he obiected against them, the consent of all Bishops, faithf•ll Laitie. &c. WHIT. pag. 97. Augustine doth not accuse them of impudency or sacriledge for denying it, nor reprou•s them much, only he saith it is better then other treatises; vvhich I acknovvledge. And the consents of the former he alledged to proue that a sentence of this booke, is not lightly to be reiected, seeing many Churches did reade it, though all did not receiue it, as himselfe saith de ciuit. Dei lib. 27. cap. 20.
cDVR. Melito affirmeth this book to be Canonical. WHIT. pag. 98. Be it so, yet he rejects all your other and what have you got by it? But by the name of Wisdom some think, he meaneth the Proverbs of Solomon.DVR. Melito affirmeth this booke to be Canonicall. WHIT. pag. 98. Be it so, yet he reiectes all your other and what haue you got by it? But by the name of Wisdome some thinke, he meaneth the Prouerbs of Salomon.
But you who glory so greatly in Antiquity, in the voice of the Church, in Councils, what will you answer to the Laodicene Council,1 which forbids the reading of those books, which are without the Canon, and commandeth the reading of those only which are of the Canon of the old and new Testament:f But which are they? are all those which the ⟨p. 44⟩Tridentine Council hath put in the Catalogue? nothing less, but those only which our Church doth hold Canonical. If Campian, you will stand to the judgement of this Council, neither the book of Wisdom, nor any one of the other shall have place among the Canonical Scriptures. Now then whatsoever Augustine should say, if he were alive, doth not much trouble us: for whatsoever he should say in this kind, he could speak nothing against us, but it would touch the Fathers of the Laodicene Council, whose decree in this point, touching the Canonical Scriptures, either he had seen, or at least might take notice of it.
But you who glory so greatly in Antiquitie, in the voice of the Church, in Councels, what will you answere to the Laodicene Councell,1 which forbids the reading of those bookes, which are without the Canon, and commaundeth the reading of those only which are of the Canon of the old and new Testament:f But which are they? are all those which the ⟨p. 44⟩Tridentine Councell hath put in the Catalogue? nothing lesse, but those only which our Church doth hold Canonicall. If Campian, you will stand to the iudgement of this Councell, neither the booke of Wisdome, nor any one of the other shall haue place among the Canonicall Scriptures. Now then whatsoeuer Augustine should say, if he were aliue, doth not much trouble vs: for whatsoeuer he should say in this kind, he could speake nothing against vs, but it would touch the Fathers of the Laodicene Councell, whose decree in this point, touching the Canonicall Scriptures, either he had seene, or at least might take notice of it.
1Concil. Laodic. Canon. 59.
fDVR. It hath been answered a thousand times, that as yet in this age all the books were not received into the Canon. WHIT. pag. 102. Then by your confession, for 300. years after Christ these books were not in the Canon; it skilleth not much what the latter Churches have affirmed, when the purest and most ancient Churches affirm the same wedo. DVR. The Councels of Carthage, Florence, and Trent, have allowed them for Canonical. WHIT. pag. 102. We acknowledge not the two last to be lawful Councels, the first allowed it for manners, not doctrine and faith, and if the authority of it be so great with you, then you may not call your Pope universal Bishop? for that Councell denied it to him. Carthag. 3. cap. 26. distinct. 99. prima sedis.DVR. It hath been answered a thousand times, that as yet in this age all the bookes vvere not receiued into the Canon. WHIT. pag. 102. Then by your confession, for 300. yeeres after Christ these bookes were not in the Canon; it skilleth not much what the latter Churches haue affirmed, when the purest and most auncient Churches affirme the same wedo. DVR. The Councels of Carthage, Florence, and Trent, haue allovved them for Canonicall. WHIT. pag. 102. We acknowledge not the two last to be lawfull Councels, the first allowed it for manners, not doctrine and faith, and if the authoritie of it bee so great with you, then you may not call your Pope vniuersall Bishoppe? for that Councell denied it to him. Carthag. 3. cap. 26. distinct. 99. prima sedis.
Now for the things which follow you show much colour but little reason. You call this a horrible and detestable shift. Then do you, Campian, if you can, drive us out of this hold. Me thinketh it is so safe and well fortified, that it will easily bear off and repel all your assaults. Though, say you, their arms be blazed never so far abroad by their own disciples, though they buy and sell benefices, though in their sermons they cry out against Catholics, though they procure them the sword, rack and gallows, yet are they overcome, naught set by, horrible in mens sight, and quite overthrown. But yet young Friar, •ow thus much, by Gods blessing we hitherto stand upright on our feet, neither ever were we soiled at your hands, but have long ago by the help of God scattered, overthrown, and put to flight many of your armies. And the whole huge form of your pontifical and glorious synagogue hath long since tottered, and in short time will fall to the ground, as Dagon before the Ark; unless you Jesuits manfully uphold and sustain it: for it is impossible for us to be vanquished of you, in the defence of this cause. Therefore with good courage and cheerfulness we pursue this flight, nothing doubting but that the Lord in the end will repress you, and all ⟨p. 45⟩the enemies of his name and glory, and make you his footstool. And for that you write, touching buying & selling of benefices, if any be yet amongst us, it is but the relics of your wicked practises heretofore among us. For you know the custom of the Romish Court, you know their filthiness, their avarice, their Simony, yea you know how the whole world crieth out, and that continually of your most gainful Merchandises. Have you now leisure since you left Rome, to pry into our carriage, are all things so well at home, that you can without shame find faults abroad? Suppose you were now become honest and holy; yet you shall never be able to clear your Church of those filthy blemishes, wherewith it hath bin defiled in former times. And if there be any yet amongst us that use so foul a trade, they are well worthy to hear such reproaches from you, as such practises do deserve. But I marvel the less that you object to us buying and selling of Benefices, when you complain of our cruelty. Now, good God, are we so cruel and you so mild? what shall I say to it or what answer may I make?
Now for the things which follow you shew much colour but little reason. You call this a horrible and detestable shift. Then doe you, Campian, if you can, driue vs out of this hold. Me thinketh it is so safe and well fortified, that it will easily beare off and repell all your assaults. Though, say you, their armes be blased neuer so far abroad by their owne disciples, though they buy and sell benefices, though in their sermons they cry out against Catholikes, though they procure them the sword, racke and gallowes, yet are they ouercome, naught set by, horrible in mens sight, and quite ouerthrowne. But yet young Frier, •ow thus much, by Gods blessing we hitherto stand vpright on our seete, neither euer were we soyled at your hands, but haue long agoe by the helpe of God scattered, ouerthrowne, and put to flight many of your armies. And the whole huge forme of your pontificall and glorious synagogue hath long since tottered, and in short time will fall to the ground, as Dagon before the Arke; vnlesse you Iesuits manfully vphold and susteine it: for it is impossible for vs to be vanquished of you, in the defence of this cause. Therfore with good courage and cheerefulnes we pursue this flight, nothing doubting but that the Lord in the end will represse you, and all ⟨p. 45⟩the enemies of his name and glorie, and make you his footstoole. And for that you write, touching buying & selling of benefices, if any be yet amongst vs, it is but the reliques of your wicked practises heretofore among vs. For you know the custome of the Romish Court, you know their filthines, their auarice, their Simony, yea you know how the whole world crieth out, and that continually of your most gainfull Marchandizes. Haue you now leisure since you left Rome, to prie into our carriage, are all things so wel at home, that you can without shame find faults abroad? Suppose you were now become honest and holy; yet you shall neuer bee able to cleere your Church of those filthie blemishes, wherewith it hath bin desiled in former times. And if there be any yet amongst vs that vse so foule a trade, they are well worthy to heare such reproaches from you, as such practises do deserue. But I maruell the lesse that you obiect to vs buying and selling of Benefices, when you complaine of our crueltie. Now, good God, are we so cruell and you so mild? what shall I say to it or what answere may I make?
sure it is, there is nothing more inhumane, then cruelty, or more opposite to a Christians virtue: for the disciples of Christ ought to be gentle, clement, and meek, master-like: what then? are we more cruel then you? I will never deny this trial, that their cause should be judged the worst, whose cruelty appears to be the greatest: I call to witness all the people of the Christian world, who have yet any sense of humanity and equity remaining in them. Let Italy speak, also Germany, Spain, France, and our England. It were tedious to recite the horrible murders, the fearful burnings, and exquisite punishments you exercised amongst us. Your cruelty is known, and is yet fresh in memory, neither shall ever be buried in oblivion: what like to these did we ever practise, or wherein is our ⟨p. 46⟩cruelty so great? was it because we suffered not our throats to be cut by you, nor received your weapons into our bodies, nor laid our necks upon the block, nor willingly gave up our lives, that we might give you leave to live as you list. This is it indeed you wished for, for this you labour, and go about: we poor wretches are accounted cruel, because we live, and live to withstand your proceedings. But I doubt not but all indifferent men do sufficiently discern,g how injuriously you lay this crimination upon us, for these things which you name as the sword, the rack, the gallows, and fire, are the instruments of your cruelty, and had it not been for these, your Church had been overthrown long ago: for by these weapons it was first founded, after increased, and is now maintained? if once these fail you, questionless it cannot long continue.
sure it is, there is nothing more inhumane, then cruelty, or more opposite to a Christians vertue: for the disciples of Christ ought to be gentle, clement, and meeke, master-like: what then? are we more cruell then you? I will neuer deny this triall, that their cause should be iudged the worst, whose cruelty appeares to be the greatest: I call to witnes all the people of the Christian world, who haue yet any sense of humanity and equity remaining in them. Let Italy speake, also Germany, Spaine, Fraunce, and our England. It were tedious to recite the horrible murders, the fearefull burnings, and exquisite punishments you exercised amongst vs. Your cruelty is knowne, and is yet fresh in memory, neither shall euer be buried in obliuion: what like to these did we euer practise, or wherein is our ⟨p. 46⟩cruelty so great? was it because we suffered not our throats to be cut by you, nor receiued your weapons into our bodies, nor laid our neckes vpon the block, nor willingly gaue vp our liues, that we might giue you leaue to liue as you list. This is it indeed you wished for, for this you labour, and goe about: we poore wretches are accounted cruell, because we liue, and liue to withstand your proceedings. But I doubt not but all indifferent men do sufficiently discerne,g how iniuriously you lay this crimination vpon vs, for these things which you name as the sword, the racke, the gallowes, and fier, are the instruments of your cruelty, and had it not been for these, your Church had been ouerthrowne long agoe: for by these weapons it was first founded, after increased, and is now maintained? if once these faile you, questionlesse it cannot long continue.
gDVR Campian himself had experience of your cruelty. WHIT. pag. 105. If Campian was by public proceeding condemned for treason, and put to death: who will accuse our cruelty, and not the greatness of his offence, yea and that he suffered not for religion, appeareth thus; others who were condemned with him at the same time, and for the same offence, when they renounced the Popes authority of deposing of Kings, and freeing of subjects from obedience, were not put to death, as he was.DVR Campian himselfe had experience of your cruelty. WHIT. pag. 105. If Campian was by publike proceeding condemned for treason, and put to death: who will accuse our cruelty, and not the greatnes of his offence, yea and that he suffered not for religion, appeareth thus; others who were condemned with him at the same time, and for the same offence, when they renounced the Popes authority of deposing of Kings, and freeing of subiects from obedience, were not put to death, as he was.
But you now begin to press your adversaries somewhat more forcibly; and you demand of them, for example sake, by what authority they maim; and rob the corps of the Bible, I answer we offer no violence to this body, ne•ther do we cut off any which do appertain to the substance, and perfection of it; we dash out no part of it, we pull away no member. For (to use your own words) we do not cut out any true Canonical Scriptures, but cull out such as are not Canonical, but foisted in and counterfeit. But you would know who shall be judge; you make Calvin to answer for us: the holy Ghost: and you suggesting that he giveth this answer, to escape the judgement of the Church; if you enquire how we know these writings, which we call Scriptures, to be heavenly, and given by the inspiration of God, that is, by what testimony we are persuaded that those writings are holy Scripture, which are so called: I would ask you with as much reason another question, how know you the sun is the sun, ⟨p. 47⟩or how ye come not to doubt, that God is God: for we verily have as much certainty that th•se books are the sacred Scripture, commended of the Lord to the Church, written by the Prophets and Apostles, proceeding from divine authority, as that the Moon is the Moon, yea as we are sure of any thing else, which by undoubted knowledge we are full assured of; this answer Calvin also hath given you,1 writing that many things might be produced, which would easily prove, that if there be a God in heaven, the Law, the Prophets, and the Gospel came from him: yea and with many words at large he urgeth it with most strong arguments, such as may satisfy any reasonable man touching the authority, and credit of the Scriptures. There are in the books themselves proofs enough, both certain; and perspicuous, which will prove and demonstrate the credit of the Scriptures, that no man need boubt of them. But because the sense and reason of man is often times weak, and easily distracted into divers and doubtful cogitations, the inward and hidden testimony of the spirit must be had, that men may firmly rest in the Scriptures. For though outward testimonies will so convince us, that for shame we cannot deny the Scriptures to be the word of God;
But you now begin to presse your aduersaries somewhat more forceably; and you demaund of them, for example sake, by what authority they maime; and robbe the corpes of the Bible, I answere we offer no violence to this body, ne•ther do we cut off any which doe appertain to the substance, and perfection of it; we dash out no part of it, we pull away no member. For (to vse your owne words) we do not cut out any true Canonicall Scriptures, but cull out such as are not Canonical, but foisted in and counterfeit. But you would know who shal be iudge; you make Caluin to answere for vs: the holy Ghost: and you suggesting that he giueth this answere, to escape the iudgement of the Church; if you enquire how we know these writings, which we call Scriptures, to be heauenly, and giuen by the inspiration of God, that is, by what testimony we are perswaded that those writings are holy Scripture, which are so called: I would aske you with as much reason another question, how know you the sonne is the sonne, ⟨p. 47⟩or how ye come not to doubt, that God is God: for we verely haue as much certeinty that th•se bookes are the sacred Scripture, commended of the Lord to the Church, written by the Prophets and Apostles, proceeding from diuine authoritie, as that the Moone is the Moone, yea as wee are sure of any thing else, which by vndoubted knowledge we are full assured of; this answere Caluin also hath giuen you,1 writing that many things might be produced, which would easily proue, that if there be a God in heauen, the Law, the Prophets, and the Gospell came from him: yea and with many words at large he vrgeth it with most strong arguments, such as may satisfie any reasonable man touching the authoritie, and credit of the Scriptures. There are in the bookes themselues proofes enough, both certeine; and perspicuous, which will proue and demonstrate the credit of the Scriptures, that no man need boubt of them. But because the sense and reason of man is often times weake, and easily distracted into diuers and doubtfull cogitations, the inward and hidden testimony of the spirit must be had, that men may firmely rest in the Scriptures. For though outward testimonies will so conuince vs, that for shame we cannot deny the Scriptures to be the word of God;
yet then only do we attain a certain and saving full assurance, when the same spirit, which writ and published them, doth persuade our harts of the credit of them. And this is that spirit, which the Lord hath promised to his Church, and which dwelleth in the harts of the faithful, and is as a seal unto them, he that hath not this spirit, shall ever in himself be uncertain and doubtful, though he hear the Church a thousand times. What is the fault then you find, Campian? Calvin, say you, doth make the spirit Judge thereby to escape the judgement of the Church, by whose authority all spirits are tried. The judgement of the ⟨p. 48⟩Church ought not to differ from the judgement of the spirit: the same spirit governeth the wholeh Church and every particular believer. But your Church knoweth not this spirit; no marvel then if it dislike the judgement of the spirit: yet I would have you take this for an answer once for all: that the authority of the Scriptures doth not depend upon the judgement of the Church: for let the Church judge what it will, yet can it never by all the authority it hath make the Canonical books to be no Canonical; and that those which are not Canonical, should be had in reputation as Canonical. The Scripture hath it own proper authority in it self, not borrowed from another. And as little can the Church add authority to the Scripture, as it can to God, the author of it. But say you, how cometh it to pass, that the Calvinists spirit alloweth six Epistles, which the Lutheran spirit doth disallow? you go in a ring, making only the repetition of the same things without any proceeding. Those Epistles the Lutheransi do not reject, nor dash them out of the new Testament; yea ⟨p. 49⟩they acknowledge them, they make use of them in unfolding of controversies, they expound them in their schools and churches, and they read them both privately and publicly: upon many of them Luther hath writtenk Commentaries, Illyricus upon all. That of the authority of those Epistles in times past the Catholic Church made some doubt, they discover to their Auditors, and show withal the causes of that doubt, and that done, leave it undetermined. I pray you, Campian, what contradiction find you here, betwixt the spirit of the Calvinists and the Lutherans? Yet still you cavil at this judgement of the spirit, which of all other is most certain and heavenly:
yet then only do we attaine a certeine and sauing ful assurance, when the same spirit, which writ and published them, doth perswade our harts of the credit of them. And this is that spirit, which the Lord hath promised to his Church, and which dwelleth in the harts of the faithfull, and is as a seale vnto them, he that hath not this spirit, shall euer in himselfe be vncerteine and doubtfull, though he heare the Church a thousand times. What is the fault then you find, Campian? Caluin, say you, doth make the spirit Iudge thereby to escape the iudgement of the Church, by whose authoritie all spirits are tried. The iudgement of the ⟨p. 48⟩Church ought not to differ from the iudgement of the spirit: the same spirit gouerneth the wholeh Church and euery particular beleeuer. But your Church knoweth not this spirit; no maruell then if it dislike the iudgement of the spirit: yet I would haue you take this for an answere once for all: that the authority of the Scriptures doth not depend vpon the iudgement of the Church: for let the Church iudge what it will, yet can it neuer by all the authority it hath make the Canonicall bookes to be no Canonicall; and that those which are not Canonicall, should be had in reputation as Canonical. The Scripture hath it owne proper authority in it selfe, not borrowed frō another. And as little can the Church add authority to the Scripture, as it can to God, the authour of it. But say you, how commeth it to passe, that the Caluinists spirit alloweth six Epistles, which the Lutheran spirit doth disallow? you go in a ring, making only the repetition of the same things without any proceeding. Those Epistles the Lutheransi doe not reiect, nor dash them out of the new Testament; yea ⟨p. 49⟩they acknowledge them, they make vse of them in vnfoulding of controuersies, they expound them in their schooles and churches, and they reade them both priuately and publikely: vpon many of them Luther hath writtenk Commentaries, Illyricus vpon all. That of the authority of those Epistles in times past the Catholike Church made some doubt, they discouer to their Auditors, and shew withall the causes of that doubt, and that done, leaue it vndetermined. I pray you, Campian, what contradiction find you heere, betwixt the spirit of the Caluinists and the Lutherans? Yet still you cauil at this iudgement of the spirit, which of all other is most certeine and heauenly:
hDVR. What an absurd thing is this, that you contemn the voice of the Church, and allow your common people to judge rather of the Scriptures, and give all to the spirit; when the Fathers have objected the Church against heretics? WHIT. pag. 109. We contemn not the voice of the first Church, wherein these were written, and from them commended to succeeding Churches. But, pag. 108. we much regard not the voice of your Romish Church; for as we know there is a God, though it tell us not so much: so that the Scriptures are the word of God, though it be silent; and by the same grounds that your Church knoweth the Scriptures to be the Scriptures, by the same proofs may every private Christian know them. pag. 111. If you know not, that the grace of the spirit is necessary to discern the Scriptures, then read these places John 14, 26. 1. John 2, 26, 27. 1, Cor. 2, 14, 10. Isaiah 51, 16. Now the same spirit who w•it them, seals them up to us: without which some knowledge may be had of them, b•t no faith; we may acknowledge them, but not certainly believe them without the spirit. And if the Fathers have objected the Church against heretics, in the like case we will do the same. For the testimony of the spirit is not of validity to confute others, but to confirm our selves.DVR. What an absurd thing is this, that you contemne the voice of the Church, and allow your common people to iudge rather of the Script•res, and giue all to the spirit; when the Fathers haue obiected the Church against heretikes? WHIT. pag. 109. We contemne not the voice of the first Church, wherein these were written, and from thē commended to succeeding Churches. But, pag. 108. we much regard not the voice of your Romish Church; for as we know there is a God, though it tell vs not so much: so that the Scriptures are the word of God, though it be silent; and by the same grounds that your Church knoweth the Scriptures to be the Scriptures, by the same proofes may euery priuate Christian know them. pag. 111. If you know not, that the grace of the spirit is necessary to discerne the Scriptures, then reade these places John 14, 26. 1. Iohn 2, 26, 27. 1, Cor. 2, 14, 10. Esay 51, 16. Now the same spirit who w•it them, seales them vp to vs: without which some knowledge may be had of them, bt no faith; we may acknowledge them, but not certeinly beleeue them without the spirit. And if the Fathers haue obiected the Church against heretikes, in the like case we will do the same. For the testimony of the spirit is not of validity to confute others, but to confirme our selues.
and here you produce Anabaptists, Castalio, Brentius, Kemnitius, Luther, and Beza. And by these you hope that you may diminish the authority of the spirit.1 The Anabaptists, (say you) call the history of Job a fable, interlaced with tragical and Comical matters. As though we were ignorant, how wickedly and blasphemously they conceive, not only of the history of Job, but also of the whole books both of the new and old Testament; and that spirit of the Anabaptists, what was it but a kind of frenzy, and a violent and head-strong madness; which no spirit ever did more repress, thenl the Calvinist and Lutheran spirit? Why then do you mention their madness, thereby to scoff at the certain judgements of the holy Ghost?3 Castalio, say you, made no more account of Solomons Song, then he did of a bandy song and ribald talk of a Courtly waiting maid with her lover. I will not take upon me to defend all that any man hath written at random, much less will I trouble my self to defend the credit of Castalio, whom I well know hath erred in many great points ⟨p. 50⟩very shamefully. Yet in this place I find you have notably abused Castalio: for in that short preface which he hath set before this book, he hath none of those you speak of, neither a song, nor a Love, nor courtly waiting maids, nor wanton talk, nor any such thing, but hath truly, learnedly, and modestly in few words comprised the sum of the whole book: his first words are these: A conference betwixt the Saviour and his Church. Now you may see how highly Caestalio accounted of this song, and how shameless your cavil is against him. I cannot now be much offended with you, for casting so many false things upon Calvin and Luther, when you are not ashamed so palpably to belly Castalio. And that you say next touching the Revelation, is much like to the rest of your cavils. In it, say you, Luther, and Brentius, 4and Kemnisius, find, I know not what, lacking. What is the meaning of this, They find somewhat lacking? do they reject it, do they disallow it? you cannot say so: therefore you speak faintly and diffidently: They find somewhat lacking. Howsoever, if you will read Eusebius, you shall understand that in it many things were found lacking, and that it was not received of all, yea plainly rejected of many.
and heere you produce Anabaptists, Castalio, Brentius, Kemnitius, Luther, and Beza. And by these you hope that you may diminish the authority of the spirit.1 The Anabaptists, (say you) call the historie of Iob a fable, interlaced with tragicall and Comicall matters. As though we were ignorant, how wickedly and blasphemously they conceiue, not only of the history of Iob, but also of the whole bookes both of the new and old Testament; and that spirit of the Anabaptists, what was it but a kind of frency, and a violent and head-strong madnes; which no spirit euer did more represse, thenl the Caluinist and Lutheran spirit? Why then doe you mention their madnes, therby to scoffe at the certeine iudgements of the holy Ghost?3 Castalio, say you, made no more account of Salomons Song, then he did of a bandy song and ribauldous talke of a Courtly waiting maide with her louer. I will not take vpon me to defend all that any man hath written at randome, much lesse will I trouble my selfe to defend the credit of Castalio, whom I well know hath erred in many great points ⟨p. 50⟩very shamefully. Yet in this place I find you haue notably abused Castalio: for in that short preface which he hath set before this booke, he hath none of those you speake of, neither a song, nor a Loue, nor courtly waiting maides, nor wanton talke, nor any such thing, but hath truly, learnedly, and modestly in few words comprised the summe of the whole booke: his first words are these: A conference betwixt the Sauiour and his Church. Now you may see how highly Caestalio accounted of this song, and how shamelesse your cauill is against him. I cannot now be much offended with you, for casting so many false things vpon Caluin and Luther, when you are not ashamed so palpably to bely Castalio. And that you say next touching the Reuelation, is much like to the rest of your cauils. In it, say you, Luther, and Brentius, 4and Kemnisius, find, I know not what, lacking. What is the meaning of this, They find somewhat lacking? do they reiect it, do they disallow it? you cannot say so: therefore you speake faintly and diffidently: They find somewhat lacking. Howsoeuer, if you will reade Eusebius, you shall vnderstand that in it many things were found lacking, and that it was not receiued of all, yea plainly reiected of many.
1Sixth. Senens. lib. 7.Sixt. Senens. lib. 7.
lDVR. The Anabaptists will aswell accuse the spirit of Calnin of madness and folly. WHIT. pag. 119. Yet I durst make you judge of this controu••fie, & unless you were also as mad, you would judge them very unlike.DVR. The Anabaptists will aswell accuse the spirit of Calnin of madnes and solly. WHIT. pag. 119. Yet I durst make you iudge of this controu••fie, & vnles you were also as mad, you would iudge them very vnlike.
But what is this to us, when as you cannot deny we have received this book, and do no less reverence the mysteries that are in it, then your selves? and perhaps it had fitted your turn well, if this book had either perished, or been of no credit at all: for it doth so lively paint out your Pope, & your purple whore in her colours, that it clearly discovereth to all men, who is Antichrist.
But what is this to vs, when as you cannot deny wee haue receiued this booke, and do no lesse reuerence the mysteries that are in it, then your selues? and perhaps it had fitted your turne well, if this booke had either perished, or been of no credit at all: for it doth so liuely paint out your Pope, & your purple whore in her colours, that it cleerely discouereth to all men, who is Antichrist.
Have you yet any thing more against Luther? 1Luther, say you, casteth above among the four Evangelists and preferring S. Pauls Epistles far before the three former Gospels, in the end concludeth, that the only Gospel of S. John from henceforth is to be taken for the gay, the true, and the principal Gospel; Luther indeed ⟨p. 51⟩preferreth the Gospel of John before the other three, because he setteth down the Acts of Christ more briefly, and his Sermons more fully. Now a Gospel consisteth rather in heavenly doctrine, then in the history of things done. Yet he denies not but that the other Gospels are well set out, true, and very excellent; and far is he from esteeming this the only gay and true Gospel. Now this very point you speak of here, I find also in the preface of the first Epistle of S. Peter. And I would entreat the Christian reader to take thorough notice of this thing, so shall he easily perceive both Luther's integrity, and Campians cavilling. First Luther teacheth what a Gospel is: and writeth that a Gospel signifieth nothing else, But the preaching and publishing of the grace, and mercy of God by the Lord Christ, merited and purchased to us by his death. He that either preacheth or writeth this grace and mercy of God in Christ, he, as Luther affirmeth, teacheth the Gospel. And therefore not the four Evangelists only have taught the Gospel; but also all the Apostles have done so too, and especially Saint Paul & Saint Peter in their Epistles. And moreover he affirmeth, that of all those they are the bestm Evangelists, who have therein specially laboured, to teach justification by faith in Christ alone: for this is the sum of the Gospel. And hereupon he concludeth that the Epistles of Paul may more fitly be called the Gospel, then those things Matthew, Mark, and Luke have written: for that he doth more fully & plentifully decipher to us the grace of God in Christ, then those three, whose history is for the most part spent in the declaration of the Acts and Miracles of Christ. And this is the true cause wherefore he preferred the Gospel of S. John and the Epistles of S. Paul before the three other Gospels; ⟨p. 52⟩whereby he neither casteth a bone among the Evangelists, nor goeth about to make the Apostles partakers of his brawlings; neither hath said any thing either frowardly or preposterously: for why, I pray you, may we not say, that S.
Haue you yet any thing more against Luther? 1Luther, say you, casteth a boue among the foure Euangelists and preferring S. Pauls Epistles farre before the three former Gospels, in the end concludeth, that the only Gospell of S. Iohn from henceforth is to be taken for the gay, the true, and the principall Gospell; Luther indeed ⟨p. 51⟩preferreth the Gospell of Iohn before the other three, because he setteth downe the Acts of Christ more briefly, and his Sermons more fully. Now a Gospell consisteth rather in heauenly doctrine, then in the history of things done. Yet he denies not but that the other Gospels are well set out, true, and very excellent; and farre is he from esteeming this the only gay and true Gospell. Now this very point you speake of heere, I find also in the preface of the first Epistle of S. Peter. And I would intreate the Christian reader to take thorough notice of this thing, so shall he easily perceiue both Luthers integritie, and Campians cauilling. First Luther teacheth what a Gospell is: and writeth that a Gospell signifieth nothing else, But the preaching and publishing of the grace, and mercy of God by the Lord Christ, merited and purchased to vs by his death. He that either preacheth or writeth this grace and mercy of God in Christ, he, as Luther affirmeth, teacheth the Gospell. And therefore not the foure Euangelists only haue taught the Gospell; but also all the Apostles haue done so too, and especially Saint Paul & Saint Peter in their Epistles. And moreouer he affirmeth, that of all those they are the bestm Euangelists, who haue therein specially laboured, to teach iustification by faith in Christ alone: for this is the summe of the Gospell. And hereupon he concludeth that the Epistles of Paul may more fitly be called the Gospell, then those things Matthew, Marke, and Luke haue written: for that he doth more fully & plentifully decipher to vs the grace of God in Christ, then those three, whose history is for the most part spent in the declaration of the Acts and Miracles of Christ. And this is the true cause wherfore he preferred the Gospell of S. Iohn and the Epistles of S. Paul before the three other Gospels; ⟨p. 52⟩whereby he neither casteth a bone among the Euangelists, nor goeth about to make the Apostles partakers of his brawlings; neither hath said any thing either frowardly or preposterously: for why, I pray you, may we not say, that S.
1Praefat. in novum Testamentum.Praefat. in nouum Testamentum.
mDVR. What Scripture teacheth us, that be is an Evangelist, which teacheth justificatio by faith only? Jf any, then Luther was the best Evangelist. WHIT. pag. 125. I can reckon you up many, but these may suffice, Isaiah 52▪ 7. Rom. 10.15. Now peace •iseth of our reconciliation with God and remission of sins, which things faith only lays hold on. Rom. 5.1. 2, Cor. 5, 19. Rom. 4, 4. And this matter S. Paul principally, in his Epistles to the Romans and Galatians, hath fully and plainly handled, and not Luther so much. DVR. But the Angel taught no such thing Luk. 2.10. WHIT. pag 126. If you had looked to the next verse, you should have found that the Angel did teach as much in effect.DVR. VVhat Scripture teacheth vs, that be is an Euangelist, which teacheth iustificatio by faith only? Jf any, then Luther was the best Euangelist. WHIT. pag. 125. I can recken you vp many, but these may suffice, Esay 52▪ 7. Rom. 10.15. Now peace •iseth of our reconciliation with God and remission of sinnes, which things faith only layes hold on. Rom. 5.1. 2, Cor. 5, 19. Rom. 4, 4. And this matter S. Paul principally, in his Epistles to the Romans and Galathians, hath fully and plainly handled, and not Luther so much. DVR. But the Angell tau•ht no such thing Luk. 2.10. WHIT. pag 126. If you had looked to the next verse, you should haue found that the Angell did te•ch as much in effect.
Paul hath more clearly and excellently described the power of the Cross of Christ in his Epistles, then any of the Evangelists in their history; when as by it the authority of the history of the Gospel is nothing disparaged? And now I doubt not but I have sufficiently defended Luther's innocency against your railing and outrageous sauciness.
Paul hath more cleerely and excellently described the power of the Crosse of Christ in his Epistles, then any of the Euangelists in their historie; when as by it the authoritie of the historie of the Gospell is nothing disparaged? And now I doubt not but I haue sufficiently defended Luthers innocency against your rayling and outragious saucines.
But yet again you assault Luther: whom you say doubted not to tax S. Lukes Gospel, 1as if it were written in a wanton stile, because therein good works are often recommended unto us. Was there ever read or heard of the like impudency, audaciousness, and treacherous dealing in any man? The place you note in the margin I have very diligently and heedfully observed, that I might discern; wherein Luther hath showed such male pertness: but I have not found one unholy, nor dishonourable term, unfit to be given to S. Luke, as being an heavenly Evangelist. For that which Luther propounds to himself is to take out of mens minds a scruple, which S. Lukes often mention of works might move in them; lest any happily might think that S. Luke by often speaking of works, should detract somewhat from faith, or place our justification in our works. And this is, as you affirm, saucily to give S. Luke a wipe; if you can tell me of any greater matter, I will no ways defend or excuse Luther's malapertness. But what malapertness is this of yours, Campian, whom neither the fear of God, nor the reverence of men, can restrain from writing or divulging of those things, which your own conscience tells you are most false? and you cannot pass by Beza neither without the like Calumnious ⟨p. 53⟩censure. Who, say you, was so bold as to reprehend that mystical word, Hic est calix, n•u•m Testame•tum in s••guine meo, qui (calix) pro vobis fundetur, This is the cup of the new Testament in my blood, which (cup) shall be shed for you; a• corrupted and depraved. I see well where your error is in following that corrupt and adulterous vulgar translation, for [Greek or Hebrew], you thus translate.a Hic est calix novum Testamentum. This is the cup of the new Testament: when the words are rather thus to be placed. Hic calix est novum Testamentum, This cup is the new Testament: and [Greek or Hebrew] being a participle of the present tense, you translate by a verb of the future tence: Qui fundetur, shall be shed for you: for, Qui funditur, is shed for you. But you dare not go a hairs breadth from the vulgar translation, for fear of incurring that curse of the Council of Trent. But here Theodor Beza apparently is caught in a heinous crime: for he writeth that Luke hath committed a Solecism: what then I pray you? a very foul fact and very intolerable. Is it so indeed?
But yet againe you assault Luther: whom you say doubted not to taxe S. Lukes Gospell, 1as if it were written in a wanton stile, because therein good workes are often recommended vnto vs. Was there euer read or heard of the like impudencie, audaciousnes, and treacherous dealing in any man? The place you note in the margent I haue very diligently and heedfully obserued, that I might discerne; wherin Luther hath shewed such male pertnes: but I haue not found one vnholy, nor dishonorable terme, vnfit to be giuen to S. Luke, as being an heauenly Euangelist. For that which Luther propounds to himselfe is to take out of mens minds a scruple, which S. Lukes often mention of workes might moue in them; lest any happilie might thinke that S. Luke by often speaking of works, should detract somewhat from faith, or place our iustification in our workes. And this is, as you affirme, saucilie to giue S. Luke a wipe; if you can tel me of any greater matter, I will no waies defend or excuse Luthers malepertnes. But what malepertnes is this of yours, Campian, whom neither the feare of God, nor the reuerence of men, can restraine frō writing or diuulging of those things, which your owne conscience tels you are most false? and you cannot passe by Beza neither without the like Calumnious ⟨p. 53⟩censure. Who, say you, was so bould as to reprehend that mysticall word, Hic est calix, n•u•m Testame•tum in s••guine meo, qui (calix) pro vobis fundetur, This is the cup of the new Testament in my blood, which (cup) shall be shedde for you; a• corrupted and depraued. I see well where your error is in following that corrupt and adulterous vulgar translation, for 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, you thus translate.a Hic est calix nouum Testamentum. This is the cup of the new Testament: when the words are rather thus to be placed. Hic calix est nouum Testamentum, This cup is the new Testament: and 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 being a participle of the present tence, you translate by a verbe of the future tence: Qui fundetur, shall be shed for you: for, Qui funditur, is shedde for you. But you dare not goe a haires breadth from the vulgar translation, for feare of incurring that curse of the Councell of Trent. But heere Theodor Beza apparantly is caught in a haynous crime: for he writeth that Luke hath committed a Solecisme: what then I pray you? a very foule fact and very intolerable. Is it so indeed?
1Serm. de Pharis. & Publi.
aDVR. I confess there is a Metonymy in the cup: the cup being put for the blood. WHIT. pag. 130. Then, this cup, is as much, as this blood: Then see what a sentence you have made: This blood is the new Testament in my blood, which is shed for you. As if Christ had said: This blood is the new Testament in my blood. And so here are two bloods, and the one in the other.DVR. I confesse there is a Metonymy in the cup: the cup being put for the blood. WHIT. pag. 130. Then, this cup, is as much, as this blood: Then see what a sentence you haue made: This blood is the new Testament in my blood, which is shed for you. As if Christ had said: This blood is the new Testament in my blood. And so heere are two bloods, and the one in the other.
how shall we then defend Hierome, who writeth that Paul committed such solecisms in his words, that by no good ordering any good sense could be made of them? 1If S. Paul might commit Solecisms in his words, why may we not think S. Luke may do as much? and if Hierome without sin might accuse S. Paul, not to speak properly or scholar-like; why might not Beza note some want of propriety of speech in S. Luke? for you are wide, Campian, if you think this any thing diminisheth the authority & dignity of the Scriptures, for Hier•me construeth it quite contrary. Let us look therefore upon the place of the Evangelist, that we may judge where this fault is.
how shall we then defend Hierome, who writeth that Paul committed such solecismes in his words, that by no good ordering any good sense could be made of them? 1If S. Paul might commit Solecismes in his words, why may we not thinke S. Luke may doe as much? and if Hierome without sinne might accuse S. Paul, not to speake properly or scholer-like; why might not Beza note some want of propriety of speech in S. Luke? for you are wide, Campian, if you thinke this any thing diminisheth the authoritie & dignity of the Scriptures, for Hier•me construeth it quite contrarie. Let vs looke therefore vpon the place of the Euangelist, that we may iudge where this fault is.
The words run thus. This cup is the new Testament in my blood which is shed for you. If you change nothing in the words and exclude all incongruity, ⟨p. 54⟩then these last words, Which is shed for you, must be referred to the first, This cup. And so this should be the meaning, This cup is shed for you: But not the cup, but the blood of Christ was shed for us. But you will say the cup is put for the wine in the cup. So that whether you will or no, you must acknowledge that in these words there is a trope or figure: though you Papists usually deny the same, and vehemently cry out, none of them is to be taken figuratively. But you your selves in these words make two figures; first you take the cup for the wine in it, then the wine for the blood of Christ, which in no hand you can do without a figure: therefore hereafter stand not upon words; for if you will now stand to the words, you must either grant that the cup was shed for us, or you must admit a solecism and unproper speech. If we will read them as Basil doth;1 Which blood is shed for you: the meaning will be plain, when these words which is shed for you, are referred to the blood of Christ. These are Campians collections of such things, wherein our men have offended against the authority and dignity of the Scripture. These he crieth out do evidently open our diffidence and desperation, these are those things he propoundeth unto you, that are most learned of the University. Whose judgement I am therefore also well contented to stand unto, because I well know your learning and wisdom, together with your studious endeavours in the best authors, to be such, that this silly foolish sophister with all his slanders and lies shall never be able to remove or corrupt you: for what matter hath he brought, or what invention, which may seem to savour either of deep learning, much reading, or witty conceit? Therefore you shall do well to set light by the threats of this Philistine, and to cleave with constancy to that holy religion which you have learned out of the holy Scriptures: as also proceed in that ⟨p. 55⟩course of virtue and learning you have begun, that the Jesuits with all their enchantments may lose all their labour in seeking to seduce you.
The words runne thus. This cup is the new Testament in my blood which is shedde for you. If you change nothing in the words and exclude all incongruitie, ⟨p. 54⟩then these last words, Which is shed for you, must be referred to the first, This cup. And so this should be the meaning, This cup is shed for you: But not the cup, but the blood of Christ was shed for vs. But you will say the cup is put for the wine in the cup. So that whether you will or no, you must acknowledge that in these words there is a trope or figure: though you Papists vsually deny the same, and vehemently cry out, none of them is to be taken figuratiuely. But you your selues in these words make two figures; first you take the cuppe for the wine in it, then the wine for the blood of Christ, which in no hand you can do without a figure: therefore heereafter stand not vpon words; for if you will now stand to the words, you must either graunt that the cup was shed for vs, or you must admit a solecisme and vnproper speech. If we will read them as Basill doth;1 Which blood is shed for you: the meaning wil be plaine, when these words which is shedde for you, are referred to the blood of Christ. These are Campians collectiōs of such things, wherein our men haue offended against the authoritie and dignity of the Scripture. These he crieth out do euidently open our diffidence and desperation, these are those things he propoundeth vnto you, that are most learned of the Vniuersity. Whose iudgement I am therefore also wel contented to stand vnto, because I well know your learning and wisdome, together with your studious endeuours in the best authors, to be such, that this sillie foolish sophister with all his slaunders and lies shall neuer be able to remoue or corrupt you: for what matter hath he brought, or what inuention, which may seeme to sauour either of deepe learning, much reading, or witty conceit? Therefore you shall do wel to set light by the threats of this Philistine, and to cleaue with constancy to that holy religion which you haue learned out of the holy Scriptures: as also proceed in that ⟨p. 55⟩course of vertue and learning you haue begun, that the Iesuits with all their inchauntments may lose all their labour in seeking to seduce you.
1Basil. in Eth. [Greek or Hebrew].Basil. in Eth. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
S. Iohn, euery little title whereof S. Hierome affirmeth to containe some high and notable mysterie; yet neuertheles, these
seuere Iudges, Luther, Brentius and Kemnitius find I know not what lacking shooting all at this marke, that the booke might be defaced, and be of no authoritie: whom did they aske? the spirit.
DVR. Doth hee therefore doubt of the authoritie of this booke; what shall vve then say to Caluin, vvho hath plainely denied that the Epistle to the Hebrues vvas vvritten by Saint Paul? and if you had not been a deceiuer, you vvould haue alleadged Hierome vvholy: for it follovveth. Though by little and little in succeeding ages it obtained authoritie. WHIT. Pag. 16 He that saith, It is thus held, and neither dislikes nor refures such a suspition, sheweth he not himself also doubtful of it? Caluin had some reason, because that Epistle was not published in the name of Saint Paul, as this was of Saint Iames. What comparison is there in these two? the Epistle of Saint Iames hath his name in the beginning of it, as the author of it; so hath not the other the name of Saint Paul: so that hee that denies that to bee written by Saint Iames, must needes make it counterfeit. But no such thing here. Therefore may this be held to be canonicall, though it be denied to be written by Saint Paul. If you had read but a few lines more, you should finde that I vsed no deceite, neither had you caus• to be so bitter. And these words of Hierome prooue directly, that the authoritie of this Epistle was sometimes doubted of.
*Calvin. in argument. in Epist. Jacob.Caluin. in argument. in Epist. Iacob.
and Paul, that you may see that we are not broachers of any Noueltie. Wherefore, saith
the iudgements of the two Apostles, S. Paul, & S. Iames, are not contrarie each to other, when the one saith a man is iustified by faith without workes; and the other saith, that it is a vaine faith which is without workes; because S.
DVR. Basil excludes only those workes which are wrought by the sole power of freewill. WHIT. pag. 38. Basil excludes not only the workes wrought by the power of freewill, but euen those which proceed from faith and grace; for he produced S. Paul, and Saint Peter whom he denies to haue been iustified by workes, yet had they both faith and grace.
iDVR. Nazianzene excludeth only that high knowledge of divine mysteries. WHIT. pag. 41. Nazianzene excludes not only that high knowledge of divine mysteries, but also by it all other works; for seeing it is the most excellent, and so excluding the greatest, he must needs exclude the less.DVR. Nazianzene excludeth only that high knowledge of diuine mysteries. WHIT. pag. 41. Nazianzene excludes not only that high knowledge of diuine mysteries, but also by it all other workes; for seeing it is the most excellent, and so excluding the greatest, he must needs exclude the lesse.
kDVR. Saint James speaketh not of a feigned faith: for how can be thē speak of Abrahams faith? how is it feigned to believe that God is? WHIT. pag. 42. S. James speaketh of a feigned faith, as is plain vers. 14. for it is in words only vers. 15.16. it giveth nothing, when relief is required. verse 17. it is without works and dead. vers. 18 only that is true faith, which can be showed by works, here no works vers. 19. It is only such a faith as the devils have: so a feigned and dead faith. pag. 44. And Augustine thus expoundeth it, De fide & oper. Cap. 14. & in Psal. 31. in Praefat. and pag 45. Though Abrahams faith was a true faith, because it showed it self by true fruits and true works: that proves not, but their faith is feigned who have no works. Of which Saint James speaketh. pag. 46. faith is not the less feigned and vain, because it believes that God is: seeing Saint James affirmeth the devils believe as much.DVR. Saint Iames speaketh not of a faigned faith: for how can be thē speake of Abrahams faith? how is it fayned to beleeue that God is? WHIT. pag. 42. S. Iames speak•th of a fayned faith, as is plaine vers. 14. for it is in words only vers. 15.16. it giueth nothing, when reliefe is required. verse 17. it is without workes and dead. vers. 18 only that is true faith, which can be shewed by workes, heere no workes vers. 19. It is only such a faith as the diuels haue: so a fayned and dead fa•th. pag. 44. And Augustine thus expoundeth it, De fide & oper. Cap. 14. & in Psal. 31. in Praefat. and pag 45. Though Abrahams faith was a true faith, because it shewed it selfe by true fruites and true workes: that proues not, but their faith is fayned who haue no workes. Of which Saint Iames speaketh. pag. 46. faith is not the lesse fayned and vaine, because it beleeues that God is: seeing Saint Iames affirmeth the di•els beleeue as much.
lDVR. It is ridiculous to think, that Saint James should teach men how to show themselves just, and speak nothing of true justice. WHIT. pag 47. We say not that Saint James teacheth only how a man may obtain the opinion of justice with men, but how he may show and declare himself by certain proofs and arguments to be endued with true justice. And that this place toucheth the declaration of true faith by works, and so the demonstration of our justification, not we, but your own men do so teach. Thomas Aquin. in Jacob. 2. Glossa-Ordin. in Jacob.DVR. It is ridiculous to thinke, that Saint Iames should teach men how to shew themselues iust, and speake nothing of true iustice. WHIT. pag 47. We say not that Saint Iames teacheth only how a man may obtaine the opinion of iustice with men, but how he may shew and declare himselfe by certaine proofes and arguments to be indued with true iustice. And that this place toucheth the declaration of true faith by workes, and so the demonstration of our iustification, not we, but your owne men do so teach. Thomas Aquin. in Iacob. 2. Glossa-Ordin. in Iacob.
mDVR. Augustine maketh nothing for you, but against you. WHIT. pag. 50. Augustine affirmeth directly that S. James speaketh of a vain and feigned faith, which is as much as we here produce him for.DVR. Augustine maketh nothing for you, but against you. WHIT. pag. 50. Augustin• affirm•th directly that S. Iames speaketh of a vaine and fayned faith, which is as much as we here produce him for.
Fathers also, and euery mans owne experience: howsoeuer these words may be vnderstood of mankind, as he was sometime in Adam. For thus he writeth a little before.
He made man from the beginning, and left him in the hand of his owne counsaile; if he speake of the first condition and state of man, and of his perfect and vncorrupt nature, wherein he was created of the Lord, he speaketh very true:
sDVR. Saint John did n•t worship the Angel, but took the person of those who held that Angels were to be worshipped with sacrifices, that he being forbidden, they might be reproved in him. WHIT. pag. 72. John did not as you say; for neither offered he any sacrifice•, neither affirmeth he that he dissembled; but saith directly: I fell down to worship before him. You on the contrary say, he fell not down to worship. And your Thomas upon Apoc. 19. saith, S. John intended to worship with Dulia. And upon Apocal. 22. with Latria.DVR. Saint Iohn did n•t worship the Angell, but tooke the person of those who held that Angels were to be worshipped with sacrifices, that he being forbidden, they might be reproued in him. WHIT. pag. 72. John did not as you say; for neither offered he any sacrifice•, neither affirmeth he that he dissembled; but saith directly: I fell downe to worship before him. You on the cōtrary say, he fell not downe to worship. And your Thomas vpon Apoc. 19. saith, S. John intended to worship with Dulia. And vpon Apocal. 22. with Latria.
tDVR. The ancient Fathers have cited the book of Toby, a• Irene, Cyprian, Hula. WHIT. pag. 73. Then will it follow: that out of what book soever the Fathers have alleged any testimony, it must be of the Canon, & •o the 3 & 4. books of Esdra; for Augustine, Cyprian, & Ambrose cite them, yet your Church rejecteth them. DVR. Hierome putteth them out of the Jewish Canon, not of the Canon of the Church. WHIT. pag. 74. It is strange those Fathers should make them Canonical, when i• Hieromes time long after them, they were not; no they were neither in the Canons of the Church, nor of the Jews Canon. Hieron. in Prasat. in lib. Salom. DVR. Your English Synagogues read Toby very much. WHIT. pag. 76. And other Apochryphae•, but accounteth them not in the Canon.DVR. The auncient Fathers haue cited the booke of Toby, a• Irene, Cyprian, H•la. WHIT. pag. 73. Then will it follovv: th•t out of what booke soeuer the Fathers haue alledged any testimony, it must be of the Canon, & •o the 3 & 4. bookes of Esdra; for Augustine, Cyprian, & Ambrose cite them, yet your Church reiecteth them. DVR. Hierome putteth them out of the Iewish Canon, not of the Canon of the Church. WHIT. pag. 74. It is strange those Fathers should make them Canonicall, when i• Hieromes time long after them, they were not; no they were neither in the Canons of the Church, nor of the Ievves Canon. Hieron. in Prasat. in lib. Salom. DVR. Your English Synagogues reade Toby very much. WHIT. pag. 76. And other Apochryphae•, but accounteth them not in the Canon.
uDVR. pag. 76. If you de•y free wil• to man by nature; a•d that be cannot but sin, you establish the Fate of the S•• ickes. WHIT. pag. 77. No more, then when we say Angels necessarily do good, and devils ever evil. Again we deny not mans freewill to natural and civill actions, but to the duties of faith; because till the sonne hath made him free, he must needs be a servant of sin.DVR. pag. 76. If you de•y free wil• to man by nature; a•d that be cannot but sinne, you establish the Fate of the S•• ickes. WHIT. pag. 77. No more, then vvhen vve say Angells necessarily doe good, and diuels euer euill. Againe vve deny not mans freewill to naturall and ciuill actions, but to the duties of faith; because till the sonne hath made him free, he must needs be a seruant of sinne.
xDVR. The Scripture doth not teach that men have lost free will by nature. WHIT. p. 78. What then meaneth it, 1. Cor. 2.14. If man cannot understand the things of God and eternal life, how can he will them or do them? Phil. 2.13. The will and deed is wrought in us by God. Gen. 6.5. If he can think nothing but evil, where is free will?DVR. The Scripture doth not teach that men haue lost free will by nature. WHIT. p. 78. What then meaneth it, 1. Cor. 2.14. If man cannot vnderstand the things of God and eternall life, how can hee will them or doe them? Phil. 2.13. The will and deede is wrought in vs by God. Gen. 6.5. If hee can thinke nothing but euill, where is free will?
yDVR. The Fathers do not deny free vvill. WHIT. pag. 79. August. Enchirid. cap. 30. Ambrose de vocat. gent. cap. 9. Bernard de libr. arb•t. do deny it.DVR. The Fathers doe not deny free vvill. WHIT. pag. 79. August. Enchirid. cap. 30. Ambrose de vocat. gent. cap. 9. Bernard de libr. arb•t. doe deny it.
12Ecelesi•it. 15. vers. 14.
bDVR. Many things were declared to the Prophets by dreams. WHIT. pag. 87. Must I therefore believe every dream written in the Apocrypha books, as divine oracles? neither did that dream make the Maccabees pray to Onia or Jeremiah, but to the Lord only. 2. Mac. 15.21. DVR. The Jews thought that Christ had prayed to Elijah, when Matth. 27.47. he said Eli Eli Lamb. &c. therefore praying to Saints was familiar and common with them. WHIT. pag 87. It is plain that the Jews said this only to deri•e Christ, whom they thought God had forsaken, and therefore he fled to Elijah for help.DVR. Many things were declared to the Prophets by dreames. WHIT. pag. 87. Must I therefore beleeue euery dreame written in the Apochrypha bookes, as diuine oracles? neither did that dreame make the Macchabees pray to Onia or Jeremie, but to the Lord only. 2. Mac. 15.21. DVR. The Ievves thought that Christ had praied to Eliah, vvhen Matth. 27.47. he said Eli Eli Lamb. &c. therefore praying to Saints vvas familiar and common vvith them. WHIT. pag 87. It is plaine that the Iewes said this only to deri•e Christ, whom they thought God had forsaken, and therefore he fled to Eliah for helpe.
•
iDVR. That the Luthe•an• do not like these Epi•iles, they of Magdeburg. Centur. 1. lib. 2. cap. 4. tell us plainly. WHIT. pag. 117. What is that to us who think as honourably of them as you do? but if they, by the example of ancient churches have spoken somewhat hardly of those Epistles, is there here any such difference of spirits? All things are not reve•led to all a like: all have not the like measure of the spirit. If any be otherwise minded, God will in his time reve•le •t to him.DVR. That the Luthe•an• do not like these Epi•iles, t•ey of Magdeburg. Centur. 1. lib. 2. cap. 4. tell vs plainely. WHIT. pag. 117. What is that to vs who thinke as honorablie of them as you do? but if they, by the example of auncient •hurches haue spokē somewhat hardly of those Epistles, is there heere any such difference of •pirits? All things are not reue•led to all a like: all haue not the like measure of the spirit. If any be otherwise minded, God will in his time reue•le •t to him.
kDVR. By the same reason, if Luther should comment upon certain of Aesops fables, and Illyricus upon all, then by their spirit they are certainly received into the Canon. WHIT. pag. 117. And why may not Aesops fables be in the Canon, if your Church please; seeing your Wolfangus & Hermannus affirm, the Scriptures are of no more authority, then those fables without the authority of your Church? But I add if you would have seen it, that they used them in preaching, in expounding Scriptures, in deciding controversies, and did interpret them both privately and publicly.DVR. By the same reason, if Luther should comment vpon certeine of Aesops fables, and Illyricus vpon al, then by their spirit they are certeinly receiued into the Canon. WHIT. pag. 117. And why may not Aesops fables be in the Canon, if your Church please; seeing your VVolfangus & Hermannus affirme, the Scriptures are of no more authority, then those fables without the authority of your Church? But I adde if you would haue seene it, that they vsed them in preaching, in expounding Scriptures, in deciding controuersies, and did interpret them both priuately and publikely.