A15061:271
An answer to a certain book, writtenAn answere to a certeine booke, written
An answer to a certain book, written by Master William Rainolds student of divinity in the English college at Rhemes, and entitled, A refutation of sundry reprehensions, cavils, etc. by William Whitaker ...An answere to a certeine booke, written by Maister William Rainolds student of diuinitie in the English colledge at Rhemes, and entituled, A refutation of sundrie reprehensions, cauils, etc. by William Whitaker ...
Printed at London : For Thomas Chard, 1585
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
First you say, I am ignorant of the catholic faith. For in the Church catholic we see Christ offered. Then you maintain that S. Chrysostom, in saying we see Christ sacrificed, ⟨p. 203⟩speaketh properly: for this, you say, is seen in the catholic Church. The godly, I grant, see in spirit this sacrifice of Christ: & thus the oblation of Christ is seen in the catholic Church. But we speak of a real sacrifice of Christ, which no man seeth, nor ever shall see. For a real sacrifice proveth a real death: & so Christ when he was sacrificed really, died also really. But no man seeth Christ dying, who died but once, & now liveth for ever. And they that really sacrificed our saviour Christ, did in that act really & wickedly murder him: & so your Priests if they be real sacrificers of Christ, are in the same action also real murderers of Christ. Take both, or refuse both: if you take upon you the one, you must not, nor cannot deny the other. Murderers of Christ you will not be accounted, & yet you profess your selves to be sacrificers of Christ, & that openly: which is all one, as if the Jews should confess, that they crucified Christ, but yet they murdered him not: wherefore it is in a word an heresy & blasphemy, to say Christ is sacrificed in the Church, otherwise then in a sacrament & remembrance of that one sacrifice, as both Chrysostom, & the fathers write commonly: ⟨p. 204⟩in which manner, and no other, he is seen to be sacrificed in the Church. That you add of seeing god, is poor divinity: & being admitted that we see Christ in the Catholic Church, how followeth your reason, therefore we see him sacrificed: if you have either wit, or religion, your self may see you speak without all wit and religion.
First you saie, I am ignorant of the catholike faith. For in the Church catholike we see Christ offered. Then you maintaine that S. Chrysostome, in saying we see Christ sacrificed, ⟨p. 203⟩speaketh properlie: for this, you saie, is seene in the catholike Church. The godly, I graunt, see in spirit this sacrifice of Christ: & thus the oblation of Christ is seene in the catholike Church. But we speake of a real sacrifice of Christ, which no man seeth, nor euer shal see. For a reall sacrifice prooueth a real death: & so Christ when he was sacrificed reallie, died also reallie. But no man seeth Christ dying, who died but once, & now liueth for euer. And they that really sacrificed our sauiour Christ, did in that acte really & wickedly murther him: & so your Priests if they be reall sacrificers of Christ, are in the same action also reall murtherers of Christ. Take both, or refuse both: if you take vppon you the one, you must not, nor cannot denie the other. Murtherers of Christ you wil not be accounted, & yet you professe your selues to be sacrificers of Christ, & that openly: which is al one, as if the Iewes should confesse, that they crucified Christ, but yet they murthered him not: wherefore it is in a word an heresie & blasphemie, to saie Christ is sacrificed in the Church, otherwise then in a sacrament & remembrance of that one sacrifice, as both Chrysostome, & the fathers write commonlie: