A18080:1028
The second reply of Thomas CartwrightThe second replie of Thomas Cartwright
The second reply of Thomas Cartwright: against Master Doctor Whitgiftes second answer, touching the Church disciplineThe second replie of Thomas Cartwright: agaynst Maister Doctor Whitgiftes second answer, touching the Churche discipline
Heidelberg: printed by Michael Schirat, 1575
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
After I saying / that forsomuch as Cornelius, said to have banished one out of his church, could not banish him out of the Province, therefore church and Province be divers: he answereth / though he could not banish him out off the province, yet he might excommunicate him, from the congregation throughout the Province. wherein beside ⟨p. DXLI⟩that he still presupposeth an archbishop / which is in controversy / whilst he giveth Cornelius power to excommunicate / through the whole Province: he is also deceived / that thinketh by thes words / is meant that Cornelius did excommunicate Felinus. For he was excommunicated before / by the Bishops off Afric: so that Cornelius had not to do / to excommunicate him. Where for confirmation of his answer / he asketh / whether he forcibly shut him out of the local church of Rome: I answer / that if he had remembered that there were then doorkeepers / to withstand those that cut from the church / would enter in: he should not have thought it so strange a thing / that Heretics were shut forth from the local church: especially seeing he seemeth to have allowed doorkeepers / as officers necessary for those times. And although it were permitted unto heretics by Cornelius / and his fellows / to enter into the local church: yet he might have considered / that when they offered them selves unto the lords table / Cornelius with his assistance ought to see them removed. Seeing therefore this not suffering of Felicissimus to enter into the church / is no excommunication / (as the D. saith) and carieth necessarily with it / that which Cornelius could not do / through the Province / but only in place where he was present: it must follow / that by the word church, where this was done / a particular place must be understanded / and not as is supposed / ether diocese / or Province.
After I saying / that forsomuch as Cornelius, saied to haue banished one ovvt of his church, could not banish him ovvt of the Prouince, therfore church ād Prouīce be diuers: he answereth / thowgh he could not banish him owt off the prouince, yet he might excō municate him, frō the cōgregatiō thorowghowt the Prouince. wherin beside ⟨p. DXLI⟩that he still presupposeth an archbishop / which is in cōtrouersie / whilest he gyueth Cornelius power to excommunicate / thorowgh the whole Prouince: he is also deceiued / that thincketh by thes wordes / is ment that Cornelius did excommunicate Felinus. For he was excommunicated before / by the Bishops off Africk: so that Cornelius had not to doo / to excommunicate him. Where for confirmacion of his answere / he asketh / whether he forcibly shut him owt of the locall church of Rome: I answer / that if he had remembred that there were then doorekepers / to withstand those that cut from the church / would enter in: he should not haue thought it so straunge a thing / that Heretikes vvere shut forth from the locall church: especially seing he seemeth to haue allowed dorekepers / as officers necessarie for those times. And althowgh it were permitted vnto heretikes by Cornelius / and his fellowes / to enter into the locall church: yet he might haue considered / that when they offered them selues vnto the lordes table / Cornelius with his assistance owght to see them remoued. Seing therfore this not suffring of Felicissimus to enter into the church / is no excommunication / (as the D. saith) and carieth necessarily with yt / that which Cornelius coulde not doo / throwghe the Prouince / but onely in place where he was present: yt muste folow / that by the worde churche, where this was doone / a particular place muste be vnderstanded / and not as is supposed / ether diocese / or Prouince.