A18080:1108
The second reply of Thomas CartwrightThe second replie of Thomas Cartwright
The second reply of Thomas Cartwright: against Master Doctor Whitgiftes second answer, touching the Church disciplineThe second replie of Thomas Cartwright: agaynst Maister Doctor Whitgiftes second answer, touching the Churche discipline
Heidelberg: printed by Michael Schirat, 1575
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Where he concludeth upon that the elders chose one amongest them whom they made bishop, as the captain is chosen of the the soldiers, that therefore the bishop was over divers congregations: there is no likelihood off reason. And where to give it some / he threapeth two things at my hand / the one that this word elder, signifieth only a minister off the word, the other that every minister of the word had his several flock: he doth but dally. For he knoweth well that I hold that the word elder / reacheth to such as govern only: and that there were in divers congregations more then one / which ⟨p. DXCVI⟩preached the word of God. Where he saith / those which I call obscure villages, were little cities, such as with us, Ely, or Peterborough: I leave it to the reader to judge / how much I have therein squared from Erasmus 1/ who calleth them peevish little Townes. Where he saith / he calleth them base cities: I am content the reader take which he liketh best. For both in proper speech can not be true: for to call a town / and a little town / and a peevish little town / a city: is not for any thing I know / wonted. Howbeit I will not here strive: it is sufficient that I have showed / that there were bishops in other places which were no cities. And even in this the D. letteth fall the Popes decree / which he defendeth in an other place: which forbiddeth as well to place bishops in base / and small cities, as in uplandish towns.
Where he concludeth vpon that the elders chose one amongeste them whom they made bishop, as the captaine is chosen of the the soldiars, that therfore the bishop was ouer diuers congregations: there is no likelyhood off reason. And where to giue yt some / he threapeth twoo thinges at my hande / the one that this worde elder, signifieth onely a minister off the worde, thother that euery minister of the worde had his seuerall flocke: he doothe but dalie. For he knoweth well that I hould that the worde elder / reacheth to such as gouerne onely: and that there were in diuers congregations more then one / which ⟨p. DXCVI⟩preached the word of God. Where he saith / those which I call obscure villages, were litle cyties, suche as with vs, Ely, or Peterborowgh: I leue it to the reader to iudge / how muche I haue therin squared from Erasmus