A18080:1183
The second reply of Thomas CartwrightThe second replie of Thomas Cartwright
The second reply of Thomas Cartwright: against Master Doctor Whitgiftes second answer, touching the Church disciplineThe second replie of Thomas Cartwright: agaynst Maister Doctor Whitgiftes second answer, touching the Churche discipline
Heidelberg: printed by Michael Schirat, 1575
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Where also he would make men believe / that they are come to this excess by Christian princes liberality, the truth is otherwise. For they to whom they succeeded in this princely estate: came to this wealth by church robbery. Seeing it is easy to prove / by divers aswell gifts off the Emperors an others / as by statutes and prerogatives (made in favour off the church): that it was very rich in time off those bishops. Therefore that he allegeth otherwhere for the continuance off these large revenues to one bishop, lest 1our bishops (as some in Augustins time) should take occasion of pillag•• is absurd. It is high time that he were (to speak no grievous liar) unbishoped: which will take occasion off pillage / having to live on a hundred pound a year. And as it is observed that the 2church goods were committed unto the bishops trust / to this end that he taking so much as would honestly maintain him / should bestow the rest upon divers other church necessities: so the same appeareth / in that it was aordained / that the bishop should use the church goods as things given to him to keep, and not as his own. Also by the examples off Athanasius and Augustine: where off for the first falsely accused of the turning away off the corn given to the church unto his own use: was answered by the Council assembled at the Alexandria / that he had nothing but the travail in disposing off it. The bother showing how the Donatists had not only their own when they returned unto the church / but also off the church goods: addeth that the church goods were both theirs and his, seeing he was poor as well they. But if (saith he) we possess privately as much as may suffice us, then the church goods are none of ours, but the poor's: off which goods we have the ordering, and do not challenge them as proper unto us, which is a damnable abuse,
Where also he would make men beleue / that they are come to this excesse by Christian princes liberalitie, the trewthe is otherwise. For they to whome they succeded in this princely estat: came to this wealth by church robbery. Seinge yt is easy to proue / by diuers aswell giftes off the Emperours an others / as by statutes and prerogatiues (made in fauour off the church): that yt was very riche in time off those bishops. Therfore that he alledgeth otherwhere for the continuance off these large reuenewes to one bishop, lest