A18080:25
The second reply of Thomas CartwrightThe second replie of Thomas Cartwright
The second reply of Thomas Cartwright: against Master Doctor Whitgiftes second answer, touching the Church disciplineThe second replie of Thomas Cartwright: agaynst Maister Doctor Whitgiftes second answer, touching the Churche discipline
Heidelberg: printed by Michael Schirat, 1575
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
My duty towards him / is accused diversly / of unbrotherhood, 1unfaithfulness, want of good will: made heinous / by circumstance of perjury and unthankfulness Wherein I will not answer / that I used not you as master / because you used not me as fellow: but ask 2you / wherein this breach off duty consisteth? If I owe you fidelity, I owe it more unto the lord: if good will, the truth must be preferred: if the master of Trinity College be a friend / the truth is more: If you a brother, the truth ought to be brother, sister, mother and all. Against what part off true fidelity is it / to reprove him openly by writing: which had openly by writing spoken evil off that / which I was / and am persuaded to be the everlasting truth off God / and reviled those / which maintained it. Against what point / off good will / to have showed him the way / whom I judged to be out: to light him a candle / whom I saw in this point to grope in darkness. And if I did it sharper / then your taste can like off / beside that bitter things / are often wholesomer then sweet: you should not think much to be stricken with the back off the sword / which have smitten others with the edge / nor to be lightly ⟨image 8⟩pricked with some impair off your credit / which haven thrust others through / in taking from them so much as lay i• you / all opinion both of godliness and learning. You doubt / whether I meant good faith when I called you a brother: take heed lest in giving no credit unto others / you leave no place for others to give any to you. And if I had offended / in these: yet my unthankfulness / can not be great. You never gave me any thing in my bosom or secretly / what you have given by sound off trump and openly: can not be hidden. But my reproaches, and (as you often call them) gybes: can not be excused. it is not meet / that I should my self sit in judgement off my own modesty: it is unreasonable also / that you the party grieved should. For as selfelove may blind mine eyes / and (as parents in their children) not only cause me not to see the blemish / but also to think it an ornament: so may displeasure dazzle yours / and cause your judgement to decline to much on the one side. My conscience doth not hitherto accuse me / in this behalf: others also whom this hath misliked / vvil peradventure be more favourable: