A18080:472
The second reply of Thomas CartwrightThe second replie of Thomas Cartwright
The second reply of Thomas Cartwright: against Master Doctor Whitgiftes second answer, touching the Church disciplineThe second replie of Thomas Cartwright: agaynst Maister Doctor Whitgiftes second answer, touching the Churche discipline
Heidelberg: printed by Michael Schirat, 1575
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Although men may be good Christians without selling their lands, and distributings of the price off them unto those which have need: yet they can not be good Christians / if for necessary relief of the poor of the church whereof they are / they be not content to sell (the need so requiring) even their lands. And such was the estate of the church off Jerusalem / where there were so many poor / and so few rich / that the want of those which had not / with much a do was supplied by sale off lands / and houses off them / that had such possessions. Which extreme poverty may easily be seen in other places / where not able to be furnished of the rich of that church / it was fain to be supplied by divers other. Unto 1the reasons alleged out off S. Paul / to prove that the same community is commanded of him to all Christians: you answer not one word. Unto the which I vvill ad this / that I doubt not but that which was done there / was so far from extraordinary doing: that it was done by the commandment of God in the law / where the lord chargeth the Israelites / that there should be no beggars amongest them For Saint Luke 2seemeth to have alluded to that place / when he saith / there was no needy amongest them: which expresseth most aptly / the ⟨p. CCIX⟩Hebrew word which Moses useth.
Althowghe men maie be good Christians withowte sellinge their landes, and distributings of the price off them vnto those whiche haue nede: yet they can not be good Christiās / if for necessarie releife of the poore of the churche weroff they are / they be not contente to sell (the neede so requirring) euen their landes. And suche was the estate of the churche off Ierusalē / vvhere there were so manie poore / and so fewe riche / that the vvante of those vvhiche had not / vvith muche a doo vvas supplied by sale off landes / and howses off them / that had suche possessions. Which extreme pouertie maie easely be seene in other places / vvhere not hable to be fournished of the riche of that churche / yt vvas faine to be supplied by diuers other. Vnto 1the reasons alledged owte off S. Paule / to proue that the same communitie is commaunded of him to all Christians: yowe answere not one worde. Vnto the vvhiche I vvill ad this / that I doubte not but that vvhiche vvas doone there / vvas so farre from oxtraordinarie doinge: that yt vvas doone by the cōmaundemente of God in the lawe / vvhere the lorde chargeth the Israelites / that there shoulde be no beggers amongeste them For Saincte Luke