A18080:601
The second reply of Thomas CartwrightThe second replie of Thomas Cartwright
The second reply of Thomas Cartwright: against Master Doctor Whitgiftes second answer, touching the Church disciplineThe second replie of Thomas Cartwright: agaynst Maister Doctor Whitgiftes second answer, touching the Churche discipline
Heidelberg: printed by Michael Schirat, 1575
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
I grant that I took Musculus words / for Jeromes: yet if that make to the purpose / I had red the place. And Jerome 1himself / in an other place / hath a sentence not much unlike. For in a epistle against the bishop off Jerusalem / he reproacheth him that he despised the laity deacons / and elders / for that he could in one hour as himself boasted / make a thousand clerks, whereby appeareth the corruption which Muscu. speaketh of / and which is now used with us / off making so many at a clap at the bishops pleasure only / both the people / and the elders being neglected: to have been in those times / and yet not to have gotten such footing / nether to have been so universally done / but that the bishops which used that manner / were thereby subject to shameful reproach. And how cometh it to pass / that you send Musculus here without all answer? Which doth both flatly condemn all such ordinations / which are made off the bishop before election off the church and bringeth Jerome for his warrant / referring Jerome (which saith / there was no election off ministers at all) unto that the bishop did appoint 2whom he lifted / without the consent off the church. As for the place you city out off that epistle: it maketh not to purpose. For it is not denied that the bishop hath to do in the choice ⟨p. CCLXXVIII⟩off the minister: but that he alone hath to do.
I graunte that I tooke Musculus wordes / for Ieromes: yet iff that make to the pourpose / I had redd the place. And Ierome 1himselffe / in an other place / hath a sentence not much vnlyke. For in a epistell againste the bishope off Ierusalem / he reprocheth him that he dispised the laitie deacons / and elders / for that he coulde in one howre as himselfe boasted / make a thowsande clearkes, wherby appeareth the corruption which Muscu. speaketh of / and which is nowe vsed with vs / off makinge so manie at a clappe at the bishopps pleasure onely / both the people / and the elders beinge neglected: to haue bene in those times / and yet not to haue gotten such footinge / nether to haue bene so vniuersally doone / but that the bishoppes which vsed that manner / were therby subiecte to shamfull reproch. And how cometh yt to passe / that yow send Musculus here withoute all answer? Which dooth bothe flatly condemne all such odinacions / which are made off the bishoppe before election off the church and bringeth Ierome for his warrante / referring Ierome (which saith / there vvas no election off mynisters at all) vnto that the bishoppe did appoincte