A18080:652
The second reply of Thomas CartwrightThe second replie of Thomas Cartwright
The second reply of Thomas Cartwright: against Master Doctor Whitgiftes second answer, touching the Church disciplineThe second replie of Thomas Cartwright: agaynst Maister Doctor Whitgiftes second answer, touching the Churche discipline
Heidelberg: printed by Michael Schirat, 1575
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
That I alleged the Apostles declaring that they would not have this order continued in the church, in that they renewed not that order of Apostles, as they were taken away by death: he answereth / first that the scripture doth not express it. As if S. Luke which so diligently described the election off Matthias / would have quit overleaped this / if there had been any. And considering that they had not such cause to draw them to a new consultation of a new Apostle / as in the 1. Act. which was an express word / off taking an other into the room off Judas: it is manifest that they attempted no such thing after. So that although it be not expressed: yet it is contained in scripture / that there was no consultation off an other Apostle. If not / how is he (as he saith) persuaded / that there was none chosen into their places? or how knoweth he / that it was not necessary? will he still have his persuasions in divinity / without the word? without which they are no persuasions / but idle fancies. After he asketh who ever said, that there must be twelve Apostles, nether more nor less? as though my reason tended to that. But if the Apostles did not uphold that small number off twelve / which the Lord instituted: it proveth that their mind was / not to choose about that number. And if they would not continue 12. to gather the •2. tribes off Israel / scattered thorough the whole world: they meant not that there should be a greater number / to gather those which were scattered in one Island,
That I alledged the Apostels declaring that they vvould not haue this order continued in the church, in that they renevved not that order of Apostels, as they vvere taken avvay by death: he answereth / first that the scripture doth not expresse it. As yf S. Luke which so diligently described the election off Matthias / would haue quit ouerleaped this / if there had bene any. And considering that they had not such cause to drawe them to a newe consultation of a newe Apostel / as in the 1. Act. which was an expresse word / off taking an other into the roume off Iudas: it is manifest that they attempted no such thing after. So that alththough yt be not expressed: yet it is conteined in scripture / that there was no consultation off an other Apostel. Yf not / howe is he (as he saith) persuaded / that there was none chosen into their places? or how knoweth he / that it was not necessarie? will he still haue his persuasions in diuinitie / without the word? without which they are no persuasions / but idle phansies. After he asketh who euer saied, that there muste be twelue Apostels, nether more nor lesse? as though my reason tended to that. But yf the Apostels did not vphould that small nomber off twelue / which the Lord instituted: yt proueth that their minde was / not to choose about that nomber. And if they would not continue 12. to gather the 2. tribes off Israel / scattered thoroughe the whole worlde: they ment not that there should be a greater nomber / to gather those which were scattered in one Iland,