A18080:654
The second reply of Thomas CartwrightThe second replie of Thomas Cartwright
The second reply of Thomas Cartwright: against Master Doctor Whitgiftes second answer, touching the Church disciplineThe second replie of Thomas Cartwright: agaynst Maister Doctor Whitgiftes second answer, touching the Churche discipline
Heidelberg: printed by Michael Schirat, 1575
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
But the D. seeing his folly laid open to the derision off young children / hath in favour off his Apostles / and Prophets / invented a new distinction. For where I alleged certain proper ⟨p. CCCVIII⟩marks off the Prophets / as foretelling things to come / and Apostles / as immediate calling from God / seeing off Christ / embassage into the whole world / which not falling into any function now in use / prove that they are ceased: he answereth / that 1Prophets, and Apostles in such respects are ceased, but continue still as touching preaching the gospel. Then which what can be more bluntly spoken? For it as much as if one should say / that a beast is a man / although not in respect that it hath a natural capacity off reason / and speech: yet in that it liveth / and hath sense as a man. For as a man / and a beast being both living things / are severed one from an other by their properties / and special differences (as they be called off the Logicians): even so Apost. Prophets / Evangelists / Pastors / Doctors / being all preachers off the Gospel / are severed by that wherein they differ / one from an other. And as he can be no man which hath none off those differences / whereby a man is severed from other living things: so he can not be Prophet / or Apostle / which hath nothing whereby he may differ / from a Pastor / Doctor / or Evangelist. It is also too childish / that he understandeth not how the difference off a thing (which is the substantial form) being taken away / the thing it self can not remain.
But the D. seing his folie laide open to the derision off younge children / hath in fauour off his Apostels / and Prophetes / inuented a newe distinction. For where I alledged certeine proper ⟨p. CCCVIII⟩markes off the Prophetes / as foretelling thinges to come / and Apostels / as immediat calling from God / seing off Christ / embassadge into the whole world / which not falling into any function nowe in vse / proue that they are ceassed: he aswereth / that 1Prophetes, and Apostels in such respectes are ceassed, but continue still as towching preaching the gospell. Then which what can be more bluntly spoken? For yt as much as yf one should say / that a beast is a man / although not in respect that it hath a naturall capacity off reason / and speach: yet in that it liueth / and hath sense as a man. For as a man / and a beast being both liuing thinges / are seuered one from an other by their properties / and speciall differences (as they be called off the Logicians): euen so Apost. Prophetes / Euangelistes / Pastors / Doctors / being all preachers off the Gospell / are seuered by that wherein they differ / one from an other. And as he can be no man which hath none off those differences / whereby a man is seuered from other liuing thinges: so he can not be Prophete / or Apostel / which hath nothing whereby he may differ / from a Pastor / Doctor / or Euangelist. Yt is also too childishe / that he vnderstandeth not how the difference off a thing (which is the substantiall forme) being taken away / the thing it selfe can not remaine.