A18081:134
The rest of the second reply of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]The rest of the second replie of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]
The rest of the second reply of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]: against Master Doctor Vuhitgifts second answer, touching the Church disciplineThe rest of the second replie of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]: agaynst Master Doctor Vuhitgifts second ansvuer, touching the Church discipline
Basel: printed by Thomas Guarinus, 1577
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Where against his distinction, that this government of Elders 1may be in a City, but not in a Realm, I alleged, that it hath had place, by his own confession, in a whole Realm: he saith, that that is true, where every church is, as it were, within it self a common wealth, as in France and other persecuted churches. wherein he doeth shameful injury, to all those churches of god, and to the Apostles them selves which used that order: in ascribing unto them, as though they made new common wealths, or lived not under the same form of civil government, were not obedient unto the same civil laws, and to the same Magistrates, which the Idolaters them selves were. what one, ether action, or property can you assign in an Eldership, under a kingdom, which should cause this rent: that there should be so many common wealths, and so many kingdoms, as there are Elderships? why also doeth this Eldership make a greater rent, in a monarchy where one governeth: then in a common wealth, where many govern. If you think therefore, because a monarchy is greater, then a common wealth, whereby there must be moe Elderships in the one, then in the other: beside that the argument is naught, that also whereupon it is grounded, is untrue. For, there are common wealths, where many rule, greater then the monarchies, where one only governeth: as Rome in times past, Venice within our remembrance, and such like.
Vuhere against his distinction, that this gouernment of Elders 1may be in a Cytie, but not in a Realm, I alledged, that it hath had place, by his ovun confession, in a vuhole Realm: he saith, that that is true, where euery church is, as yt were, within yt self a common wealth, as in Fraunce and other persecuted churches. wherein he doeth shameful iniury, to al those churches of god, and to the Apostles them selues which vsed that order: in ascribing vnto them, as thowgh they made new common wealthes, or liued not vnder the same form of ciuil gouernment, were not obedient vnto the same ciuil lawes, and to the same Magistrates, which the Idolatres them selues were. what one, ether action, or property can yow assign in an Eldership, vnder a kingdome, which should cause this rent: that there should be so many common wealthes, and so many kingdomes, as there are Elderships? why also doeth this Eldership make a greater rent, in a monarchy where one gouerneth: then in a common wealth, where many gouern. If yow think therfore, because a monarchy is greater, then a common wealth, wherby there must be moe Elderships in the one, then in the other: beside that the argument is nawght, that also wherevpon it is grounded, is vntrue. For, there are common wealthes, where many rule, greater then the monarchies, where one onely gouerneth: as Rome in tymes past, Venys within our remembrāce, and such like.