A18081:173
The rest of the second reply of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]The rest of the second replie of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]
The rest of the second reply of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]: against Master Doctor Vuhitgifts second answer, touching the Church disciplineThe rest of the second replie of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]: agaynst Master Doctor Vuhitgifts second ansvuer, touching the Church discipline
Basel: printed by Thomas Guarinus, 1577
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
THAT EXCOMMUNICATION, BELONGETH NOT TO THE Bishop alone: Tractate ix. and xviij, according to the D. pag. 661.
THAT EXCOMMƲNICATION, BELONGETH NOT TO THE Bishop alone: Tractate ix. and xviij, according to the D. pag. 661.
IT having been showed, that in elections and depositions, the Bishop can do nothing without the advise of the whole church, nor in the common government without assistance of the Eldership: it must follow, that in excommunication, which is one of the weightiest judgments in the church, this sole authority of the Bishop is unlawful. For as, when in civil matters, the judgment is of life and death, and as in the art of curing, when consultation is taken of cutting or burning, the bench is fuller, and the assistance greater, then when matters of less importance be debated: even so, if it might be accorded to the Bishop, to pas some other matters by him self, yet it were not safe to commit unto him the judgment of excommunication. whereupon I marvel, why even here also you go about, to peck out our eyes. For the light of this truth is such, that some of the Papists them selves, are ashamed to look against it: as appeareth by Pigghius, which seeking all manner of paintings to hide the filthiness of Rome, could find no colour to disguise this with: but is fain, partly to confess her nakedness in this behalf: saying that it is not lawful (the Bishop of Rome only excepted) 1for any Bishop to excommunicate by him self alone. So that, although the weightiness of the cause, might require a long treatise: yet the plains of it, will be content with a short.
YT hauing bene shewed, that in elections and depositions, the Bishop can doe nothing withowt the aduise of the whole church, nor in the common gouernmēt withowt assistance of the Eldership: yt must folow, that in excommunication, which is one of the weightiest iudgmentes in the church, this sole autoritie of the Bishop is vnlawful. For as, when in ciuil matters, the iudgment is of life and death, and as in the art of curing, when consultation is taken of cutting or burning, the bench is fuller, and the assistance greater, then when matters of les importance be debated: euen so, if it might be accorded to the Bishop, to pas some other matters by him self, yet it were not safe to cōmit vnto him the iudgment of excommunication. wherevpon I mervail, why euen here also yow goe abowt, to pek owt our eys. For the light of this truth is such, that some of the Papistes them selues, are ashamed to look against yt: as appeareth by Pigghius, which seeking al maner of peintynges to hyde the filthines of Rome, could finde no colour to disguise this with: but is fayn, partly to confes her nakednes in this behalf: saiyng that it is not lavuful (the Bishop of Rome onely excepted)