A18081:189
The rest of the second reply of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]The rest of the second replie of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]
The rest of the second reply of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]: against Master Doctor Vuhitgifts second answer, touching the Church disciplineThe rest of the second replie of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]: agaynst Master Doctor Vuhitgifts second ansvuer, touching the Church discipline
Basel: printed by Thomas Guarinus, 1577
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
As for his reason to prove them all one, because they were all spoken to the Apostles, it is frivolous: seeing our Sa. Christ did not only instruct them of things belonging to their Ministry, but also of those that touched their private life, and of the duties of the whole church. Of the same sort is, that the same words are used in all three places. which is all one, as when the Prince ordaining, that one chest may be opened and shut by one only, one other not so, but by others with him: he should conclude, that all have power alike, because Keys with power to lock and unlock, be given to all. For this manifest difference, is in the manner of speech, considering that Math. 16, he speaketh of one in the singular number, in John 20, although he speak in the plural, yet he understandeth it distributively, that is, that every one of the Ministers bindeth and loseth by preaching. But in S. Math. 18, those words being added to authorise the church's excommunication, which word church, is a noun collective: they can not be drawn, to the particular person of the Minister.
As for his reason to proue them al one, because they were al spoken to the Apostles, yt is friuolous: seing our Sa. Christ did not onely instruct them of thinges belonging to their Ministery, but also of those that touched their priuate lyfe, and of the duties of the whole church. Of the same sort is, that the same wordes are vsed in al three places. which is al one, as when the Prince ordeining, that one chest may be opened and shut by one onely, one other not so, but by others with him: he should conclude, that al haue power alike, because Keis with power to lok and vnlok, be giuen to al. For this manifest difference, is in the maner of speach, considering that Math. 16, he speaketh of one in the singuler nombre, in Iohn 20, althowgh he speak in the plural, yet he vnderstandeth yt distributiuely, that ys, that euery one of the Ministers binedeth and loseth by preaching. But in S. Math. 18, those wordes being added to autorise the churchis excommunication, which word church, is a noun collectiue: they can not be drawen, to the particular person of the Minister.
Here also, it is to be observed: that the D. hath quite overthrown his difference, of the Bishop, and of another Minister, in the matter of excommunication. For if in S. Math. 16 and John 20, together with the preaching of the word, is understanded power to excommunicate: all Ministers of the word having by those places authority to preach, it must follow necessarily, that they all have power committed unto them to excommunicate. And so falleth, his whole cause: which is, that by the word of god, the Bishop only hath the right of excommunication.
Here also, it is to be obserued: that the D. hath quite ouerthrowen his difference, of the Bishop, and of another Minister, in the matter of excommunication. For if in S. Math. 16 and Iohn 20, togither with the preaching of the word, is vnderstanded power to excommunicate: al Ministers of the word hauing by those places autority to preach, it must folow necessarily, that they al haue power committed vnto them to excommunicate. And so falleth, his whole cause: which is, that by the word of god, the Bishop onely hath the right of excommunication.
Where to that of S. Pauls excommunicating Alexander &c, I1 answered, that one is said to do alone, that which he was moderator of, and wherein he had assistance: he answereth, ⟨p. 84⟩that it is an imagined shift. But now he knoweth at least, if he will not acknowledge it: that it standeth of unfallible areason, and is confirmed with most grave authority of learned men. To that I answer, touching the place of Titus, that to avoid an heretic, is not to excommunicate him, but to trouble him self no more with him: he opposeth M. Calvins authority, without any aid of reason. wherein, when I have showed the reason, which led me so to expound the place: let the reader do, as him thinketh good: remembering, that if he understand it of excommunication, yet it helpeth him not, the same answer serving, which was given to the place of Timothy.
Vuhere to that of S. Paules excommunicating Alexander &c, I1 answered, that one is said to doe alone, that vuhich he vuas moderator of, and vuherein he had assistāce: he answereth, ⟨p. 84⟩that it is an imagined shift. But now he knoweth at least, if he wil not acknowledg it: that it standeth of vnfallible areason, and is confirmed with moste graue autority of learned men. To that I answer, towching the place of Titus, that to auoid an heritik, is not to excommunicate him, but to troble him self no more vuith him: he opposeth M. Caluins autoritie, withowt any aid of reason. wherein, when I haue shewed the reason, which led me so to expound the place: let the reader doe, as him thinketh good: remembring, that if he vnderstand it of excommunication, yet it helpeth him not, the same answer seruing, which was giuen to the place of Timothe.
- 1Divi. 10. p. 667.Diui. 10. p. 667.
- aIn the former part of this booK. pag. 196.
For so much then, as the Apostle willeth that the Minister should avoid him, as one utterly perverted: and notwithstanding willeth botherwhere, that the excommunicate should be holden for a brother, until such time as it appeareth, how that medicine of excommunication will work with him: and for that also, it appertaineth unto the Minister especially, even then privately to call upon him, when he is excommunicate: it seemeth, that this can not be understanded of one to be excommunicated, but of a desperate enemy whom excommunication hath not cured, but rather is (through the poison in him) hardened. And hereof, I have the judgment of Ireneus: which saith, that the fact of S. John the Apostle, which would not go into the bathes where Cerinthus the heretic was, nor once so much as speak unto him, was done according to this rule of S. Paul to Titus. 2And if an heretic be taken in that sense, which the D. hath often taken him, in saying he may err, but that he will be no heretic, that is to say for one that standeth stiff in his false opinion: then we must needs understand, that this order which S. Paul prescribeth, is understanded of that which is to be done after excommunication. For in such, we must not tarry, until two or three admonitions be given: but as soon as one showeth him self an heretic in that sense, the sentence of excommunication lieth against him.
For so much then, as the Apostle willeth that the Minister should avoid him, as one vtterly peruerted: and notwithstanding willeth botherwhere, that the excommunicate should be houlden for a brother, vntil such time as it appeareth, how that medicine of excommunication wil work with him: and for that also, yt apperteineth vnto the Minister especially, euen then priuately to cal vpon him, when he is excommunicate: it seemeth, that this can not be vnderstanded of one to be excommunicated, but of a desperate enemy whom excommunication hath not cured, but rather is (throwgh the poison in him) hardened. And hereof, I haue the iudgment of Ireneus: which saith, that the fact of S. Iohn the Apostle, which would not goe into the bathes where Cerinthus the heritik was, nor once so much as speak vnto him, vuas doen according to this rule of S. Paul to Titus. 2And if an heretik be taken in that sens, which the D. hath often taken him, in saying he mayer, but that he wil be no heretik, that is to say for one that standeth stif in his fals opinion: then we must needes vnderstād, that this order which S. Paul prescribeth, is vnderstāded of that which is to be doen after excommunication. For in such, we must not tarry, vntil two or three admonitiōs be giuen: but assone as one sheweth him self an heretik in that sens, the sentence of excommunication lieth against him.
- b2. Thess. 3. 15.
- 2•useb. li. 4. cap 14.
But if the D. will needs have it understanded, of excommunication: it shall be the bane of his own cause, and a confirmation of that answer, which he so scornfully rejecteth. For S. Paul noting excommunication, by the avoiding of the person excommunicate: in commanding Titus to avoid him, doeth not therefore command him alone. where as the D. will have these, and such like commandments: addressed unto Titus and Timothy alone. But ether, the church is not here excluded, which you deny: or else it followeth, that the church may keep company with an heretic, and the Minister only forbidden so to do, which is absurd.
But if the D. wil needes haue it vnderstanded, of excommunication: it shal be the bane of his own cause, and a confirmation of that answer, which he so scornefully reiecteth. For S. Paul noting excommunication, by the auoiding of the person excommunicate: in commanding Titus to auoid him, doeth not therefore command him alone. where as the D. wil haue these, and such like commandementes: addressed vnto Titus and Timothe alone. But ether, the church is not here excluded, which yow denie: or els it foloweth, that the church may kepe company with an heretik, and the Minister onely forbidden so to doe, which is absurd.
In the next division, in steed of Basiles offices cited in the latin and English book, he hath set out a long sentence of Ambrose, but which maketh nether hot nor cold: it being granted, that it appertaineth to the Bishop, but denied, that it doeth only. whether to take one man for an other, be so gross a fault, as to cite a book which never was: let all judg. you should rather have compared my fault, with yours in the next division saving one: which you pas by, as you do other without any confession. The next division, I leave unanswered.
In the next diuision, in steed of Basiles offices cited in the latin and English book, he hath set owt a long sentence of Ambrose, but which maketh nether whot nor kould: it being graunted, that it apperteyneth to the Bishop, but denied, that it doeth onely. whether to take one man for an other, be so gros a faut, as to cite a book which neuer was: let al iudg. yow should rather haue compared my faut, with yours in the next diuision sauing one: which yow pas by, as yow doe other withowt any confession. The next diuision, I leau vnanswered.
In the next, I confess I was deceived in the order of the story, which came thereupon, that Sozomene telleth that first, which was done after, and contrariwise: but my answer, that the Bishops sole excommunicating, was but the publishing of the sentence, given by him and the church, standeth. Nether is it of any weight, that George would not be entreated, or that suit was made to him for absolution. For it is easily answered, that George had numbers of his faction, for the gaining of which, it behoved to win him first.
In the next, I confes I was deceiued in the order of the story, which came thereupon, that Sozomene telleth that first, which was doen after, and contrariwise: but my answer, that the Bishops sole excommunicating, vuas but the publishing of the sentence, giuen by him and the church, standeth. Nether is it of any weight, that George would not be entreated, or that sute was made to him for absolution. For it is easely answered, that George had numbers of his faction, for the gaining of which, it behoued to win him first.
The D. would with words bear us down, that Theodoret 1and Sozom. affirm Ambrose to have excommunicated the Emperor alone: which is but a facing, there being nether the word, alone, nether any words which countervail it. his reason, that Ambrose carried away all the commendation, is nothing worth: seeing it is known, that the chief beareth the name, as the general of the field or Captain, is often said to have won the field, when ⟨p. 86⟩notwithstanding he used thereto, the valiancy of the soldiers. And to set aside the institution of god, it had been no commendation of Ambrose's courage, but a note of rashness and foolish hardiness: to have enterprised that of him self, against such a mighty Emperor, wherein he might have had the support of others. seeing thereby, not only the danger should have been less towards him: but also the fruit greater, towards the Emperor, whilst it should have had more authority, that was done by him with others, then by him self alone.2 And when Ambrose saith precisely, that he should be more charged with displeasure, then the rest: he giveth to understand, that some of the displeasure would lye upon the necks of the other Bishops, which with him determined of that excommunication, although not so much as upon his, that should have the execution of it. whereby it is yet more apparent, that the place out of Ambrose's epistle touching the Synod, and of his answer to the Emperor, was cited faithfully, without falsifying. As for his answer, that the Bishops lamented it only, it hath no likelihood, as it is aobserved. Where he saith, that the Synod was assembled, before the slaughter, there appeareth no such thing: although the cause lieth not in that point. For it is all one to us, whether the Council met for that matter: or being assembled for other, upon the report of it, decreed of that censure.
The D. would with wordes bear vs down, that Theodoret 1and Sozom. affirm Ambrose to haue excōmunicated the Emperour alone: which is but a facing, there being nether the word, alone, nether any wordes which countervail yt. his reason, that Ambrose caried away al the commendation, is nothing worth: seing it is knowen, that the chief beareth the name, as the general of the field or Captayn, is often said to haue won the field, whē ⟨p. 86⟩notwithstanding he vsed thereto, the valiancie of the souldiers. And to set aside the institution of god, it had bene no commendation of Ambrosis courage, but a note of rashnes and folish hardines: to haue enterprised that of him self, against such a mightie Emperour, wherein he might haue had the support of others. seing therby, not onely the danger should haue bene les towardes him: but also the fruit greater, towardes the Emperour, whilest yt should haue had more autority, that was doen by him with others, then by him self alone.2 And when Ambrose saith precisely, that he should be more charged vuith displeasure, then the rest: he giueth to vnderstād, that some of the displeasure would lye vpon the neckes of the other Bishops, which with hym determined of that excommunication, althowgh not so much as vpon his, that should haue the execution of yt. whereby yt is yet more apparant, that the place owt of Ambrosis epistel towching the Synod, and of his answer to the Emperour, was cited faithfully, withowt falsifying. As for his answer, that the Bishopes lamented it onely, it hath no likelyhood, as it is aobserued. Vuhere he saith, that the Synod was assembled, before the slaughter, there appeareth no such thing: althowgh the cause lieth not in that point. For yt is al one to vs, whether the Coūcel met for that matter: or being assembled for other, vpon the report of yt, decreed of that censure.
- 1Divis. 14. p. 670.Diuis. 14. p. 670.
- 2Ambrose Epist. 38.
- aIn te examination of the D. censures.In te examinatiō of the D. censures.
The confession of his fault before the congregation, and asking forgiveness of the church: was alleged to purpose. For what is it, to ask forgiveness, but to ask absolution of the church: and why should he ask to be absolved of the church, if the church had not bound him? That he saith, the penitents do so with us: touching any demand of absolution of the church, I think it be untrue, wherein notwithstanding, I refer me unto the practise. but if it be, it is a very mockery, to crave absolution of it, when as, howsoever it is satisfied, the Bishops absolution, right or wrong, must stand. In the first section of his next division, let the reader judg, how shameful his denials, and in the fourth section, how miserable his defence is: the rest are answered.
The confession of his faut before the congregation, and asking forgiuenes of the church: was alledged to purpose. For what is yt, to ask forgiuenes, but to ask absolutiō of the church: and why should he ask to be absolued of the church, if the church had not bound hym? That he saith, the penitentes doe so with vs: touching any demaund of absolution of the church, I think it be vntrue, wherein nothwithstanding, I refer me vnto the practise. but if it be, it is a very mockery, to craue absolution of it, whē as, howsoeuer it is satisfied, the Bishops absolution, right or wrong, must stand. In the first section of his next diuision, let the reader iudg, how shameful his denialis, and in the fourth section, how miserable his defence is: the rest are answered.
Here, as though Tertullian, had committed some high treason,1 the D. draweth him, and quartereth him, upon Rhenanus comment: whereas, although Rhenanus disjoin the sentences by putting his comment between that which I conjoined: yet he joineth them in exposition, as those which hang together. for Tertull. having before spoken, of the casting forth of the wicked out of the communion of the church: Rhenanus addeth, least it should be thought a confused company it is said, that there were certain Elders etc. It is to much boldness therefore for you to say, that it can not be gathered of this place, that these elders meddled with excommunication. If they meddled with other things (as you confess) much more with this: if the putting between of Rhenanus commentary, doeth not hinder, that this sentence should be referred, unto things which are further from it: why should it hinder the referring of it, to excommunication, which goeth immediately before. And beside this open light of Tertullians words, you have M. Peter Martyr, that was no mangler nor corrupter of Tertullian: which upon this place, precisely affirmeth, that these Seniors had their government in 2excommunication. your shift, that the Elders Tertullian speaketh of, were likely to be Ministers of the word and sacraments: is aanswered.
Here, as thowgh Tertullian, had cōmitted some high treason,1 the D. draweth him, and quartereth him, vpon Rhenanus coment: whereas, althowgh Rhenanus disioyn the sentēces by putting his comment betwene that which I conioyned: yet he ioyneth thē in expositiō, as those which hang togither. for Tertull. hauing before spokē, of the casting forth of the wicked owt of the cōmunion of the church: Rhenanus addeth, least yt should be thovught a confused cōpany it is said, that there vuere certein Elders etc. yt is to much bouldnes therfore for yow to say, that it can not be gathered of this place, that these elders medled with excommunication. If they medled with other thinges (as yow confes) much more with this: if the putting betwene of Rhenanus commentary, doeth not hinder, that this sentence should be referred, vnto thinges which are further from yt: why should it hinder the referring of yt, to excommunication, which goeth immediatly before. And beside this open light of Tertulliās wordes, yow haue M. Peter Martyr, that was no mangler nor corrupter of Tertullian: which vpon this place, precisely affirmeth, that these Seniors had their gouernment in 2excommunication. your shift, that the Elders Tertullian speaketh of, were likely to be Ministers of the word and sacramētes: is aanswered.
- 1Divis. 16. p. 673.Diuis. 16. p. 673.
- 2upon the•. epist. to the Cor. cap. 5.vpon the•. epist. to the Cor. cap. 5.
- aIn the 8. tract. divis. 8.In the 8. tract. diuis. 8.
In that you say, this authority being admitted, the people is quite shut out, first you conclude negatively of authority, namely that they have nothing to do, because Tertullian doeth not say they had. Then you fault again in not marking, that when Tertullian saith, that these were Presidents or chief in the matter: he leaveth a signification, that other had to do in it, which followed with their sentence those, that with the ripeness of their judgment, went before the rest is banswered.
In that yow say, this autority being admitted, the people is quite shut owt, first yow cōclude negatiuely of autority, namely that they haue nothing to doe, because Tertullian doeth not say they had. Then yow faut again in not marking, that when Tertullian saith, that these were Presidentes or cheif in the matter: he leaueth a significatiō, that other had to doe in yt, which folowed with their sentence those, that with the ripenes of their iudgment, went before the rest is banswered.
- bIn this chap. 2. divis.In this chap. 2. diuis.
If the excommunicate might not be received, without the1 peoples request, much less without their consent: for men use not to make request, for that they consent not unto. As for that alleged, because Cyprian would have that absolution stand, 2which was done by one, that therefore it is lawful for the Bishop alone to absolve: is to trifle. For so Cyprian, will have it stand, ⟨p. 88⟩that in the mean season, he condemneth the doer of it. And the D. ought to understand, that it is one thing to prescribe what should be done: and another to support a thing which being commanded, is otherwise done then it ought: as hath been showed, in the baptism by heretics. Victor also being repentant, and having showed fruits thereof: it had been against right, to have thrust him out again. If he had not repented: it is certain, that Cyprian would have dealt with him afresh.
If the excōmunicate might not be receiued, withowt the1 peoples request, much les withowt their consent: for men vse not to make request, for that they consent not vnto. As for that alledged, because Cyprian would haue that absolution stand, 2which was doen by one, that therefore it is lawful for the Bishop alone to absolue: is to trifle. For so Cyprian, wil haue it stand, ⟨p. 88⟩that in the mean season, he condemneth the doer of yt. And the D. owght to vnderstand, that it is one thing to prescribe what should be doen: and another to support a thing which being commanded, is otherwise doen then it owght: as hath bene shewed, in the baptim by heretikes. Victor also being repentant, and hauing shewed fruites thereof: it had bene against right, to haue thrust him owt again. Yf he had not repented: it is certain, that Cyprian would haue dealt with him afresh.
- 1Divis. 17. p. 674.Diuis. 17. p. 674.
- 2Cyp. lib Epist. 3 epist. 8.
Cyprian professeth, that he would never do any thing 1in his bishopric, without the counsel of the Elders, and consent of the people: and yet the D. can not see, how this should make against his sole excommunication. what stronger words, could there have been? If he would do nothing without them, how much less excommunicate, which is so weighty a judgment. As for that he expoundeth no matter, that is no doubtful matter: it is a shameful corruption. which appeareth, in that beside the counsel of the Elders, to resolve him of the doubt, if any were: he addeth also, the consent of the people. Also, for that the same case, wherein he protesteth he would have done nothing without the church: was a plain case, and whereof he was able to resolve, without the advise of other. Likewise that he saith, it was in Cyprian's power to have done all him self alone, because he saith, he determined not to do so) is yet more ridiculous: as though David in saying he determined to 2keep the word of god, or any other, that he determineth to keep his promise, do thereby give to understand, that ether the one needed not to keep the word of god, or the other his promise.
Cyprian professeth, that he vuould neuer doe any thing 1in his bishoprik, vuithovut the counsail of the Elders, and consent of the people: and yet the D. can not see, how this should make against his sole excommunication. what stronger wordes, could there haue bene? If he vuould doe nothing vuithovut them, how much les excommunicate, which is so weighty a iudgment. As for that he expoundeth no matter, that is no doutful matter: it is a shameful corruptiō. which appeareth, in that beside the counsail of the Elders, to resolue him of the dowt, if any were: he addeth also, the consent of the people. Also, for that the same case, wherein he protesteth he would haue doen nothing withowt the church: was a plain case, and whereof he was able to resolue, withowt the aduise of other. Likewise that he sayth, it was in Cyprians power to haue doen al him self alone, because he saith, he determined not to doe so) is yet more ridiculous: as thowgh Dauid in saying he determined to 2kepe the vuord of god, or any other, that he determineth to kepe his promis, doe therby giue to vnderstand, that ether the one needed not to kepe the word of god, or the other his promis.
- 1Epist. 10.
- 2Psalm. 119. vers. 57.
The next aplace maketh the Elders and other church men, as well to have power in absolving, as the Bishop: yet the D. seeth not how that maketh against him, which would have the Bishop alone. but (saith he) the people is not there mentioned: as though that was not sufficiently showed in other places, ⟨p. 89⟩and here left out, because they did not lay on their hands as the church officers. although in the later end of that epistle, he also threateneth the disordered persons: that if they go forward, they shall be made to answer the matter before the people. But it appeareth (saith he) that it could not be done without the Bishop: even as it could not be done without those, whom Cyprian calleth clerks: beside that it is to great dalliance, seeing none denieth the Bishops an interest.
The next aplace maketh the Elders and other church men, as vuel to haue povuer in absoluing, as the Bishop: yet the D. seeth not how that maketh against him, which would haue the Bishop alone. but (saith he) the people is not there mentioned: as thowgh that was not sufficiently shewed in other places, ⟨p. 89⟩and here left owt, because they did not lay on their handes as the church officers. althowgh in the later end of that epistle, he also threatneth the disordered persōs: that if they goe forvuard, they shal be made to ansvuer the matter before the people. But yt appeareth (saith he) that it could not be doen withowt the Bishop: euen as it could not be doen withowt those, whome Cypriā calleth clerkes: beside that it is to great daliance, seing none denieth the Bishops an interest.
- aCyp. Epi. 14.
The next place is wherein Cyprian saith, that for so much 1as absolution belonged unto all, meaning of those in his church, that he alone durst not do it. yet (saith he) in that they desire it at Cyprian's hand: it argueth, that the manner was then for one to absolve. was it in deed, the manner to do that which was not lawful, even by your own confession: that is for one to lose that which many had bound? For they which desired absolution, knew that they were excommunicate by many: if therefore upon that they desired absolution of one, it be well concluded that one was wont to absolve: it followeth, that they were wont to do that, which was unlawful, which is a slander of that time, and yet helpeth you not. But the reader may understand, that they came therefore to desire absolution of Cyprian: because it belonged unto him, to assemble the Seniors by whom the receiving was first handled, before it came to the church.
The next place is wherein Cyprian saith, that for so much 1as absolution belonged vnto al, meaing of those in his church, that he alone durst not doe yt. yet (sayth he) in that they desire it at Cyprians hand: it argueth, that the maner was then for one to absolue. was yt in deed, the maner to doe that which was not lawful, euen by your own confession: that is for one to lose that which many had bound? For they which desired absolution, knw that they were excommunicate by many: if therfore vpon that they desired absolution of one, it be wel concluded that one was wont to absolue: it foloweth, that they were wont to doe that, which was vnlawful, which is a slaunder of that tyme, and yet helpeth yow not. But the reader may vnderstand, that they came therfore to desire absolution of Cyprian: because it belonged vnto him, to assemble the Seniors by whom the receiuing was first handled, before yt came to the church.
- 1Cyp. Epist. 19.
And who knoweth not, that the grief of the penitent sinner, languishing and feinting with desire of being joined with the church again, doeth even wring out petitions to be helped of them, which are not able alone to help: especially when as they (likely) thought, that the rest would be counselled by Cyprian. who seeth not also, that the sense of Cyprian's answer to those afflicted persons, which would have been delivered before the time prescribed of their repentance: is to show him self moved with compassion of their sorrow, which he for his part was ready to help, if the other would thereto agree. which may better appear by that1 epistle, where the D. saith, he can find nothing of this matter: which ⟨p. 90⟩notwithstanding is most pregnant. For Cyprian showeth there, how he travailed greatly with his church, to receive those which, having fallen away, repented them: declaring thereby, that it was not in him alone. In the end, although he hath used such boldness, as I am ashamed to give the proper name of: yet he feareth not to say, that I have abused the reader. which, let him understand (as touching three of the middle places) to be spoken as well against M. Calvin, as me:2 who useth them, to condemn the sole excommunication of the Bishop.
And who knoweth not, that the grief of the penitent synner, languishing and feinting with desire of being ioyned with the church again, doeth euen wring owt petitions to be helped of them, which are not able alone to help: especially when as they (likely) thowght, that the rest would be counsailed by Cyprian. who seeth not also, that the sens of Cypriās answer to those afflicted persons, which would haue bene deliuered before the tyme prescribed of their repentance: is to shew him self moued with compassion of their sorow, which he for his part was ready to help, if the other would thereto agree. which may better appear by that1 epistle, where the D. saith, he can finde nothing of this matter: which ⟨p. 90⟩notwithstanding is most pregnant. For Cyprian sheweth there, how he trauailed greatly vuith his church, to receiue those vuhich, hauing fallen avuay, repented them: declaring thereby, that it was not in him alone. In the end, althowgh he hath vsed such bouldnes, as I am ashamed to giue the proper name of: yet he feareth not to say, that I haue abused the reader. which, let him vnderstand (as touching three of the middle places) to be spoken as wel against M. Caluin, as me:2 who vseth them, to condemn the sole excommunication of the Bishop.
- 12. lib. Epist. 3.
- 2Inst. 4. lib. cap 11 s. 6.