A18081:251
The rest of the second reply of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]The rest of the second replie of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]
The rest of the second reply of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]: against Master Doctor Vuhitgifts second answer, touching the Church disciplineThe rest of the second replie of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]: agaynst Master Doctor Vuhitgifts second ansvuer, touching the Church discipline
Basel: printed by Thomas Guarinus, 1577
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
I grant, a man may defend him self against false accusations in a sermon: but that is not, when he standeth judicially accused like a malefactor, as S. Steven did. whose whole oration, how apt a purgation it is (which he denieth): the reader may fetch from M. Calvin, upon that place: that I be not compelled, to lengthen my book by so long translations. Against M. Beza (in quoting of whom, I failed) are opposed Gualter and the Centuries: of whose sentences, which is truer, let it be judged of the reasons on both sides. whether in the two next divisions, the Ans. shifteth his gross oversight, let the reader judg: especially, when as his pretence, that the Adm. assigned the deaconship, to be only in handling the church treasure, is untrue. For nether have they the word, only, nor any thing of that value: and it is manifest, that their drift was, only to shut out the Deacon from the administration of the word and sacraments. so that, in taking his words, in that sense which he now would have them: in effect he confesseth, him self to have but trifled with the Admonition: changing the pricks, which they had set him to shoot at and roving after a mark of his own finding. In the next, I alleged, that if the Deaconship were granted, a step to the ministry, yet thereof followeth not that it is the ministry: but contrariwise, that it is not, and therefore ought not to do things pertaining to the ministers. To this he answereth, he concluded not so: which I confess, can not be forcibly won out of his words. But he saith, he might have so concluded: which is absurd, and all one as if he should say, that the foot of the stair is the same with the top, whether it, in ascending, leadeth. And how dare he say that ⟨p. 108⟩he might have so reasoned: when as to the argument, which I drew from these words of his, he can answer nothing, how could he have hurt us, with this, which he suffereth to be driven so flat, upon the head of his own cause.
I graunt, a man may defend hym self against fals accusations in a sermon: but that is not, whē he standeth iudicially accused like a malefactor, as S. Steuen did. whose vuhole oration, how apt a purgation yt is (which he denieth): the reader may fetch from M. Caluin, vpon that place: that I be not cōpelled, to lenghthen my book by so long translations. Against M. Beza (in quoting of whome, I failed) are opposed Gualter and the Centuries: of whose sentēces, which is truer, let it be iudged of the reasons on boeth sides. whether in the two next diuisiōs, the Ans. shifteth his gros ouersight, let the reader iudg: especially, whē as his pretence, that the Adm. assigned the deaconship, to be onely in handling the church treasure, is vntrue. For nether haue they the word, onely, nor any thing of that value: and it is manifest, that their drift was, onely to shut owt the Deacō from the administratiō of the word and sacramētes. so that, in taking his wordes, in that sens which he now would haue them: in effect he cōfesseth, hym self to haue but trifled with the Admonition: chaunging the prickes, which they had set hym to shoot at and roving after a mark of his own finedīg. In the next, I alledged, that if the Deacōship vuere graūted, a step to the ministery, yet thereof folovueth not that yt is the mynistery: but contrarivuise, that it is not, and therefore ovught not to doe thinges pertayning to the ministers. To this he answereth, he concluded not so: which I confes, can not be forcibly won owt of his wordes. But he saith, he might haue so concluded: which is absurd, and al one as if he should say, that the foot of the stayer is the same with the top, whether it, in ascending, leadeth. And how dare he say that