A18081:29
The rest of the second reply of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]The rest of the second replie of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]
The rest of the second reply of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]: against Master Doctor Vuhitgifts second answer, touching the Church disciplineThe rest of the second replie of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]: agaynst Master Doctor Vuhitgifts second ansvuer, touching the Church discipline
Basel: printed by Thomas Guarinus, 1577
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And if it be true that he saith after, the pastor must use such discipline, as seemeth good to the Magistrate: when the Magistrate ordaineth civil discipline only, ether that discipline must be incident to the pastorship, or else in such a time, there shall be a Pastor of god, which hath no discipline incident into his office: seeing the ecclesiastical discipline, which is taken (by his judgment) from him lawfully, is not incident: so that this idle distinction goeth flat to the ground. I call it idle, be cause it maketh nothing to the question: which is not, whether a Minister may bear civil office, in that respect that he is a Minister, but whether he may bear it at all. And of this sort also is, that our Bishops break not violently into these offices, but receive them of the Princes gift: whereas our question is, whether he may receive these offices when they be given: yet hath he used this distinction, at the least, five times.
And if it be trw that he saith after, the pastor must vse such discipline, as semeth good to the Magistrate: when the Magistrate ordeineth ciuil discipline onely, ether that discipline must be incident to the pastorship, or els in such a time, there shal be a Pastor of god, which hath no discipline incident into his office: seing the ecclesiastical discipline, which is taken (by his iudgment) from him laufully, is not incident: so that this idle distinction goeth flat to the ground. I cal it idle, be cause it maketh nothing to the question: which is not, whether a Minister may bear ciuil office, in that respect that he is a Minister, but whether he may bear it at al. And of this sort also is, that our Bishops break not violently into these offices, but receiue them of the Princes gift: whereas our question is, whether he may receiu these offices when they be giuen: yet hath he vsed this distinction, at the least, fiue tymes.
After is added, that it is committed to them by the Magistrate, for fuller satisfying of their duty: if so, why should not all the Ministers alike have this power, to the end, that all might do their duties the better. Again, in saying that it is necessary for this time: you openly wrest this power, out of the Magistrates hand. For thereby it followeth, that the Magistrate of duty, ought to commit this unto them: and if he do not, he is guilty of gods wrath, in leaving undone, that which is necessary to be done. you do also open injury to the holy ghost, which is thus supposed to have left that in the liberty of the Magistrate, which is necessary for the accomplishing of the ministry: whereas, if it had been necessary, there had been also nothing more easy, then to have given this general rule, that always under a Christian Magistrate, the Minister should be armed with civil authority. But this succour which you seek in the time, is Pigghius shift: as is also this whole cause, and the flower of your arguments. For he saith, As long as the church