A18081:313
The rest of the second reply of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]The rest of the second replie of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]
The rest of the second reply of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]: against Master Doctor Vuhitgifts second answer, touching the Church disciplineThe rest of the second replie of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]: agaynst Master Doctor Vuhitgifts second ansvuer, touching the Church discipline
Basel: printed by Thomas Guarinus, 1577
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
To that alleged, that the breaking of the orders of god, 1whereof one is, that the minister only should baptize, the other, that it be done publicly, confirmeth men greatly in that heresy, that all are damned, which are not baptized: he answereth nothing. Likewise, to that, that if a man could not be saved without baptism, yet we might not therefore break the order of god, he answereth also nothing, but wandereth idly in talking of the necessity of baptism, which we confess, as hath been bbefore declared. Where, against his absurd saying, that the teaching of this kind of private baptism, implieth no more the tying of salvation unto the sacrament, then to teach that children should be baptized before they be able to answer for them selves, I replied that the baptism of young children, hath ground in the scripture, but baptism by lay men or women hath none: he answereth, that this confirmeth his saying. wherein, the reproach of trifling, is to easy, to set forth his untollerable abusing of his reader. For to have answered, he ought to have taught, a rule out of the word of god, whereby it might have appeared: that a private person, may take upon him in this pretensed case of necessity, to do that which god hath not committed, but unto the Minister: so that here, it is manifest, that he had never a knee to bow unto the truth,3 but was like that beast, which having never a joint in her leg, must rather break then bend.
To that alledged, that the breaking of the orders of god, 1vuhereof one is, that the minister onely should baptiz, the other, that it be doen publikly, confirmeth men greatly in that heresy, that al are damned, vuhich are not baptized: he answereth nothing. Likewise, to that, that if a man could not be saued vuithovut baptim, yet vue might not therefore break the order of god, he answereth also nothing, but wandereth idly in talking of the necessity of baptim, which we confes, as hath bene bbefore declared. Vuhere, against his absurd saying, that the teaching of this kinde of priuate baptim, implieth no more the tying of saluation vnto the sacrament, then to teach that children should be baptized before they be able to answer for them selues, I replied that the baptim of young children, hath ground in the scripture, but baptim by lay men or vuemen hath none: he answereth, that this confirmeth his saying. wherein, the reproch of triflyng, is to easy, to set forth his vntollerable abusing of his reader. For to haue answered, he owght to haue tawght, a rule owt of the word of god, whereby it might haue appeared: that a priuate person, may take vpon him in this pretensed case of necessity, to doe that which god hath not committed, but vnto the Minister: so that here, it is manifest, that he had neuer a knee to bow vnto the truth,