A18081:321
The rest of the second reply of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]The rest of the second replie of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]
The rest of the second reply of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]: against Master Doctor Vuhitgifts second answer, touching the Church disciplineThe rest of the second replie of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]: agaynst Master Doctor Vuhitgifts second ansvuer, touching the Church discipline
Basel: printed by Thomas Guarinus, 1577
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Howbeit, let it be, that the usage of these words, is the only essential form: what shall be the material cause? For there must be aswell a matter, whereof the sacrament must consist, as a form whereby it is: and as well is the material cause of the sacrament a substantial cause, as is the form. For even as a thing can not stand without the form: so can it not stand without the matter. Now when the one is as necessary, to the constitution of a thing, as the other: let him show me, why a fault in the form, or departing from the words, should more destroy the nature of the sacrament, then a defect, or departure from the matter, which is the water. And verily for my part, I would rather judg him baptized, which is baptized into the name of Christ, without adding the father and holy ghost, when the element of water is added: then when the other words being duly kept, some other liquor is used.
Howbeit, let it be, that the vsage of these wordes, is the onely essential form: what shal be the material cause? For there must be aswel a matter, whereof the sacrament must consist, as a form whereby it is: and as wel is the material cause of the sacrament a substantial cause, as ys the form. For euē as a thing can not stand withowt the form: so can yt not stand withowt the matter. Now when the one is as necessary, to the constitution of a thing, as the other: let him shew me, why a faut in the form, or departing from the wordes, should more destroy the nature of the sacrament, then a defaut, or departure from the matter, which is the water. And verely for my part, I would rather iudg him baptized, which is baptized into the name of Christ, withowt adding the father and holy gost, when the element of water is added: then when the other wordes being duly kept, some other liquor is vsed.
This also is declared by his own example of the •ue baptized with sand: in that it was decreed, that he should have water poured on him. whereby appeareth, that it is untrue which he saith, that the sacrament alway remaineth, what error soever be committed, when the form of words is retained. For there the words were kept, and yet the sacrament was not supposed, to be ministered. Although the example otherwise, in my poor judgment, be unsound: that a man having the words said at one time, and the Element poured at another, should be judged baptized. For it is as much, as if a man receiving the bread in the church at Easter, and the cup at the Nativity: should be therefore said, to have received the holy