A18081:324
The rest of the second reply of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]The rest of the second replie of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]
The rest of the second reply of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]: against Master Doctor Vuhitgifts second answer, touching the Church disciplineThe rest of the second replie of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]: agaynst Master Doctor Vuhitgifts second ansvuer, touching the Church discipline
Basel: printed by Thomas Guarinus, 1577
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Having thus spoken of the matter, that it must necessarily be such as the institution of god hath prescribed: let us come to the Minister, which is a subordinate efficient cause. whom seeing I have also proved (whatsoever he say) to be instituted the only minister of the sacraments: let him show me, why the breach of the institution in the form should make the sacrament unavailable, and not the breach of this part. for if this be not also necessary, and of the being of the sacram: then when two go together, if one speak the words of the institution, although no man pour on water, but god only by rain from heaven, it is baptism. And if it be baptism which is ministered of a child in sport (which thing M. Farel derideth as a mere toy) then if a mad man, with mind to hurt, do speak1 those words in pouring water upon his head, which is not baptised, it shall be baptism also. further, if it be administered by him, which is by profession a Turk: it must, by his rule, be a good baptism. so we shall come to the dotage of the papists, which imagine that the Shepard in the field consecrated their host; in saying certain words of the institution of the supper: which was the cause why, afterward, they would have them mumbled up in secret. These things being absurd, it is certain that the D. rule, that it is baptism by whomsoever it be ministered: is crooked. But when none can wash us from our since but our S. Christ, and none can represent his person in that outward sacrament of the inward washing, but he whom our Say. Christ him self hath appointed: if we will receive the benefit of ⟨p. 139⟩the holy seal of baptism, to assurance of our conscience, that we are washed from our since, we must have the public minister. If it be said, that this is to tie men to straight to the outward means, and that for so much as it is Christ that washeth from sins, there is less matter who be the Minister: I answer, that as our Sa. Christs blood, being the spiritual matter of the sacrament, and that only wherewith we are purged, yet we may not therefore lack the water, which he hath ordained: so although he be he which alone washeth us from our since, yet we may not therefore lack that outward minister, which he hath appointed.
Hauing thus spoken of the matter, that it must necessarily be such as the institutiō of god hath prescribed: let vs come to the Minister, which is a subordinat efficiēt cause. whome seing I haue also proued (whatsoeuer he say) to be instituted the onely minister of the sacramentes: let him shew me, why the breach of the institutiō in the form should make the sacramēt vnavailable, and not the breach of this part. for if this be not also necessary, and of the being of the sacram: then when two goe togither, if one speak the wordes of the institution, althowgh no man powr on water, but god onely by rayn from heauen, yt is baptim. And if it be baptim which is ministred of a childe in sport (which thing M. Farel derideth as a mere toy) then if a mad mā, with minde to hurt, doe speak