A18081:327
The rest of the second reply of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]The rest of the second replie of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]
The rest of the second reply of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]: against Master Doctor Vuhitgifts second answer, touching the Church disciplineThe rest of the second replie of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]: agaynst Master Doctor Vuhitgifts second ansvuer, touching the Church discipline
Basel: printed by Thomas Guarinus, 1577
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
I alleged, that part of the institution (as that which 1toucheth the words of the holy Trinity) being observed, and not this, it is no more baptism, then the papists communion is the supper, where one piece taken, the other is left. whereto he answereth, that the cup is of the substance, because it is expressly commanded. So is this of the Minister also commanded: therefore by his own answer, of the substance of the sacrament. But (saith he) I can not show a commandment, that a Minister only shall celebrate the Baptism, or else be no Baptism: no more can he in so many words, that if the cup be not received, it is no supper. But if his proof be sufficient, because the lord hath commanded that it should be received: my proof is also, that have showed the same in the ministering of baptism: especially seeing the breach is not in the circumstance, but in the causes.
I alledged, that part of the institution (as that vuhich 1tovucheth the vuordes of the holy Trinity) being obserued, and not this, it is no more baptim, then the papistes communiō is the supper, vuhere one peece takē, the other is left. whereto he answereth, that the cup is of the substance, because it is expresly commanded. So is this of the Minister also commanded: therfore by his own answer, of the substance of the sacrament. But (saith he) I can not shew a commandement, that a Minister onely shal celebrate the Baptim, or els be no Baptim: no more can he in so many wordes, that if the cup be not receiued, it is no supper. But yf his proof be sufficient, because the lord hath cō manded that yt should be receiued: my proof is also, that haue shewed the same in the ministring of baptim: especially seing the breach is not in the circumstance, but in the causes.
- 1Divis. 5. p. 520.Diuis. 5. p. 520.
He allegeth further, that circumcision ministered by such as were no Priests, was good: I grant, if it were done by those which were simple Levites, if it were done also by Prophets which were no Priests: But if he can show it good, done by those to whom it belonged not, then he saith some what.