A18081:366
The rest of the second reply of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]The rest of the second replie of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]
The rest of the second reply of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]: against Master Doctor Vuhitgifts second answer, touching the Church disciplineThe rest of the second replie of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]: agaynst Master Doctor Vuhitgifts second ansvuer, touching the Church discipline
Basel: printed by Thomas Guarinus, 1577
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Here also, I would ask of him, how the Council of Nice was fitter to judg of the matter, then the Emperor? was it by some singular case, or by reason of their office of being Bishops? If (as needs he must) he answer, that they are by calling and by office, fitter to judg of such causes: how must not that pertain unto them, which are hereof, by calling, the fittest Judges. For, although there be found sometimes, some civil governor which hath more skill to judg in church matters, then some Bishop, as also some Bishops to have more skill in common wealth matters, then some civil governor: yet notwithstanding, nether the one, nor the other hath this cunning, by any gift incident into his office which he exerciseth. So that, the Answerer, in reputing it, for wisdom in the Emperor, to commit these matters unto the Bishops, as unto the most able Judges, maketh a deep wound in the wisdom of god, whilst he supposeth, that god hath committed that to be done by the Magistrate, whereof, by office, he is not the fittest doer: which is a voice, unworthy of a very suckling, much more, of a D. in divinity. And, that this is most properly belonging1 unto a Bishop, it appeareth, in that the Apostle requireth, that he should be able to convince the gainsayers: which he never required of the civil Magistrate: and notwithstanding would have required it, if the decision of such causes, had appertained unto him. For the lord, calleth no man to any thing: of whom he requireth not gifts, meet to furnish his calling.
Here also, I would ask of him, how the Councel of Nice was fitter to iudg of the matter, then the Emperour? was it by some singuler case, or by reason of their office of being Bishops? Yf (as needes he must) he answer, that they are by calling and by office, fitter to iudg of such causes: how must not that pertein vnto them, which are hereof, by calling, the fittest Iudges. For, althowgh there be found sometymes, some ciuil gouernour which hath more skil to iudg in church matters, then some Bishop, as also some Bishops to haue more skil in common wealth matters, then some ciuil gouernour: yet notwithstanding, nether the one, nor the other hath this kunning, by any gift incident into his office which he exerciseth. So that, the Answerer, in reputing it, for wisdome in the Emperour, to commit these matters vnto the Bishops, as vnto the most able Iudges, maketh a deep wound in the wisdome of god, whilest he supposeth, that god hath committed that to be doen by the Magistrate, whereof, by office, he is not the fittest doer: which is a voice, vnworthy of a very sukling, much more, of a D. in diuinity. And, that this is most properly belonging