A18081:368
The rest of the second reply of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]The rest of the second replie of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]
The rest of the second reply of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]: against Master Doctor Vuhitgifts second answer, touching the Church disciplineThe rest of the second replie of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]: agaynst Master Doctor Vuhitgifts second ansvuer, touching the Church discipline
Basel: printed by Thomas Guarinus, 1577
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Now, because he dissenting from them, would yet seem to be at one, he also hath set down, that it is necessary: but how? mark I pray you, and you shall see that, in striving against a manifest truth, he became speechless. Forsooth it is necessary, that they may decide: he durst not say ⟨image 86⟩that it is necessary they should, but that they may decide. where in saying that it is necessary, he leaveth no choice: again, in saying that they may, he destroyeth the necessity, which he had before put, leaving it in the Princes power, whether they shall or no. Thus as the mouse cleaving fast in the pitch box, in one sentence: he affirmeth that a godly and learned ministry, must of necessity, and not of necessity, decide of these causes.
Now, because he dissenting from them, would yet seeme to be at one, he also hath set down, that it is necessary: but how? mark I pray yow, and yow shal see that, in stryuing against a manifest truth, he became speachles. Forsooth it is necessary, that they may decide: he durst not say ⟨image 86⟩that it is necessary they should, but that they may decide. where in saying that it is necessary, he leaueth no choise: again, in saying that they may, he destroyeth the necessity, which he had before put, leauing it in the Princis power, whether they shal or no. Thus as the mous kleauing fast in the pitchbox, in one sentence: he affirmeth that a godly and learned ministery, must of necessity, and not of necessity, decide of these causes.
That which he addeth, that the authority doeth as well still remain in the Prince, when the Ministers decide, as when the Judges determine of civil causes: is untrue. If, as he pretendeth, it were at the Princes choice, whether a godly ministry, should decide of them or no, then it were true he saith: but if it be true, which the Bishop and M. Nowel say, that it is necessary, that a godly ministry should decide of them, and that it belongeth to the the Bishops office so to do: then the comparison, is most unequal. For the judgment of civil causes, doeth so be long unto the Magistrate, that he is not bound by the law of god, to translate it unto other. Nay the law of god, will have, that Princes them selves (so far as they may, and are able) shall bear their dominion upon their own shoulders, and judg the causes of their subjects in their own persons: considering that the scripture calleth all princes, Judges, and setteth every one a Throne, to judg the causes of his people. Now (to return back, where I left) followeth his answer to the Council of Constantinople: that it is to late a testimony, being other in the year 549 or 681. which might have place in this case, where the question is of the Bishops jurisdiction, as that which in process of time did outreach: were it not confirmed, by other testimonies of the former age. In the first of which Councils, Menna the Patriarch being president, it is said that the decree of the Bishops firm in it self, was con firmed by the Emperor. Now seeing the Bishops, had then this authority: how much more, by his own confession, had they the same, in the other which was later. And the same Constantine which the D. speaketh of, giveth more to the Bishops, then we do: namely that he would compel none