A18081:404
The rest of the second reply of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]The rest of the second replie of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]
The rest of the second reply of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]: against Master Doctor Vuhitgifts second answer, touching the Church disciplineThe rest of the second replie of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]: agaynst Master Doctor Vuhitgifts second ansvuer, touching the Church discipline
Basel: printed by Thomas Guarinus, 1577
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
To that of Tertullian, commending the Gentiles, which 1would not wittingly keep any of the feasts of the Christians, and of the other side, discommending the Christians, that kept the feasts of the Gentiles: he answereth, that they communicated with them, in their Idols: which is untrue, there being not a word cited here by him self, importing so much. For, to cease from labours the same days they did: was not simply unlawful. He chargeth them also, with feasting on the same days which they did, also with sending of new year's gifts: were these not things, in them selves indifferent, and only condemned of Tertullian, because they were the ceremonies of profane nations? and doeth he not see, how Tertullian maketh with us, in that he preferreth the use of the ceremonies of the Ives which are abrogated (for that they were sometime authorized of god) to the ceremonies, which other profane nations, had taken up of their own brain. This also, may be understood, by the opposition he maketh, of the commendation of the Gentiles. for, seeing Tert. commendeth not the Gentiles, for that they worshipped not god with the Christians, but for that they would not admit the ceremonies, of a religion contrary to their own: to make the opposition answerable, we must needs say, that he rebuketh the Christians, for that they used the ceremonies of a religion, contrary to that they approved. For further knowledge, of Tertullians judgment herein: I refer the reader, to that abefore written.
To that of Tertullian, commending the Gentiles, vuhich 1vuould not vuittingly kepe any of the feastes of the Christiās, and of the other side, discōmending the Christians, that kept the feastes of the Gentiles: he answereth, that they cōmunicated with thē, in their Idoles: which is vntrue, there being not a word cyted here by him self, importing so much. For, to ceas frō labors the same dayes they did: was not simply vnlawful. He chargeth thē also, vuith feasting on the same dayes vuhich they did, also vuith sending of nueyeares giftes: were these not thinges, in thē selues indifferēt, and onely condēned of Tertullian, because they were the ceremonies of prophane nations? and doeth he not see, how Tertulliā maketh with vs, in that he preferreth the vse of the ceremonies of the Iues which are abrogated (for that they were sometyme autorized of god) to the ceremōies, which other prophane natiōs, had takē vp of their own brayn. This also, may be vnderstood, by the opposition he maketh, of the cōmendatiō of the Gentiles. for, seing Tert. cōmendeth not the Gētiles, for that they worshipped not god with the Christians, but for that they would not admit the ceremonies, of a religion contrary to their own: to make the opposition answerable, we must needes say, that he rebuketh the Christians, for that they vsed the ceremonies of a religion, contrary to that they approued. For further knowledg, of Tertullians iudgment herein: I refer the reader, to that