A18081:504
The rest of the second reply of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]The rest of the second replie of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]
The rest of the second reply of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]: against Master Doctor Vuhitgifts second answer, touching the Church disciplineThe rest of the second replie of Thomas Cartvurihgt [sic]: agaynst Master Doctor Vuhitgifts second ansvuer, touching the Church discipline
Basel: printed by Thomas Guarinus, 1577
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
To this defence may well be referred, that which he answereth pag. 275 unto my objection: that Sensors. Tapers holy bread &c, are even of the same coat that the surplice is of, and to be measured with the same pole. for if his answer there, which is, that the surplice is indifferent, but that these things be falsely accounted indifferent, be good: it will help to succour, his weakness here: and if it be showed naught here, nether will it serve him there. Let him tell us therefore, why the surplice and the cross with their significations should be indifferent, and oil and tapers &c with their interpretations, falsely counted indifferent. Here, we must believe him of his word, for reason, he hath none. Howbeit page 291, where he repeateth this again, he pretendeth this reason: that the one have an opinion of salvation and of worship annexed, all which (saith he) we remove from these orders: which, saving that it is against him self, is to no purpose. For, in the first part of his answer, he giveth to understand, that the papists shameful abuse of these things, is cause enough to make them now unindifferent, which is contrary to the whole course of his defence: and in the later part of his answer, he giveth to understand, that their oil, tapers, censors, holy bread, and holy water may be brought into our church: so that the opinion of salvation and worship, be, by a public and solemn protestation of the indifferency of them, removed. Who knoweth not also, that the abuse of the papists, hath been as great, and rather greater in the cross especially, by opinion of salvation and worship: then ever were, the tapers or sensors. whereupon it is manifest, that the D. herein, can make no more distinction or difference, between the cross and the surplice, with oil and tapers &c: then he uhich chalketh▪ ⟨p. 227⟩(as they say) a white line, upon a white wall. Let us1 therefore return.
To this defence may wel be referred, that which he answereth pag. 275 vnto my obiection: that Sensors. Tapers holy bread &c, are euen of the same coate that the surplice is of, and to be measured with the same pole. for yf his answer there, which is, that the surplice is indifferēt, but that these thinges be falsly accoūted indifferent, be good: yt wil help to succour, his weaknes here: and yf yt be shewed nawght here, nether wil yt serue hym there. Let hym tel vs therefore, why the surplice and the cros with their significations should be indifferent, and oyl and tapers &c with their interpretations, falsly counted indifferent. Here, we must beleue hym of his word, for reason, he hath none. Howbeit page 291, where he repeateth this again, he pretendeth this reason: that the one haue an opinion of saluation and of worship annexed, al which (saith he) we remoue from these orders: which, sauing that yt is against hym self, is to no purpose. For, in the first part of his answer, he giueth to vnderstand, that the papistes shameful abuse of these thinges, is cause enowgh to make them now vnindifferent, which is contrary to the whole cours of his defence: and in the later part of his answer, he giueth to vnderstand, that their oyl, tapers, censors, holy bread, and holy water may be browght into our church: so that the opinion of saluation and worship, be, by a publik and solemn protestation of the indifferency of them, remoued. Vho knoweth not also, that the abuse of the papistes, hath bene as great, and rather greater in the cros especially, by opinion of saluation and worship: then euer were, the tapers or sensors. whereupon yt is manifest, that the D. herein, can make no more distinction or difference, betwene the cros and the surplice, with oyl and tapers &c: then he vhich chaulketh